r/technology • • Aug 21 '21

R1.i: guidelines Bay Area doctor found with 2k images, videos of child pornography on iCloud

https://www.kron4.com/news/bay-area/bay-area-doctor-had-2000-child-pornography-images-and-videos-federal-complaint-alleges/

[removed] — view removed post

16.3k Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

3.4k

u/OppositeStrength Aug 21 '21

Why do people save child pornography on iCloud, especially since these announcements and news stories?

1.0k

u/DingleBerrieIcecream Aug 21 '21

Because saving photos to iCloud is set to default when you get a new iPhone. This guy is in his mid 50’s and likely doesn’t know or care about such granular options that he could disable. On top of that, he probably doesn’t read tech articles which would have alerted him that this is apple’s new policy to scan said iCloud photos. So his tech illiteracy, along with sexual perversion, just caused his professional and personal life to be over as he knew it.

319

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21 edited Aug 21 '21

Not disagreeing on you! But it’s important to note for overall privacy concerns Apples new policy is looking at photos on your personal device offline as well as iCloud

Edit: I stand corrected the search works on photos uploaded by your or applications you use to iCloud. Thanks

13

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

"But it is to protect our children from racist rapist pedophile terrorists. Please obey. Why don't you want your photos to be scanned? Are you a racist rapist pedophile terrorist?"

24

u/MegatronsAbortedBro Aug 21 '21

I thought it was to only look at iCloud, but they have the ability to look at devices too. Could be wrong.

→ More replies (9)

18

u/BldGlch Aug 21 '21

Not completely true. Apple only scans images that are uploaded to iCloud - it just scans them on your device before it gets to the cloud. For clarification, if you are not uploading a photo to iCloud it will not get scanned.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (126)
→ More replies (16)

5.8k

u/PeppyMinotaur Aug 21 '21 edited Aug 21 '21

Because Apple needs stories like these to make people fine with them invading our privacy and inevitably using this tech for evil shit

Edit: can’t believe this post is getting awards but thanks lol. To clarify I am happy this guy is caught I just think Apple can use this as justification for what they are trying to do with that tech and I think that can lead to some very bad things. I don’t think they made this story up or anything. Just haven’t seen any articles in the past about this type of thing and like a week after that tech is announced we see this.

1.1k

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

But if they found this before the scanning then why do they need to scan everyone phones? They already have a way to catch these predators.

95

u/marcuscontagius Aug 21 '21

Apple didn’t, it was probably the police that then notified Apple…that’s the whole reason apple is taking this task over… ppl are ok with a company invading privacy without a warrant but not the cops…this whole thing is a PR play…nothing actually changes except normalizing some invasive shit…now we can’t even be outraged by snooping because we’re being conditioned to see it as a service lmao.

→ More replies (15)

21

u/braiam Aug 21 '21

But if they found this before the scanning then why do they need to scan everyone phones? They already have a way to catch these predators.

Only if they upload them to iCloud. if they are not uploaded, they can't scan them.

→ More replies (29)

32

u/_PM_ME_PANGOLINS_ Aug 21 '21

Because they want to make iCloud end-to-end encrypted to improve privacy and security. So you have to do the CP scan on the device before it’s encrypted.

→ More replies (19)

8

u/12340987654321 Aug 21 '21

They have been scanning it on the server side. The changes open the door for them to keep everything encrypted once it leaves your phone since the scanning will be done on your phone right before it is uploaded.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (226)

101

u/happyscrappy Aug 21 '21

Just haven’t seen any articles in the past about this type of thing

http://www.yourgv.com/news/court/judge-denies-series-of-motions-in-child-porn-case/article_d0e87292-0bfd-11eb-8ff5-2379f117d72b.html

Probably you weren't looking. This is basically a Bader-Meinhof situation. Once you are aware suddenly you notice things you didn't notice before.

Also very interesting I thought:

Here is a 2020 article explaining how the system probably isn't even new.

https://9to5mac.com/2020/02/11/child-abuse-images/

It's just moving from the cloud to the device.

The talk of hashes, threshold of content, etc. What if this privacy intrusion has already happened?

13

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

Yeah I think they were already doing this on icloud, the difference is now it will be done to images stored locally on your phone. Images are hashed (so the image itself is never transmitted or viewed) and once you have 30 matches then an actual person reviews it

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (11)

24

u/Franc000 Aug 21 '21

Yep, like most things regarding data and privacy, the problem isn't necessary that the current actor will abuse it, but of a future actor that will abuse it.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

The road to hell is paved with good intentions

2

u/OmegaXesis Aug 21 '21

This wasn't even Apple who detected this.

"According to a criminal complaint filed on July 13, Mollick used the social media application Kik to upload an image depicting child pornography on Aug. 30, 2019. Kik Interactive Inc., which at the time owned the application and was based in Canada, closed Mollick’s account after learning about the image and alerted the Royal Canadian Mounted Police. That agency in turn contacted Homeland Security Investigations."

https://www.mercurynews.com/2021/08/20/bay-area-doctor-charged-with-possession-of-child-pornography/

The original article failed to mention who was responsible for notifying the authorities. But everyone here is just assuming Apple did it.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

“Im not saying it’s fake. Im just saying…” lol

2

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

These stories happen constantly, it's just confirmation bias because you're seeing it on Reddit. Not defending Apple, but they're not trying to manually go through your photos and creep around. you scan for certain types of photos and those flagged ones get checked. It's not a job anyone really wants to do, and can really cause a lot of trauma to those who have to check and verify for CP. I've personally worked on similar tech that checks devices and flags for any NSFW content (user consents to scan, of course) and works similarly. Only images flagged are shown to someone to verify

the biggest issue would be adults with petite builds (small frames, low/no bust size, shaved) would be more likely to get flagged.

2

u/Thatweasel Aug 21 '21

Are you really accusing apple of false flag child porn to manufacture consent for hash based child porn detection? Methinks the gentleman doth protest too much

→ More replies (10)

2

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

Of course Reddit up votes this

→ More replies (1)

2

u/psaux_grep Aug 21 '21

The timing is conspicuous, to say the least. I’m guessing we’ll se a lot of these until the feature is released or they decide to drop it.

Was a story the other day about Apple/iMessage/iCloud being the prime platform for CP as quoted by someone at Apple as well.

While I condone CP as much as the next guy, I do value the right to privacy. If Apple becomes a tattletale they’ll just jump ship anyway.

Sure, there will probably be a short time were there’ll be lots of busts, but most of these bad actors are likely to stay ahead of this scheme and get away with it anyway.

Then afterwards, what will the ramifications of this scheme be?

19

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

Apple turned him into a pervert?

27

u/psinerd Aug 21 '21

There is no suggestion in the comment that apple did anything to him, only that his case is being highlighted to bolster what apple is doing with regards to scanning phones for child porn.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (8)

3

u/SalemWolf Aug 21 '21 edited Aug 21 '21

They haven't even implemented the client-side scan yet, this is just a story of child porn being found by the same technology apple and other cloud-based services have already been using for years.

This is just your typical "apple bad" comment sending reddit into an upvoting frenzy.

→ More replies (102)

44

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

Because people are idiots

→ More replies (3)

7

u/CleverNameTheSecond Aug 21 '21

Be sure they're the dumb ones. There are countless more you don't hear about because they don't get caught because they don't upload it to fucking iCloud.

66

u/boli99 Aug 21 '21 edited Aug 21 '21

Because they are automatically conditioned to do as they are told?

Backup your photos to the cloud? [ ]No    [X]Yes
                                          Default

...and because folks are getting wise to that - in some cases it actually looks like this

Backup your photos to the cloud? [X]Yes    [OK]
                                 Default




















                                                    No [ ]

38

u/ThatOneGuy1294 Aug 21 '21

Same deal with cookies.

"Confirm" means "I consent to ALL cookies". You have to click on "Customize" or "Advanced" or similar to turn off each category one by one.

And then the same "Confirm" button is still there to try and make you think that's the button you want to press.

11

u/Krutonium Aug 21 '21

That's actually illegal BTW. Still waiting for the lawsuit. The law specifically states that opting out shouldn't have anything like that going on.

15

u/zimmah Aug 21 '21

Often the actual button you need is hidden, and often greyed out or disguised as plain text.

They should make a law to make denying cookies as easy as accepting them. This cookie bullshit is horrible.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/BombTheFuckers Aug 21 '21

A better question would be: why on earth would you take, receive or share CP with your god damn always-connected smartphone? That's just stupid.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

because you dont need to be technologically savvy to be a sick pervert

allot of these people are too stupid to be using a computer let alone diddle kids with one

14

u/dontbenebby Aug 21 '21

Why do people save child pornography on iCloud

It says he used Kik, the type of person who values a messaging service not tied to a phone number or real name, who moves to said messenger from another place on the internet, is usually so terrible I take any mention of that app to mean either they're a sex worker (I'm not buying), a sex pest (don't want to have an unfun time) or... like this guy, literally a goddamn Esptein guy.

The real question is how did Kik turn him in? Hash check on upload or someone he messaged went "what the actual fuck" and called the 4chan party van in from the garage?

15

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

Kik apparently has a huge CSAM problem. I'm not sure why pedos picked that app, given that there are apps you can use to communicate with end-to-end privacy, but for some reason they did. Darknet Diaries has a really interesting episode covering a pedo on Kik and a guy doing vigilante work to disrupt pedos. Maybe Kik is starting to take it more seriously after the publicity about it?

→ More replies (4)

2

u/skgoa Aug 21 '21

The images I get sent in WhatsApp get saved on my iPhone automatically and Apple decided to upload them to iCloud automatically, even though I never set up an iCloud account. Maybe the same happened here?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Jesykapie Aug 21 '21

Let’s call it Child Sex Abuse Materials and stop referring to it as porn. Porn is for entertainment. Those images/videos etc. containing children are abuse.

2

u/switch495 Aug 21 '21

Probably people don’t understand what’s going onto I cloud - similarly to the ways MS one drive invasively doubles files in places you might not expect (desktop?).

2

u/SureFudge Aug 21 '21

They don't but making this stuff up is good PR because of all the current backlash,

2

u/green_tea_bag Aug 21 '21

Probably unintentional. A lot of times things will go to iCloud unless you specifically instruct it not to.

2

u/atsinged Aug 21 '21

We just served process for someone's Google Drive contents for the same reason. People don't understand that the cloud is just "someone else's computer". Two thousand isn't a shocking number, I'd call it about average, you virtually never find one image or one video.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/INTERGALACTIC_CAGR Aug 21 '21

I don't care what they find, they need to stop invading peoples privacy. you fucking morons are going to be slaves before you know it and ask how did this happen?

→ More replies (12)

4

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21 edited Aug 21 '21

Compared to other cloud storage platforms, iCloud is the least invasive. I read a report that they only removed around 200 abusive photos last year, contrasted with Facebook removing upwards of 20.3 million.

I do think this is timely news considering the backlash for Apple’s CSAM scanning.

Edited after mgacy corrected my numbers.

39

u/GabiGamerRO Aug 21 '21

On iCloud you store private files. Facebook is not cloud storage. On Facebook, you post publicly. That's why they removed much more photos. A fair comparison would be Google Drive vs iCloud.

21

u/mgacy Aug 21 '21

You’re absolutely right about Apple being the least invasive, but you are off by a couple order of magnitude on the number FB reported:

U.S. law requires tech companies to flag cases of child sexual abuse to the authorities. Apple has historically flagged fewer cases than other companies. Last year, for instance, Apple reported 265 cases to the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children, while Facebook reported 20.3 million, according to the center’s statistics. That enormous gap is due in part to Apple’s decision not to scan for such material, citing the privacy of its users. Source

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/JReddeko Aug 21 '21

Drs and technology just don't mix.

→ More replies (33)

2.4k

u/Midgetwombat Aug 21 '21

Has anyone else notice the rise in stories of people with child abuse material on their phones ever since the up roar of apples spyware?

755

u/Larsaf Aug 21 '21

Well, isn’t it odd that nobody cared about the 21.7 million reports of CSAM on Facebook last year alone until Apple got involved.

59

u/juju_man Aug 21 '21

Posting CSAM on FB and getting blocked vs pushing scanning EVERYONE for potential CSAM. Sure, people really are unfair to poor apple

21

u/Ducallan Aug 21 '21

Pretty sure that FB can’t just block you; they have to report it.

What I’d like to know is:

  1. how many innocent images were looked at by a human to get to that number of reported images

  2. how many of the reported images were actually determined not to be CSAM by NCMEC

Content scanning is, to me, much more of a privacy violation than hash matching, is far easier for a government to abuse, and far more prone to false positives.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/MurgleMcGurgle Aug 21 '21

It makes sense given that Facebook isn't considered private storage. Like how people are okay with cops checking your bags when you're entering a venue but if they just walked into your home and started rifling through your stuff it would be a problem.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/redldr1 Aug 21 '21

What Facebook does has almost zero impact as to how Apple conducts its business. You can't connect the two.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

[deleted]

48

u/BolognaTugboat Aug 21 '21

Huh? ICloud has been scanned this entire time, just like Google photos. All because they don’t report on it doesn’t mean they haven’t been looking and reporting people to authorities.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

44

u/llamadramas Aug 21 '21

It's surprising haven't been looking on their cloud servers I feel like Google has been doing it for years or at least we've been seeing the stories for a while.

22

u/Kir4_ Aug 21 '21

Google def scans content, at least on YouTube and they'll remove the video before it's even public.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

[deleted]

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

, it means they are actually finding it and removing it.

And how do you think they find it? By looking at pictures... Just like Apple will do?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

929

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

Gotta push the narrative to fit their agenda.

414

u/LinoleumFairy Aug 21 '21

Looking forward to a few years from now when scanning hashes for CSAM turns into scanning a full database of screenshots of copyrighted material etc. This literally could be the first step towards paying royalties for downloaded pictures. Obviously an extreme endgame but I highly doubt their plans stop with the most publicly outrageous target.

43

u/miekle Aug 21 '21

This is pretty much the endgame. The copyright regime has long been mad that computers can copy stuff without caring about laws, and that's one of the biggest reasons our computers are becoming more phone-like, taking control away from the "owner". The usual red herring excuse is to improve security for the end user, but it's more about big business & government protecting their own interests FROM users.

24

u/Cronyx Aug 21 '21

Linux, my friend. The solution is exists.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/kent2441 Aug 21 '21

Have Google or Dropbox done this?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (71)

11

u/Ducallan Aug 21 '21

If they can control the media, why aren’t they suppressing the reporting that directly paints their future CSAM detection methods in a bad light?

Why wouldn’t they just keep the whole thing quiet, if they are that influential?

→ More replies (10)

47

u/anubus72 Aug 21 '21

not everything is a conspiracy. This type of news just wouldn't get upvoted before. Now that the apple thing is on peoples minds they upvote it, either out of rage or not. Do you really think Tim Cook is pulling the strings at Kron4 news?

44

u/CurvedLightsaber Aug 21 '21

It’s not really a conspiracy to think Apple hires PR agencies.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

25

u/Uristqwerty Aug 21 '21

It's now an excitingly-relevant headline for the clickbait-chasers to post, where before it'd be overshadowed by whatever else is going on?

10

u/mgacy Aug 21 '21

Is it a rise in the number of stories about people with CSAM on their phones, or a rise in the number of stories that you have noticed?

→ More replies (2)

11

u/dethb0y Aug 21 '21

Hey now, we can't have the plebes fighting back against privacy invasions - gotta keep the fear and paranoia amped up so they just go along with whatever the nice authority figures want to do.

2

u/JMDeutsch Aug 21 '21

Did you read the article? He literally uploaded some to TikTok.

They don’t need spyware to catch a person distributing child abuse material on social media.

I’m honestly surprised we don’t hear about arrests like this more often given how vocal Facebook is about their efforts to prevent it on their site/how much they claim to take down.

2

u/throwaway1_x Aug 21 '21

It's the Apple marketing machine working. The best in the business at manufacturing consent for the apple devices.

2

u/wookinpanub1 Aug 21 '21

Are images teens take of themselves and share amongst each other considered CSAM? If so, this is an absurd excuse for invasion of privacy.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/MartiniPhilosopher Aug 21 '21

That "story" is barely four lines of text and three of them are about who the man was!

There's no information on when or how he was found out, let alone any other relevant details. It's so blank it could be put into a bathroom and called a mirror!

2

u/dewayneestes Aug 21 '21

There’s a good Daily podcast yesterday on this. Apple is way behind other tech companies is reporting images, but they have not implemented the new on device image scanning. I think it should be scanned when shared vs in a private device, hut we’ll see where it goes.

→ More replies (23)

520

u/mrbungles- Aug 21 '21

I don’t care. I don’t want Apple spying on my phone. His guilt doesn’t reflect on me or give Apple the right to invade my privacy

80

u/PadyEos Aug 21 '21 edited Aug 21 '21

The nazis and other dictatorial regimes and systems came to power under the cover of "doing the right thing for society" but underneath that cover individual and private liberties were eroded away.

There are many good decisions for society, but this one is full of pitfalls. This is basically being illegally searched 24/7 wihout a warrant or any suspicion based in reality by a private corporation without any legal law enforcement mandates. The only reasoning is: you use our service so we can.

5

u/TechWOP Aug 21 '21

Imagine police coming in your home for a search with no warrant or anything. “Officer, why are you searching my house?”
“Ah it’s just that you might be a pedophile.”

Your phone is your home. Pedophiles must be caught but with other methods. Trampling everyone’s privacy is not a method.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/andygchicago Aug 21 '21

This reminds me of the argument people make to ban trans people from bathrooms because of sexual assault risks. There’s only been a few incidents of this occurring over the years, a much smaller percentage when compared to non trans assaults, and yet people bring up the examples as some weird justification

2

u/backwithpics Aug 21 '21

I mean, I do care that children are being abused. But what needs to happen is our justice system to start punishing these perps adequately and give funding to FBI units trying to shut this stuff down. Apple can mind its own business.

→ More replies (74)

71

u/Huge_Nebula_3549 Aug 21 '21

That’s fantastic news!

I still don’t want Apple scanning my data.

→ More replies (6)

120

u/LunarIncense Aug 21 '21

iOS15 isn't even out yet. Is this story even related to the neural hashing Apple plans to do?

75

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

No. But iOS 15 is out in a public beta. Anyone can get it. I’ve been running it for a couple weeks now.

…and it doesn’t have the CSAM monitoring. That is coming in a later update. It won’t be in the first couple versions of iOS 15.

17

u/VaishakhD Aug 21 '21

But is the doctor that much of a geek to get the public beta in the first place? I sense bs in these articles.

14

u/lachlanhunt Aug 21 '21

This guy got caught because he uploaded the photo to another social media site. Then they got a warrant for his iCloud data. This article has nothing to do with Apple’s upcoming CSAM detection.

12

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

But is the doctor that much of a geek to get the public beta in the first place? I sense bs in these articles.

You act like scanning for CP only just now started.

It's been going on forever, Apple's latest thing is just another tool a tech company will add to their existing suite, not some brand new behavior

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

31

u/aaaaaaaarrrrrgh Aug 21 '21

Is this story even related to the neural hashing Apple plans to do?

Yes, but only in the sense that they're pushing it now to justify those plans. The guy didn't get caught through neural hashing.

He is also accused of using the social media app Kik to upload one of these images.

Bet that's how he got caught. Then they got a warrant and went digging through is cloud storage, which they can do because Apple doesn't encrypt it.

→ More replies (5)

180

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

Very convenient this hits the news during the midst of Apple getting a shit ton of flak from their scanning plans.

60

u/James_Mamsy Aug 21 '21

NGL it’s gonna take like 5 of these headlines and then people will be fine with Apples hashing and that really scares me.

8

u/Uuugggg Aug 21 '21

Well, let's spin up 4 more new corporations to make 4 more headlines of this event, then the job's done!

4

u/confusiondiffusion Aug 21 '21

This is getting at a much larger issue. You already trust Apple with all this data. If they were already doing this without telling anyone, would you know? Not just Apple, every tech company that touches your data. You trust them with so much and they largely did not earn that trust. I actually think Apple is better than most.

It seems like people are desperately grasping at privacy they already gave up because they don't realize it's gone. I'm hopeful that people still care. But if consumers really cared and were informed, no one would own a smartphone. Where's the source code? Where's the datasheets? Schematics? It's all trust.

I run Lineage with no Google apps on my phone. The fact that my Qualcomm chipset has a "Trusted" execution environment with keys I don't own means I still treat this phone with caution. The code that runs all the radio transceivers in this device--no idea what it's up to, I'm not allowed to change it, and it likely has access to all of my data. Privacy is extremely hard to achieve these days.

I guess people treat Apple like the last bastion of privacy and so it's a big deal when they do stuff like this. But the fact that they are in a position to push this update onto their customers is the real problem. The data is practically already in their hands.

To be clear, I don't think this particular technology is going to violate privacy if implemented in the way Apple says it will be. But I am pointing out the deeper problem of us already trusting these tech companies. If an Apple algorithm going through your pictures bothers you--I mean, how did you know they weren't already doing that or worse? Why did you trust them? Because your friends did? The marketing?

Companies change. Your data is forever. We have the technology to secure our data but no one wants it badly enough to demand it. Open hardware and software, strong crypto, and education can fix all of this.

→ More replies (4)

114

u/BlueLaceSensor128 Aug 21 '21

An article 3 years from now will casually mention how police are able to flip through your texts and photos after looking you up in a database (with a distant face scan) and with no real protections on who does it and for what purposes.

We boiled frogs clearly have had most of our eyeballs burst out at this point.

→ More replies (16)

11

u/Zantillian Aug 21 '21

This should not be the method to catch child predators. And to be clear, I hate child pornography and Sexual predators, but this is clearly PR so it's more fuel for Apple to invade our privacy.

→ More replies (2)

153

u/Ephemeral_Being Aug 21 '21

How fucking stupid do you have to be to put illegal files onto someone else's server?

You know what the FBI will never be tipped off about? The encrypted hard drive that is only ever hooked up to an airgapped system, running TAILS. Which, for the record, a child can setup. Takes maybe fifteen minutes on a slow internet connection.

I know we should be glad criminals are stupid, but it's just pathetic. There HAVE to be smart criminals out there that don't make the news, right? They can't all be morons.

60

u/Zaptruder Aug 21 '21

There HAVE to be smart criminals out there that don't make the news, right?

Yes, they're plenty of them. They just don't make the news.

9

u/Bootyhole-dungeon Aug 21 '21

I think that means they don't get caught.

→ More replies (8)

24

u/Catsrules Aug 21 '21

How fucking stupid do you have to be to put illegal files onto someone else's server?

What?? I thought the cloud was a magical void where files are just floating in the sky.

→ More replies (2)

101

u/ISuckAtFunny Aug 21 '21

A lot of people have ZERO idea how cloud storage works. You’d be surprised how many people I’ve spoken to who think it’s a literal cloud of data lmao

35

u/Ephemeral_Being Aug 21 '21

I'm aware, but before I decided to put evidence of my felonies somewhere, I like to think I'd do some research.

Then again, my current plan of "don't commit felonies" works even better...

→ More replies (3)

24

u/Beliriel Aug 21 '21

Literal conversation I had with tech people:
TGuy: "And then we can save all this data into the cloud."
Me: "Why not run a server yourself? It's probably cheaper to pay a guy and you retain control over your data."
TGuy: "No a server is old tech, we need the cloud now."
Can you believe he had no idea what Kubernetes was? Like how tf do these people get project management positions?

15

u/ISuckAtFunny Aug 21 '21

Scalability is a big consideration a lot of the time. For a small business an on prem server could work fine, but so could an Azure AD hosted by Microsoft with less headache tbh

20

u/aidenr Aug 21 '21

It’s a bulk purchasing problem. Buying cloud services scales with your usage, but servers do not. You pay for 1 whole unit of storage or processing but then you use 30% of it during business hours and then it sits silent all night. It’s hard for finance to want to throw money down a purchasing problem.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/ultrafud Aug 21 '21

Sorry what does airgapped mean?

23

u/Ephemeral_Being Aug 21 '21

Airgapped systems are not connected to a network. There is physically no way for you to interface with the system outside of walking up to the unit and pushing buttons.

Wiki: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_gap_(networking)

→ More replies (1)

12

u/aaaaaaaarrrrrgh Aug 21 '21

There HAVE to be smart criminals out there that don't make the news, right? They can't all be morons.

Exactly. But as you say, those don't make the news. Also (obviously doesn't apply in this case, as the goal was satisfying is sexual desires, not money) many criminals are criminals because they have a hard time making a good living otherwise. If you have a high paying IT job, you're not going to be acting like an idiot trying to sell drugs on Facebook.

5

u/russlo Aug 21 '21

The truly paranoid have known for a long time that even air-gapping may not be enough. That article is from 2014, but I remember reading about interception of radio frequency emissions from computers and their monitors 25 years ago, and those concepts were old and dusty even then.

2

u/piecat Aug 21 '21

Allegedly there's ways to sniff out video going to a monitor. All you need is some passive device hidden in the ferrite bead of a VGA, and you can snoop a-la theremin's bug.

No doubt this is even more possible with digital signals.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/modifiedbears Aug 21 '21

Or someone who can transfer files to your account on a server and make it seem as if you did it. Not saying that's what happened with this case but it's a possibility

→ More replies (1)

2

u/RawrSean Aug 21 '21

It’s just like you say.. the fbi will never know about this portion of offenders, right, so you’ll only ever hear about the dumb ones.

→ More replies (7)

78

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

I mean they can’t ram through invasions of privacy on their own, they need sympathetic media stories to make you angry about what someone else did to convince you to be ok with everyone losing their privacy and individual liberty!

→ More replies (3)

51

u/wookinpanub1 Aug 21 '21

Regardless of whether this is indeed true, it’s no justification for the creation of a mass surveillance technology that will inevitably be used in nefarious ways by governments and other corrupt interests. Also, there’s no way to verify this story because anyone attempting to (eg a journalist) will have committed a felony by viewing the material. I guess we just have to take the governments word for it 😂

14

u/_TheDust_ Aug 21 '21

But, but, they caught one criminal. That should be enough to scan all your photos right, pretty pleeease?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Kantrh Aug 21 '21

Journalists don't usually verify crime stories.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/69_Nice_Bot Aug 21 '21

Hey wookinpanub1, I counted 69 words in your comment. Nice.

→ More replies (6)

25

u/cassydd Aug 21 '21

As far as I know, the csam scanning is coming with iOS 15, so odds are this dude just got caught when he uploaded the image then the FBI got access to his phone and then his iCloud.

18

u/Kantrh Aug 21 '21

It says recently unsealed so definitely before the scanning was implemented

65

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

“Look we caught a criminal! Don’t take away our spyware!!”

19

u/_TheDust_ Aug 21 '21

“We caught one criminal, that should be enough to scan billions and billions of images made by millions of users, right?”

36

u/Choui4 Aug 21 '21

We can all clearly see what's happening here. It's the same propaganda that's pulled every time our rights and freedoms are taken from us (hi NSA analyst currently reading this).

Suddenly start pushing stories that support the narrative of why we NEED less privacy because "won't somebody please think of the [insert oppressed du jour] (not that people aren't oppressed, don't get me wrong, it's just that the using of a specific person for specific aims and only those aims is gross).

The most recent mass example is sudden" INCREASE IN CRIMES, POST [insert any nominal police reform, that hasn't even taken effect yet]

Really good recent episode of citations Needed about anti-BLM backlash on it actually.

If we all recognize this happening, like most seem to do. Why is this post up voted? This post should be down voted to hell. Do no allow the story to spread.

Join me in down voting and attempting to control a false narrative before its too late

2

u/SparklySpencer Aug 21 '21

A very wise commenter once told me an upvote isn't always about approval, but rather exposure and making sure eyes are watching the results. I upvoted the article because it's important for people to be aware of what is happening. Kindly keep that in mind

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

19

u/dnuohxof1 Aug 21 '21

So…. If they found this without NueralHash on our devices, why do we need NueralHash on our devices?

2

u/BretTheShitmanFart69 Aug 21 '21

I’m not saying we need it but “we didn’t have cars before so we don’t need cars now” wasn’t a good argument for not advancing technology back in the day and it’s not a totally valid argument now.

There are good arguments to be made about this but you didn’t just make one.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

Then let's make this one.

A company only set out to extrapolate every last penny snooping in your personal information heavily will never bode well in your favorm no matter how many pedos it catches

17

u/MaggoLive Aug 21 '21

Paid for by Apple Inc.

28

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

how very convinient...

21

u/CommunismIsForLosers Aug 21 '21

Serious question: If Apple wanted to "find" something on your device, who could argue with them that they're mistaken?

12

u/AdPlastic5240 Aug 21 '21

Exactly my thoughts. Planting photos would be so easy to do. Big shots could literally pay apple to ruin their political enemies

→ More replies (1)

5

u/BearsGetRekt Aug 21 '21

I still think it's wrong for apple to scan every single picture that goes into the cloud, they will always show you these success stories, and yeah it's awesome they caught this guy, but they'll always show you the success stories to get you to comply with less privacy.

5

u/SaltMineSpelunker Aug 21 '21

Uploaded childporn to public networks? Thought doctors were smart.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

Intelligence in a medical field doesn't assume the same for technology.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/VA_MD Aug 21 '21

https://www.doximity.com/profiles/978a31e3-a365-4ee0-9192-f3044580b326/view

This guy's pedigree is no joke, residency and stanford fellowship, lots of publications. This guy was one of the faculty at my med school too. There goes all of his grants holy fak

5

u/MrNudeGuy Aug 21 '21

For ppl complaining about privacy. Apple is already using the same algorithm to make cute little albums for you. It’s the same tech

5

u/okmarshall Aug 21 '21

For anyone concerned about privacy, if you use Google photos then go on the app and search for random words like dog, car, baby etc, whatever is most applicable to your life. Your photos are already being scanned.

8

u/slabtard_casual666 Aug 21 '21

I must say, you manufacture a good consent Apple.

4

u/SrGrimey Aug 21 '21

This is one of those stories that will be common in the next months in order to appear that Apple wasn't wrong with their new scanning system??? Because it sounds like that, not that this is an invention because we've seen news like this in the past but Apple is going to use it as "see? This is why".

4

u/SuburbanDiver Aug 21 '21

I wonder how many of his “colleagues” also had access to that iCloud.

17

u/snoogenfloop Aug 21 '21

Still an unacceptable step in the direction of an uncontrolled surveillance state.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

Awfully convenient news after what Apple just announced…

7

u/Rshahnyc Aug 21 '21

Bruh this is not the same but I feel like this is a terrible idea every time my fiancé takes a pic of her nieces running around the backyard naked on my phone.

Edit: my nieces**

14

u/forestcall Aug 21 '21

There have been cases where Grandpa had pictures on his mobile of his naked under 6 years old grandchildren after swimming in his pool. Totally innocent as in the same picture was grandma and other relatives. Clearly not kids porno. But he spent 2 years in jail until the cops dropped the charges.

10

u/Rshahnyc Aug 21 '21

Excuse me while I go on a deletion crusade. But on a serious note, that’s absurd. How are there even charges if the parents don’t press them and everyone knows the photos are innocent.

I don’t have kids so I had no idea, but there is a lot of turning around and “the kids are naked again” that happens in the course of a day.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

I wonder if I take thousands of pictures of my butthole up close, will apple send out the police to arrest me for having point of view butthole images

3

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

They’ll probably have to confirm by comparing buttholes first.

9

u/wynnduffyisking Aug 21 '21

Ok so a sex offender got caught. Good. I hope he rots in jail.

But what happens when China pressures Apple to use the tech to scan for images related to political dissidents. Or if Iran for instance wants them to scan for images of same sex relationships. Or a million other ways that Apple can abuse this tech. Do you trust Apple to only use this for good? I sure as fuck don’t.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/FLCLHero Aug 21 '21

Who the fuck would have this on something that can go to the cloud? Thank god he did, but seriously?

3

u/Person2277 Aug 21 '21

I’d hate to be the guy who has to review the content to make sure it’s cp

10

u/Ducallan Aug 21 '21

So, from the article, it sounds like he got caught elsewhere and then had his iCloud account investigated.

The reason why we’re hearing about this is because it’s news that Apple is implementing a new CSAM detection method that is controversial ,and therefore news-worthy. To suggest that Apple controls the media and can choose whether a story like this is reported is ridiculous.

5

u/obeythefro Aug 21 '21

They do control a lot of money though, and money tends to help when you are trying to control a narrative. While they do not control the media directly (except Apple news maybe), they definitely have teams of people whose only jobs are to ensure the media is playing their particular song, and that the major outlets are prioritizing their narrative over one that is counter productive to their cause.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

Watch out. Apple is going to use this as justification for why they should go along with their plan to scan all of your pictures

5

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

The ends don’t justify the means

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Horace_P_MctittiesIV Aug 21 '21

Time to chuck him into the pit of despair

4

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

Nice try, Apple.

5

u/Chickenflocker Aug 21 '21

I know this story is pre-iOS 15 but what are predictions on how long it will be before the first new style of swatting someone by uploading images to their iCloud.

→ More replies (10)

11

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

Not everything is a fucking conspiracy. Jesus. Apple had nothing to do with this. He was caught, and the DOJ made the announcement. It’s on this news site because it’s a local story on a local news network. It happens all the fucking time. The FBI caught him uploading by on Kik, they got a search warrant for all his electronics, and they found the stuff.

Fucking hell.

5

u/edlonac Aug 21 '21 edited Aug 21 '21

And I mean I guess it’s intuitive that we’re all concerned about the kids caught up in this shit, but there’s a surprising lack of that being mentioned around here. There’s some degree in which technological advancement increases the prevalence of CP material and its distribution - and that does need to be counteracted imho.

Regarding apple - if they have the responsibility of storing all of this data on their servers, they are within their right to make sure they’re not storing anything illegal.

That said I think it’s a fair criticism that they essentially force cloud storage on customers, so if the scanning goes anywhere beyond CP, then yeah, it’s not ok.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/uzlonewolf Aug 21 '21

Apple had nothing to do with this.

That's only half correct. It is true that Apple had absolutely nothing to do with catching this guy, however the only reason this case made news is because of the waves Apple made with their CSAM scanner.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/RandomFish338 Aug 21 '21

Yup so fucking sick of these paranoid conspiracy theories

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/ujibana Aug 21 '21

Good apple. Clock the bitches

2

u/mcsimeon Aug 21 '21

2k resolution images or 2000 images?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/HotFightingHistory Aug 21 '21

So what happens when they find said content on the phones of powerful politicians, executives, and celebrities? Who determines what gets sent to law enforcement and what doesn't?

2

u/speedymarie420 Aug 21 '21

Good

Send him to pound him in the ass prison even though he will enjoy it

2

u/vitringur Aug 22 '21

I wonder how much more private porn they have been looking at on peoples phones.

3

u/OfficialMaxBox Aug 21 '21

On ICLOUD!? man's simultaneously got a phd and no brain

3

u/Several_Tone1248 Aug 21 '21

So did his phone turn him in?

3

u/HIVnotAdeathSentence Aug 21 '21

This is before Apple’s has started scanning phones and accounts? Seems no reason to continue their plan.

4

u/zdiggler Aug 21 '21

I'm really fucking tired of "Think of the Children" way of taking our liberty and privacy away.

Lazy laws need to find a better way to combat crime.

3

u/bakedlasaugana Aug 21 '21

Only a matter of time before apple starts planting images on people’s phones to silence their critics. Freedom of privacy is dead

→ More replies (7)

3

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

If you don’t like it, use one of those service providers that doesn’t look at you the same way a billionaire looks at a penny on the sidewalk.

Oh, right, those don’t exist.

Just remember, it’s easier to whine on Reddit and upvote the angriest, whiniest comments than it is to accept that capitalism is failing, and make peace with the fact that we need to do something drastic to fix this fucking nightmare. No, we don’t wanna do that. These companies will fix themselves if we just whine loud enough.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

Seriously fuck Apple. I bought into their ecosystem cause they promised privacy which has now been proven to be a lie.

My privacy is more important to me than some random child who may or may not be helped by INVADING my privacy so I’m done with Apple.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/SparklySpencer Aug 21 '21

How would it distinguish between a parent taking an innocent photo, and creepy perv who is doing harm?

31

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

Because the photo a parent takes wouldn't appear in a CSAM database. Either way, Apple's solution would do nothing about people creating CP, if that's the nature of your question. It's only for preexisting CP.

13

u/LunarIncense Aug 21 '21

It would very much be able to stop production. Think about it like this.

Dad harms his daughter, takes photos of it. Neural hashing doesn't do anything because it's not in a database.

Now lets say he uploads it to the darknet. People share it and eventually it ends up in a database.

Now that it's in the database when the phone checks the photo again it will show up. So not only did you detect CSAM, you also end up identifying the person who created it.

I know people like to go on about privacy, but this kind of stuff has been happening for a while, and it will just become more and more common. Microsoft has PhotoDNA after all, which has similar goals, and that came out with Windows 10's original release.

Society has already chosen willingly giving up our information to corporations and governments. Many people are not aware of how much information they're really giving up, but this is already the new normal. Privacy is pretty much already dead.

15

u/SparklySpencer Aug 21 '21

Privacy being dead is a sad thought.

Understanding your points about how it might stop proliferation and would activity prevent new CSAM content (in some cases) is appreciated.

All I will mention is that once a tool is created, it's going to be used in creative ways for good and bad. What consequences are we allowing by inviting the entire internet to snoop through our devices?

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (23)

2

u/Penis-Envys Aug 21 '21

Thought Apple was about to shift into the privacy business but that doesn’t seem like the case anymore

2

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

State secrets and terrorism is allowed but child porn, oh hell no gtfo!

-3

u/MoroccoGMok Aug 21 '21

Sounds like we found the next republican candidate for Senate

18

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

He’s actually a registered Democrat. Go figure.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

This is Apple PR trying to spin its spying program.

2

u/jambazi99 Aug 21 '21

This story is obviously manufacturing consent for the Apple photo scan feature. A Bay Area news outlet putting this out a few days after backlash from their spying on photos announcement. It’s disgusting.

2

u/kansle Aug 21 '21

It's so weird any time these stories come up. 2,000! PICS and VIDEOS.

Who even needs 5-6 ordinary mature porn clips on their laptops?!?!?!

It's so frikkin weird.

17

u/wfaulk Aug 21 '21

Part of the reason for that, though, is that you can get "ordinary" porn on the internet within seconds, and it largely doesn't go away.

Imagine you have a porn obsession but it isn't available just by going to a well-known web site, and knowing that when you do find it that it's likely to go away at any time. You'd probably be inclined to download it and keep it.

4

u/kansle Aug 21 '21

Man this world sucks

→ More replies (4)

15

u/Knyfe-Wrench Aug 21 '21

I think the complete opposite. As someone who's downloaded normal porn you can easily get several hundred images in one folder. 2000 could be the result of one afternoon.

Videos are a different story, but the article didn't enumerate them, so it could be 2000 pictures and 5 videos.

I think the shocking part should be the presence of child porn at all. The seemingly large number is just an attempt to up the shock value, which is weird.

5

u/brickmack Aug 21 '21

Theres 2 types of porn collections:

  1. None at all. "I just watch whatevers on the front page of pornhub because I care about neither quality of plot nor quality of the video itself"

  2. /r/datahoarder. "I have hundreds of thousands of hours of video, all in its original release resolution, uncut, and I designed my own semantical tagging pseudofilesystem so I can find any video or any set of fetishes with a few clicks, and I have every video or image ever produced by my favorite actresses. I spend 15000 dollars a year on storage hardware, have a dedicated server running an automated download process on a dedicated internet connection, and 5 part-time software engineers and file clerks assisting me"

4

u/Ephemeral_Being Aug 21 '21

It's not weird. It's used as barter. Currency. Trading like for like. Whenever articles like this start to crop up, eventually enough people ask this question that the information gets tacked onto the end of subsequent stories. When the fervor dies down and then starts up again, it takes a few weeks for media organizations to remember not everyone has previously read about the topic. If you dig through BBC articles on arrests from previous years, you'll eventually find one with a couple paragraphs detailing the practice. Alternately, you can wait two weeks for them to reappear.

I'd say you can read all about this, but I have no idea what search terms you can enter to find relevant news articles without getting on some kind of watch list. So. Research at your own peril.

2

u/Peakomegaflare Aug 21 '21

So it begins then. Guess it's time to form DeadSec.

1

u/Peachmuffin91 Aug 21 '21

I have a 2 year old son and I have some bath pictures of him as a baby. They better not flag my shit.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

I have a 1 year old son, but I still block out his peen before sending to his mother in law. Lol

4

u/SparklySpencer Aug 21 '21

Your child isn't old enough to thank you for that, so thanks for being a considerate parent

3

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

I usually put this emote over it. 🙈 lol.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/fatbob42 Aug 21 '21

I wonder if they can have people like this work in the prison hospital so that his expertise doesn’t go to waste. Maybe he would be attacked by the prisoners…

1

u/viper12a1a Aug 21 '21

Yeah it's San Francisco

1

u/Thrillwaters Aug 21 '21

This scanning software is quite the intrusion. What happens if you have a nude photo of your own child on your phone? Do you then have to prove that it is your own child and that the photo was taken with their consent?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

The system scans for known CP images only.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

From the article:

58-year-old Joseph Andrew Mollick had at least 2,000 sexually exploitive images and videos of children on his Apple iCloud account.

1

u/kossimak Aug 21 '21

Shot on iPhone

1

u/HundoGuy Aug 21 '21

Apple has found an ingenious way to watch child porn, while pinning it on someone else.