r/science • u/mepper • Jun 16 '12
The US military's X-37B Orbital Test Vehicle landed in the early morning today in California; it spent 469 days in orbit to conduct on-orbit experiments
http://www.af.mil/news/story.asp?id=12330624318
u/ballstein Jun 16 '12
"on-orbit experiments" = spying, right?
7
u/JustinTime112 Jun 16 '12
Not sure why you would need a human crew of six for that though.
7
u/TheGOPkilledJesus Jun 17 '12
Repairing spy satellites.
4
Jun 17 '12
I was thinking, fucking up spy satellites. And attaching bugs to them. And "America, Fuck Yeah" stickers.
3
u/0l01o1ol0 Jun 17 '12
a human crew of six
That's what they want you to think.
I'm not saying it's aliens, but...
→ More replies (1)7
u/EatSleepJeep Jun 17 '12 edited Jun 17 '12
Send a crew up, snag a Chinese/DPRK satellite, bring it home or disable it, slap a transmitter on it, etc.
7
u/alupus1000 Jun 17 '12
Attaching a little motor and boosting a spysat to a higher orbit is kinda funny actually.
"Haha! Now all your pictures are blurry!"
4
u/OK_Eric Jun 17 '12
Probably more hardcore than that, probably docking with orbiting satellites and doing things to them (making repairs to satellites while in orbit, disabling enemy spy satellites, etc.).
23
Jun 16 '12
It may be that putting people up there isn't very useful, after all.
46
Jun 16 '12
Space programs have always just been bomb-delivery research in disguise.
10
u/random_digital Jun 16 '12
Space programs have always just been bomb-delivery research
in disguise.FTFY
2
Jun 16 '12
Or in this case, possibly a special operations personnel-to-China/Iran/Russia-in-less-than-an-hour-delivery research in disguise.
15
u/harlows_monkeys Jun 16 '12
Generally, I believe that when they want to insert special operations personnel someplace they want to do it quietly. That generally precludes coming in from space in a hypersonic vehicle.
→ More replies (5)6
u/CUNTBERT_RAPINGTON Jun 16 '12
Gee I hope the Iranians have a 2-mile long runway and launch pad that the X37 can use to get in and out when nobodys looking.
→ More replies (5)1
2
u/Enkmarl Jun 16 '12
fabrications, manufacturing, and mining would all be easier in zero-g
1
32
u/facetiously Jun 16 '12
Seeing as how it's in the hands of those wacky guys and gals from DARPA, no telling what "experiments" they conducted.
18
u/TheBawlrus Jun 16 '12
I'm betting on kinetic penetrators, IE: Rods from God. Sling shot a tungsten allow telephone pole sized spear from space at some bastard.
19
u/kbrewsky Jun 16 '12
Unfortunately, or, actually, very fortunately, tungsten is very dense. Roughly, a telephone pole sized piece of tungsten would weigh 150,000 Kg. Given a very generous $10,000/Kg price to orbit, it would cost $1,500,000,000 to launch each weapon into orbit. I'd use smaller bits, myself, but I don't know where the reduced effectiveness would begin to catch up with you.
11
Jun 16 '12
Orbital KE weapons probably won't become cost-effective until launch costs drop significantly or space-based manufacturing becomes commonplace.
3
u/alupus1000 Jun 17 '12
Cost-effective to what though? The military already happily throws up multi-ton spy and communications satellites. And there's absolutely no comparable weapon besides an ICBM - the reason these don't exist yet is the politics.
2
Jun 17 '12
I think we'd be willing to pay a few bucks to have just a couple dozen of them up there. All sorts of fun could be had...
8
u/TinyCuts Jun 16 '12
That is exactly why you don't need it the size of a telephone pole. Some the size of a bus stop post should do.
7
u/alupus1000 Jun 17 '12
Bus stop post would pretty much work out to a typical air-dropped bomb.
In the case of the system mentioned in the 2003 USAF report above, a 6.1m x 0.3m tungsten cylinder impacting at Mach 10 has a kinetic energy equivalent to approximately 11.5 tons of TNT (or 7.2 tons of dynamite). The mass of such a cylinder is itself over 8 tons, so it is clear that the practical applications of such a system are limited to those situations where its other characteristics provide a decisive advantage - a conventional bomb/warhead of similar weight to the tungsten rod, delivered by conventional means, provides similar destructive capability and is a far more practical method.
5
u/DriveOver Jun 16 '12
Very true. Since the X-37B has a cargo bay that is only 7' x 4' you would be restricted in how large the rods could be. A tungsten rod about 4.5 feet long and 4 inches in diameter would only weigh around 500 pounds. Slap on a 2' long guidance system to one end and drop it from LEO.
→ More replies (5)3
u/kbrewsky Jun 17 '12
Indeed. I would assume that you'd want some more precision anyway. There's definitely a reason that they stopped designing for 10+ megaton nuclear weapons.
2
u/DriveOver Jun 16 '12
What are the dimensions of a telephone pole in your example? Assuming a 10 metre pole with a diameter averaging 18 cm I estimated the mass to be more like 20,000 kilograms.
→ More replies (1)1
u/pez319 Jun 17 '12
I think a more important point is how the tungsten rod would separate from its carriage assembly without some sort of firing mechanism and guidance system. The rod won't just drop down, it'll continue on whatever velocity it was going at.The carriage assembly then has to counteract the force of the firing mechanism. It'll essentially just become a guided missile, just super high up. Probably cheaper and more accurate just to put it on an ICBM and drop it from there.
→ More replies (2)3
Jun 17 '12
See also the Prompt Global Strike program, which once considered and might include conventional ICBMs.
2
u/pez319 Jun 17 '12
I started looking at the wiki ICBM page and I found a pretty cool photo of the MRV in action http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Peacekeeper-missile-testing.jpg
1
u/bikiniduck Jun 17 '12
But its worth it when you take into account there is no radioactive fallout. It has as much destructive energy as a small nuke, but without the radiation.
1
→ More replies (1)1
u/rivermandan Jun 17 '12
why would they bother wasting money testing that? the science and technology is pretty basic compared to other things they do up there, so why bother?
4
u/DeFex Jun 16 '12
I am sure the death boffins have come up with some new and amazing ways to kill or spy on people.
25
u/facetiously Jun 16 '12
Well, they did (eventually) give us the internet, which is an amazing way to kill time and spy on people.
6
u/algo Jun 16 '12
This goes up on a rocket right?
15
u/jagedlion Jun 16 '12
Yeah, the thing that makes it special is it's ability to glide down. With the loss of the space shuttle, there was no vehicle capable to returning whole satellites or other large components to earth.
9
u/lotu Jun 16 '12
yeah I think the military wants the ability to kidnap satellites.
1
u/alcalde Jun 17 '12
That's been my suspicion too. Far easier than knocking them out of orbit. That said, it could be they had two telescope-equipped satellites to spare for NASA recently because the X-37B is going to be the new go-to tool for placing a spy platform in orbit quickly.
2
u/happyscrappy Jun 17 '12
Really? I would think knocking them out of orbit is easier than kidnapping them.
2
u/Joe091 Jun 17 '12
That fills space with debris and fucks things up for everyone, including us, in the future. Plus, if we steal a satellite then I'd imagine there would be intel to be gained.
→ More replies (6)1
u/frumperino Jun 17 '12
That's hardly much of a realistic possibility, is it? Unless you have a cooperative and confirmed shutdown of the target satellite then its onboard attitude jets and other hydrazine nastiness could surely jeopardize your capture vehicle if they start firing while the thing is in your cargo bay.
There's also the satellite's deployed and extended solar panels and instruments booms and antennas to worry about. Could a purely robotic coercive kidnap mission have sufficiently sophisticated tools and manipulators to even deal with all those things?
I think if the X37 is going to visit satellites of potential adversarial nations, it's missions may be more likely things like snooping and capability inspection type jobs, or if the gloves come out - outright sabotage. Simpler than retrieval... also, keep in mind that the position of the X37 was fairly reliably tracked by groundside amateurs in its missions. The eyes of potential target nations will surely be firmly on the X37 as well whenever it is near their junk.
5
11
u/Arknell Jun 16 '12
X-37B? [Where have I seen that airframe before?] (http://i.imgur.com/7kvDF.jpg)
[Thinking hard...] (http://i.imgur.com/kKNdS.jpg)
5
14
Jun 17 '12
So... NASA isn't doing space missions anymore... but the military is?
3
u/balorina Jun 17 '12
The military has always done space missions, rocketry itself started as a military operation that NASA took over. The story a cpl weeks ago of the military handing over two satellites they just had sitting around kind of supports the idea.
The difference is NASA is doing a lot of research and development so it gets a lot of news. The military is figuring out better ways to blow things up, so they keep it under wraps.
1
3
10
Jun 17 '12
NASA is the military. Von Braun was a Nazi too.
1
u/stox Jun 17 '12
Von Braun was a whore. He would have built a rocket for anyone who was filling to pony up the bucks.
2
Jun 17 '12
Excuse me? The shuttle program ended. What made you think NASA wasn't doing space missions? Do you mean besides the dozens of satellites, probes, rovers, and telescopes it's sending out into the solar system?
18
Jun 16 '12
As I open and read through this thread I am thankful that redditors have not lost their edge. Every day you guys take a somewhat mundane project and turn it into somewhat exciting.
NASA/DARPA space project run by the Air Force? Must be an evil spy satellite used specifically for deprivation of civil liberties or used to destroy the the Chinese.
This is why I keep coming back to Reddit day in and out.
9
u/MyAssDoesHeeHawww Jun 16 '12
Those videos of cats trying to catch a laser point on a wall? Yeah, that's X-37B's orbital laser on show!
4
u/facetiously Jun 17 '12
I'm with you. Science is a fearsome beast, but r/science, you scary. And you both enlighten, entertain and correct me.
10
11
u/MrWhite Jun 16 '12
If only there were some sort of permanently orbiting lab upon which they could perform such experiments.
9
Jun 17 '12
Many of the experiments were testing the spacecraft itself.
The X-37B Orbital Test Vehicle, one of two such vehicles, spent 469 days in orbit to conduct on-orbit experiments, primarily checkout of the vehicle itself.
However, one of the intentions of the spacecraft is to be able to send up and bring back experiments, presumably more rapidly than trips to the ISS.
The 11,000-pound state-of-the-art vehicle, which is about a fourth the size of the shuttle, allows space technology experts to continue sending up experiments, with results returning safely to Earth for study.
1
3
u/Ihmhi Jun 17 '12
I read an article about the X-37 in Popular Science a few years ago. They brought up the point that such a craft would be able to fly over Airspace.
See, if we need to get guys into a country we need to request permission from all the countries we would pass through. This greatly increases the time it takes to actually get them there. If we can literally fly over the airspace, the issue does not exist at all and we can just drop guys in straight down.
As for recovery, if it were not part of a larger deployment operation, then a traditionally permitted vehicle could pick it up with tow cables similar to a Skyhook or the vehicle could just be blown to bits.
12
u/Bhima Jun 16 '12
I am very enamored with this project but I have this niggling feeling that it's going to turn out that some TLA is using for a wildly immoral, illegal, and ultimately self defeating project.
4
Jun 16 '12
I feel like you guys keep trying to distract from the [issues] (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N-NkX86uPI0&feature=youtube_gdata_player)
→ More replies (1)1
2
u/kicktriple Jun 17 '12
Any idea how the vehicle stays in orbit so long? What does it use as fuel?
7
u/AstonMartin2195 Jun 17 '12
It does not need much fuel when in orbit. The gravitational pull of the earth allows it to orbit the earth without propulsion. To power the systems on board would require either solar panels or something very efficient. I would think the systems on board do not take up that much energy.
3
3
u/SnifflyWhale Jun 17 '12
Once you have something in orbit you only need to use fuel to get it down.
2
Jun 17 '12
Not true. LEO still has drag from the atmosphere so you need to compensate for that or fall to earth.
2
u/SnifflyWhale Jun 17 '12
Yes, but you can leave satellites in low earth orbit for (in some cases) over a decade without a boost. Mir took about 4 years to fall. I don't think the X-37B would need to use its fuel on a 469 day flight unless it was changing its orbit or deorbiting.
2
Jun 17 '12
If it can reach orbit, it doesn't have to expend any significant fuel to maintain that orbit, only to modify it.
1
u/balorina Jun 17 '12
In theory an object will stay in orbit for as long as the object's gravity remains constant. Players of Kerbal Space Program know the unfortunates of an unfueled apogee (high orbit) and perigee (low orbit).
1
2
2
2
2
u/keraneuology Jun 17 '12
The interesting bit of this craft is that it can change orbit whenever anybody has a whim to send it elsewhere. Tracking satellites is fairly easy - anybody who paid attention in high school trig can work out the numbers to know when a particular satellite is going to be overhead: going for an all-over tan and don't want the government taking shots from space? Work out the orbits and you know exactly when the camera is overhead and can go inside. (The same concepts apply if you are working on some new tank or plane or something - the bad guys know when our satellites are coming up so they'll stop operations.)
With a camera mounted on a space plane - that is pretty hard to spot from such a distance - you can sneak up and take pictures at irregular intervals and they won't ever know when their are in view of the lens.
4
u/grendelt Jun 16 '12
5
1
6
u/isotope123 Jun 16 '12 edited Jun 16 '12
I'm glad that even with all the budget cut backs we are still able to explore space in some capacity.
edit: I know that it's a military spacecraft. I simply meant that having anything in space at all is a good thing. Romantic idea, I suppose.
27
Jun 16 '12
It is a military spacecraft and was not carrying research instruments. The flight was primarily to test the vehicle itself.
The budget cut-backs are very much hampering real space exploration.
10
u/Alphasite Jun 16 '12
In the end, i don't care who's doing it, wether it be the Chinese or the Americans, Space Exploration is still what the name implies, its just exploring with different goals. Military expenditure may be very expensive and focused, but it generally gives very tangible and targeted benefits that bleed into the real world.
In my opinion, governments generally handle the 'hard problems' that don't make economic sense to solve but, in the long term give massive benefits and prove their worth, it just needs a careful hand a a strong oversight.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)1
u/herbal_savvy Jun 16 '12
We might be exploring how to best use space to control people on earth, nothing this plane did in it's year + orbit was to benefit humanity in anyway.
11
7
Jun 16 '12
That's how it's always been. USA's space exploration was not started as a means to explore space or for the name of science and progress of mankind. No, rather it was started to improve our rocket technology, to improve or tracking technology, to improve our recon technology, and most importantly to show the USSR how capable we were and to be scared of us.
So yes, this might not be for the benefit of humanity or in the name of science, but it is progress. This technology will later find its way to the civilian space exploration industry and will be beneficial.
A good example of this is satellites. Yes, they weren't started for a good reason, but they are now used for good reasons. Same for nuclear weapons and nuclear power. Same with radar and radio waves. Same for many military technology.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Ruprect124 Jun 21 '12
Please continue giving me negative 'karma points'. I don't state my opinions to curry favor, they are to make peole wake the fuck up, perhaps incline someone/anyone to investigate the basis of my statements. Kill me with Bad Karma--wait isn't negativity on your part going to lead to bad dharma/karma for yourselves? Superstitious horse shit....
-11
u/Tjebbe Jun 16 '12 edited Jun 16 '12
I'm not sure how to feel about this. On one hand it might be great for space exploration, on the other hand I imagine that outfitting that thing with a nuke would make all missile shields useless and trigger a strong response from other nations.
Edit: Snacknuts rightly pointed out that subs already do that. But I do have a question for those more knowledgeable than me; I thought that a missile shield only has time to respond to a missile in the cruising phase, but guessing from the replies one dropped straight down from orbit might still be intercepted?
12
u/Chairboy Jun 16 '12
What would it offer that ICBMs don't already?
3
u/Monomorphic Jun 16 '12
It could also launch Kinetic bombardment weapons on short notice without rousing ICBM launch radar warnings. The so-called 'Rods from God' weapons. All the power of a nuclear explosion without any of the radioactive fallout.
→ More replies (1)1
u/boomshanka Jun 17 '12 edited Jun 17 '12
A lot? Speed of weapon deployment, increased geographical scope, elevated fear of god in whoever the US's latest 'enemy of freedom' is
1
u/Chairboy Jun 17 '12
I believe ICBMs do all of this. Anything that needs to seorbit burn will take longer to strike than a ballistic missile so you gain no speed advantage.
4
u/fgalv Jun 16 '12
how would it make nuke shields useless? It would take the same path as an ICBM, i.e. low orbit
2
u/Obi_Kwiet Jun 16 '12
Correct. It would just be an ICBM. Nothing new.
2
u/WarthogOsl Jun 16 '12
Well, consider that it could be launched well ahead of any attack, and remain in orbit for a long period of time (months). So effectively, there'd be no launch warning. You wouldn't know it was attacking unless you were already tracking it long term, and saw it do it's de-orbit burn.
→ More replies (5)4
u/w2tpmf Jun 16 '12
ICBM detection systems look for rockets. This could drop a ballistic bomb while it it floating over. I'm not saying that they can/will equip it that way, I'm just saying that if they did that would function way differently than a nuke missile.
1
Jun 16 '12
ICBMs don't really go into a full orbit.
This space plane can also move around and change its orbit while in space, and could potentially hold a warhead up there for over a year. It would also be way harder to defend against a nuclear attack when there are already 10 of them whizzing around at radically different orbits.
As a target you lose the crucial launch phase detection too.
7
u/snacknuts Jun 16 '12
You realize subs already make missile shields useless? And they are harder to detect than a sub-orbital vehicle.
3
2
u/RecordHigh Jun 16 '12
As far as I know, no nation has a missle shield capable of reliably shooting down more than a handful of ICBMs, and even that's a stretch with the technology that's been deployed so far. So very little would be rendered useless.
2
u/regularmoe Jun 16 '12
Yeah. The technical nuances of ICBM's aside, I don't like the message this sends.
We can cut NASA's ability to explore space, but the military gets its own shuttle?
1
u/Zazzerpan Jun 16 '12
NASA and the Airforce are closely related. I'm sure there will be a lot of cross over. If anything it would prove an interesting emergency vehicle for the space station.
1
u/needed_to_vote Jun 16 '12
Because other nations have missile shields?
The US was the only one talking about missile shields (SDI) and they're forbidden in a few treaties because they would upset the balance of power and continue the nuclear arms race, just in another fashion.
-7
u/forgotusername11 Jun 16 '12
Rather fishy this came down just as soon as China send their own astronauts to their space station...especially as there are thoughts that the this X-37B was kept in an extended orbit to specifically spy on China's space station and/or satellites, as well as other reconnaissance (North Korea, etc.)
8
Jun 16 '12
that the this X-37B was kept in an extended orbit to specifically spy on China's space station and/or satellites
No it wasn't. The only people suggesting this are the government controlled Chinese media outlets. The X-37B wasn't in a convenient orbit to spy on the Chinese Space Station.
→ More replies (1)5
-4
u/One_Catholic Jun 16 '12
Why isn't NASA using stuff like this already?
8
u/RobinBennett Jun 16 '12
Because NASA has different priorities to the Air Force.
NASA want to send people and tonnes of stuff to the ISS, the USAF want a robot that can fly around in secret for a year, doing secret stuff.
13
u/varukasalt Jun 16 '12
Did you read where it said it was a NASA project that was transfered to DARPA?
→ More replies (3)
122
u/Ascott1989 Jun 16 '12
This whole project is simply a test platform for the X-37C which is a crewed vehicle.