r/science • u/col_tasha • Jun 10 '12
Wales is the first nation in the world to have its plants DNA barcoded. A tiny fragment of leaf, seed, root or a single pollen grain can be used to identify species.
http://dx.plos.org/10.1371/journal.pone.003794519
u/nuxenolith Jun 10 '12
Using binomial or Welsh nomenclature?
Sunflower
Heliannthus anuus
Blodyn yr haul
19
u/col_tasha Jun 10 '12
The project works with the Latin binomials but all of the Welsh and English names have been collated for the species as well.
http://www.gardenofwales.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/List-of-plant-names-for-website-1.pdf
8
5
u/ababby Jun 10 '12
Interesting paper about limitations of DNA barcoding [http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1096-0031.2003.00008.x/full]
1
u/col_tasha Jun 10 '12
It is definitely true that DNA barcoding should not replace morphological identification. Good taxonomists are vital for DNA barcoding to ensure that the reference specimens are correctly identified. The value of DNA barcoding is not where you have a whole plant - its real value is when you have a tiny fragment or a mixture of samples that would be impossible to identify using morphology alone.
1
u/ababby Jun 10 '12
Right, but how can you definitively say that an organism was identified correctly if you don't have any other information? Using a small segment of a mitochondrial or chloroplast genome can really only be a useful tool if you have morphological data or nuclear genome data to support it.
1
u/col_tasha Jun 10 '12
Yep, that's right. DNA barcoding relies on the existing classification of the species. Each DNA barcode reference for a plant needs to have a herbarium specimen showing where the DNA came from. When you have an unknown sample of DNA you compare it to the database of reference DNA barcodes. Bit more info here http://www.gardenofwales.org.uk/science/barcode-wales/
4
u/aazav Jun 10 '12
Please tell me how this will be used - or how this can be used.
I'm trying to think of real world applications to how people could use this.
6
u/col_tasha Jun 10 '12
A couple of examples. First of all pollinators: we know that pollinators are facing declines but it is often difficult to know why. It's possible to track where pollinators go by DNA barcoding the pollen carried on their bodies. This may help to conserve them better.
We can also DNA barcode honey to find out the plants bees visited to make it. We have a project looking at the medicinal properties of honey to see if honey from particular plants has better effects.
There is some more info here: http://www.gardenofwales.org.uk/science/barcode-wales/
-1
Jun 10 '12
The most far-reaching one is that if a plant goes extinct we could recreate it in a lab someday
5
u/col_tasha Jun 10 '12
Unfortunately we cannot use DNA barcoding for this. The DNA barcodes use two smallish pieces of DNA from the chloroplast. Not enough to recreate the plant.
52
Jun 10 '12
We're a country not a nation! :P
16
u/col_tasha Jun 10 '12
Happy to go with country - Wales is the first country in the world to have DNA barcoded its native flora!
22
Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
Cymru am byth.
10
u/buckley118 Jun 10 '12
*byth
8
Jun 10 '12
Doh! Fixed. Only half Welsh, the other half, wanker, but the good sort of wanker.
25
u/buckley118 Jun 10 '12
It still shocks me to see references to Wales on Reddit! Truth be told - nobody seems to know it exists.
10
10
u/othermike Jun 10 '12
nobody seems to know it exists
Don't be daft. How else are you going to measure Amazonian deforestation?
1
u/poon-is-food BS | Chemistry Jun 10 '12
"an area the size of wales" is popular to use, because wales is small, well known and looking at a map without lines for countries you wouldnt be able to guess at the border.
6
4
u/cantquitreddit Jun 10 '12
I learned about Wales from the Susan Cooper 'Dark is Rising' books. They even touch a bit on pronunciation of the Welsh language.
4
→ More replies (9)4
u/Golden-Calf Jun 10 '12
Really? I think Wales is one of the most beautiful places I've ever been, and the language is awesome. They have some really interesting folklore too!
1
u/buckley118 Jun 10 '12
Agreed! I'm Welsh myself - I love our lack of Vowels, crazy street-signs and stories. Music in our blood and poetry in our souls.
→ More replies (2)0
0
0
Jun 10 '12
[deleted]
4
1
Jun 11 '12
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/superfuzzy Jun 11 '12
But nation is more correct, because it doesn't necessarily mean they are independent, self-ruling or have a contained economy.
28
u/djmor Jun 10 '12
na·tion/ˈnāSHən/ Noun: -A large aggregate of people united by common descent, history, culture, or language, inhabiting a particular country or territory.
-A North American Indian people or confederation of peoples.
Fairly certain Wales falls into that first definition.
37
u/flyingnomad Jun 10 '12
Don't let the people of Cornwall, England see that first definition. There'll be nations springing up all over the country.
39
10
u/steviesteveo12 Jun 10 '12
I think they already know.
To be fair, the whole idea of the United Kingdom is that it's a large whole consisting of smaller units. The idea that there are several historical kingdoms/nations rolled up in that makes a lot of sense.
→ More replies (2)4
u/sirbruce Jun 10 '12
Cornwall should be considered its own country just like Wales.
8
u/BritainNotEngland Jun 10 '12
The Celtic Cornish have a history siding with the invading Danes and Norsemen against the Anglo Saxons. Why it's known as English while Wales isn't is very inconsistent.
Cornwall should be considered its own 'country' just like Wales. As should northern England and highland Scotland. And London too in itself.
Let them have their cool stories, bro.
0
Jun 10 '12
[deleted]
11
u/flyingnomad Jun 10 '12
All hail his Majesty the High King of the People's Republic of the Metropolitan Borough of Stockport and Its Outlying Territories of Reddish, Cheadle and Gatley and the Four Heatons!
→ More replies (1)5
Jun 10 '12
But the way this is worded, it seems like we're talking about the geographic region of Wales, not Wales-the-people-who-live-there. "Region" would have been a better word.
2
u/TheRealmsOfGold Jun 10 '12
Dictionaries are political. Not that everyone who writes a dictionary is chuckling and fingering gold coins; rather, that it's impossible to write anything without a subjective point of view. These are just two ways of understanding the "definition" of a nation, right down to the tiny nuances of exact word choice (which is the level at which the difference is made—for example, here the inclusion of the clause "inhabiting a particular country or territory").
</postmodernism>
2
u/XtremeGoose Jun 10 '12
But then you could potentially call anything a nation. For all intents and purposes it is correct to call Wales a state, and leave the definition of nation as a recognised nation by the united nations. Wales is not the first nation in the world to do this because the whole of the uk has not.
3
u/Benocrates Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
You've got that backward. A state is best described by Weber as the institution which holds a monopoly on the legitimate use of force within a territory. Nations can exist within a state without being a state themselves, e.g. Quebec in Canada. In fact, the UK is considered one of the best examples of a multinational state, along with Canada, Spain, and arguably Switzerland...though it's a hotly debated topic.
0
Jun 10 '12
[deleted]
2
u/djmor Jun 10 '12
I live in the province of Quebec, in Canada. Quebec is it's own nation, as is Canada. The multiculturalism that exists in downtown Toronto/Montreal/Ottawa/Vancouver doesn't go much further than major cities. Small towns in any given nation are culturally identical. Just like if you go to Dubai, what you see is definitely not the same as what is in the rest of the UAE/Arab peninsula.
Many of the middle-eastern and african countries are culturally similar, and several countries may make up a single nation.
1
u/Benocrates Jun 10 '12
To be fair, Quebec and Canada are two different types of nations. Canada includes Quebec in its civic nationality, cf. Cartier.
0
Jun 10 '12
[deleted]
0
Jun 10 '12
You've replied to 2 of my comments saying the same thing, correcting me and being pedantic. I'll say it again.
Haters gon' hate.
4
Jun 11 '12
Very nice, and congratulations on the DNA bar-coding.
How much longer must we wait for you to put some actual vowels in that language of yours?
7
u/lcdrambrose Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
Any collection of people that share a uniting quality is a nation. A country is the physical place. So Wales is both a country and a nation.
Source: I'm of the Welsh Nation by lineage and a of the Red Sox Nation by choice.
3
u/Welshrosi Jun 10 '12
Welch?
0
Jun 10 '12
[deleted]
3
u/lcdrambrose Jun 10 '12
Yes. We are mortal enemies of the Smucker's Clan. What kind of fools use grapes to make jams and jellies?
1
u/Strid Jun 10 '12
The uniting quality in original definition of nation is a common heritage (ethnicity)
1
2
Jun 10 '12
We need to stop using the words country and nation as they're not that useful. If we stick with the clear legal definition of a State we'd avoid such ambiguity.
2
u/Benocrates Jun 10 '12
Words like country and nation are definitely useful in many areas. In this case it doesn't really matter. In political theory they are very important concepts.
1
u/Bierton Jun 10 '12
Wales is not a country, it's a nation . I'm Welsh and only really properly understood earlier this year that England, Wales, Scotland and N.I. aren't countries, they're constituents. The United Kingdom is the country.
5
u/BritainNotEngland Jun 10 '12
Let them have their semantics like "country" and "nation".
England Wales Scotland and N.I can all be called as such. It doesn't mean anything. There is no English army. There is no Welsh seat at the UN. There is no ambassador of Scotland to a foreign nation. There is no Northern Irish place in NATO.
Yeah I'm anal. That's what this account is for. The first 5 seconds of this clip from an otherwise good film made me rage.
1
1
u/Benocrates Jun 10 '12
The distinction is useful in theoretical issues. The Scottish separatism of late is a perfect example of this.
1
u/BritainNotEngland Jun 19 '12
The Scottish have the best case out of any for separation I begrudgingly admit. They were actually a country once, for one thing.
2
1
u/Keilly Jun 10 '12
So when can we take up our seat at the United Nations?
United Countries?
1
u/Benocrates Jun 10 '12
It would be more accurately called the United States, but that was already taken.
1
Jun 10 '12
Your understanding is at odds with Wikipedia which describes the UK as containing constituent countries, Wales as a country is debatable since it is still a principality (that itself is denied by the Welsh assembly although they do accept that Charles is the prince of Wales!). The more I read the more I think the truth depends upon who you ask rather than there being a true definition.
3
u/Welshrosi Jun 10 '12
"A principality (or princedom) is a monarchical feudatory or sovereign state, ruled or reigned over by a monarch with the title of prince or princess" Charles has literally no ruling power in Wales or any say in the policies of the Welsh Assembly.. I'm tired of having to say this Wales is a f'in country! The Romans couldn't conquer her and neither will the English!
1
1
u/KaiserMacCleg Jun 12 '12
Wales is not a principality, and there is no legal or constitutional basis for saying it is. The title "Prince of Wales" is, today, just an honorary one - there is no grant of land that goes with it, and certainly not one that encompasses the whole of Wales!
There's a lot of confusion over the word "principality", in any case. Being a principality and being a country are not mutually exclusive. The word "principality" just refers to the mode of government of the country - i.e. an area of land that's ruled by a guy who calls himself a prince. I suggest you seek out the Wikipedia pages of Monaco and Liechtenstein, which are both countries and principalities (the latter of which Wales isn't).
1
u/Strid Jun 10 '12
The original meaning of nation is: Which has been born of (Race of people). But I don't know the heritage of Wales, celtic? Did you avoid heavy Germanic influence?
2
Jun 10 '12
I'd be happy to discuss in another thread but I dont want to hijack this one as the OP has clearly put a lot of effort into it. :)
1
u/Welshrosi Jun 10 '12
Celtic Originally but there's obviously going to be some modern Welsh people with some Germanic or Roman in them.
-1
u/willjsm Jun 11 '12
oh ffs. wales is no more a country than louisiana or texas is a country - in important ways wales is even less of a country than them. a different culture / language and a history that involves being independent doesn't make you a country.
0
0
u/zephyy Jun 11 '12
Some people in here could have used an International Politics class. Or a visit to Wikipedia.
Wales is a nation and (constituent) country of the United Kingdom, which is a nation-state. Wales is not a nation-state. Another example is Quebec, which is recognized as a nation within a united Canada, but not a country, and obviously not a nation-state.
0
-2
-1
0
Jun 10 '12
[deleted]
10
3
6
u/Bierton Jun 10 '12
Wales hasn't been a Principality since the 16th century, when the English cock up our arse was there enough to have us classed as 1 country, which is now the U.K.
30
8
Jun 10 '12
I'll be very surprised if England or the UK as a whole doesn't become the second place to do it. We have a habit of testing things in Wales before rolling them out to the rest of the UK.
5
1
Jun 10 '12
Rna?
4
1
Jun 10 '12
When was this? I live in NY and majored in Horticulture. We had atleast a dozen varieties of plants on file and every third-year student has to be able to perform a genetic comparison for the midterm. I don't even go to any special college. It's a state university!
9
u/col_tasha Jun 10 '12
Yep, lots of countries throughout the world are DNA barcoding plants - the DNA barcodes for the Welsh plants though provide the most comprehensive coverage so far for any national flora.
1
u/dbrta Jun 10 '12
This is fantastic! Now I don't have to learn botany any more! I'll just scan it with my iPhone plant sampler attachment.
And finally, we can close all the university botany positions and replace them with geneticists.
3
u/col_tasha Jun 10 '12
Most definitely not! The real value of DNA barcoding is if you have a sample that cannot be identified using morphological approaches. A pollen grain, fragment of material or a mixture of plants. If you have a whole plant then its much better to identify it with a key or guidebook. Good taxonomy is vital for DNA barcoding as the reference DNA barcodes have to be correctly identified to create the DNA barcode database.
1
u/JanusKinase Jun 10 '12
Not to mention that you'd have to perform PCR first... morphological ID would be a lot faster.
Though, to be honest, maybe your comment was sarcastic... so if it was, sorry for missing that joke.
8
u/NobblyNobody Jun 10 '12
Hmm, rather Bladerunner-ish
This kind of makes sense if you've ever driven through South Wales past Port Talbot at night. (During the day, just don't look, it'll scar you for life).
5
4
u/suo Jun 10 '12
I used to love driving past Port Talbot at night when I was a kid.
4
u/NobblyNobody Jun 10 '12
It is strangely wonderful
for anyone that's unlikely ever to get to see: Port Talbot at night it can look amazing
but by day, not so much
1
u/InvertedGoat Jun 10 '12
The mountains next to the steel works have some of the nicest views at night. You wouldn't think something that ugly could look so cool.
4
Jun 10 '12
While we're warning people, we might as well suggest they don't inhale through the nose while in Port Talbot.
1
u/NobblyNobody Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
yep, close your vents, aircon to recirculate
edit: repel all borders
2
2
Jun 10 '12
This is amazing. If a device capable of doing this becomes commercially available in the future it could revolutionize the public's interest in learning about wildlife. Just imagine going on a hike/safari and being able to identify any organism one sees, or possibly discovering something previously unknown!
2
u/MoonDoggiie Jun 10 '12
About time we were known for something else other than sheep shagging... Don't think this will catch on quite as well though
4
u/marginalboy Jun 10 '12
TIL Wales is a nation and not a region of Great Britain ...
→ More replies (1)10
Jun 10 '12
Wales is a country and a nation, but NOT a UN-recognized independent state
7
u/tricolon Jun 10 '12
Funny, UN-recognized and un-recognized are so close...
2
Jun 10 '12
It's rather meaningless. Taiwan isn't in the UN yet it's recognised by much of the world.
3
u/sambt5 Jun 10 '12
being from wales, acturly seeing a good post about us is very reliving for a change
2
1
1
u/Secondsemblance Jun 10 '12
When I joined the department of defense, they took a DNA sample. Get ready, soon all of you will have to do that. You will learn to love big brother.
1
1
u/ReasonableRadio Jun 10 '12
This should go on future timeline: except not in the future part of it... http://www.futuretimeline.net/
1
1
u/climateer Jun 11 '12
Number of plant species barcoded: 1,143 Average Number of plant species in a 4 square mile patch of Amazonian rainforest: 1,500
1
1
0
Jun 10 '12
1984 for plants. Next they'll be planting microchips in their stems.
1
u/doodaddp Jun 10 '12
Don't think they need them since they now have their DNA barcode region on record... :)
0
u/swa17 Jun 10 '12
We are getting close to a real life POKE'DEX!! Can't wait to go out into the forest and be like, "The fuck is that? The fuck is THAT? My gawd." and read tons of cool shit about every fuckin plant and animal.
-1
0
0
0
0
0
Jun 11 '12
I sense dangerous implications to this kind of technology, I can see this helping large agro-industrial organizations harassing farmers for their dues.
0
-4
u/timefiller25 Jun 10 '12
Are you telling me that WALES made a contribution to society? (Kidding, folks).
-1
Jun 10 '12
Next stop, people.
1
u/dnew Jun 10 '12
I'm pretty sure we can identify which species of human you are without genetic sequencing of any type.
0
-1
Jun 11 '12
What is with you people referring to Wales as a nation and a country? Texas is 3x the size of the UK and we don't refer to it as a nation. The nation of Texas. If you ever come to my country called Texas you will get your ass whooped. Sounds dumb huh.
-2
u/jimbojamesiv Jun 10 '12
I'm not surprised that the Prince of Wales chose his country first. They say he's an environmentalist, so it's not surprising.
4
u/whit123 Jun 10 '12
He's actually very much English, the title is granted to him as heir to the throne
-2
Jun 11 '12
It isn't officially nation. It isn't recognised by the UN. It has a devolved government. The United Kingdom of which it is a part of is the nation. So this could read "Wales first country" perhaps. But not nation, welsh isn't a nationality, it's like calling ones self a New Yorker. They are British Citizens as per their passports.
-2
155
u/gerry_villa Jun 10 '12
I love this.
Gene sequencing is a way of building a true library from which (in the future) it will be possible to recreate "extinct" organisms.
In Stephen Baxter's stories he often has third world citizens running around with portable hand held gene sequencers sequencing every insect and plant they come across. When they go back to the town center they get their information uploaded and actually get paid if they have sequenced something that is not in the library already.