r/science • u/nomdeweb • May 21 '12
A materials scientist at Michigan Technological University has discovered a chemical reaction that not only eats up the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide, it also creates something useful. And, by the way, it releases energy.
http://phys.org/news/2012-05-lemons-lemonade-reaction-carbon-dioxide.html78
May 21 '12
Did you know that there's not enough Li on the planet to even consume the CO2 emission used to mine and refine Li?
2
u/GeneralMakaveli May 22 '12
I didn't read the article so for the life of me I couldn't figure out why you wanted to mine Chinese people.
0
May 21 '12
[deleted]
42
May 21 '12
2
u/antman100 May 21 '12
Am I reading this wrong? The article talks about total C02 emission in the atmosphere. Not the amount generated by processing Li.
3
May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
The significant figures work out like this: 100,000 to 1
So, if even 0.001% of the CO2 emissions result from mining operations that produce Li, I am correct.
I'm comfortable with my assertion, especially when you consider the fact that most of the Li is still in the ground and the general rate of CO2 increase the referenced article covers (another exponent to the CO2 side of the equation in fairly short order and certainly before all the Li is mined).
→ More replies (1)4
u/Iximi May 22 '12 edited May 22 '12
You need to know the balanced chemical equation of this reaction and need to convert to molar mass to do the math correctly here.
→ More replies (3)
29
u/l1ghtning May 21 '12
The reaction seems novel and scientifically interesting (speaking as a chemist / materials scientist myself) BUT THIS WILL NOT SAVE THE PLANET.
If not for ANY ONE of the simple reasons:
We'd need billions of kilograms of Lithium just sitting around for the taking. If it has to be mined, then there are energy costs with mining/transporting/processing.
To make lithium nitride you must add lithium and nitrogen in a high temperature environment. High temperature environments (~300+ degrees C) require energy to be maintained. This energy must come from somewhere that doesn't make CO2.
Where the fuck would all the final product go? Billions of tonnes of anything are going to be hard to dispose of. I'll make an assumption that even if it was only 1 part per billion soluble in water then dumping it in the oceans would result in the destruction of said oceans thanks to massively increased quantities of lithium. How did the 'waste' product get to the ocean anyway? Solar powered green boats?
I am not going to do any calculations to prove this since its all farcical anyway.
2
u/IonOtter May 21 '12
Well, technically the way the article is presented, and from the comments, this could turn into a closed-loop system. Put in a little initial energy to get things going, then WHOOSH!, it takes off, providing more energy that you used to start the reaction.
That seems like a perpetual motion machine at first glance, but the reactants in question already have that much energy within them. So it's valid, just as using one match to light 500 matches is valid.
As for the by-products, they claim that they would be used to make fertilizer, as well as providing raw materials for semiconductor production. After a quick search on Google for lithium cyanamide, it turns out Phys.org is rather late to the party, and this has been around for nearly a year.
So far, the only issue I see causing a problem with mass adoption of this is the lack of large amounts of Lithium just laying around for us to scoop up. It's sort of being used at the moment, in great quantities, to power our iToys.
→ More replies (2)1
May 22 '12
This energy must come from somewhere that doesn't make CO2.
Is it cool if it produces helium instead? 'cause I can totally hook you up with an energy source that does that.
32
u/unknownpoltroon May 21 '12
This almost sounds like it would make more sense in a rebreather for diving, or a spaceships airmaker or something, rather than as a large scale CO2 remedy.
17
u/goatworship May 21 '12
Definitely. I think a nice big forest and a lot of time might be the best remedy for excess environmental CO2.
→ More replies (1)
8
u/Khoeth_Mora May 21 '12
This is pure bunk! Not once is the energy requirement for making elemental lithium or nitrogen mentioned, let alone the energy cost of burning the lithium. Even worse, the author fails to mention that Li3N would react with water and oxygen way faster than CO2, so the CO2 must first be purified from the atmosphere. Pure Tom foolery!
7
u/bitchjazz May 21 '12
It's really fun that my alma mater, Michigan Tech, has made my Reddit front page. It's such a small, but amazing school.
2
u/kevinmtu May 21 '12
agreed. Tech is a great school!
2
u/bitchjazz May 21 '12
Thanks! I grew so much as a person being there. Not to mention it snowed 330 inches the first year I was there. :)
2
u/TSGS May 21 '12
95/96? As I recall, it snowed like crazy that year. It was also that never ending snow that helped me decided that two bachelor's degrees were enough, and I didn't want the master's degree any more.
I miss the Keweenaw. Lots of good times and great memories.
2
u/bitchjazz May 21 '12
Yep that's the year! The last snow storm was on May 16 with 9 inches I believe. It was gone pretty quickly on the Hancock side but stayed much longer on the Houghton side. I ran into snow in the woods in mid June.... I left just before I finished my bachelor's degree and did a couple classes at another university to get my tech degree. When did you leave?
→ More replies (5)
7
u/pkbowen Grad Student|Materials Science | Bioabsorbable metals May 21 '12
I just spoke to one of Prof. Hu's students at lunch today, and he was very excited that this had made it to the top of the Science subreddit (although I don't believe that he is a Redditor). He is one of the students working on this project, and he said that the amorphous product that is pictured in the PhysOrg article (and the MTU press release) is not their final product. They're aiming to make this a crystalline product which he says (and I quote) "will be harder than diamond."
So, to all of those who are saying that "this is not an economically viable solution" or "there is a net loss of energy," those things are very true. However, this is NOT meant to sequester all of the carbon in the world. Instead, it can use CO_2 to produce a byproduct akin to industrial-grade diamonds for use in cutting tools and so forth. Basically, it (1) sequesters limited carbon, and (2) prevents future carbon emissions resulting from mining microdiamonds.
6
18
3
u/Amplifier101 May 21 '12
lol hilarious. Reddit needs lessons in thermodynamics because to propose this as a solution to anything energy related is just wrong.
3
u/J_Jammer May 21 '12
The interesting thing is that they can make do with waste. And that's true of every form of waste. Car's wastes are no different. They can create something. Convert it. Make something of it. If people think hard enough, there really is no such thing as polution.
4
u/leon_reynauld May 21 '12
There have been several similar discoveries in the last few years like this. Unfortunately, when this methods are done in larger scales, they are economically unviable or fail all together.
2
u/Epicool May 21 '12
ok the problem is that it needs high energy to start at first place, beside how can you accommodate such high temperature unless,, you can use it as a chain reaction that had to be initiated then it continues... it will take sometime for this to be actually in use.
and good luck with removing all the jokes :D
2
u/FermiAnyon May 21 '12
Nobody's going to use this to capture CO2. No energy company is interested in deploying something like this because the cost of replacing the material is too damn high! and they're going to want a standardized plant design, which they won't have if they have some plants doing capture in the liquid phase and others doing capture in a solid phase.
At best, this is a way to use the CO2 you've already captured. It's worthless as a primary source of capture.
1
u/RileyFX May 21 '12
Exactly, sadly money comes before protecting earth in most peoples eyes. We have so much technology and scientific capabilities to do almost anything, but money is the only thing holding us back. Hopefully one company takes the initiative to implement this sort of thing.
1
u/FermiAnyon May 21 '12
It's like NIMBY. Everyone wants to benefit from the technology, but nobody wants to pay for it.
2
u/mralistair May 21 '12
and all you need to find is a few gigatonnes of elemental lithium each year and we'll be saved.
2
May 21 '12
What happens when you add the production of Li3N into the lifecycle costs of this process?
2
2
u/l1ghtning May 21 '12
And how much energy does it take to prepare the lithium nitride reagent?
How much lithium is available to us versus CO2?
Sorry to break up your party, environmentalists. You can go back to hating us scientists now.
2
u/C_T_C_C May 21 '12
Could we simply use sodium instead of lithium? It has the same characteristics as lithium, and from my basic understanding of chemistry, it should bond in the same fashion, and it's much more abundant in the world.
2
May 21 '12
I like this comment after the source article:
"Yeah right, that elemental lithium (one of the most reactive elements) is just lying around on the ground waiting to be used, no energy need to prepare that!
Get your head out of your ass, I made this account just to tell you not to spread your stupidity any more."
phys.org is sort of the tabloid of science journals. Interesting, but not to be taken too seriously without investigating the original papers.
2
2
u/QUARTER_MAST May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
Li3N requires coupling of other highly exothermic reactions to form it from Lithium and N2 since it's formation is very endothermic, what do you propose to run these reactions to mass produce Li3N? There aren't known abundant sources of Li3N in nature, so this idea is impractical for the energy crisis. Thermodynamics wins every time.
2
2
u/slapdashbr May 21 '12
Saying it "releases energy" is extremely misleading, because manufacturing Lithium Nitride is very energy-intensive. Obviously it has to have a lot of energy stored to break down carbon dioxide.
2
7
3
u/msutton4 May 21 '12
What about the laws of Thermodynamics?
9
u/ton2lavega May 21 '12 edited May 22 '12
Breaking covalent bonds releases energy, some is converted back into new covalent bonds, but the balance can be positive (hence exothermic reactions).
edit : I am wrong. As rush22 pointed out, breaking covalent bonds requires energy, and not the contrary as I suggested.
Think of combustion. I guess that's where the heat comes from in this reaction.
2
u/rush22 May 21 '12
No. Breaking bonds (whether covalent or ionic) requires energy.
2
u/ton2lavega May 22 '12
Damn you're right I don't know what I was thinking when I wrote that. Sorry, my bad, I'll edit it (keeping my original sentence though).
Thanks for the correction.
1
u/msutton4 May 21 '12
Nice. You think this can be a viable option for electricity generation?
→ More replies (4)
3
u/whitesox287 May 21 '12
instead of being cynical and finding any way possible to shoot this work down because your genius and intellect didn't come up with this, be fucking ecstatic that we are at least moving in the right way of protecting future generations than having everyone drive ugly ass cars with green leafs on them
2
u/Benign_Tempest May 21 '12
Hmm... I'd like to read to peer-reviewed literature on this one.
2
u/_delirium May 21 '12
There's a paper linked at the end of this article, in J. Phys. Chem. A.
I don't have any reason to doubt the reaction works, and is an interesting discovery. But I also doubt that it's in any way going to contribute to atmospheric CO2 reduction.
1
u/mirashii May 21 '12
Then you are welcome to click on the DOI which is linked to a peer-reviewed journal. If the peer-reviewed reference was not there, it would be removed from /r/science by a moderator. If you find posts without a reference to peer-reviewed literature, use the report button and send us a message.
1
u/EatingSteak May 21 '12
I'm quite certain it doesn't exist, and for a good reason.
→ More replies (1)
2
May 21 '12
Seems like fantastic advancements like this get buried by the press and never see the light of day. What ever happened to the kid that figured out a way to decompose plastic quickly?
1
1
1
u/Zebidee May 21 '12
I think the headline of the post "eats up the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide" has a horribly misleading sense of scale.
It's like saying that someone has discovered scotch and soda, which "eats up water as was responsible for the inundation of New Orleans during Hurricane Katrina."
1
u/Torus2112 May 21 '12
No one's asked the other obvious question; is this semiconductor useful? Is it cheaper? Better?
1
u/kleenur May 21 '12
Seems like (based on comments) that this is not the game changing silver bullet I thought when reading the article. Still it looks like a step in the right direction. Well played Science.
1
u/TehRawrz May 21 '12
I understand this is a good thing... But what's the pros and cons? Sure it could help with alot.. But what's the bad thing?
1
1
u/Qonold May 21 '12
Wait wait wait, if the 'eating' up of CO2 just releases energy, aren't we just putting more heat into the atmosphere?
1
u/psycoee May 21 '12
Yet another fraudulent claim from someone desperate for attention. There is no conceivable way that this could possibly make any sense as a solution for climate change for several obvious reasons. It also doesn't work as a semiconductor, given that the resulting material is extremely impure and low quality.
CO2 capture in general does not solve the problem at any reasonable scale. If it was an option, the easiest solution would be to plant more trees (which capture CO2 and do not require external energy or material input), then chop them down and make charcoal or paper out of them (and bury the resulting product somewhere).
How does this stuff get through peer review?
1
1
u/theBadgerJew May 21 '12
Whenever I read a post like this I just get cynical. I have been hearing about "new chemical reactions" and "bacteria that eat garbage and poop fuel", so where the fuck is this Shit? If it's so fucking brilliant and does what it says then let's fucking have it. And don't "but the corporations don't want..." Nonsense because the corporations don't want us downloading and yet the people with know how say fuck that, this is important to me. We need that attitude with science. Ugh. Rant over. Please be gentle with the downvotes.
1
u/Aceline May 22 '12
Well, often times it is possible but only really in the lab setting and there are often restrictions, such as specific growth conditions or in this case, lithium and the fact that it requires pure CO2 from what I understand, which prevent it from working on an industrial scale (along with politics and what have you). People often get excited and blow things out of proportion.
1
u/Laterface May 21 '12
All hail science, destroying my dream of a post apocalyptic society one breakthrough at time,..
1
u/j1ggy May 21 '12
One day we'll find the ultimate use for hydrocarbons. And there won't be any oil left.
1
1
1
u/THE_DOM May 21 '12
MTU is the best college north of the mackinac bridge, too bad it's not in Marquette. It is one of the only things that makes me proud to live in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan.
1
May 21 '12
TI REALISED that the di in dioxide is 2. How the flip wilson have i never realised that. I feel like an idiot because i speak 2 of the latin languages.. Je suis un grosse bête.
1
u/kurtu5 May 21 '12
And how much energy does it take to make Li3N?
Probably more that is released by reacting it with CO2 thats my guess.
1
1
u/defenastrator May 21 '12
I have a great chemical reaction that removes co2 from the air and energy it's in addition it does not require filtering. Its called photosyntsis. And if im not mistaken someone has found a viable way to do it synthetically as well
1
1
u/Alexcanfloat May 21 '12
the reaction is spontaneous and exothermic; however lithium is extremely reactive and to get it in the form of li3N would take up alot of energy; the reaction needs to consume energy to start, the overall reaction still uses energy; as converting gas to solid is counterproductive to entropy. this reaction pathway looks good on paper; but accomplishes nothing novel or even useful.
1
u/Kerpal May 21 '12
First i would like to say that it's a great discovery, everything that enhances our knowledge is worth spending. But isn't it a bit over the top to start removing CO2 from the atmosphere?
Plants are highly dependent on CO2, if we reduce the amount of CO2 to much wouldn't that make crops grow slower? what about agriculture? - food is already a scarcity.
By over the top i mean, isn't it better to reduce our emissions instead of developing other symptoms.
1
u/Benditlikebaker May 21 '12
I don't have anything smart to say but... Thanks for putting Michigan on the map guys :)
1
u/Im2grrr May 21 '12
The "scientific" argument in the comments of the article is enjoyable and semi educational.
1
u/hsfrey May 21 '12
And, how much energy does it take to make the LI3N?
It's not found in nature, because it reacts violently with water, so it's got to be produced.
All that energy it releases when it encounters CO2 (or water!) has to come from somewhere.
1
u/TrollingIsaArt May 22 '12
While of course this is not generally a magic bullet for CO2 emissions, the easily imagined meaning of the headline should describe the rational arguments against economically negative (i.e. mandated) emission reductions.
Technology will probably (even without directly focused research dollars) provide us better and more efficient ways to solve this issue in the coming decades. The humanistic benefits of waiting to solve this problem, may outweigh the negatives. That is why the question of how many degrees, and how fast (which still only have consensus in a relatively broad interval of uncertainty) are still vital highly relevant from a policy standpoint (i.e. it is an optimization problem with a number of variables, several of which will likely soon be much more concretely estimated).
1
u/CokeCanNinja May 22 '12
I was hoping for a machine that went like this: CO2 --> Diamonds+O2+energy
→ More replies (1)
1
u/flagship1 May 22 '12 edited May 22 '12
Lithium Nitride is so nasty you add water to this stuff and you still get an extremely strong base and ammonia:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_nitride
Too bad he had to use such a dangerous molecule, not to mention the limited supply of Lithium on the planet.
1
u/monkeyfishbone May 22 '12
This is the usual sensational bullshit and does not stand up to thermodynamic scrutiny. CO2 is near the bottom of the "energy ladder". CO2 reacts with a lot of things - all of the things its reacts with need to be made (other than molecules of "lower energy" eg quicklime). Making these molecules requires energy - more than what is released by reacting CO2. So, you are going backwards reacting CO2 with anything other than more stable molescules. Secondly, a 500MW power plant emits 10,000 tpd of CO2 - there is nothing that can be made with this for which a market exists of a size even close to this amount.
1
May 22 '12
That's the thing about thermodynamics: you can't win, and you can't really break even. I'm sure that the lithium nitride takes a whole lot of energy to make.
1
1
u/csmblair May 22 '12
i just hate how i always hear about amazing things like this, then never hear from them again...
1
u/fuzzyshorts May 22 '12
All I know is I'm keeping an eye on this story. I Just need a secret lab and some henchmen willing to kidnap the scientist and then I'll demand ONE. MILLION. DOLLARS!
1
u/KW710 May 22 '12
How much of the materials would you need to create a critical mass needed to power something such as a heat reactor? Is this a viable alternative to coal powered generators? Could you successfully convert the heat into enough electricity to make it worthwhile?
1
u/fervoredweb May 22 '12
Just read the article (the actual article by Dr. Hu and Dr. Huo), and it looks fairly good; again, as many have no doubt noticed by now, the whole operation is dependent upon Li reserves which are, sadly, much too valuable for any large scale implementation of this process. This concern is probably why we are reading about this now, many months after the article was published (2011, Sept. 12), as opposed to immediately after it was announced. Even so, it adds an interesting avenue of research into both the use of Li3N and the process of CO2 activation.
1
1
1
1
u/dizekat May 22 '12
Too bad making lithium nitride takes up more energy than this releases. Typical sensationalism. There's a zillion reactions that take in CO2, create something useful, and release less energy than was consumed making the reagent. Paranoid theory: news like this are promoted because they make it sound like we'll solve CO2 problem soon. Less paranoid theory: same but due to poor education rather than conspiracy.
1
u/moxfri May 25 '12
I love the title "the greenhouse gas" carbon dioxide. Cause we all know carbon dioxide has no other purpose... <.< .^ >.>
1
Jun 12 '12
To save on time (I'm in a rush), my question is short and sweet: Is this a potentially viable means of propulsion for air/space craft?
I would have read more comments but I got down about 10 and looked at the time. Sorry if this has already been asked!
1
u/glowingerectionman May 21 '12
if this becomes an option then the price of lithium batteries will go up
1
1
May 21 '12
Sounds like a plot to a great movie.
Politicians learn of this technique and create laws to have it utilized by all major energy companies. The scientist warns of possible un-intended consequences. Politicians laugh and say "Stop worrying! This is going to save humanity and you will be thanked generations from now!" Plan goes into effect and rain forests start dying from lack of CO2. Genius scientist devises formula to reverse effect. Scientist falls in love but the person loved dies the process of saving planet earth. We live to see another day.
1
u/hoss7071 May 21 '12
...discovered a chemical reaction that not only eats up the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide
It's called photosynthesis. Plants survive by consuming carbon dioxide. Unless you have not made it to an elementary school science level yet, it isn't a new concept.
1
May 21 '12
Anyone else upset by the end of this title? "And, by the way, it releases energy." Well of course it does. All chemical reactions release energy, don't they? Any change has an energy exchange, otherwise there's no reaction.
Maybe I'm wrong, if so, more info? If not, more info? (High school level education here)
0
May 21 '12
[deleted]
1
May 21 '12
I should have been a little more specific; High school education, in a hick town full of narrow minded people, graduated 5 years ago, and only took the minimum requirements (i.e. "earth science", and biology).
No way I would have remembered that ><
Anyways thank you.
1
u/Rakishdom May 21 '12
Wouldn't it be simplier to just to plant more plants to remove carbon dioxide and create something useful?
1
u/themightymekon May 22 '12
No, no amount of plants is enough to do the job on its own, though it helps a bit. More energy made by renewables like solar and wind, hydro and geothermal and low carbon sources like nuclear (instead of coal, gas and oil) is mostly what it takes to cut emissions. Solar (or night time wind) powered EVs instead of gas cars.
1
1
0
0
0
-1
u/Khaemwaset May 21 '12
Ummm, CO2 isnt bad. We're 1500 ppm below the avg, and our current levels are the bottom rung of where plants are able to thrive.
→ More replies (7)
1.1k
u/venomae May 21 '12
Ok, so whats the catch?