r/science • u/i_enjoy_science • May 10 '12
We decoded the nature of the leaf. Artificial leaf can turn water into hydrogen energy and oxygen, powered by sunlight.
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/05/120509123900.htm152
u/Sunhawk May 10 '12
Good to see advancement on this front. Could be pretty damn major, as it allows fuel production, sidestepping the battery issue for solar power.
Or you could arrange a closed cycle - water with this material spread throughout it, capture of the hydrogen in another part of the cell and recombining back into water when energy is extracted.
I don't see any mention of the efficiency of the conversion though - that could be an important issue.
91
u/thewazman May 10 '12
I work in the field (PhD candidate, just finished writing my thesis) and have studied Nocera's catalyst as well, although I am primarily involved with homogenous water splitting catalysis.
One of the main problems we're seeing with Nocera's catalyst is in long-term stability. While it is certainly a huge step in the right direction, Nocera's Co-oxide thin film water oxidation catalyst does not appear (to us at least) to be stable on the time-scale of days, and certainly not weeks when running continuously. While it is self-healing in the presence of Cobalt ions in solution, catalyst activity diminishes substantially over longer time periods, presumably as a result of leaching of the active film into solution and away from the electrode surface. This is the primary factor, in my opinion, that will hold back commercialization of these photoelectrochemical water-splitting technologies until an engineering work-around can be developed. Although it could be argued that "recharging" cycles could be incorporated to regenerate the active films.
To your efficiency inquiry, the Co-oxide films are very efficient at timescales of hours, certainly above 90%. I'm not certain about the ternary alloy, hydrogen-evolving side of the reaction, as this was only recently reported, and extensive studies have yet to appear. But I would suspect that given the requirements for the hydrogen evolution side of water-splitting, that the material would be rather stable for longer time periods.
While I am impressed in general with Nocera's water-splitting research, the actual utilization and commercialization of the technologies are not currently where they need to be in terms of wide-spread deployment. And yes, one could argue that they only recently appeared, there are still significant hurdles to be overcome.
→ More replies (7)45
u/MoonlitShadow May 10 '12
Do you think this can go beyond just fuel production though? Possibly into generators and large scale power operations?
I think it would be amazing for these to power a city.
49
May 10 '12
Nocera's goal isn't the typical centralized generator model, he's aiming for a distributed energy set up, with some of these in every house.
→ More replies (14)21
u/MoonlitShadow May 10 '12
Ah, that is true, a centralized setup would be a much larger gap to aim for. Having an artificial device in the backyard producing energy is much more tangible
→ More replies (18)9
u/lethic May 10 '12
Sometimes I wonder if we're simply trying to duplicate the efforts of scientists who spent huge amounts of time coming up with easily manufacturable, sustainable power sources long before us. I'm not advocating any sort of intelligent design, just being in awe of nature in general.
24
u/xzaramurd May 10 '12
Nature did have a head start of a few billion years. The first plants probably weren't nearly as efficient as today's plants.
→ More replies (2)15
u/deafcon May 10 '12
I wonder if it would work with salt water. generate fuel > burn for electricity > gain fresh water
10
u/thewazman May 10 '12
Nocera has actually done a study using water from the Charles river in Boston, and catalysis appears to work astonishingly well from decidedly "dirty" water.
→ More replies (3)6
u/Horst665 May 10 '12
That's a very good idea - I see a problem though, you would need to get rid of the salt inside the machine somehow. Salt, that is in the water you turn into H and O2 will begin to fall out and clog the machine, much more than the "normal" minerals in "sweetwater".
→ More replies (1)14
u/rayhond2000 May 10 '12
From the original paper:
Overall solar-to-fuels efficiencies (SFE) were observed to be as high as 4.7% (for a 7.7% solar cell) when Ohmic losses are minimized.
It seems like this process has a pretty good efficiency at converting water into hydrogen and oxygen (60% from the paper). the limiting factor was the photovoltaic efficiency which was hovering around 10%. So it seems like if they find more efficient photovoltaics, this could be a viable solution.
→ More replies (4)5
u/PancakesAreGone May 10 '12
Now if it works regardless of the water quality, that would be even more amazing. Meaning, muddy water, salt water, contaminated water, etc. If they could, and extract hydrogen and then combine it back into water, would that effectively decontaminate it as well or is that not how this works?
6
u/enhancin May 10 '12
If you boil water and condense it, it is called distilling. The same practice is used in making moonshine.
This process is similar and yes it would create very pure water depending on the contaminants in the combustion chamber.
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (2)4
u/FrogSkinBlanket May 10 '12
The cobalt oxide catalyst (the side that generates oxygen gas) works with a variety of water sources, including disgusting Charles River water from near MIT. It has also been run in sea water and works well. Using the catalyst as a way to purify water is an active research goal.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (10)22
u/kacattack May 10 '12
This seems vastly huge. Wow.
23
u/JJMcCoolio May 10 '12
It's about time. It always amazes me how simple nature appears, yet how vastly complex and rediculously tricky it is to artificially replicate.
→ More replies (2)36
u/dashik May 10 '12
Agreed. Though you have to realize that we are trying to achieve things within decades that took nature billions of years of trial and error to get right.
→ More replies (12)
25
u/lolmonger May 10 '12
I'd just like to point out that investment by Tata Group is a great sign - this is not a conglomerate that doesn't understand technology, and with a revenue in 2010-2011 upwards of 80 Billion, they aren't playing around either.
5
May 10 '12
I also place a great deal of weight on the fact that Bob Metcalfe is on their board. Bob invented ethernet when he was at Xerox, and he founded 3Com. He's not all that well known outside the computer industry, but he's one of the people who made huge contributions to networking as we know it.
→ More replies (3)
59
u/QuitReadingMyName May 10 '12
I remember seeing multiple times in /r/Science about the credibility of science daily being on par of "dailymail" and tabloids of the science community.
Either way amazing, but how much does it cost in terms of energy conversion. Also, how much water do you lose in the production of Hydrogen and oxygen?
Also, is this even cost efficient? Either way, this is big. Everything starts of small and works its way up to something bigger and more grand.
17
u/enhancin May 10 '12
It is cost efficient because they have recently found new materials to use instead of Platinum. Namely nickel-molybdenum-zinc and cobalt.
Since Platinum is a bajillion(not sure) times rarer than these we can assume that the price will drop quite a bit.
To make these devices more widely available, Nocera replaced the platinum catalyst that produces hydrogen gas with a less-expensive nickel-molybdenum-zinc compound. On the other side of the leaf, a cobalt film generates oxygen gas. Nocera notes that all of these materials are abundant on Earth, unlike the rare and expensive platinum, noble metal oxides and semiconducting materials others have used.
6
u/runvnc May 10 '12
OK but you still need to get molybdenum, which apparently usually comes from molybdenite. I am wondering if the energy required to convert molybdenite into molybdenum is less than the energy you can get out of it? Or maybe that isn't so important?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molybdenum#Occurrence
In molybdenite processing, the molybdenite is first heated to a temperature of 700 °C (1,292 °F) and the sulfide is oxidized into molybdenum(VI) oxide by air:[13]
→ More replies (1)16
u/Iazo May 10 '12
Catalysts do not get consumed in the chemical process. They are temporary reactants that find themselves back in their original form when the reaction ends.
That means that it doesn't matter how much energy is required to extract molybdenum, since once you have it, it can (theoretically) be used forever as a catalyst.
→ More replies (1)6
u/ELS May 10 '12
Well, according to the notice, the text was taken verbatim from a press release, so all Science Daily really does is find interesting things in science and put it on their website.
→ More replies (1)3
u/QuitReadingMyName May 10 '12
Yeah, I noticed that too in Science daily articles. But, I can't really find anything with Google that tears down/says science daily has zero credibility. Besides, that they just copy and past articles from other sites like Huffington Post would.
23
u/thebrownser May 10 '12
how much water do you lose in the production of Hydrogen and oxygen?
H2O -> 2H+O
62
→ More replies (3)24
2
u/gaso May 10 '12
The conclusion to the article was rather powerfully stated, I was wondering how much hyperbole was injected to drive up readership. 6/10?
→ More replies (6)2
u/ewkinder May 10 '12
It may be "daily mail" quality, but the article it links is a great one. There's also another one in Science that I'm actually doing research into to improve.
52
u/viborg May 10 '12
That was unnecessary editorializing of the title.
47
u/arcadeguy May 10 '12
And it's one of the very few r/science articles that has appeared on the front page of /all lately. I'll gladly hold my tongue regarding a stupid title if it means more people are going to read things besides rage comics and quotes in a calligraphic font on top of a picture of Carl Sagan.
→ More replies (1)4
May 10 '12
It's usually the most sensationalized headlines that get the attention. Which then leads to bitching in the comments, etc. etc.
→ More replies (4)11
u/kodo64 May 10 '12
An article very similar to this one was actually posted half a year ago, without a fancy title, and it received much less attention
http://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/kx5aq/mit_creates_an_artificial_leaf_that_produces_pure/
Sometimes it's a necessary evil
6
u/viborg May 10 '12
I would say that fallacious claim in scientific headlines do not construe a necessary evil.
39
u/LilHibachi May 10 '12
OP's title is misleading. The article doesn't seem to suggest that this technology works in the same manner as plant photosynthesis. We still don't fully understand the structure or mechanism of the oxygen-evolving complex.
→ More replies (13)
6
u/lukaslink May 10 '12
If you want to find out more about Daniel G. Nocera and the ‘Artificial leaf’ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZAkM_dV6CFs a lot of info about power consumption and why he is working on this .
→ More replies (1)2
May 10 '12
Thanks for the link. Hadn't seen that talk before. Also, from poptech. Much shorter, about 20 minutes.
6
May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Replicating the functionality of something doesn't mean you've decoded the nature of it. That almost sounds mystical.
35
u/friendlymechstudent May 10 '12
"Decoded the nature of a leaf" Just doesn't make any meaningful sense whatsoever.
9
May 10 '12
I think he meant, "decoded the biological mechanism of photosynthesis in leafy plants". But that's just me. You know, a person who speaks the English.
→ More replies (1)4
u/gordonj May 10 '12
But this work doesn't decode any biological mechanisms. It describes a chemical reaction to split water into H and O (2H20 + catalysts → 2H + 02) which is only a small aspect of and only partially analogous to photosynthesis in plants.
Biological photosynthesis is a combination of:
2 H2O + 2 NADP+ + 3 ADP + 3 Pi + light → 2 NADPH + 2 H+ + 3 ATP + O2
and
3 CO2 + 9 ATP + 6 NADPH + 6 H+ → C3H6O3-phosphate + 9 ADP + 8 Pi + 6 NADP+ + 3 H2O
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (4)2
11
u/losermcfail May 10 '12
how long before we can expect consumer availability of this technology?
22
May 10 '12
I went to a talk by Nocera, the lead researcher on this project. He has a lot of funding, I think it's planned for two or three years.
16
u/jeradj May 10 '12
Yeah, I saw one of his talks that got posted online where he mentioned that among his backers was the Tata group of India -- whose top guy is one of the wealthiest men in the world, ratan tata.
→ More replies (1)6
10
u/BillW87 May 10 '12
That's encouraging. My general rule of thumb for whether a breakthrough is actually going to be commercially viable is take the planned development time (2-3 years), divide it by 10 (.2-.3), convert to a percentage (20-30%), and then subtract from 100% (70-80%). So by my highly unscientific prediction there's a 70-80% chance we'll see something commercially viable come out of this. Protip - if a research group says their project is 10 or more years away from being monetized, that's generally another way of saying, "we know this is completely unprofitable research, but don't tell that to the people who gave us the grant."
→ More replies (4)2
u/Pilx May 10 '12
In North America, never. In other parts of the world that aren't run by corrupt oil mongering politicians, hopefully very soon!
15
u/Hempire May 10 '12
I'm no scientist but so far the general consensus is that is legitimate good news and not another one of those "cures for cancer" that come out every other week
5
u/darien_gap May 10 '12
True, lack of cynicism in redditor comments could be interpreted as "holy shit, this might be real."
5
u/thewho521 May 10 '12
It seems like the bottom will have to be - is it cheaper than conventional solar energy? Essentially, both processes rely on harnessing sunlight and creating energy directly (conventional solar panels) or converting it to hydrogen (artificial leaf). Differing degrees of efficiency and practicality will also play big factors in judging the new leaf against existing technologies. Link explaining science behind photocatalytics.
→ More replies (1)
4
u/ninjajazza May 10 '12
The wikipedia article about the paper's author, Daniel Nocera, is interesting then suddenly incredibly sad.
→ More replies (2)
3
u/ZFrostbite92 May 10 '12
Does this mean anything for space stations or space travel? Like longer trips that can support life or self sufficient spacecraft?
3
u/sonic4031 May 10 '12
I did a case study on this. Berkeley is working on artificial photosynthesis to produce liquid hydrogen from carbon dioxide. This can be an endless source of energy for hydrogen fuel cells, while cleaning up carbon dioxide emissions in the atmosphere.
5
u/FrogSkinBlanket May 10 '12
Just to clarify a bit... you can't make liquid hydrogen from carbon dioxide unless you are performing nuclear chemistry. The Berkeley approach is to split water to make hydrogen and oxygen, and then use the hydrogen to reduce carbon dioxide to liquid fuels, such as methanol. The first step is identical to what Nocera is doing, but they take it one step further in that the hydrogen is then used in further chemical transformations. This is especially attractive because liquid hydrocarbons are a lot easier to manipulate and use than hydrogen gas.
→ More replies (2)
3
u/ElQuesito May 10 '12
Realistically, how many years will go by before there's a practical use for this? And what are the practical uses?
I hate when I see an article about awesome stuff like this and then I never hear about it again.
3
u/DrugL0rd May 10 '12
They will never decode the nature of the leaf until their solution can grow on trees
5
u/T3ppic May 10 '12
Thats not how leaves work... so now its come down to lying by analogy /r/scienceEntertainment. Well played.
2
4
u/Barder07 May 10 '12
Could it be used in salt water?
→ More replies (1)3
u/travisklein May 10 '12
Good question for people that don't know what much about chemistry. I believe this technology splits water (H2O) into Hydrogen (H), plus Oxygen (O). Salt water isn't actually different than normal water when you get down to the actual water molecules (H2O), it just has other things dissolved into it etc. These shouldn't effect the technology besides leaving behind residue, like salt in salt flats.
4
6
May 10 '12
What's hydrogen energy?
5
u/llsmithll May 10 '12
you can burn hydrogen much like a combustible gas, H2 + O2 => Energy and H20
→ More replies (10)
2
u/Troll_Sauce May 10 '12
Why such an odd journal? Seems to me that something this revolutionary could have gone to Nature etc...
→ More replies (1)
2
May 10 '12
you know this just changed the world when you go to the comments and nobody explains why the article is bull-shit.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/HoopDreamsDaily May 10 '12
We're going to be able to live on different planets in the not so distant future. That is awesome!
2
May 10 '12
no offense /r/science but this is sort of old news. why is this just popping up now? its an awesome piece of R&D none the less though. i don't understand why nobody cared earlier.
→ More replies (5)
2
u/detonatoralligator May 10 '12
This wont be commercially available unless we can charge for it. Probably something similar and with the same level of ludicrousness as metering data flow.
→ More replies (3)
2
u/yasepo May 10 '12
Does this mean that if we managed to find a planet with water and some sort of atmosphere, then we could artificially create oxygen to allow us to live on it? Discoveries (if I may call them that) like these really make my imagination wonder, the future is looking rather bright. :)
2
u/yourwhiteshadow May 10 '12
i always thought my publication in JACS was worthless because its impact factor isn't as high. now i feel much better about myself.
2
u/Aspire101 May 10 '12
Does anyone else at all think this may be a bit of a waste of water? That was my immediate reaction when I heard it took water to power fuel cells...
→ More replies (1)2
u/petertclo May 10 '12
The actual report says that the cell works in seawater, riverwater, etc.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/SuperSecretAgentMan May 10 '12
This isn't new. This has been in the news for the past three years.
2
u/tallwookie May 10 '12
sooo.... instead of the hydrogen binding with the carbon to form hydrocarbates (and thus feeding the plant), the hydrogen is released from the solution to be captured?
2
u/Ghstfce May 10 '12
Why do I have a feeling I read this same article years ago??
→ More replies (2)
2
May 10 '12
I don't like the internet because I hear about all these great inventions but they usually never have a hope in hell of being developed into a product.. So here I am thinking that we're this amazingly smart and advanced human race but the ideas are never realised.
It's the biggest let down ever. I'd rather just hear about the stuff that actually becomes a product.
2
u/BrainSex May 10 '12
This may have already been asked, and I apologize if this is a dumb question, but does it work in salt water or dirty/muddy/contaminated water?
Or does it require a relatively clean source of fresh water? If so, the procurement of sufficient quantities of fresh water might be problematic to a large scale implementation would it not?
2
u/TylerDurdenJunior May 10 '12
I love how people watching television and selling used cars says "we" about scientific achievement.
2
u/johnmudd May 10 '12
The author acknowledges support from the National Science Foundation
So this belongs to the people, right?
2
u/darkr3actor May 10 '12
Decode the nature of the leaf's all you want. They still cant find a way for the Leaf's to win a Stanley Cup.
2
2
u/pewwpewpew May 10 '12
Um so, this guy made a solar cell that does electrical hydrolysis? Haven't we been doing this for years and the only novel part is using a solar cell to do it?
2
2
u/galaxym100 May 10 '12
Great I just hope it goes into production soon and is more than a story. I am so tired of such stories ---- I want a happy ending now.
4
May 10 '12
So, before I get my hopes up, why isn't this going to work, reddit?
2
u/ActualContent May 10 '12
It seems like the general consensus is that it will. First time I've ever sad an article on /r/science that didn't have a dozen comments refuting the idea.
→ More replies (2)2
u/redshield3 PhD|Chemical Engineering|Biomass Pyrolysis May 10 '12
Chemical engineer (catalysis researcher) here. This guy's with MIT and he has a good PR department. This is more or less just plain ol' electrolysis with an interesting twist on mass transport and electricity supply. It's primarily limited by the effectiveness of the solar cell material. It is cheaper than platinum, for sure, but I haven't seen a full breakdown of the reaction kinetics yet, or the energy budget for the reaction, or the cost of the manufacturing process, or the surface area/volume ratio... So it's hard for me to actually begin to assess the reality of this solution.
Here's a nature article (from last year, by the way - this is hardly new news) that explains that a little bit.
4
u/Gavither May 10 '12
Ladies and gentlemen;
Say it with me.. "time to terraform Mars!?"
→ More replies (1)2
u/darien_gap May 10 '12
My first thought was making electricity and rocket fuel on the moon if there's water in the S. pole crater.
3
2
u/bohemianmichfestie May 10 '12
We need to invest in this and replace dirty energy and move on as an ecosystem past the distractive behaviors of the past century... but what about the oil companies, oh someone please think about the poor helpless oil companies!
2
2
u/SludgeMunkey May 10 '12
This is another case of "journalists" misunderstanding the facts:
This is not an artificial leaf, it is a photo-voltaic cell that generates hydrogen via electrolysis...which does not work in pure water...the presence of mineral salts in solution is required for conductivity.
Photosynthesis produces various carbohydrates with O2 as waste utilizing sunlight and darkness in the presence of N2, O2 and CO2.
Gaseous hydrogen is not a viable, stable fuel source, no matter the method of generation utilizing current affordable technology at this time.
1
u/nosoupforyou May 10 '12
I wonder if anyone will try to reverse it, and generate sunlight from water and hydrogen.
That could end up being a lightscreen. Instead of a bulb, it would be a screen giving off light. Of course, the drawback of water coming off could be bad.
→ More replies (6)
1
1
1
1
u/SchadeyDrummer May 10 '12
Can I get a TL;DR from one of reddit's fine scientific community? Thank you.
→ More replies (3)
1
u/kodo64 May 10 '12
Here's a Video
I wrote a paper on this a while ago actually, this is the article I used.
http://web.mit.edu/newsoffice/2011/artificial-leaf-0930.html
1
u/tehMorag May 10 '12
Why does this feel like an article that a scifi would zoom into during filming? Haha
1
u/wx_reader May 10 '12
"Kill him with fire. Oh, wait, a whole bunch of people have heard about this already? Then let's just hope this ends up in the dust bin of Reddit energy posts of past. We have good odds"
1
1
1
May 10 '12
So, here's what I'd like to know: what determines the limit of how rapidly these devices can separate water? Is it the surface area of the catalyst? The temperature of the water? Would it help to have a collector concentrating the light on the device?
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Oreiad May 10 '12
Imagine a layer of this under clear fiberglass laid out over all of the pavement everywhere. O.O
1
1
1
1
May 10 '12
Another "save the world" energy device that uses ITO. Yawn (until there's a practical replacement).
1
1
u/mrfurious May 10 '12
"Our ancestors harnessed the power of a sun, and so again shall we."
Comissioner Pravin Lal, "The Science of Our Fathers", Datalinks
1
u/IwillMakeYouMad May 10 '12
I used to do that. I used to dream about sci-fi movies being real. I used to wonder that as a kid. Now my kids will have to dream about something wonderful so that it will become truth.
1
u/AzzaFaz May 10 '12
is this related to the decoding of the photosystemII molecule? sorry i'm not so insightful but i'd love an explanation of how this really works, as far as my knowledge extends we didnt know how the molecule really worked and this was the limiting factor on producing the natural products of photosynthesis
1
u/downthecrapper May 10 '12
What we read "New technology to make energy cheaper and more sustainable" verses what will happen "Prices for energy stay mostly the same and slowly increase while the costs decrease excessively"
1
1
u/vishun May 10 '12
I may become an engineer hugger. Even though the first man made leaf would weigh 100 lbs, I am so proud of us!
→ More replies (1)
1
1
May 10 '12
I love the WE in the title. We as in "humanity", i guess. Makes me feel as if i personally made some contribution.
1
u/gunnin_and_runnin May 10 '12
Perfect for those trips to anywhere beyond this planet. This coupled with that urine recycling machine would solve 2 major issues for long distance space travel. Plus you could use the hydrogen as fuel.
1
1
1
1
May 10 '12
I have read before that trees follow a fractal pattern for how the leaves are spaced, and that this is actually the most efficient way of collecting sunlight than a flat solar panel.
I can envision groves artificial trees with these artificial leaves collecting sunlight!
1
1
u/optionsanarchist May 10 '12
There's a lot of talk about using the hydrogen for energy, but what about the oxygen? Could this technology be used by scuba divers to produce oxygen while submerged?
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/PC-Bjorn May 10 '12
So when can we put these in jars, hang them outside our windows, collect the hydrogen and fuel our hydrogen cars with the gas?
1
1
1
1
May 10 '12
That looks/sounds really cool. Being able to generate our own H or O with such ease would be pretty amazing.
One question, the article mentions using metal films as catalysts, I don't really understand the interactions very well, but how long would a system like this last? Would the metals ever 'run out of juice'?
1
1
1
u/The_GhostofHektik May 10 '12
Holy fuck, is Reddit this sensationalist... do you guys honestly think Transformer was a documentary?
We decoded a goat+, i didn't think leafs were that complex. Hydrogen and Oxygen... you Mean Fuel Cell? How about, how is Hydrogen stored. That's our current issue. Can we improve that field to benefit us as a whole?
1
1
1
May 10 '12
Is this really feasible in all of the components though? Recently I was viewing an infographic about the costs of iPhone production on the environment and I was pretty sure that cobalt mining was mentioned as being bad for the environment and that in a lot of places where cobalt is mined the work conditions are horrendous and are in countries with terrible worker's rights.
1
u/waterseer May 10 '12
As a Biologist, I am extremely excited, and have high hopes for this engineering marvel.
1
u/miellaby May 10 '12
A bit off-topic but can someone explain me some strategies about how to store the amount of oxygen and hydrogen so produced?
For example, let's imagine I build such a solar panel in my backyard. How could I prevent it to explode? How could I store Hydrogen in a small container?
1
1
u/Alexanderdaawesome May 10 '12
how the hell are there 4200 or so downvotes? I really want to know what mindset that causes this, or is it bots? There is not even like a 70% like percentage to a really good post. ever. what is up with reddit?
1
May 10 '12
I was on board with Dan G Nocera when I first heard about him, but now I'm not sure. This article provides some healthy skepticism, but I don't know for sure if they have an agenda of their own or are misinterpreting his research
1
u/Hidemesometime May 10 '12
So, this doesn't use CO2 at all though, am I right? Sounds like we still have a long way to go if not.
1
1
1
1
u/eboss28 May 10 '12
"These self-contained units are attractive for making fuel for electricity in remote places and the developing world, but designs demonstrated thus far rely on metals like platinum and manufacturing processes that make them cost-prohibitive." How come it says its inexpensive and has cheap manufacturing cost and then says that 5 paragraphs later?
1
1
u/brucecrossan May 10 '12
When can we actually take into the electrical energy released form chlorophyll, and turn trees into 99% efficiency solar panels?
1
u/Makes_You_Smile May 10 '12
This is awesome, and is also the last time you will ever hear of it. Back to fossil fuels for us.
1
1
u/antnx May 10 '12
I just wish that they won't kill this project just like they killed electric car and other innovative stuff. Those Pesky Corporations and their need for Huge profits.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
u/agentmage2012 May 10 '12
How much power is required to convert enough water into hydrogen to power a hydrogen car to a "full tank" let's say?
Also, what are the current "average generating hours" on a moderately sunny day of solar generators, if anyone knows offhand, per square ft?
1
u/Shaun_R May 10 '12
Brilliant, thank you for this. Needed an article for Environmental Science class, looks like I found it!
1
u/Gingestar May 10 '12
This poses a dilemma for bear grylls .... Power the car or drink my own wee? Hmmm
1
May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Plants do not split H2O into hydrogen and oxygen! The process that plants use is called carbon sequestration in which plants break up CO2 into carbon and oxygen! The ability to do hydrolysis with electrical (or solar for that matter) energy has been around for hundreds of years. The 2H20 => 2H2 + O2 process does not occur in ANY biological organism that I know of.
1
u/josephanthony May 10 '12
As we speak, the oil companies and government are putting on their 'Blackmail and Bribe' pants.
1
u/sp4mfilter May 10 '12
Fascinating phrase: "6 billion nonlegacy users". What are the other 1 billion users called?
1
u/CelticSavage May 10 '12
They'd better have very high security for this tech. Oil companies would pay very big money for scientist involved to disappear along with their research.
This is what humanity should be researching and it's encouraging to hear about these type of advancements.
1
u/sp4mfilter May 10 '12
Because this actually splits the water molecules apart, it actually 'destroys' the water itself in the process. Water is not released from the system in the form of steam or in any other way: water (H2-O) goes in and is separated into H2 and O. So, we also need a way to produce water if this is really 'renewable'.
3
u/mfenniak May 10 '12
2H2(g) + O2(g) --> 2H2O(g)
Burning hydrogen consumes oxygen in the atmosphere, and produces water.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/sp4mfilter May 10 '12
Unless I misunderstand the process, turning water into energy could be the worse thing ever invented by man.
1
u/Aozi May 10 '12
Well this is pretty amazing. I hope this stuff goes into mass production soon. I mean, we could literally plate our buildings with this to create actual cities that rather than pollution, produce oxygen and energy in a self sustained and clean way.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
u/conpermiso May 10 '12
My concern with this process is that it requires a necessity (water) to create a luxury (fuel). This has the potential to recreate the food shortages caused by excessive ethanol production.
1
1
May 10 '12
Its pretty awesome, BUT. Leaves dont turn water into hydrogen, energy and oxygen, then turn CO2 into that.
1
1
u/deep_pants_mcgee May 10 '12
Not intended, but would this be a cheap way to generate clean water from sea water as well?
1
u/ShadowRam May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Doesn't Hydrogen just escape the atmosphere and is gone, like Helium?
If we went full scale with something like this, could we eventually dry up our water resources by losing Hydrogen to the atmosphere?
350
u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
I wish the article went into more detail about how it worked.
They mentioned that there are two sides to this artificial leaf: one side consists of nickel-molybdenum-zinc, and produces hydrogen when exposed to sunlight. The other consists of cobalt and produces oxygen when exposed to sunlight.
What is the mechanism behind that? If it were a photovoltaic (solar) cell, then there would need to be an applied voltage to separate the negatively charged electrons and positively charged holes when sunlight hit the apparatus. There isn't.
If the device were a traditional chemical catalyst that allowed hydrolysis to occur at lower energies, them I would expect the device to use proteins with a unique shape that allowed water molecules to fit perfectly inside a crevice inside the protein. And yet the device is made of metal.
Does anyone else have any ideas?
Edit: this is actually brontina's field of study. Ask him anything.