r/science • u/phileconomicus • May 08 '12
Psychiatry's "Bible" Gets an Overhaul: Psychiatry's diagnostic guidebook gets its first major update in 30 years. The changes may surprise you
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=redefining-mental-illness549
u/Handout May 08 '12
This is my favorite addition:
Absexual Disorder
Feeling aroused by moving away from sexuality or behaving as though moralistically opposed to sex. As sex educator Betty Dodson told Canadian newspaper Xtra! West, these are “folks who get off complaining about sex and trying to censor porn.” —F.J.
272
20
u/someonewrongonthenet May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
My first instinct is to say that this is ridiculous. My second instinct is: hey, psychology is a respectable science, right? If there is a disorder in the DSM, it must have some basis in reality, right?
In that spirit, can someone please link me to some scientific paper documenting scientific evidence for the existence of people who are sexually aroused by being moralistically opposed to sex? I've been searching in vain...
It's possible that they are referring to the whole "spank me I've been a bad girl", "oh gosh this is so naughty," type of thing, but somehow I highly doubt that this is what they meant...
11
→ More replies (14)10
u/Diogenes71 May 08 '12
Absexual appears to have been deleted from the proposed revision. It appears to have been an attempt by a specific doctor to get her coined term recognized by the profession. If this particular behavior is actually a "thing" that some people do, it would probably fall under a Dx of a more general paraphilia.
60
u/GreatGo0glyMo0gly May 08 '12
Wait till the religious right find some of their own are getting off on keeping others from getting off.
→ More replies (3)32
u/genai May 08 '12
They've been actively ignoring/denying this for a long time.
→ More replies (1)22
u/Engineers_Disasters May 08 '12
Well they have too, lest they give rise to a group that gets off on keeping others from getting off on keeping others from getting off.
→ More replies (4)45
u/appleseed1234 May 08 '12
I'm just waiting for them to add "Diagnosis Disorder: Feeling the need to label every single idiosyncrasy as some type of disorder."
→ More replies (7)29
u/Yst May 08 '12
Oddly, it's usually the opposite criticism psychopathology faces: that because it does not consider an idiosyncrasy to be a disorder unless it causes distress, it does not judge enough. Moralists have trouble with the idea that, say, your uncle's fondness for dressing up iguanas in tutus, then suffocating them in vats of jam while doing a raindance featuring seven distinct types of self-flagellation doesn't actually constitute or imply a disorder if it doesn't negatively impact (or imply a condition which negatively impacts) his quality of life. The idea doesn't mesh with the notion that there is one right way of life, which one ought follow.
→ More replies (2)10
u/Shogouki May 08 '12
Well it certainly impacts the quality of life for the iguanas! Does that not count? :(
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (29)10
u/HooDidDis May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
I bet this diagnosis will be removed in the next revision (DSM VI).
4
u/boomfarmer May 08 '12
Next major revision is likely to be the DSM-6, since the new revision is DSM-5. They stepped away from Roman numerals so they could do DSM-5.1
→ More replies (1)
377
u/atheistjubu May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Fun fact: it took until 1974 to get homosexuality removed as a mental disorder.
EDIT: My dad (psychiatrist) pointed this out to me as an example of why a psychiatrist's individual judgement is also important to the process, and why the DSM is just a taxonomy book, not an encyclopedia.
197
May 08 '12
If not a disorder, but still a deviation from normal, what is homosexuality? A trait?
263
May 08 '12
I don't envy the men who have to come up with a polite descriptor for strong deviancies that aren't detrimental.
235
→ More replies (26)61
u/masterzora May 08 '12
Do we really need to? "Strongly deviant but not detrimental" sexualities are estimated to be more prevalent than green eyes worldwide but we don't have a polite descriptor for people with green eyes; we say they have green eyes.
→ More replies (25)36
u/kstein1110 May 08 '12
What about left-handedness (not sure if this is a word)? I knew my brother was disordered!
→ More replies (6)41
May 08 '12
Living in a right handed world is more difficult than you'd think. I'm constantly called clumsy for trying to adapt to this backwardsness. That being said, I'm currently filling my house with various left handed items to confuse and annoy my guests. HA HA HA! NOW YOU WILL KNOW MY SUFFERING!!!
→ More replies (17)42
u/Plumerian May 08 '12
I don't think we know for sure. Sexuality, even among homosexuals, falls on a nameless continuum.
→ More replies (7)36
u/Hypersapien May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Maybe we need to have a name for it. Kinsey started the work. Someone needs to continue it.
Check me on this, but even in societies that condoned, and even encouraged, homosexual behavior, they didn't split people up into "homosexuals" and "heterosexuals". 20th century western culture is the first one to "decide" that people are either one or the other.
Edit: Quotes around "decide"
→ More replies (24)→ More replies (124)4
May 08 '12
Orthonormal behavior.
Duh.
Real answer: many contend that the idea of normal behavior needs to be scrapped entirely and be based on a "symptom management" plan instead. The idea that anyone fits close to an average is absurd as everyone has millions of quirks and the average isn't even defined. Instead, it's much more convenient and useful to use symptom management as a form of diagnosis - if they have social anxiety and it's treated, they have an anxiety disorder. If you're not treating it, it's obviously not a disorder, just a quirk.
This is an imperfect method, but it does allow for a margin of error on the side of the psychiatrist/psychologist so that they feel safe in their diagnosis and in changing their diagnosis, allowing them more bold treatments (and simultaneously, more haphazard or even negligent treatments) to give them time and space to better analyze treatment options.
7
May 08 '12
why a psychiatrist's individual judgement is also important to the process
The flip side of that is that you can be denied treatment for no real reason or flat out prejudice, and then have no recourse for compensation when you're mistreated, since the diagnosis is just a judgement call, and hence it can be almost impossible to prove that it was unjustified.
12
u/Redcorns May 08 '12
Great fact -- thanks. And Gender Identity Disorder is still in there, as far as I've seen.
43
u/stompanie May 08 '12
GID is a sticky issue, but it remains in the DSM because it's a mental-physical disconnect that can cause a lot of distress in the patient. Most people don't disagree that it should be treated by psychologists/psychiatrists, but do disagree about the word "disorder" being in the name. Treatment doesn't involve telling a patient that they're wrong for feeling as though they were assigned the wrong gender, but trying to help them come to a non-dissonant place mentally (and many times, with GID, physically). Which, I'm sure, is something a lot of people still do for homosexuality; go to therapy to learn coping mechanisms for this "new" self they've discovered. Not to become straight.
5
u/Redcorns May 08 '12
Sure, totally -- I think you hit it on the head. It's a diag so the people who our culture hurts can get treatment for that hurt -- not to "fix" who they are or anything like that. But, simultaneously, they're hurt by the diagnosis/stigmatized by its being a "disorder" as you pointed out because that allows folks to see them as "officially" different/abnormal/etc. It's definitely a sticky situation.
→ More replies (2)13
67
May 08 '12
How would that not be a disorder? I mean, even if you think you literally have a female brain in a male body, that's a disorder right? Something unfortunate has happened if your brain and body don't feel like a match.
→ More replies (21)→ More replies (2)13
u/mmmm_whatchasay May 08 '12
From what professors have told me, they'd rather keep it in so that transgendered people can get some of their medications and procedures covered by insurance.
→ More replies (1)15
u/whitchan May 08 '12
This is actually false. Insurance companies use this inclusion as a reason to categorize the disorder as pathological, meaning therapy is sufficient to cure the ailment. Therefore, procedures such as FFS, SRS, BA, mastectomy, and hysterectomy are often categorized as purely cosmetic, and therefore not covered. These procedures are the bulk expense of transitioning, medically speaking, and are recommended by the WPATH version 6.1.
→ More replies (7)2
u/_delirium May 08 '12
There's been an ongoing acrimonious debate over the sex-related disorders still in there as well. It looks like DSM-5 is going to soften the definition of paraphilias, so that, for example, people who engage in consensual S&M are not considered mentally ill, if it doesn't cause serious problems in their life. Under the DSM-IV criteria many doctors (especially in more liberal countries) have been de-facto using that qualifier anyway, but it's not really written into the official criteria.
2
May 08 '12
What is even more interesting is that the argument for its removal was that it wasn't something they were born with, it was a choice.... which is quite contradictory to current views.
→ More replies (74)2
175
u/wellscounty May 08 '12
Hope they get a better handle on PTSD and Combat Stress related trauma. Very interested to see where they go in these categories.
179
20
u/VictorRomeo May 08 '12
Kinda Related: I'd like to see them affirm Complex-PTSD (C-PTSD) in a more diagnosable context. For those from a "fucked up life" who've never seen combat.
p.s. Also a former vet5
u/genfinelineius May 08 '12
PTSD was never defined with combat in context. Could be witnessing a murder or a bad accident. My beef with the d/o is when folks (media or legal) use it to excuse or explain acts of violence or aggression.
78
May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Shit, even if they do, the people sending other people to war need to understand these things, and start being proactive toward mitigating the psychological effects of war. It's not like this shit is new, talk to any Vietnam vet about "flashbacks", this has been going on for decades.
I went to war a while back, the extent of psychological "treatment" I received was a group de-briefing. Basically a "Raise your hand if" kind of thing, as if ANY of these battle-weary men were going to say "Yeah, I have a problem with my brain" in front of their friends.
It was embarrassing. It's several years later...a lot of guys in my unit have had problems. Several are in jail, at least one is dead, I know more than a few who have fallen into drug abuse/self-medication...because the people who sent them to war basically figured that getting shot at/seeing death every day for a year wouldn't have any significant lasting effect on their minds.
27
u/stapletaper May 08 '12
"Raise your hand if"? That's absurd! Running a unit isn't running a kindergarten class.
When I delivered my baby, I wasn't even asked in front of other nurses, the same nurses who would be there when I was in hospital after the birth, whether I had a history of post-partem depression.
That's quite depressing, I'm sorry that you've had to endure such loss because of that kind of ignorance.
22
May 08 '12
I've heard that some improvements are being made in identifying soldiers who are having problems. There is still a long way to go, and as I understand it, treatment is still pathetic at best.
A big problem is that the VA gets to deal with most of it. Soldiers who are identified as having significant psychological trauma are going to be medically discharged, if they don't ETS (i.e., voluntarily leave at the end of a term) first. The VA is entirely hamstrung by being deprived of adequate funding and laughable mismanaged into an impossible-to-navigate bureaucracy. Shit, just getting the education benefits I rightfully earned was like pulling teeth...every damned semester, fill out a ream of paperwork and send it to ten different agencies, along with other things I've sent to them a dozen times before (How many copies of my DD214 DO YOU FUCKERS NEED??). Luckily, my school's VA advocate was incredible and made things go by easier than other guys I talked to...
If the military in the US is going to start taking care of the people it is breaking, they need to properly fund the VA, and remove all of the ridiculous hoops soldiers need to jump through just to get any kind of service. They need to get their heads out of their asses and create a decent information network that will streamline things like this, and sort out a way to let soldiers and veterans get competent care from qualified individuals in a timely manner.
Until then, all of the "thank you for your service"'s we get are empty, patronizing gestures from a government that chewed us up and spit us out.
The joke we always had, when we talked about how Uncle Same treats Joe? "You can't spell soldier without S.O.L."
When you realize how this country REALLY treats veterans, it becomes a lot harder to have pride in your service.
→ More replies (12)13
u/wellscounty May 08 '12
oh you know their (political / capital ) brains don't work like that, they too often rely on an ideology that we are all in this together until something is wrong with you...then its YOUR FAULT. it goes like this "AMERICA NEEDS HER DAUGHTER/SON, FIGHT FOR HER." "NOT BAD, GO GET A JOB NOW" "IN JAIL? DRUGS? ANGER? SOCIALIZATION PROBLEMS? WHY DID YOU LET THAT HAPPEN?"
Seriously though, a lot of the battle could be over before it began if we would adjust our "soldier" cookie cutter to allow for the acceptance of feelings that don't really fit as of now. ( yes these men and women do get scared and sometimes make mistakes in the moment that are haunting to the limit, yes they are going to cry from time to time, Yes friendly fire will happen, NO we don't want any of that at all ever, but when things like that happen (assuming war is going to continue) we need the cookie cutter to include these aspects so that we don't have real people unable to confront their real emotions because their FAKE persona doesn't allow for it or has been smashed into their reality so hard they don't remember what that real person is anymore. I hope that you are confronting your experiences head on and hopefully with the help of loved ones and professionals weather or not it seems necessary. More people like yourself need to take the time to write it down, raise their hand, and say "HEY, if your going to give me and my buddies Benadryl for our night terrors, WE ARE ALL GOING TO HAVE A BAD TIME!"
Thanks for sharing.
3
u/greengordon May 08 '12
the people sending other people to war need to understand these things
They don't care. Really, they don't. Were Cheney, Bush II, Rumsfeld, etc concerned? Not apparent from their actions.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (20)3
u/TheGOPkilledJesus May 08 '12
They're sending you to war for their profit, if it messes up your brain in the process that's just collateral damage. Do you really think the career generals, politicians, and the corporate military industrial complex see you as anything but a grunt with a rifle? I can't believe people honestly believe send you off to war in the interests of a nation rather than for greed. Vietnam was the ultimate proof of this.
→ More replies (4)14
May 08 '12
PTSD just isn't for soldiers. Anyone that experiences any sort of traumatic or stressful event can get it to some degree.
→ More replies (4)2
u/TurboGranny May 08 '12
I thought they had already discovered that group therapy with PTSD patients on Ecstasy was a very effective treatment.
→ More replies (6)2
u/scamperly May 08 '12
I feel like we should drop the D, as post traumatic stress is a totally normal reaction, not a disorder.
90
u/ThePwnR4nger May 08 '12
This article extremely oversimplifies a lot of things. Dsm5.org is the best resorce to see the changes and their rationales, for those who are interested.
→ More replies (23)24
u/cdcox Grad Student | Neurobiology of Learning and Memory | Depression May 08 '12
Or DSM-V Watch for a more critical (though biased in it's own way) look. So popular the APA made them change their URL and site name.
637
May 08 '12
The revised manual will very likely scrap psychiatry staples such as Asperger’s syndrome
Hoo-boy.
165
u/random12345 May 08 '12
They just move it into Autism Spectrum Disorder, it's really not a big deal from what I can tell. The criteria for ASD appears to be the same or extremely similar as for Asperger's Syndrome.
66
u/nypon May 08 '12
ASD is a spectrum. People who might previously have fallen under aspergers would simply fall under a category of ASD.
For example: Aspergers would be, lets say ASD 3, while someone with severe autism might have a 9. While most people might have a 1. or something like that.
Im not sure how it will work, but i think most people could have some degree of ASD. How high on the scale is whats relevant.
→ More replies (13)→ More replies (1)46
u/spirit_of_radio May 08 '12
As a parent of a child with Aspergers (officially diagnosed), I don't have too much problem with this. Most people who met the criteria from Aspergers will meet the criteria for ASD. I feel very bad for those few who don't, as they will lose access to all sorts of government services, which they need.
But, I do have a problem with one aspect - it takes the biggest problem with the Aspergers label and makes it worse. Aspergers is not high functioning autism, it's highly verbal autism.
Autism has many traits, and one is affected differently by each one. Kids with Aspergers are high functioning verbally, but that does not mean they are high functioning socially, behaviourally...
I would label my son low functional Aspergers. He's fully verbal, but very severe impairment socially and behaviourally. Calling him high functioning ASD give a false picture of him.
→ More replies (30)2
u/Luminessence May 08 '12
But Asperger's has always been a type of autism; this change just reflects the nature of it more accurately. And functioning levels are so fluid that it doesn't make sense to group them into separate disorders. (Plus, the change will make it harder for people to shut down discussion with things like, "You don't have the right to talk about this; you just have Asperger's, not REAL autism.")
And if there really are people out there who just want to use Asperger's as an excuse, maybe the change will scare them away since they won't want to be seen as having something in common with low-functioning autistic people.
8
u/dossier May 08 '12
It could just be a double blind experiment to see if the nature of Asperger's changes when they're told it's not a syndrome at all.
→ More replies (3)4
May 08 '12
Yea why is this?
65
May 08 '12
I assume it would be in favor of autism spectrum.
5
May 08 '12
Yup, I heard it was being replaced with ASD. Are they sticking with the AQ test or moved on to something more thorough?
→ More replies (23)29
May 08 '12
It's not being dropped per se, just dropped as a seperate condition. Now it will simply be one more point on the autism spectrum, which allows better diagnosis-shift (ie, diagnose as autism, but then as the child ages they may fit more into aspergers than autism), and also may remove some of the confusion that people seem to have between the two.
28
u/AnnaLemma May 08 '12
Who's taking bets on how long it takes for the "alarming rise in autism cases" scare to manifest?
→ More replies (4)9
u/richmondody May 08 '12
So essentially, Aspergers is like the new high functioning autism?
→ More replies (4)20
u/ToTheBlack May 08 '12
Aspergers will likely be considered a sub-type of autism.
Similar to the way ADD no longer exists as a term. It was shifted to be classified under "ADHD: Predominantly innatentive." Mostly the same diagnosis, but with a more accurate grouping.
→ More replies (6)7
→ More replies (412)6
u/scarystuff May 08 '12
I have know this for about 18 months now. Aspergers syndrome will be counted under the Autism Spectrum Disorder instead. There are several different autism disorders and aspergers have always been borderline autism, so now it's just a validation of it.
28
u/Hypersapien May 08 '12
There was apparently a continuation of Rosenhan's experiment. He told a hospital that he was going to send them a number of pseudopatients over the next year to see if the hospital could pick them out. The hospital singled out a good 10 percent of the patients as fakes. In fact, Rosenhan hadn't sent any.
→ More replies (7)4
27
u/ItWillBeMine May 08 '12
It isn't just psychiatry's 'bible' anymore - psychologists, counselors, and social workers use it as well, as do researchers.
3
88
u/Neuromancer4242 May 08 '12
1 2 3 4 5 6 Next
Really?
This is 2012. Were they running out of pixels on the page or out of space?
5
u/TakingKarmaFromABaby May 08 '12
It's so they can throw more ads in there normally, that's the reason why cracked articles are a gazillion pages long.
→ More replies (1)3
2
May 08 '12
I recommend getting autopatchwork, it's an addon for Chrome that will automatically load the next page as you scroll down (kind of like never-ending reddit with RES). Works great on NYT articles, Cracked stuff, Google searches etc.
→ More replies (16)2
May 08 '12
It's not like it's a single picture on each page.
One of the nice things about paginating an article is that it breaks it into easier to digest chunks.
7
u/azzwhole May 08 '12
Will the empathy spectrum disorders be there, as suggested by Simon Baron-Cohen in "Zero Degrees of Empathy"?
6
u/SammyD1st May 08 '12
Simon Baron-Cohen
I was going to make a Borat joke, but then I wiki-ed and... yes, they are cousins. TIL.
→ More replies (2)
13
u/EvilPicnic May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
I'm a paediatric physiotherapist currently working in education with kids with specific learning difficulties (autism/dyslexia/etc.), and it is worth pointing out that these 'new' terms (like ASD) are not being invented for the DSM or any official body. They have been around and in gradually increasing use among therapists for years because they better reflect the current state of our knowledge about these conditions than the old terms.
And this isn't just restricted to psychiatry - for example in my movement-focused field the term 'dyspraxia' is being phased out, as Developmental Co-ordination Disorder (DCD) becomes more widely accepted.
[This is because dyspraxia applies specifically to a motor planning (or 'praxis') impairment, when many children diagnosed with dyspraxia by a GP because they are 'clumsy' can actually conceptualize the movement fine; it's carrying out the movement that is the problem. DCD can be a much more flexible and accurately descriptive term.]
I think the biggest impact from this particular story will not be to the US psychiatrists (a new manual is nice, but they will have been following the changes on a paper by paper basis over the years anyway) but to the non-therapists who rely on these labels to comprehend these often complex pathologies - and I'm thinking mainly the media and legislature, but also patients, family and friends.
It is in the nature of humanity to want to put things in boxes and slap labels on them, but unfortunately the world does not in reality work like that, and when that dissonance is shown it can be very painful.
33
u/PinguPingu May 08 '12
Psychiatry and Psychology's*
Double the work (have to know DSM-IV and 5) for us Psych majors graduating soon :(
I'm pretty sure it's only in its third draft as well?
17
u/iakhre May 08 '12
The best part is that they keep going back and forth as to whether or not to include certain disorders, so depending on when you last checked you may be wrong -_-
14
u/merow May 08 '12
Don't forget clinical social workers!
I start my supervision in a few months, so by the time I finish and get ready for licensure the DSM-V will have come out and I'll be all kinds of screwed as well.
→ More replies (1)7
May 08 '12
I want to apologize for the mental illnesses that you probably think you have by now. (Former psych student here)
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (17)2
u/stompanie May 08 '12
It's not coming out until 2013, so if you graduate (or drop out of school, or start your degree over with a different major) next year, you'll be in luck.
11
u/2percentright May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Since I don't see it, here's a single page link instead of the 4+ pages you have to click through.
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=redefining-mental-illness&print=true
Edit: Nevermind. Seems the websites are starting to learn and adapt. Clicking the link take you to the click-through page. If anyone has a good way to make it so it links straight to the single page article, let me know.
4
u/rpglover64 Grad Student | Computer Science | Programming Language Theory May 08 '12
You have provided a single page link at a crucial moment, and I have you tagged as such.
Thank you.
EDIT: It didn't work for me, but thank you for trying.
3
u/2percentright May 08 '12
Shit. Looks like they're on to us. It just navigates to the click through page.
To do it yourself, just click the "print" at the top of the article below the headline and it will do it.
→ More replies (5)
15
u/Hermeran May 08 '12
Wow, I JUST had an exam (mostly) about the DSM-IV. I feel dirty.
→ More replies (2)15
14
u/tchouk May 08 '12
Honest question for those in the know:
Why is the ICD-10 not used instead (as elsewhere in the world)?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ICD-10_Chapter_V:_Mental_and_behavioural_disorders
Is there a reason besides traditional use of DSM?
13
u/bobby3eb May 08 '12
as far as i know dsm has the full diagnostic criteria and the other is just another billing code.
4
May 08 '12
Incorrect. The ICD-10 is the diagnostic manual used in favour of the DSM in many other developed countries.
2
u/sillynose12345 May 08 '12
Mostly because the DSM is created by APA, so it pretty well dominates in North America. As far as I've been able to tell, it's also been mostly preference. I've seen good sorts of reliability and validity for either diagnostic manual for many of the labels in either text.
2
u/rhodesian_mercenary May 08 '12
DSM is used widely around the world - e.g., Australia and New Zealand, and probably the UK too.
→ More replies (1)0
0
5
May 08 '12
Absexual Disorder Feeling aroused by moving away from sexuality or behaving as though moralistically opposed to sex. As sex educator Betty Dodson told Canadian newspaper Xtra! West, these are “folks who get off complaining about sex and trying to censor porn.”
3
16
u/Doc_Venture May 08 '12
It seems like the article is using Rosenhan's 1969 stint in a mental hospital as a de-validation of the DSMIV. While it has it's shortcomings, the article fails to acknowledge the extraordinary change in the dynamics mental hospitals and hospitalization.
→ More replies (5)
6
May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
I have been following this process closely for a few years now. I have 5 diagnosed disorders myself (many of which have some overlapping symptoms) and also have my BA/MA in counseling. It's so important to take the culture of psychiatry with a grain of salt and ask your docs questions, follow the research and understand how very subjective these diagnoses can be.
→ More replies (2)2
3
u/Lurker4years May 08 '12
Autism still considered psychiatric.
3
u/MC_Cuff_Lnx May 08 '12
I have to wonder if psychiatric practice isn't a little overreaching. Autism manifests differently in everyone, and in high functioning autistics, you would never realize that some of them are autistic.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/InhaleMusic May 08 '12
I have a friend who has been misdiagnosed with all sorts of mental disorders...and he's been left bitter and worse off from it. I hope that with these updates they will soon find a proper way to help him...
3
u/SayVandalay May 08 '12
As someone who works in the field I can say that there are many mixed responses to the DSM in general. Many clinicians don't really take it as a "bible" and many don't even like to diagnose based on DSM guidelines. It is mostly just a demand of insurance/government agencies to try and classify disorders and put symptoms and behaviors into rigidly defined definitions..
In the field you don't need the DSM to tell someone is depressed, anxious, etc. And I do feel sorry for those individuals who let their DSM diagnosis dictate their lives. For some it may be a relief to have a diagnosis, for others it can impact the way they think and live.
60
May 08 '12
It doesn't address a common problem which has received attention before. It is WAY to easy to slap a personality disorder on somebody, and use it as an excuse to disregard their concerns. This frequently happens to rape victims in the army. Transsexuals that seek treatment are frequently labelled as disordered and refused help. Once given such a diagnosis you have no recourse, psychiatrists are rarely held responsible for making such a diagnosis incorrectly, and patients stigmatised with one are met with doubt and suspicion when trying to get it affirmed that the diagnosis was nonsense.
161
u/aedes May 08 '12
It is WAY to easy to slap a personality disorder on somebody
It's actually supposed to be very difficult to diagnose a personality disorder. If you read the DSM criteria one of the criteria is "a pattern of behavior," generally implying that the diagnosis can only be made after an extensive period of time and discussion with the person.
People can certainly have cluster A, cluster B, cluster C traits, and those are obvious from the get-go, but to properly diagnose a personality disorder takes time.
25
u/BetaRayRyan May 08 '12
Former mental health therapist here. Having worked for community mental health centers that are almost solely funded by Medicare/Medicaid, it was common-place for diagnoses to be at INTAKE and by hell, it better be a billable diagnoses. I hope that this is a localized problem and not a widespread issue. I've left the field due to practices like this.
→ More replies (1)13
u/merow May 08 '12
I'm in an inpatient, acute care environment and ours is similar. They give an "initial" or "working" diagnosis based on what they've presented in the assessment, but it's not until they've met with the psychiatrist that they receive the official charted diagnosis. I'm really lucky with the doctors I work with because if they don't see a patient meeting criteria then they won't give a diagnosis.
63
u/TP53 May 08 '12
How refreshing for a comment to come from someone who has read something about what they comment on.
This is pretty accurate to how I've seen it practiced, too. People are pretty hesitant to diagnoses a personality disorder until they've seen a patient several times. They sometimes will discuss the possibility of one earlier on, but they'll wait a while to feel confident enough to diagnose.
24
May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
There is still a major gap between what the DSM suggests and what clinicians actually follow. As someone who gets counseling referrals from psychiatrists often, I can assure you that it doesn't take that long to give a personality diagnosis. I have clients tell me their psychiatrist told them they had a personality disorder after one 45 minute visit. Then they go home and look them up, and all of sudden the start exhibiting disorder traits... Not all that is the DSM's fault, but rather a lack of desire among APA to change anything.
Edit: I mistakenly a word.
→ More replies (6)17
u/acog May 08 '12
I have clients tell me their psychiatrist told them they had a personality after one 45 minute visit.
Should I be worried? I've been told I have a personality. Not a particularly engaging or sparkling one, but a personality nonetheless.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (32)3
May 08 '12
It's actually supposed to be very difficult to diagnose a personality disorder. If you read the DSM criteria one of the criteria is "a pattern of behavior," generally implying that the diagnosis can only be made after an extensive period of time and discussion with the person.
Well, let me give you an idea of what happened to me. I waited 18 months to even get to see a psychiatrist for referring me to treatment for transsexualism. Eventually I gave up and started self medicating. When I finally got there I begged to be allowed to do it through a doctor instead of having to buy it from the black market, but he refused. I wasn't able to go elsewhere, because there isn't anywhere else local that accepts transsexual patients.
After nearly one year of questioning I was completely broken down and nearly suicidal. They basically decided to refuse me treatment, and justified it by claiming I had borderline personality disorder, and thus not fit to undergo reassignment. The thing is, I don't fit the criteria in the slightest, I don't have trouble getting along with friends, coworkers and so on... but none of that matters because apparently BPD is one of those diagnoses where you count symptomes, and if you get a high enough "score" of problems that can be construed to fit, you're diagnosed.
As a result I've been met with scepticism everywhere else I went. Psychiatrists act understanding when they see me, but when you read the medical records it is pretty much clear that they just took the diagnosis at face value.
What is worse is that because the description of this condition supposedly involves people misinterpretation situations, I am not believed when I try to explain what happened to me. It is basically just assumed I'm just disordered and hence don't understand that people are just trying to help.
Worst bit about it is that people will not believe things could have been this bad. People want to believe the psychiatrists are right, and that I just don't know what is best for me. I'm now counting 3 years one estrogen, even longer since I changed my name, but I still have an "M" staring at me in my passport, because without an official diagnosis of transsexualism, I'm not allowed to change it.
Now what I am met with when mentioning this is basically a claim that such a diagnosis SHOULD be made such and such way. However, this is not made sufficiently clear in the diagnostic criteria, so psychiatrists can easily get away with just slapping it on you and never be held accountable for it, and once you got stamped with that diagnosis you're doubted and disbelieved whenever you seek help.
→ More replies (2)15
u/iakhre May 08 '12
Well to be fair, that isn't really the goal of the DSM. It's called a diagnostic manual for a reason; the intent is to make diagnoses accurate and explanatory, not to resolve issues with the community at large.
→ More replies (11)6
u/TP53 May 08 '12
The goal of the manual is really to standardize inclusion criteria for research studies to improve the quality of psychiatric research. It's important to know for diagnosing patients, but it should not be used as a checklist.
→ More replies (1)3
u/richmondody May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
In my country, the PDNOS diagnosis is used when they don't really have enough evidence to make a formal diagnosis for other PD's so that annulments easier to approve. It's actually pretty depressing.
EDIT: Forgot to add a few words.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (6)3
u/merow May 08 '12
Remember the DSM is just a manual, a guide. You wouldn't believe how many times in treatment team meetings that 3 of us will have totally different perceptions about a patient and what is going on with him/her. Every clinician is different and I've seen quite a few that wait as long as they can (insurance companies make this difficult) before giving a diagnosis.
→ More replies (1)
7
u/bartink May 08 '12
My mother teaches the DSM course in a local university and her take is that the new one is a power grab by behaviorists. They stacked the committee with like-minded folks and seem intent on using the manual to validate their view of psychology. She thinks its mostly a big step backward.
7
u/kru5h May 08 '12
Could you expound upon this?
5
u/bartink May 08 '12
I can't, unfortunately. She is at work. I will talk to her tonight, probably soon enough to not matter. I'm sure there will be another DSM thread though.
→ More replies (1)2
13
u/drbs May 08 '12
And S&M isn't a disorder unless you're unhappy with it!
10
u/firex726 May 08 '12
Yea, though TBH I think it's how it's viewed by many.
Pain is just a sensation like any other. Would anyone say you have a disorder because you like to watch scary movies and experience fear?
→ More replies (1)22
u/ngroot May 08 '12
If you didn't like S&M, there's something wrong with your brain. The S.F. Symphony killed it on that album!
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)3
u/threnody_42 May 08 '12
True. For someone to have a "disorder" it has to significantly impact his/her life in a negative way.
2
u/jjbean May 08 '12
diodi's comment gives a clue as to what is going on:
The main concept adopted by DSM-5 is acknowledging the fact that there is often no discrete boundaries with what is "normal" and what is "disorder". Many diagnoses don't identify clear disorder. They are just bundles of similar symptoms with artificial borders. Bundling autistic disorder, Asperger’s, CDD and PDD-NOS together reflects this. Giving too specific names when we don't have a clue what is going on is counterproductive.
This is going to be a HUGE bonanza for drug companies...they will have a much larger prescription user base now that anyone in the spectrum could be diagnosed with a condition that could be treated with drugs.
→ More replies (2)
2
2
May 08 '12
Others worry that the stricter, more precise diagnostic criteria may inadvertently give insurance companies new ways to deny medication to patients who need it.
This shouldn't be a consideration, since many nations will use this guide and not all use that system. Letting politics affect our definitions of illness is dangerous, whether it helps or hinders the patient in the short term or not.
2
u/flatblackvw May 08 '12
My mom is a clinical social worker and actually took part in studies for the new dsm. Her names gonna be in it and everything!
2
u/rDr4g0n May 08 '12
I've only read about 1/3rd of this article, but I really like the idea of the rating system for disorders. I'm of the belief that we are all screwed up anyway, so rating how screwed up a person is in one way or another makes more sense than slapping a big ol label on someone and calling it a day.
2
u/T55DWXpv May 08 '12
Finally, Internet Use Disorder! So when the entertainment biz finally criminalizes all non-commercial use of the internet, we can just plead insanity and spend a few weeks in rehab instead of getting 20 years and a hundred-thousand-dollar fine.
2
u/Drakkanrider May 08 '12
As a psych major looking to go to graduate school for Clinical psych, them pushing back the release of this book is starting to get annoying. I'm learning all about the DSM-IV criteria for disorders, which is going to be a little useless once this thing hits the shelves. It was supposed to be out in 2010.
→ More replies (5)
2
2
u/finitude May 08 '12
I don't understand the 30 years statement. It was updated just a few years ago with some major updates, with the DSM4-TR
2
u/fallingstarr123 May 08 '12
As a psych student, pretty much all of my professor's have made it clear that everything we're learning, is just going to have to be relearned. Timing is everything folks.
2
May 08 '12
Sometime back in the 80s the American Psychiatric Association or some other authoritative body declared that the term "neurotic" would no longer be used as a diagnostic term because its widespread popular use had diluted its meaning so that had no clinical value. My roommate remarked that suddenly there were no more neurotics! They had been cured with the stroke of a pen! Of course he wasn't literally correct, but I wonder what new name Asperger's is getting.
2
u/websnarf May 08 '12
Newsflash From APA Meeting: DSM 5 Has Flunked Its Reliability Tests
Not sure anyone should be happy that this revision exists.
2
u/stormtroopin May 08 '12
Not to be too picky (even though I now will proceed to be), but Rosenhan's study actually argued AGAINST diagnostic labels for patients. After his study, which, by the way, was tremendously flawed in methodology, he concluded that people should not be placed in diagnostic categories because it would cause them to experience a sort of self-fulfilling prophecy due to expectations of mental health staff. I find it sad that Scientific American didn't do more homework on this one. But I'm just being a psychology snob. Steps down from soap box
→ More replies (1)
2
May 09 '12
Maybe I don't read magazine-type articles of science enough, but without seeing in text citations this just kind of pissed me off. It's funny how much people think we know about the brain. We're surface-scratching, at best.
2
May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
The Dutch association of Psychiatrists has decided to give it a good scrutiny and stop using it, as a lot of the "new" diagnosis methods and treatments therein seem developed to get drugs prescribed where non-chemical treatment used to be the norm. This, according to the association, is probably due to the fact that the re-writing of DSM has been heavily sponsored by farmaceutical companies.
The British association of Psychologists has also protested, as a lot of behaviour that used to be classified as normal has suddenly been moved into classes that require treatment -with pills.
TL, DR the new version of DSM is rejected in the Netherlands because it seems to have been written to sell pills.
6
u/Psych277 May 08 '12
I am SO PUMPED! I've been waiting for this for the past 7 years!
→ More replies (3)
4
u/Viperbunny May 08 '12
This is going to have a huge effect on what services people qualify for in both medicine and education. Schools administrators do not like shelling out money for kids with special needs and I see this as a step backwards in a lot of respects. Especially doing away with Aspergers. This disorder's place has been debated for years, because it is different from autism. This disorder is different and deserves to recognized. Doing away with it is going to cause more problems than it solves. Especially when the argument isn't that it exists, but what it is. This is going to cause major issues with insurance companies and coverage as well.
Yes, depression comes in different levels of severity, but it also has different causes. Some people do better with therapy, others medication. Denying them access to medication without trying all other treatments first is going to cause a lot of people to shy away from treatment. Part of depression can be embarrassment over being depressed. Not everyone is ready for therapy, and therapy only helps if the patient is willing to put the work in. I'm not saying I think people should be blindly medicated, but denying this as an option for doctors are going to cause a huge problem.
3
u/bluesatin May 08 '12
Especially doing away with Aspergers.
They're not 'doing away with Aspergers', they're renaming it.
→ More replies (15)
3
May 08 '12
I'm curious as to the effects this will have on the health insurance industry. I bet there's going to be a lot of things that they will either no longer cover.. maybe some stricter guidelines or something as far as diagonses are concerned
→ More replies (1)
4
u/blog_farts May 08 '12
Historically, names change in the DSM to remove stigmas to existing names (eg Multiple Personality Disorder). These updates in the new DSM are a move in a different direction though, putting more things on a scale of severity, like they're doing with Autism. What the article doesn't mention is the belief by many in the business that this DSM is headed in the wrong direction. By putting everything on a scale, diagnoses are even more subjective than they were previously. Plus, there are still no inclusions of any biological testing whatsoever making it appear like pseudo-science. IMO, this move towards scales reinforces the belief that psychology still doesn't know what the hell it's doing and I'm glad I got out when I could.
9
u/HooDidDis May 08 '12
When you study a disorder in a population and find that the symptoms are normally distributed, the only scientifically honest thing to do is to make scales and set arbitrary cut-offs.
→ More replies (3)2
u/Dissonanz May 08 '12
Plus, there are still no inclusions of any biological testing whatsoever making it appear like pseudo-science.
Why?
→ More replies (9)
3
2
u/nofunnynamesleft May 08 '12
I would definitely like to see some changes to the diagnostic parameters of ADHD. It is so over-diagnosed, especially in the states, that Ritalin is becoming too much of a generic wonder-drug for kids with problems that could be controlled, or at least improved, with behavioural therapies
2
u/sillynose12345 May 08 '12
Interesting that this new version (which has been worked on since 2004, right after the DSM-IV-TR was published), but the article is entirely too sensationalized. Every time I read "psychiatry bible" I cringed. It's not like diagnosis was that stiff and primative, there was something called "evidence based practice" that tells clinicians to go with the latest science rather than the diagnostic tool.
At least some attention is being brought to the improvement of diagnostic criteria, trying to eliminate the stigma that's associated with the practice in general.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/Certhas May 08 '12
They categorized the right wing culture warriors:
Absexual Disorder Feeling aroused by moving away from sexuality or behaving as though moralistically opposed to sex. As sex educator Betty Dodson told Canadian newspaper Xtra! West, these are “folks who get off complaining about sex and trying to censor porn.”
2
u/cefm May 08 '12
So what mental disorder is associated with spreading an article across 6 pages with no option to view as a single page??
2
u/asldkfououhe May 08 '12
every time i've visited with a therapist, i've left laughing. it's a ruse. a very expensive, very predatory ruse
2
u/beyond_repair May 08 '12
There needs to be a section in there pointed DIRECTLY at asshole shrinks with superiority complexes. Maybe include a bulleted checklist of signs and symptoms of asshole-mania.
2
u/SunshineBlind May 08 '12
I knew about the Asperger thing, but I really don't see the point of it. And what will happen with people who has the diagnose? Will they lose it or will they keep the diagnose but no new cases will ever be reported for it?
23
May 08 '12
I believe it will all change to Autism Spectrum Disorder, which makes more sense both from a logical, scientific standpoint as well from a social one. Asperger's carries a stigma that something abbreviated ASD will not.
16
u/SunshineBlind May 08 '12
Really? I would have imagined "I'm sort of autistic" sounds worse than "I have asperger".
→ More replies (8)10
May 08 '12
I'd rather say, "I have ASD. It makes some social interactions difficult, but it's no biggie."
Labeling it ASD will also probably improve diagnosis, catching it earlier in younger kids. When caught early enough, many kids with ASD can become so high-functioning that you wouldn't even know they have it.
→ More replies (10)→ More replies (1)3
u/sooibot May 08 '12
The diagnosis doesn't change as much as it gets reworded. The point of it is to allow for people to be diagnosed with varying degrees of certain illnesses, the follow-up of it being that there isn't one "blanket treatment" where people who have much lower degrees of an illness, receive the same drugs that someone who has like crazy level: crazy. Also, try reading the article, it helps.
1
u/ApertureJunkie May 08 '12
It's just mind-boggling to me that psychiatrists in modern days still have no reliable method for accurate diagnosis, and yet label children with mental conditions and prescribe drugs with side-effect listings that rival the Quran. Anti-depressants that can cause depression, suicidal thoughts and anal hemmoraging? Yeah that's cool to give to a 12 year old because he's upset sometimes.
What's with this social viewpoint that everything is a disorder that must be medicated? Being unhappy about things at times is a fundamental human trait. If you're sad when your parents are getting a divorce, that's not some insane trait that needs to be medicated - its a normal fucking response to a loss and it's part of the process.
All I see is they now have a bigger buffet of conditions to blindly assume you have. Yippee. I'm sure Eli Lilly's stock holders will be pleased.
8
u/neurorex May 08 '12
The reliable methods exist. It's just that some people don't really consider the insurance and pharma factors involved, which can weigh really heavily sometimes.
→ More replies (1)8
u/Dissonanz May 08 '12
Being unhappy about things at times is a fundamental human trait.
That's why being unhappy does not make a depression.
3
u/wobwobwobbuffet May 08 '12
What's with this social viewpoint that everything is a disorder that must be medicated? Being unhappy about things at times is a fundamental human trait. If you're sad when your parents are getting a divorce, that's not some insane trait that needs to be medicated - its a normal fucking response to a loss and it's part of the process.
While I understand your point, the way you're going about it isn't the best. You're talking about being sad, which is normal. It seems, though, as if you're implying that's all depression is. That implication really couldn't be further from the truth.
→ More replies (1)4
u/buttersugarbun May 08 '12
No. Psychiatrist will generally have long history taking sessions with the patient and the family. Do you really think they'll dish out SSRIs at the drop of a pin? It actually mentions in the diagnostic criteria that the "depression" must not be a grief response. They also only give meds if there's an impact on social function. There's also a separate diagnosis for adjustment disorder, which has a management that focuses on therapy as opposed to medication.
→ More replies (21)→ More replies (8)3
u/captainmajesty May 09 '12
I was severely abused as a child. I saw my younger sister killed by my father. When I came to America I was 5150'd after an incident at school where I strangled another boy (he's fine but never bothere me again).
When I was placed with the other children, I was given medicine for "bipolar disorder" and schizophrenia because my mother told the doctor this:
"Sometimes he very kind and peaceful, but other times he explodes and throws fits and cries. He doesn't sleep and he just does homework or draws picture instead of sleeping and he sees pictures in shapes. He will tell me an oil spill o carpet stain looks like animals or an architectural structure and sometimes he hears voices. Mostly his father and sister".She had already told the doctor about all the other stuff before, but instead of saying "your son is traumatized, has sleep issues from the abuse, distracts himself with homework or drawing, has audio flashbacks, and a vivid imagination" I was given so many pills I slept for 18 hours a day for 6 months and almost liver failure even with the blood tests. He said people are born with bipolar and schizophrenia and that it is a "biological chemical imbalance". He kept pumping up the dose when I said it wasn't helping me at all. I hate him for all my suffering that he caused. I finally stopped taking it by hiding my medicine in my cheeks from my mother who he fooled.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/certainsomebody May 08 '12
Here's an interesting article about the struggles of defining mental disorders for the DSM.
1
u/PsyDyl May 08 '12
Information about some of the very concerning and potentially dangerous revisions proposed by the DSM-5 (supported by over 13000 petition signers and 40 national and international organizations) can be found here: The Coalition for DSM-5 Reform.
1
1
u/Freterz May 08 '12
Huh, I didn't know bipolar was so uncommon in under 20's. I was diagnosed with that and Schizophrenia at 16/17.
→ More replies (1)
1
May 08 '12
As someone with rapid cycling BiPolar Disorder II I can say I'm actually relieved to see the final product. I cycle through hypomania in a little under a week, sometimes less than four days if my sleep patterns are completely out of wack. In the old system rapid cycleing was measured in months rather than days. There doesn't seem to be a final consensus on waht to call us but at least there is a tacit acknowledgement that we do have a real disorder.
For me it's academic really. I've been rock solid stable on tegretol for over 9 years. But the fact that I occasionally read idiots saying my disorder is a myth and backing up their ignorance with the vague DSM IV still gets to me.
1
u/Kickinthegonads May 08 '12
Now the diagnosis will disappear, and Aspies may find an important part of their identity stripped away.
"Oh noes!" Ugh. That's exactly what's wrong with psychodiagnostics these days. Or better, with what people see psychodiagnostics as/using it for. I, for one, welcome our new DSM-V overlord.
1
1
u/Shishkababz May 08 '12
As an undergraduate psych student, I'm hoping the transition won't be too difficult, having spent the last four years working with the DSM IV.
1
1
u/cyllene May 08 '12
If this interests you, I highly recommend reading The Psychopath Test by Jon Ronson.
1
u/suxdix May 08 '12
i dont understand this. they removed some personality disorders? does this mean i am normal now or do i need a new diagnosis.
1
1
1
May 08 '12
Wired had a great article about this in its January 2011 issue of its Magazine. A great read for those interested.
1
1
1
u/ravia May 08 '12
One should be able to see that there pretty well needs to be a disorder called "DSMCD": DSM categorizing disorder, in which people reduce others to symptomatology to the point of rupturing their basic, irreducible human relation to the other through the deploying of DSM categories. Not joking.
1
u/tim0th May 08 '12
I'm interested in what DSM-IV and particularly DSM-5 will have to say about conditions like bipolar disorder (both type 1 and type 2) and chronic anxiety and panic disorder.
1
u/Ariel7304 May 08 '12
Everything about this article made me cringe. The DSM is NOT a Bible and it was last revised about 12 years ago. Bad journalism here....
1
u/TrinaM May 08 '12
There needs to be a definitive line between what is insanity in an adult and insanity in a child. Not many doctors will diagnose or treat a child who has deep seated mental disorders. I have a student who, at age 10, is not getting treatment for her mental health. She is most likely schizophrenic and is often delusional.
I understand caution, I don't understand the cruelty of not treating the symptoms.
1
May 08 '12
Wow, I remember being back in Psychology 101 in High School, and our teacher was explaining that the DSM-IV would be updated soon.
1
u/CrawdaddyJoe May 08 '12
Huh. Soon I'll be have ASD lvl 1 instead of Asperger's. Won't change much for me.
1
u/2th May 08 '12
As long as they actually put in a decent definition of Interent Addiction that isnt pretty much the definition of Gambling Addiction with a few words changed.
1
u/tre101 May 08 '12
Just did a project on internet addiction..it is something that needs to be addressed in the next 30 years so it isnt just left in the appendix of the next issue. My fear is Facebook addiction (or Social networking addiction) will too make it in the next edition
1
1
u/blog_farts May 08 '12
It sure helps when surrounded by doctors and scientists that do biological tests all day long.
1
May 09 '12
The main problem is that there is no psychiatric definition for "normal" behavior
→ More replies (2)
1
u/boredwaitingforlife May 09 '12
Someone in my psych class mentioned this link and article. Whoever you are: I know who you are.
1
1
u/MARSbarsATTACK May 09 '12
Not surprising. I was in Timberlawn for about 21 days. About 13 days in they were about to make me an outpatient. I was 18 at the time, still in high school and my parents were divorced due to my fathers arrest for trafficking pedophilia related materials. I really needed the help and knew if I didn't act crazier than I was I would never get the help that I needed. I didn't want to spend the rest of my life with daddy issues and a fucked up childhood/teenage experience to haunt me. So I told my doctor the next morning after a shower (hair still wet) that I had really wanted to gouge my eyes out with the shower curtain rods. She knew I was lying, I think anyways. After that I was put on suicide watch for 3 days and I no longer had a shower curtain. Needless to say I got help. Now I am happily married in our own place at 22, and he's going to college. I never thought I'd be where I am now 4 years ago. So all in all being intelligent with actual problems I used the system to procure the psychiatric aid I needed.
336
u/NyQuilNyQuilNyQuil May 08 '12
The DSM-IV and DSM-IV-TR without Dx revisions was written in 1994 and 2000 respectively. Even my Psychiatry professors in medical school don't sensationalize the the revision as "[the] first major update in 30 years." And yes, most Dxs that are taken out are being put into a spectrum of disorders. And most of these Dxs have rigid criteria, it's up to the clinician to distinguish pertinent findings and decide if the clinical findings warrant a Psychiatric Dx.