r/runningquestions • • 10d ago

Faster Long Runs for Sub 3 Goal, No More Zone 2 Propaganda

30 Upvotes

Looking for advice from fast & experienced runners on your approach to long runs, here's the layout:

After consecutive 3:08 marathons, I went back to the drawing board this summer to identify weaknesses in my latest training to finally breakthrough to 2:58 at NYC this past Sunday. My biggest takeaways from my previous races & blocks were:

- more volume + better training absorption (recovery)
- more MP specific work
- better fueling (50g of carbs -> 85g carbs per hour)

This led to the plan HERE that seemingly covered it all: higher volume (65ish peak week), Thurs MP work, LSD on Saturdays ~8:50 pace). My adherence to this plan was 95%, never had been more dialed and smooth through a 16 week block and completed all my MP work at 6:48 pace.

Now, I just raced NYC last week and have never felt WORSE in my life for a pitiful 3:25:40. I felt slow and unathletic by mile 6 and just continually got worse as the race went on. I've done multiple 1:26 halfs and came through half during NYC at 1:32:40 - brutal. One bright spot was increased carbs though, definite game changer for myself at 6'1 188lbs.

Going back to my previous 2 training blocks - all of my long run work usually averaged out around 7:30 to 8:00 min pace with HR usually falling between 136-152 which would put me at zone 2 upper limit/lower zone 3 (my max HR is 188), which people told me was "too fast" or to slow it down for "recovery" purposes.

Wanting to do my own research - I read Pftizinger's Advanced Marathoning book which prescribes long runs at 10%-20% slower than race pace (approx. 7:29 - 8:09 pace) or 80% of HMR (150 for me) with some give or take accounting for the weeks that have MP or progression built in. So basically, I was unknowingly doing Pfitz's long run plan the previous two training blocks when I was dumber and not hung up on zone 2 optimization.

Then, I listened to Stephen Scullion's (2:09 PB) interview with w/ Spencer Matthews, where he covers training hard in long runs and that true zone 2 for the majority of people - in the case of long runs is too slow to create stimulus and get faster for marathon race pace durability, and also lends itself to promoting slower mechanics as an overall system.

To top it all off, NYC's winner this year, Andreas Almgren, shared his training approach and specifically highlights his "four documented hard long runs during the block, and his average pace improved in each one."

So here's my take, I think I slowed my long runs too much prioritizing being at high 120s - mid 130s HR and roughly 8:50 pace in the name of "optimal zone 2 training & absorption", believing the higher MP work on thursdays would be sufficient & it backfired. So, yes - we don't want to intensify our long runs to the point where we can't recover + execute/stay healthy for the following days & weeks, but I also think 99% of us are slow enough to still get better even if we occasionally "overdo" it on long run intensity (aka beginner gains).

For my next training block starting in a few weeks for Jersey City (goal 2:58), my approach to the long run will be simple - be smart, but train fast to be fast. Sometimes we are better off being smart enough, to be naive enough, to not know what we can't accomplish.

With all the zone 2 propaganda & long runs specifically, we're talking about RACING and I don't think that can be forgotten - there's an old saying that goes "I'd rather say whoa than sic' em" and I think that applies here with training, we can't always be afraid of crossing the "limit" in the name of optimization and sometimes the feedback when we do is just as informative.

Advice/thoughts?


r/runningquestions • • 12d ago

What’s one change you made to your running routine that had a surprisingly big impact on your performance?

29 Upvotes

Workout schedule, diet, shoes - could be anything


r/runningquestions • • Aug 16 '25

Zone 2 at 180 BPM… Lactate test shows max HR 207 — anyone else in this boat?

15 Upvotes

I just did a lactate threshold test, and the results were surprising. I’m a 37F, and apparently my heart runs way faster than most charts predict. Here are the key numbers: • Aerobic threshold (top of Zone 2): 186 bpm • Anaerobic threshold: 199 bpm • Max HR measured: 207 bpm

For context: I can run at ~180 bpm and still feel like I’m cruising in Zone 2. My kinesiologist told me it was the highest HR he’d ever seen in a test, but the lactate curve itself was perfectly normal — nothing pathological.

I’ve always felt like my HR zones didn’t match what other runners report, and now I know why. My endurance feels good, but my “easy” numbers look insane compared to standard formulas like 220 – age.

Has anyone else experienced something like this? Would love to hear if I’m not the only one with this kind of engine.

Any idea on how to optimize my training according to these results?


r/runningquestions • • 10d ago

Winter Running?

12 Upvotes

Im curious, as a beginner runner, how do you guys continue running during winter.

It was great in Summer because after work the sun was still up and my clothes were light to carry in my small backpack. I think now I'd definitely need to stop home first to change.

But apart from that I feel like the usual short (and already sub-par) running are also taking a hit in output.

Any beginner advice?

I'd say currently 3-4km are comfortable. (around 20 ~ 30mins)
I do Push, Pull, Legs at the gym. Enjoy running outdoors for fun, I'd rather not quit over the next 4 months if theres a good way to get around the bitter cold.

*I recently got some upper&lower body thermals and fleece-line exercise pants


r/runningquestions • • Sep 22 '26

Running after stent insert

Post image
12 Upvotes

Ran my first 8km today after a stent insertion in July. Cardiologist said to keep intensity low and it would be fine, but I was quite anxious , nervous and hesitant. Can anyone share experience of getting back to running after this procedure, both physically and mentally, as physically I feel great, so I think the challenge might be more getting confident and comfortable in my mind


r/runningquestions • • 5d ago

Walkers/hikers/do walkers will not move for runners?

10 Upvotes

Hi all,

I have a question, and wanted to see if anyone had the same experiences, and what they do in situations like mine.

With the weather turning and the grass getting muddy, I’ve been sticking more to gravel tracks, gravel pavements and some concrete paths (not built-up areas ; more open tracks wide enough for a couple of vehicles or narrower single-file paths).

There seem to be a lot of hikers and dog walkers out at this time of year, many of them older (roughly 40–70). On wider tracks you’ll get groups of 6–7 people chatting with their dogs taking up most of the width. On narrower paths you get pairs of hikers walking two-abreast like they are in the Army (I know as I'm ex mil lol)

When I’m running towards them, a fair number can clearly see me coming but don’t move, don’t put dogs on leads, and don’t make any space. I always slow right down or stop, walk past, and try to be polite. When I see a runner coming and I’m with my own dog, I put the dog between my legs and stand still so they can go past ; and people usually thank me for it. Some walkers do the same for me. A lot don’t, and dogs I have accidentally hit before and fell over.

The ones who refuse to budge are often the older men. They just keep coming and expect me to step off into the wet grass and mud or the main road with cars whizzing by. Today I had two pairs (about 40) walking two-abreast on a narrow path with hiking sticks, pots and pans handing off their days sacks I stopped, stayed on the firm surface and said something like “There’s room for both of us ; you can just step to the right.” They wouldn’t. I ended up going around them and pointing out that the path is for everyone and I’d already stopped to be courteous. They just walked off with scrunched up faces.

I have had it when you run behind them, cough and they know you're there but won't move, I usually just say I am coming through on your left, sorry if I startled you, I just can't get past please.

Has anyone else experienced this regularly on shared gravel tracks or paths? How do you usually handle people who can see you but still won’t move or control their dogs? Do you just go around into the mud every time, or is there a better approach?


r/runningquestions • • 29d ago

Stuck around 21 minutes for my 5K – how do I get faster?

10 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I’m looking for some advice on improving my 5K time. My PB is around 21 minutes, and I feel like I’ve hit a bit of a plateau. I want to get faster but I’m not sure what I should be focusing on to make the biggest improvement.

For those of you who have gone from around 21 minutes to sub-20 or even faster, what worked best for you?

Should I focus more on interval training, tempo runs, easy mileage, or long runs? Also, how many times a week would you recommend running?

I’d appreciate any advice, training plans or personal experiences. Keen to hear what’s worked for other runners!

Thanks!


r/runningquestions • • Oct 02 '25

Training to progress from 22 min to sub-20 5k

10 Upvotes

After returning from injury, I'm hoping to go from ~22 min 5k to sub-20 in the next few months. I'm relatively new to running, having started just under a year ago, but managed to progress faster than I expected so far. From what I can find elsewhere, some people & training plans imply 22 -> sub-20 could be possible in a 1-3 month timeframe given the right conditions, but others imply this may be a full season of work, or more. I'd love any thoughts on my current situation, planned training, and anything else.

Running background:

  • Male, 37, running for nearly a year

  • November: started running

  • December: 5k in ~33 mins, long runs up to 10k

  • January: 27 min 5k, started training for first HM race

  • February: Long runs up to HM distance each week, 30k+ weekly distance

  • March: Long runs 25k, 50k weekly distance

  • April: unofficial sub-25 min 5k, long runs 30k, 60k weekly distance

  • May: unofficial 22:30 5k, 1:46 hilly half marathon race

  • June: completed training for 50k trail and felt confident in completing (was doing ~45k combined distance for back-to-back long runs lots of elevation, peaked at 80k weeks). Injured foot on easy run from mis-step/bad landing.

  • July/Aug: short, slow runs only and some cycling to keep fitness under advice of physio.

  • Sept: starting to introduce some more speed and distance up to 10-12k.

  • Oct (yesterday): ran a ~22 min 5k, but definitely capable of more - this was as part of a hilly 4-mile route, and I started off waaay too enthusiastically (the first 2k were both at ~4 min/km). Currently at ~35 k/week, but plan to up this to more like 40-50k/week.

Training planned currently

  • 40k/week, increasing slowly, mainly easy pace (5:30-6:00 min/km)

  • Speedwork - 1 session per week, potentially with:

    • 10 x 0.5k at 4 min/km, 90s light jog float

    • 5 x 1k at 4 min/km, 120s light jog float

    • 3 x 2k at 4 min/km, 180s light jog float

    • Norwegian 4x4s at 4 min/km

    • Fartleks

Targets for next 9 months

  • Sub-20 5k, hopefully within a few months

  • HM early Feb (target time TBC based on 5k pace early December)

  • Hilly 50k in June (training after HM, aiming just to complete with no time goal)

Would love any thoughts on training (in particular the type of speed work I'm thinking of), and whether I'm being realistic in hoping I might be able to get to a sub-20 5k in the near future.


r/runningquestions • • Oct 01 '26

Easy, tempo, long?

9 Upvotes

My running is largely “easy” runs. But I feel like I need to switch it up to get better.

What exactly is the difference between these three? How do you structure it? What has worked best for you?


r/runningquestions • • Feb 08 '26

High heart rate advice

8 Upvotes

I'm relatively new to running. I went on a 10k run with some friends yesterday. While their heart rate was around 127bpm, mine was 157. My max for the run was 176bpm, theirs was 136. My heart seems to need to do a lot more to get the oxygen into my system. This feels really high!

I've been trying to do some zone 2 runs for the last month to train my parasympathetic system, but this run was not a controlled zone 2 run and I'm wondering what I should do to get a more efficient system, so I don't have such high heart rate, any advice?


r/runningquestions • • Feb 06 '26

Shoes recs if I don’t want two inches of foam under me

8 Upvotes

I like ground contact. I play sports that involve sharp cuts and burst running, and I personally view running on the common outsoles we are seeing in the shoe market as the equivalent of what smith machine overuse does to muscle stability but for the ankles.

I’m looking for like minded people to tell me what shoes they’re wearing (ideally that also double as a daily sneaker) now that every company is copying Hoka-level lifts. Mizuno has ONE shoe that fits this description and its so sad to see.


r/runningquestions • • 18d ago

Easy running

7 Upvotes

I’ve been running seriously for about 7 years, run 6 days a week, weekly mileage around 70-80km.

Ok so I’ve been thinking about easy runs which make up the bulk of my running and a question came to mind…based on two ways I’ve found myself running easy.

(1) running every km slow so that it feels really easy and my HR and effort rating stay in the middle of my zone 2.

(2) running 1 km a bit faster and then taking a walking break for 20-30 seconds. Then run the next KM etc. my heart rate would climb slowly to the top of my zone 2 then come right down to the bottom of my zone 2 by the end of the walking break.

I generally run around 11-12 km on my easy runs.

The question is : does it matter either way ? What would be the pros and cons of each method or am I just over thinking the whole thing?


r/runningquestions • • Sep 07 '25

Lactate Threshold vs 5k Times

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

So I noticed that Garmin thinks my 5k time should be 18s/km faster than my current lactate threshold pace. I haven't done any all out 5k's as part of my training, so I have no real tangible benchmark to compare to, but I suspect Garmin is being hopeful with my 5k times. Are people typically able to sustain speeds much faster than threshold for that long? I'm curious how you guys have seen 5k times compare to threshold pace.


r/runningquestions • • 7d ago

How many months/years of consistent running did it take you to have a zone 2 pace of less than 10:00min/mile?

6 Upvotes

I’m a 32 year old female. According to most calculations my zone 2 HR should be around 135-148.
I’ve been running VERY consistently (10-15 miles per week, spread over 3 runs, 15+ miles weekly when I was training for my half marathon last spring) for 18 months now. I STILL cannot run in zone 2 unless it’s very very slow on a treadmill. We’re talking 12+ minute miles, and after 30 minutes it spikes.

I am not unfit, my resting HR is 60. I have lifted weights for years and am a healthy weight. I ran a half marathon for the first time in May with a 10:24 average pace, ran the whole time, did not walk, my average HR was 164. And I felt pretty good honestly! I can easily run for 60-90 minutes straight and have for over a year now.

Today I ran 5.5 miles and I was determined to keep my heart rate low, I even took a couple of walking breaks despite not feeling like I needed them, more so because I was just trying my best to make it a textbook “easy run” but my HR was still in the 150’s the entire time, no matter how slow I went. It would dip while walking and then go right back up. I don’t feel spent, I feel like I could still talk in short sentences if needed, so why is my HR still so high? I see all these runners posting their easy runs with their average HR in the 130’s-140’s. I know it takes time, but after 18 months I would have thought my zone 2 pace would be better than a shuffle?

I hate the slow runs because they kill my joints and my form sucks when I run that slow, but with trying to improve my pace and increase my mileage I know I can’t push it every time. I know I need the easy runs. But my HR is never in zone 2 for my “easy runs”, it’s always the 150’s. I have even taken my pulse manually because I know the watch isn’t totally accurate, but it’s pretty dang close.

My iron and ferritin are good, I have checked.
It doesn’t matter if it’s hot or cold outside, I’ve tried both.


r/runningquestions • • 11d ago

Running shoes...whats my next step...recommendations?

6 Upvotes

My Novablast 5s are coming to the end of their life and I'm looking at what to get next. Can't fault them, so I'm not against getting the same again, but open to suggestions. I'm not chasing PBs so don't need carbon plates. Main goal is staying injury free and getting consistent miles in. Running about 30 km a week, mostly tempo sessions but with some easy and hard runs thrown in.

What would you go for?


r/runningquestions • • 11d ago

How to simplify running?

6 Upvotes

As a beginner runner, what is the most important metric to track progress? Distance, time, heart rate zone? I find that I am becoming very obsessed with the numbers and I want less to track. I really need a simple method of recording my progress and figuring out future workouts.

And do I really need to do interval runs, short runs, long runs?? Or can I just… run? Ideally, I’d like to just run without having to think of intervals (when to stop and go).


r/runningquestions • • Sep 02 '26

Is there an in-between (medium level) running community?

6 Upvotes

Making a somewhat generic post here because after a little bit of research I don't feel like it directly applies to the current reddit communities, where people are either posting their sub 2, or sub 3, 4 hour half and full marathon times, respectively, or starting out running their first 5 or 10k races and posting their times there as well. I don't feel like I fit into either, since although I started running long distance races in 2023, I have yet to officially break a sub 2hr 1/2 or a sub 4hr full. I moved from the States to a subtropical climate in northeastern Brazil in early 2025, and while I made gains in adjusting to the climate, my most recent 1/2 was the second slowest I ran in the past 3 years. I've learned a lot about fueling, pacing, hydration, etc., and ran two fulls- one in May of this year, and then Sept of last year- but just recently I ran a half, and it was by far the worst race I've ran here. I was gassed halfway through, and just a few weeks prior I blew through the same checkpoints. I'm not a beginner, nor an elite runner, but my shorter races are respectable in terms of speed and endurance, so I'm hoping there's some kind of goldilocks running community that I can post this to and get some feedback from.


r/runningquestions • • Jul 23 '26

Best shoes for flat feet

6 Upvotes

I've just started to get into running using hand-me-down hoka cliffton 10s, but find that my arches hurt when running (especially uphill). Im now looking to get new shoes and am wondering if anyone has advice for flat feet? I also wear inserts.

Edit: I got brooks adrenalines. Arch pain is a small fraction of what it used to be, and I was told to not wear my inserts with them


r/runningquestions • • 2d ago

How should I pace myself for my next 5k?

5 Upvotes

Hey reddit!

I done my first 5k race a little while ago which came out to 27:25. I basically just went all out so I could have a general idea of what time I should try and beat. I plan on doing another 5k in the near future, but I have no idea what time I should pace myself for. I think sub 26, but is that shooting a bit too far? Maybe just sub 27 is enough? Or should I just run and ignore trying to make a new time?

I have no clue.

Thanks!


r/runningquestions • • 9d ago

How was my first run?

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

I followed the advice of many of you who said that to simplify my running I can run based on how I feel, but no longer than 30 minutes to start out. I’ll only track distance and time. I can progress by no more than 10% each week.

Today was my first run. On my treadmill, I started with a five-minute warm-up walk followed by a 30-minute run, and concluded with a five-minute cool-down walk.

I had to keep reducing my speed and cadence in order to keep myself at a conversational pace within Zone 2. I felt like the speed was set so low. Is this normal?


r/runningquestions • • Sep 28 '26

Challenged my friend to a milk mile vs regular mile. How should I train?

5 Upvotes

I’ll be doing the milk mile


r/runningquestions • • Sep 03 '26

SUB 32 10K?

5 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I’m racing a 10K in 3 days and my absolute dream goal is to break 32:00 (3:11.2/km average). Im 19 years old, all the workouts were solo. Im very sure i will have a pack that can run with me during the race

I’d love to get some opinions from more experienced runners on whether that goal looks realistic based on these two workouts.

Workout 1

10 × 1 km, 200 m jog recovery

  • Average: 3:08/km

  • Last rep: 3:07

  • Recovery: 65–70 sec easy jog

  • The last rep did NOT feel like an all-out effort. I even had enough energy to talk to a guy riding next to me on a bike while running it.

Workout 2

1k / 2k / 3k / 2k / 1k / 1k

Average pace for each rep:

  • 1k 3:08/km

  • 2k 3:04/km

  • 3k 3:11/km

  • 2k 3:12/km

  • 1k 3:10/km

  • 1k 3:08/km

Again, 200 m jog recovery between reps, around 65–70 sec.

The last 1k was 3:08/km and I could still talk out loud while running it. Is SUB32 possible?


r/runningquestions • • Mar 22 '26

I need advice

5 Upvotes

Idk what to do

I really don't know what to do. I feel like my daughter is doing to much but she keeps saying she is fine. She wakes up at 4:30 for an hour of weights. Then at 7-9 she does an intense swim practice. At 10 she runs 3 miles. Then from 11 am -7 pm she works as a lifeguard at a water park. After that she does a 6 mile run. Then gets home. She is always so grumpy and irrated and is annoyed at the dinner table. She seems exhausted but says she can't quit either sport. She does xc, swim, and track. I wasn't a big sport person in high school. So I just don't know what to do. Should I let her keep going or sit down and talk to her about choosing a sport.


r/runningquestions • • Feb 22 '26

Looking for a training plan (that's not Runna)

5 Upvotes

I'm stuck looking for a new training plan/platform! I used runna all last year which I somewhat enjoyed. I used it for random 5ks, a 10miler, and my two half marathons. Part of me is saying "if it's not broke don't fix it" but honestly I dont wanna pay $20 a month for AI. Anyone have any plans/platforms they recommend. Is Garmin training coach any good?