r/runningquestions • u/OperationMassive6621 • 10d ago
Faster Long Runs for Sub 3 Goal, No More Zone 2 Propaganda
Looking for advice from fast & experienced runners on your approach to long runs, here's the layout:
After consecutive 3:08 marathons, I went back to the drawing board this summer to identify weaknesses in my latest training to finally breakthrough to 2:58 at NYC this past Sunday. My biggest takeaways from my previous races & blocks were:
- more volume + better training absorption (recovery)
- more MP specific work
- better fueling (50g of carbs -> 85g carbs per hour)
This led to the plan HERE that seemingly covered it all: higher volume (65ish peak week), Thurs MP work, LSD on Saturdays ~8:50 pace). My adherence to this plan was 95%, never had been more dialed and smooth through a 16 week block and completed all my MP work at 6:48 pace.
Now, I just raced NYC last week and have never felt WORSE in my life for a pitiful 3:25:40. I felt slow and unathletic by mile 6 and just continually got worse as the race went on. I've done multiple 1:26 halfs and came through half during NYC at 1:32:40 - brutal. One bright spot was increased carbs though, definite game changer for myself at 6'1 188lbs.
Going back to my previous 2 training blocks - all of my long run work usually averaged out around 7:30 to 8:00 min pace with HR usually falling between 136-152 which would put me at zone 2 upper limit/lower zone 3 (my max HR is 188), which people told me was "too fast" or to slow it down for "recovery" purposes.
Wanting to do my own research - I read Pftizinger's Advanced Marathoning book which prescribes long runs at 10%-20% slower than race pace (approx. 7:29 - 8:09 pace) or 80% of HMR (150 for me) with some give or take accounting for the weeks that have MP or progression built in. So basically, I was unknowingly doing Pfitz's long run plan the previous two training blocks when I was dumber and not hung up on zone 2 optimization.
Then, I listened to Stephen Scullion's (2:09 PB) interview with w/ Spencer Matthews, where he covers training hard in long runs and that true zone 2 for the majority of people - in the case of long runs is too slow to create stimulus and get faster for marathon race pace durability, and also lends itself to promoting slower mechanics as an overall system.
To top it all off, NYC's winner this year, Andreas Almgren, shared his training approach and specifically highlights his "four documented hard long runs during the block, and his average pace improved in each one."
So here's my take, I think I slowed my long runs too much prioritizing being at high 120s - mid 130s HR and roughly 8:50 pace in the name of "optimal zone 2 training & absorption", believing the higher MP work on thursdays would be sufficient & it backfired. So, yes - we don't want to intensify our long runs to the point where we can't recover + execute/stay healthy for the following days & weeks, but I also think 99% of us are slow enough to still get better even if we occasionally "overdo" it on long run intensity (aka beginner gains).
For my next training block starting in a few weeks for Jersey City (goal 2:58), my approach to the long run will be simple - be smart, but train fast to be fast. Sometimes we are better off being smart enough, to be naive enough, to not know what we can't accomplish.
With all the zone 2 propaganda & long runs specifically, we're talking about RACING and I don't think that can be forgotten - there's an old saying that goes "I'd rather say whoa than sic' em" and I think that applies here with training, we can't always be afraid of crossing the "limit" in the name of optimization and sometimes the feedback when we do is just as informative.
Advice/thoughts?