r/reddittotp • u/SoInsightful • Apr 18 '12
r/reddittotp • u/Azured • Apr 24 '12
The idea we have is amazing, but this subreddit is dying. Before long it will be dead. Here's a plan to fix it.
The number of posts is beginning to dwindle. Comments are few and far between. The “Sunday deadline” has been and gone and nothing seems to have been advanced.
But the idea is still great, and everyone who joined this subreddit knows it.
Although the momentum is beginning to wane, there have been a lot of positives over the past week. A number of redditors have fronted up with backing tracks, lyrics, cover art, offers to produce tracks or give them radio play. We have what it takes to make something happen, we just don't have the environment quite right.
The idea to date has been to get everyone to put something forward, and the rest to vote. While it's a fair and decent idea in principle, it's not exactly a normal creative process. A lot of voices have gone unheard, and it has been difficult to evolve ideas quickly.
Recently, one of the moderators suggested that we form teams and begin a minor competition.
This is what we need.
We aren't going to get a chart topper off a democratic clusterfuck, but we might get there through teams battling it out week after week. A small team can focus closely on the track at hand and refine it quickly.
Ok, you're a little skeptical, so let me paint you a picture:
Everyone in this subreddit who wants to enter into a team puts forward their name and the particular skill they can offer.
Teams are then formed where the key skills (lyrics, vocals, backing track) are covered.
Every team has one week to write and record a track (to soundcloud perhaps).
At the end of each week all entries are viewed by the community (and reddit at large).
Each element each team's song is assessed out of 100. For example:
Lyrics: 40/100
Backing track: 80/100
Vocals: 70/100
(we may need a website to conduct voting)
Teams are then reset, and each redditor is placed into a new team with others who gained similar scores.
Yes, this is cutthroat, but it also means that the cream will rise to the top. Those who are skilled and committed will unite. After a few weeks we will have quality teams battling it out, and (hopefully) some seriously good tracks being produced.
That's the sort of environment that gets people motivated and excited. That's the sort of environment that might just produce something good enough to hit the charts. If nothing else it will entertain the rest of reddit and get more talent interested in forming teams and joining us.
If you like this idea (if this post does well) we can set up a new thread where everyone who's interested can simply post the skill they offer, and the mods (or whoever) can start assigning teams.
Let's do this.
UPDATE: This post has received some good support. Please see the follow up:
http://www.reddit.com/r/reddittotp/comments/spl22/followup_my_last_post_received_good_support_for/
r/reddittotp • u/TylerRuinsRadio • Apr 20 '12
I work for a legit online radio station. I might be able to get them to play the finished product.
Hey everybody,
I work for an internet radio company called GoRadio. And no, we're not broadcasting out of some guy's garage. This is the big leagues of internet radio.
Anyways, we have a station called #ALLIN that is a pop/dance centric station. They play random shit all the time. I'm pretty sure they'd be down to spin whatever you fine folks come up with.
As for the song itself, might I suggest part of the song includes a chorus of people yelling "hey!" in the background from time to time. That seems to occur in a lot of shitty pop songs.
Tyler
r/reddittotp • u/Benpett • Apr 20 '12
Generic Pop Song [VOCALS AND LYRICS ADDED]
r/reddittotp • u/getbacktoworkpigs • Apr 19 '12
Using pleguyfly's lyrics, i recorded this! Dont be too harsh, i was mixing it on my computer spekars. NSFW
r/reddittotp • u/guitarFreek18 • Apr 19 '12
I wrote "Shitty Pop Song" and would love to assist.
r/reddittotp • u/Ryugi • Apr 18 '12
Lyrics: Discuss.
What kind of lyrics should we use/write?
Love song? Angst song? Gangster-wannabe song? etc. We need a theme to the song.
Well two votes say party/weekend type of song.
So let's consider Pink's Raise Your Glass, Keisha's Tick Tock, and similar such music as inspiration.
We need to mention the following: Alcohol, potential sex (or general slutty nature), the clothes the people are wearing, and the sound of the music. Perhaps a hidden meaning/mention of reddit?
We need to pick: MALE OR FEMALE SINGER?
Male with female solo/chorus?
Requires words: baby, shawty, and tonight.
r/reddittotp • u/[deleted] • Apr 24 '12
OFFICIAL: Reviving this project!
TEAMS, start working on your tracks whenever you can, we are all eager for updates!
Hello fellow Poptrapreneurs,
As you may have noticed, many of our members, Moderators included, have become, for lack of a better word, dead. We had an incredible first 48 hours of this subreddit and quickly grew to over 600 subscribers. This was due to the large amount of excitement that everyone was bringing to the table. Backing tracks were flowing in, Lyric threads were reaching 100 comments, and the mods were working their butts off trying to keep everything organized.
This project has brought us all together with a vision of something great - to get our very own pop song (however generic it may be) to the top of the charts. We have had support from actual Reddit admins, owners of radio stations, professional producers and exceptional singers. We have more resources right in front of us, than many will come across in their entire life, and we mustn't waste it.
I hereby dedicate my time and effort to keep this project alive. I will designate as much help and oversight as I can muster. You must forgive me if I seem a bit less active due to the fact that I am enrolled in my senior year taking 6 classes at my University and trying to squeeze in time for 30 hours of work and time my pregnant wife. But I honestly will try to keep my visible easily seen. I would love nothing more than to say that I contributed to this incredible project, and helped get our very own pop song/s to the top of the charts.
WHEN we do this, millions will experience our work,
We will NOT let this project die.
We will get to the top of the pops!
Now, onto the business side of things.
I feel it would be most beneficial to form teams as soon as possible. We all know what the 2/3 most popular backing tracks on this sub are
SoInsightful's http://soundcloud.com/random-insight/generic-pop-instrumental
Evenberard's http://soundcloud.com/evanberard/vip
AdrianSmeaton's http://soundcloud.com/little-flare/just-the-way-it-goes
just to name a few.
These would be good tracks to start forming teams too. I will post all backing tracks tomorrow morning and have a field that states whether there is a team formed or not, as well as if there are any team openings left, so keep an eye out. Hopefully, by having 'positions', we can make the song creating process much smoother, but PLEASE do not wait until positions are filled. Once you have a few members, feel free to begin collaborating (if you haven't done so already).
Now, just because teams are formed doesn't mean one cannot assist other teams that are "competing" against them. This is a friendly competition aimed at adding excitement, not constricting it. And if the spots are all filled, feel free to still give your input and critique! We want anyone interested to participate, and the last thing I want is to turn people away.
Also, if a backing track already has a team formed, but you and a few others really wanted to go a different direction on the track, make your own team and make it a success!
Feel free to join multiple teams as well! We can all use each others help.
To apply for teams, read the following:
Team positions are:
Team Leader
Producer
Lyric Writers
Vocals (Male, Female, Rap, Etc.)
Mixer
Mastering
Videographer
Cover Artist
Please state your application as follows:
Reddit Username: (so it is easier for me to track teams)
Team Number:
Requested Position: (i.e. producer, lyricist, etc.)
I will make new threads for each team that forms and those shall be the main meeting grounds for future team business (at least to start out). It may be a good Idea to come up with team names, and each team elect a leader to ensure that everything is done properly and effectively. The team leader can then open threads at will to offer more organized communications. Team leaders; please open new team threads in this format: TEAM GENERICSONG: Lyric Discussion. This way everything will be easily visible and teams can track their information
I look forward to seeing us grow, compete, and succeed!
All Available Backing Tracks to work with:
Please listen to all tracks before selecting just one. There are a lot of really great submissions here
Please let me know in the comments below if I have missed any tracks.
r/reddittotp • u/producer4reddit • May 27 '12
Final edit of my track.. Needs vocals.
r/reddittotp • u/someguydoes • May 03 '12
i did some vox on Little Flare's song "just the way it goes" if you listen closely you might hear the panties hitting the floor, or maybe not.
r/reddittotp • u/noahdamus • Apr 24 '12
this concept is amazing
So I think this is a brilliant idea, and it has much more value than just creating this one song. If this community were to grow large enough, and have enough talent, perhaps there is a real future in music production this way. I could see this subreddit being a place for all sorts of music projects. Someone has a concept for a song, posts about it, and can potentially generate enough interest from the right people that it turns into something great.
Someone suggested people are losing interest because they have to wait to be involved (the singers must wait for the lyrics and music to be written, the producers must wait for that, the radio host must wait for that, etc.). If we had many projects going on all the time, then people could plug in immediately, whatever their skill. I foresee projects being posted, and if enough interest is there, perhaps another website is utilized for the communication and creation. Meanwhile as the project progresses, the OP can update this community and continue to recruit as necessary. For this to function well (since for most this will be an extracurricular activity) we'll need a large user base. The best projects would surely rise to the top and get the attention they deserve.
r/reddittotp • u/[deleted] • Apr 29 '12
Band Name/Concept/Idea: The Wadsworth Constant
We will make normal, full length songs at first, but they would all be released with the first 30 percent cut off.
r/reddittotp • u/selkies • Apr 19 '12
Once we get the song finalized, I suggest we convince Keith Apicary to dance in the music video. He's a redditor and I'm sure he would support it.
All in favor?
r/reddittotp • u/Azured • May 05 '12
The first round of a reddit song-writing tournament has just closed. Teams of three randomly assembled redditors had one week to write and record a song. Listen and vote now!
One week ago we launched the /r/gameofbands tournament.
Redditors signed up under three categories (lyrics, music, vocals), and were randomly grouped into teams. Each team then had one week to write and record a song.
Here's a sample of the songs entered so far:
Further entries are currently coming in. If you want to vote or provide feedback, you can!
Here's how voting and scoring works:
You can vote for a song by upvoting the post it's found in. Upvotes for tracks are converted into scores and shared between band members once voting closes.
You can vote for individual members by upvoting their official comments within a post. Official comments are along the lines of "I wrote the music for this track". Upvotes for band members are applied to directly to their scores.
Once all scores are calculated, teams will be reshuffled and the next round will commence.
More info on r/gameofbands can be found here:
http://www.reddit.com/r/gameofbands/comments/svb5e/rgameofbands_questions_and_answers_teams/
EDIT: This is not reddittotp. This is a separate competition. I put this up here so those who wanted to collaborate on tracks could check it out. Many who joined reddittotp did so to get involved in the creative process.
The post stated that this was a tournament being run in /r/gameofbands and never mentioned anything to do with writing a pop hit. Apparently this has been hugely confusing.
Good luck to those still working on reddittotp.
r/reddittotp • u/Kippersoft • Apr 19 '12
The psychological effects are very important; not the lyrics themselves
I think this is critical and need to be seriously planned out. The actual words don't matter; we make fun of them all the time here. But the effect they have on the listener is huge.
Example: Black Eyed Peas just list off the days of the week for lyrics. But as the listener, I immediately know the words and can sing along.
Example: Rihanna adds -ella to umbrella. Every time I say the word umbrella, I now feel the need to add -ella -ella -eh -eh
Example: Lady Gaga's Poker Face's is a combo of a popular phrase ("can't read my poker face") and a repetition ("p-p-p-poker face, p-p-poker face")
Example: Rebecca Black's Friday. I can't say what day it is without following up with "and Saturday comes afterworrrddds..." because it's stuck in my head like that.
Example: LMFAO has fun phrases like "Everyday I'm shufflin'" and "I wooork ooout". Something fun to repeat and stick in your mind.
What we need:
Repetition. Simple lyrics to the beat of the music that are fun.
Well known phrase. I should know the lyrics of the chorus after one listen.
Something catchy. A fun catchy phrase to say or something the listener will likely say in an average day. This gets it stuck in their head even when not listening to the song.
Call for action. "Put your hands up." "Clap Clap Clap Clap..." "Stand up" These are standard lyrics to tell the listener to do something which makes them feel involved in the song and not just a passive listener.
I'm sure there's many more, but I think we need to focus on these. So please add to the list if you think of others. The lyrics I've seen briefly so far don't have enough of these physiological effect.
r/reddittotp • u/SquidManHero • Apr 28 '12
Remeber, we're part of something special.
I haven't seen any posts for a while in this reddit for lyrics - or anything, for that matter. I'm a terrible singer, and I would be wasting my time to post something here. But I want everyone else to remeber that we're part of something awesome on reddit. We're the only ones here collaberating on making a song. That was pretty awesome, last time I checked. And remember,this picture is fucking hilarious.
r/reddittotp • u/memefilter • Apr 22 '12
SoInsightful suggested I start a new thread - added lyrics and vocals, titled it "forever alone". (MIC)
r/reddittotp • u/[deleted] • Apr 20 '12
So have we agreed to use SoInsightful's backing track, or at least a version of it?
He made a 2nd version which is better in my opinion, but this is pretty much exactly what we need.
http://soundcloud.com/random-insight/generic-pop-instrumental-ver-2
So, if we are using this, We need a hook. That's what we need first. Reddit, this is your time to shine. Using your musical talents come up with the catchiest melody you fucking can that goes and post it here. I'm talking catchy-ass shit.
Edit: the chorus is 8 measures (I'm using 8-counts as measures btw), so if we follow generic writing, it should be 2 identical sets of four with slightly altered lyrics.
r/reddittotp • u/maniexx • May 22 '13
I know this place is dead, but whoever subscribes still, should see this
r/reddittotp • u/[deleted] • Apr 20 '12
OFFICIAL: Introducing Teams!
Hello fellow Top of the Pops!
There have been many posts and comments throughout this subreddit about creating multiple songs, having competing bands, and even creating an entire album. We on the moderation team think these are some very great ideas and would like to organize along these lines.
To please the demand for multiple mini-projects, we would like to introduce Track Specific Teams (TST's)! These TST's will be based off on the most selected tracks (between 2 and 5. Anything more and we may loose resources to other teams and reduce the chance of success), and have specific members for every department of song creation.
For example:
A very popular track on this subreddit is 'Generic Pop Song' by SoInsightful. The team for this track couldconsist of the following:
Lead producer (backing track / mixing / mastering): SoInsightful
Backing track: http://soundcloud.com/random-insight/generic-pop-instrumental
Writers (lead melody): ?
Writers (lyrics): ?
Performer (rapper for verses): ?
Performer (singer for chorus): ?
Videographer: ?
Cover artist: ?
This team would then be responsible for focusing on this track and perfecting it to be aired to the masses.
We feel this friendly competition will offer more creativity and dedication to the project. Also, by having more than one option available, we have a much greater chance of reaching our goal - Number one on the charts!
Remember, all backing tracks (the basis for this whole concept) are due by Sunday at midnight (GMT+0). Please post submissions to this thread, the most popular submissions will be the grounds for new TSTs.
If you are interested in becoming part of a particular team, please wait until after the Sunday deadline to request a particular track. When all of the top tracks are determined, TSTs can begin to form.
Good luck to all of the upcoming TSTs!
r/reddittotp • u/chuckrussell • Apr 20 '12
Potential album cover art. Suggestions welcome!