r/programming • • Jul 17 '22

Create decentralized applications with JavaScript, HTML and CSS

https://gridnet.org/wpp/index.php/2022/07/12/create-ui-dapps-right-now-developer-guide/
122 Upvotes

159 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/rafalsk Jul 18 '22 edited Jul 18 '22

centralised authority which decides what’s acceptable

Kindly do notice, that I have underlined specifically two points you have somehow decided to skip over, why? Let me rephrase these, slowly.

  • neither the end-user nor the developer might mind the app review process. The app review process does not prevent any app from making its way into the 'app store'.

  • anyone might join the review process. Thus, the review process is decentralized. Decentralized voting, to be specific.

And if a malicious application makes it past your vetting process how will you then remove it from your network?

Rating of every app might change over time, it is up to the user to decide whether to keep using the app based on the current score.

Nobody removes anything.

One may implement an app where content is removed say based on a score but that is a different story.

2

u/0s_and_1s Jul 18 '22 edited Jul 18 '22

So what’s the point of the app review process if it doesn’t prevent an app from reaching the store?

If anyone can review the process how many approves do you have? what if I got my friends who also want to publish the malicious app to out number your genuine approves and increase my chance to approve it?

So I could publish an app that does malicious activity on the users machine, if the app review process is not mandatory I could skip it and get it published, I could get my bot farm to rate it highly and people will continue to use it right?

You could completely miss the malicious code during the review process? You’re just trying to make the Apple App Store with extra steps and non of the budget.

I don’t know what you’ve been doing the last few years you claimed to be coding this but engaging your brain probably wasn’t one of those things.

2

u/rafalsk Jul 18 '22 edited Jul 18 '22

but engaging your brain probably wasn’t one of those things

Instead of desperately trying to 'win' this conversation, skipping over what's being said to you, and coming up with false assumptions to back your fudding, I would advise you to use your brain indeed and focus on the arguments presented.

So let us go again, tackling all of the points you've brought up, slowly.

We have got some of the best developers and scientists around, these are not people who play dice. Not with ideas a random person on Reddit could 'fight' easily.

We have already arrived at a common viewpoint that the review process itself, it is decentralized, right? Ok then.

what if I got my friends who also want to publish the malicious app to out number your genuine approves and increase my chance to approve it

The review process is Sybil-proof. It relies on the amount of assets you got frozen for the purpose. Your voting power is based on the amount of assets you got frozen.

if the app review process is not mandatory I could skip it and get it published

Your app does not need to 'pass' the review process that is correct. Users would know though. And it is up to them if they want to use it.

I could get my bot farm to rate it highly and people will continue to use it right

yet again, the review process is Sybil proof.

The voting power relies on a concave function, meaning it yields higher value for same amount of assets invested into a single identity (voting identity) so having a bot farm would never make sense. You would want a single identity so to maximize your voting power. And should majority of voting power ever decide your voting identity to be malicious, your malicious identity would be eliminated. Meaning lost assets.

engaging your brain

I am here to assist you further, but kindly please be precise and kindly do make the best out of your brain indeed.

2

u/0s_and_1s Jul 18 '22

So you claimed you’ll have “freedom” but third parties can silence you if for whatever reason they want if they have enough power. All of this to host a website? Wow. Good job.

1

u/rafalsk Jul 18 '22

It is called decentralized consensus.

Bitcoin relies on a decentralized consensus as well. People consider Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies as pro-freedom.

If the majority ever decides you to be a scammer, well, they just might have a point.

2

u/0s_and_1s Jul 18 '22

And how many people are in your pool? Fuck all right?

1

u/rafalsk Jul 18 '22

Say again?