r/programming • • Apr 09 '11

Lua JIT, PyPy, Tracemonkey, Python 2.7, JRuby and others removed from the Benchmark Game [shootout.alioth.debian.org]

http://thread.gmane.org/gmane.comp.python.pypy/7303/focus=7352
83 Upvotes

156 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '11

This is discouraging to all those who go to the effort to program a new implementation of an existing language that their work might not get noticed. Doubly so to Mike Pall that his got removed when he wasn't a part of this. Tracemonkey and JRuby too.

12

u/gargantuan Apr 09 '11 edited Apr 09 '11

Agreed.

It shouldn't be a big deal. The website itself mentions how these are "broken" benchmarks. But then it seems like Isaac takes it rather personally and goes to the extra effort to hurt other projects. I mean, reducing their visibility by removing them. So now PyPy and LuaJIT are gone but ATS is there. I have never even heard of ATS outside of the shootout website....

Someone mentioned a fork of the speed website and that might not be a bad idea.

-3

u/igouy Apr 09 '11

goes to the extra effort to hurt other projects

Like the extra effort to measure each new LuaJIT beta release asap so those measurements can be used immediately to promote LuaJIT?

1

u/gargantuan Apr 09 '11

Well now it is gone.

And then for Java he seems to runs a warm-up process that he doesn't necessarily do for other languages to possibly benefit from disk cache warm-ups.

0

u/igouy Apr 10 '11 edited Apr 10 '11

And then for Java he seems to runs a warm-up process

That's not true.

-13

u/igouy Apr 09 '11

Glass half full - Mike Pall has had 5 years of free publicity for LuaJIT