Why speak up? Because people should know what they're getting into. If Drupal works for you, great. But Drupal folks need to realize they are at the center of a giant reality distortion field that conveniently papers over its flaws in favor of an almost cultish feel-good vibe. It's a huge community, arguably the biggest OS community in the world, and what comes out is a product that is meh and doesn't look like anything that is exciting on the web today.
There's also the fact that I've observed these processes at work up close, for years, and don't believe Drupal will change any time soon.
But it's not like I'm on some crusade to discredit Drupal. I've barely written anything about it since I left. I merely saw an opportunity to speak up and did so. Given the response, it seems like it was a good idea.
Drupal folks need to realize they are at the center of a giant reality distortion field that conveniently papers over its flaws
I think it's unfair to say that Drupal papers over its flaws. The issue queues and IRC are full of contributors quite vocally recognising and working on these issues. Patches are picked over in detail from the POV of code and design quality. Of course there are still design issues and bugs, some persistent - just like any other large software project. This is all in public and available for anyone to see - how could it be 'papered over'?
Yes, the community markets Drupal, on the implicit understanding that widespread implementation is the path to long-term software survival and improvement - again like any other software project.
And if you want to talk about reality distortion fields, where to begin? Maybe first take a look at Rails or Agile (or the enterprise Java world for that matter). Regardless of any hype, there are still functional sites written in Rails, and Agile continues to usefully break barriers between business and dev. Applying Occam's razor, could it not be that people gush about Drupal because it actually solves their problems? Despite its reputation for weak usability, I've repeatedly had excellent feedback from business users who don' care what the underlying technology is.
what comes out is a product that is meh and doesn't look like anything that is exciting on the web today
You haven't offered a better alternative - what do you think is exciting on the web today? You've just said that the Drupal community is unable to produce quality software and held up some design imperfections as evidence. From a business perspective, Drupal leads the field in its class and is a no-brainer for many commercial websites both small and at scale. That is one definition of quality software. And then there's the more technically exciting stuff - MongoDB support, RDFa, OAuth and services, an ECA Rules engine, fieldable entities, pluggable auth and caching, l10n/i18n, external services piped through Views. (You say you tried the last and found it painful to get working, me too - but I believe that's completely expected for any cutting edge development, particularly AOP-based. And to be fair Views 3 has only recently gone into alpha.)
You say you want to warn people - then surely give a balanced view and also consider the strengths and weaknesses of the alternatives.
2
u/UnConeD Jan 07 '11
Why speak up? Because people should know what they're getting into. If Drupal works for you, great. But Drupal folks need to realize they are at the center of a giant reality distortion field that conveniently papers over its flaws in favor of an almost cultish feel-good vibe. It's a huge community, arguably the biggest OS community in the world, and what comes out is a product that is meh and doesn't look like anything that is exciting on the web today.
There's also the fact that I've observed these processes at work up close, for years, and don't believe Drupal will change any time soon.
But it's not like I'm on some crusade to discredit Drupal. I've barely written anything about it since I left. I merely saw an opportunity to speak up and did so. Given the response, it seems like it was a good idea.