r/programming • • Jan 05 '11

Drupal 7 released.

http://drupal.org/drupal-7.0
222 Upvotes

259 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/Shocker88 Jan 05 '11 edited Jan 05 '11

Until the "choose wordpress which does 90% of what Drupal does" I was in agreeance.

But unfortunately you're going to have to take this downvote for being completely misguided. I'd have been in agreeance if you had of said "choose wordpress which provides the CMS functionality". But saying Wordpress can do 90% of what Drupal can is completely incorrect. Yes Wordpress as a basic CMS (changing content from an end user perspective and adding a widget here and there) is great, but for much better extensibility you need Drupal, it's already providing the framework and CMS you're talking about trying to custom code/workout multiple systems to provide a solution for you

In the end its at the developers discretion for what they choose to develop within, however after the initial headache of learning how everything works within drupal - it does provide the solution both of you have been discussing in a much easier packaged and quick system. It's not always the answer, but it's rarely not a good answer.

edit: Probably should link to prove my point on the 90% being well off the mark - check drupals core API here

1

u/fewpeople Jan 05 '11 edited Jan 05 '11

IMO, the point of a CMS is for the End-user to focus on content, and in my experience, unless they are forced to do so (or they are technical), they won't learn the complex usability that Drupal has going on. Thus it FAILS at it's initial task.

Also, I don't get why you'd learn the quirks for a specific system, than to just learn a framework which you can apply in general anywhere. Wordpress for basic sites --> Cake/MVC frameworks for everything else.

5

u/Shocker88 Jan 05 '11 edited Jan 05 '11

Because once you understand Drupal it's about as quick as putting together a simple site as Wordpress and it cuts a TONNE of custom work out of most larger projects that you'd be throwing Cake/MVC frameworks at. Plus it's much easier learning and teaching all of your companies employees one system rather than 2+.

Drupal is essentially both a framework and a CMS integrated into a single package. Rather than custom code a CMS up for each site you do (or even code up a stock standard one) it's already there and easily extensible through content types and views.

There are some times where you'd want to move to a framework system - but Drupal with its contributed modules and CMS functionality can literally cut 3/4 of a heavy development project out by providing the solution for it in a structured and stable approach.

Drupal can be used in basically anything thrown at you given the knowledge and thus learning its quirks of it is beneficial as it's likely you won't need to move outside of it as a framework.

Cake is a great and very clean framework, however it can't cut as much time out of a project as Drupal does. (I havent used it in a few years - however seems there are no solid supported CMS options yet). My move to drupal was a forced one by my current employer. Would never have switched otherwise as it just sempt dirty from the outside.

Once you can get your head around Drupal I assure you there's little places you wish you were able to use another framework and/or CMS.

2

u/AlejandroTheGreat Jan 05 '11

It's also much better for your clients to leave them a working site that they can hire someone else to maintain. A from-scratch site will make the poor bastard coming after you who has to grok your whole codebase want to burn your house down.

1

u/boombatta Jan 05 '11

I can sorta see what you mean when comparing Drupal to Wordpress, but as I see things, if you develop your Drupal site well, create specific roles for those who will be maintaining the site, and keep the end-user in mind as you develop (creating meaningful vocabularies, fields, etc), then I don't really see there being issues due to an overly complex usability and maintainability. And I've developed for some extraordinarily untechnical people. But I don't mean to take anything away, I think Wordpress is brilliant. Cake though, I never liked, but I know I'm in the minority on that one. :)

-2

u/midri Jan 05 '11

Wordpress can do 90% of what drupal does though... I know entire web design firms that use nothing but wordpress (it scares me a bit) but it's completely possible.

4

u/Shocker88 Jan 05 '11 edited Jan 05 '11

If by wordpress can do 90% of what drupal does, you mean they use wordpress then custom code on top of it like crazy? Then sure anythings possible in that sense it can do everything drupal can...it'll just take them years of man hours to setup the same type of framework. Out of the box though however, Drupal can do so much more for heavy development projects. Wordpress can provide a nice admin interface and CMS features as well as basic framework to work upon, but it pales in comparison to the extensibility in Drupals core framework and thats without considering the thousands of custom-contributed modules that the community have created for use by anyone...

Edit: If you're going to downvote then please provide a reason for why, it might not be what you wanted but it is the truth as was re-iterated by Critter again.

1

u/CritterM72800 Jan 05 '11

And chances are those web firms are either:

  1. Making relatively simple sites or

  2. Making complex sites by doing a lot of custom plugin development

If #1 then great, but if #2 then they're just biting themselves in the foot. It's pretty amazing what you can do in Drupal with just core + contrib modules (i.e., without any custom code), and that just isn't the case in WP. Don't get me wrong, I love WP as much as the next guy and I use it fairly often, but anyone who says it can do 90% of what Drupal can do just doesn't understand what Drupal can do.

1

u/fewpeople Jan 05 '11

Sigh, if you read the initial thread, I edited that subjective 90% number everyone keeps referencing.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '11

I am a professional Drupal developer. I tell all my friends to use WordPress, but I develop in Drupal because I need that 10%.