r/programming • • Jun 15 '19

Announcing the Visual Studio Code Installer for Java

https://devblogs.microsoft.com/visualstudio/announcing-visual-studio-code-java-installer/
840 Upvotes

249 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-7

u/_cjj Jun 15 '19

I'm guessing it's "opposite" day today?

It's pretty stupid to call VSCode an IDE because it isn't - it's an editor

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '19

[deleted]

0

u/_cjj Jun 15 '19

As per Microsoft:

"Visual Studio Code is a streamlined code editor with support for development operations like debugging, task running, and version control. It aims to provide just the tools a developer needs for a quick code-build-debug cycle and leaves more complex workflows to fuller featured IDEs, such as Visual Studio IDE."

If you think VSCode is an IDE, you probably haven't needed one yet.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '19

[deleted]

-4

u/_cjj Jun 15 '19

So you've decided to take it personally. It'll affect your judgement, as per this thread.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '19

[deleted]

3

u/_cjj Jun 15 '19

Because you've chosen to ignore the word 'probably'.

Have you used IntelliJ?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '19

[deleted]

1

u/_cjj Jun 15 '19

The sheer amount of tuning and support out of the box is a big one. Can VSCode connect to, and validate, against a DB schema? Can it fully integrate application servers? Provide test integration (including coverage)? Code generation (not least generating wsdl classes)? Local history for changed files? Etc ...

The answer for most is "no", and some of the others is "well, if you install x plugin...", at which point VSCode still won't do it anywhere near as well as Intellj. Or as simply.

VSCode is essentially a push bike that isn't a motorbike. Yes, you can bolt an engine onto it, and claim it is the same, but it just isn't. A bit like how WordPress can be extended into becoming stuff it wasn't originally designed to be.

I'll add that the best thing about IntelliJ, whilst not being exactly an IDE feature, is the code inspection stuff (and the refactoring tools). It proactively makes you better by teaching you alternative/better ways of doing things. That shouldn't be disregarded.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '19

hehe. i guess the IDEs from a decade or two ago weren't IDEs because they didn't have all the features of intellij or some other bloat.

3

u/YM_Industries Jun 15 '19

It has an integrated terminal, file browser, version control, step-by-step debugger. What more do you need to call it an IDE?

If IDLE is an IDE (which it is) then VSCode certainly is. Maybe you're getting it confused with Atom?

2

u/_cjj Jun 15 '19

I've already replied to a similar posts around this. If you want to call it an IDE (which MS don't), it's a crap one. If you want to call it a code editor, is a good one.

-1

u/YM_Industries Jun 15 '19

I've been using it as an IDE for everything except C# recently. It's much better than WebStorm for JavaScript and TypeScript, it's better than PHPStorm for PHP, it's great as a Python IDE.

The only thing I've used it for where it wasn't great was Rust, and that's purely because the debugging plugin needs more work. (Currently it doesn't support stdio)

-1

u/_cjj Jun 15 '19

IntelliJ != WebStorm, PHPStorm, or VSCode.

JavaScript and PHP don't have or require what a proper IDE does for Java. If you use IntelliJ for non-Java purposes, and find VSC is better, then fair enough. It's like comparing a Golf to an R8 - you won't see the advantages if you're not using them.

1

u/YM_Industries Jun 15 '19

VS and VSCode both have IntelliSense, which is pretty fantastic. Maybe IntelliJ is better, but if you define an IDE as "something which has IntelliJ" then there's literally only one IDE in the world. That's a terrible definition.

1

u/_cjj Jun 15 '19

Well this is about a Java-specific version of VSCode, and IntelliJ - which is primarily a Java IDE, so it's pretty redundant to call VSCode an IDE 'when it's not for Java', considering the context?

2

u/YM_Industries Jun 15 '19

This isn't a Java-specific version of VSCode, it's just an installer that bundles both VSCode and OpenJDK. VSCode isn't like the JetBrains offerings where they have different versions for different purposes, it's a single piece of software that uses extensions to cater for different languages. The extensions are activated based on what type of file you are editing.

I never said VSCode isn't an IDE for Java and I'm really not sure how you're still arguing this.

VSCode is a fully-featured Java IDE. It has syntax highlighthing, step-through debugging, a test runner, support for dependencies and builds using Maven, ability to insert snippets, inline documentation, refactoring suggestions, and code completion. Even if IntelliJ is better, it's absurd to say that that means VSCode somehow doesn't qualify for the title of IDE.

Eclipse and NetBeans are both IDEs and they are blown out of the water by VSCode.

Could you please give me your definition of IDE that somehow doesn't include VSCode? What are the missing features that make VSCode an editor instead of an IDE?

1

u/_cjj Jun 15 '19

Could you please give me your definition of IDE that somehow doesn't include VSCode? What are the missing features that make VSCode an editor instead of an IDE?

Ask Microsoft - they make the thing, and make it pretty clear it isn't an IDE. They have written it, so should be the authority.

As far as I'm concerned, I tried it when looking to use anything other than Eclipse and it was terrible. It's like a beta of a lite version of something like IntelliJ. Without a lot of features. Any attempt to get it near something that goes beyond "fancy code editor" involves installing plugin-upon-plugin.

So, as far as theory goes, if you think something is an IDE because it can be extensibly made to resemble one, then you'd be basically calling Notepad++ an IDE.