r/programming • • Jun 15 '19

Announcing the Visual Studio Code Installer for Java

https://devblogs.microsoft.com/visualstudio/announcing-visual-studio-code-java-installer/
840 Upvotes

249 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

39

u/YM_Industries Jun 15 '19

VSCode is an "everything IDE".

-31

u/ivancea Jun 15 '19

Where is my "everything installer" then

22

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '19

Why'd you want that? Not everyone wants everything, it'd be bloated as hell.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '19

[deleted]

6

u/PM_ME_UR_OBSIDIAN Jun 15 '19

VS Code has performance in a completely different class vs. Slack and Spotify. I don't know how they do it but it's not just a typical Electron app.

2

u/vqrs Jun 15 '19

I'm guessing part of it is dogfooding their editor/IDE. And having competent programmers. They probably also make changes to electron to help them with performance.

-18

u/ivancea Jun 15 '19

The point is, is a bit strange fro a generic editor to have a special installer for one language...

5

u/Kissaki0 Jun 15 '19

A separate installer reduces barrier to entry.

Consequently it makes sense for multiple reasons.

I missed when Microsoft started promoting and committing to Java. But they have a developer blog category for the Java language, and this delegated installer further supports their commitment to supporting Java.

It’s a great way to promote VS Code in the Java ecosystem (both practically and as a commitment statement), it makes it easier for devs to start out with Java and VS Code, and easier to try it out if you’re already familiar with Java.

The Eclipse IDE always had a vibrant ecosystem with their IDE platform and framework, and distributed and prepared various use case specific installers for languages, modeling, plugin development etc. Because the alternative of installing a bare bone installer and then individual plugins is a lot of work, and would be for every user that will install it. Providing a prepared installer is way more efficient and easier on the user.

16

u/Kwinten Jun 15 '19

No, that's literally the entire point of having a plugin-based architecture on top of a lightweight base framework.

-4

u/ivancea Jun 15 '19

Te point of a plugin based arch is to have plugins with that functionality, no installers...

12

u/Kwinten Jun 15 '19

It's just a little helper tool. You can install all those dependencies and plugins by yourself too.

-7

u/ivancea Jun 15 '19

That's the point. I think any Java programmer can install both cide and the jdk with two commands, in any OS... And there it is OmniSharp that depends on the msbuild tools... Where are they focusing their efforts 🙄

5

u/Kissaki0 Jun 15 '19

That’s the normal installer then. And then you install the plugins/language plugin you want.

Because surely, you don’t want to start out with ALL languages/plugins installed?

-3

u/ivancea Jun 15 '19

It was sarcasm...