r/programming • • Sep 26 '18

Do not fall into Oracle's Java 11 trap

https://blog.joda.org/2018/09/do-not-fall-into-oracles-java-11-trap.html
797 Upvotes

382 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/duhace Sep 27 '18

OpenJDK is the reference jvm.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

again, totally changeable. Yes, currently everything isn't bad, but essentially this is Oracle testing the waters. If they don't have anything go wrong they will turn up the heat a little more until they cook the frog. We are the frog in this scenario.

2

u/duhace Sep 27 '18

You realize the community can just continue opendk if oracle tries anything right?

Making the openjdk the free to use version they push everyone to is the opposite of killing or closing it

0

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

it's a move to make it so people aren't mad that they are profiteering. If they turned up the heat too quickly we would fight back hard. You act like there's no way in the future Oracle could disable the OpenJDK's ability to use the JVM. Apple has been controlling things on the development side for years, Oracle is looking to do the same thing. Hence why they are so mad about the use of Java in the Android SDK- they can't control that in the future if they decide to take down the openJDK. It may not be happening now, but this is a sign that it will happen in the future because eventually they will want more money.

0

u/duhace Sep 27 '18

openjdk is the JVM. it doesn't use the JVM. it is the jvm

since openjdk is the jvm, they can't disable our ability to use the jvm.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

bro, it wasn't the JVM recently. They can make it not the JVM at any time.

2

u/duhace Sep 27 '18

bro, it wasn't the JVM recently.

it's been the reference jvm for quite a while now.

They can make it not the JVM at any time.

they'd have to override the java community as a whole to do that. and those community members (IBM, Intel, Azul, RedHat, etc) would raise a fuss about it and a fork would happen. just like with libre office (which is not dead btw)

under what mechanism do you think they'd be able to move people back off the openjdk after moving people on to it?