r/programming • • Sep 26 '18

Do not fall into Oracle's Java 11 trap

https://blog.joda.org/2018/09/do-not-fall-into-oracles-java-11-trap.html
797 Upvotes

382 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-1

u/jl2352 Sep 26 '18

It’s open source with Oracle characteristics.

7

u/pron98 Sep 26 '18

It's open source under the GPLv2. The license fully covers the liberties you have. Oracle didn't write the license and they have not restricted it.

1

u/jl2352 Sep 26 '18

You said it yourself. I can fork, but only if it’s forked to be an OpenJDK derivative. So it is a restriction on forking.

I would also add that given Oracle’s history, it’s very hard to believe they will be playing fair. Because that’s not how they play in the recent past.

Oracle has a lot more movement to do to prove they can be trusted. They have a lot of work to do to build that trust.

4

u/pron98 Sep 26 '18 edited Sep 26 '18

I can fork, but only if it’s forked to be an OpenJDK derivative. So it is a restriction on forking.

No, no restriction other than -- as with every open source project -- the use of trademarks. What exactly is the difference between OpenJDK and Linux?

Because that’s not how they play in the recent past... They have a lot of work to do to build that trust.

Does Oracle have a history of violating open-source licenses? OpenJDK has been around for about a decade now (and under Oracle's leadership for most of that time), and I am not aware of any legal issues surrounding it. It's a GPL project, just like Linux (although, one would argue, with more adult leadership).

-1

u/jl2352 Sep 26 '18

No, you weren’t talking about trademarks in that section. You were talking about patents.

4

u/pron98 Sep 26 '18

Again, OpenJDK is licensed under GPL, with whatever patent liberties it entails -- like every other GPL project.

1

u/duhace Sep 27 '18

1

u/jl2352 Sep 27 '18

I just learned that Oracle developers will not be helping to fix any bug older than 6 months. That's pretty bad.

1

u/duhace Sep 27 '18

that isn't true. they will not be maintaining the openjdk 11 past 6 months, but bugs that are discovered will be fixed in 12, 13, etc. A number of companies in the opensource community have already stepped forward to provide backports of said fixes to openjdk 11 for 4 years.

1

u/jl2352 Sep 27 '18

6 months is pretty shit for open source maintenance. For a real company using Java in production, 6 months is a very short time to force them update their version of Java.

In comparison Node is 2 to 3 years.

1

u/duhace Sep 27 '18

that's why the lts will have 4 years of maintenance provided by the opensource community. redhat, intel, ibm, azul, and others are gonna be maintaining openjdk 11 past the 6 month mark, while oracle develops future versions of the jvm.

-1

u/nowylie Sep 26 '18

I don't know anything about OpenJDK licensing but I just wanted to point out that there is a difference between copyright, trademarks, and patents.

3

u/pron98 Sep 26 '18

Yes, but OpenJDK, like Linux, is subject to the GPL with everything it does and does not entail pertaining to all those aspects.

1

u/duhace Sep 27 '18

then read up on the effects of the gplv2 on patents: https://copyleft.org/guide/comprehensive-gpl-guidech7.html

also, note that openjdk is gplv2 with classpath exception, a special gplv2 by oracle. what the classpath exception means is that your software is not required to be GPL as well if using the openjdk's classpath (basically, you can run your program, and use the base java libraries without obligating you to be gpl). if you modify the openjdk and distribute it, you must have it be gplv2