This is not for OpenJDK, but for the Java specification. OpenJDK is fully open, and you can fork it at will, just like any other OSS project. What you cannot do is use the Java trademark (same as Linux). OpenJDK is no more and no less open than Linux, and is not subject to any other restrictions than the license it is released under (GPL), which incidentally explicitly prohibits any further restrictions. Say what you will about Oracle, they take these license/legal matters very seriously.
You can't fork it, extend it, and still call it Java. That last part is key: in order to be able to call it Java, you must comply with the spec.
The patent indemnification still flows to you so long as you continue to abide by the OpenJDK license terms (i.e. the GPL), as you lawfully did get the license for patent use in that way. You can fork it all you want. You just can't call it Java.
The GPLv2 does not grant a patent license; it is only concerned with copyright. Some people argue that a patent license is implied, but I don't think there has ever been a court case testing that theory. The GPLv3 has an explicit patent grant, but Java is only licensed under v2.
For example, if Company A has a patent on advanced Web browsing, but also licenses a Web browsing program under the GPLv2, then it cannot assert the patent against any party based on that party’s use of Company A’s GPL’d Web browsing software program, or on that party’s creation and use of modified versions of that GPL’d program.
That's the problem with relying on shit third parties say about licenses. There is nothing actually in GPLv2 mentioning patents at all, except for a section that prohibits adding further distribution restrictions in a patent license. Apparently, the FSF thinks there is an implicit patent license due to US case law, but that's a pretty shaky argument that could easily be negated by a court.
They are not a court, and their opinions on this matter are basically irrelevant. In particular, the precedent they are citing applies to physical goods that are purchased from a vendor, and the purchase price is the consideration that results in the patent license for the inventions embodied in the patented article. Applying this to software that is given away for free is rather dubious.
I've just read the licence, and the word "patent" is only mentioned in the preamble (which is not binding), section 7, and section 8.
Section 7 basically says that if patents prevent you from distributing the software under the GPL, you simply cannot distribute it. It does not grant you any patent. Not from Oracle, not from whoever distributed this copy of the software, not from anybody.
Section 8 only talks about geographical restriction, which can be a consequence of local regulations, including patents. Nothing interesting there.
I haven't read the GPLv3, which may indeed handle patents. This is not the GPLv3, this is the GPLv2. And this version of the licence does not handle patents. If you infringe on Oracle's patents you will still get sued, GPLv2 or not.
32
u/pron98 Sep 26 '18
This is not for OpenJDK, but for the Java specification. OpenJDK is fully open, and you can fork it at will, just like any other OSS project. What you cannot do is use the Java trademark (same as Linux). OpenJDK is no more and no less open than Linux, and is not subject to any other restrictions than the license it is released under (GPL), which incidentally explicitly prohibits any further restrictions. Say what you will about Oracle, they take these license/legal matters very seriously.