r/programming • • Sep 26 '18

Do not fall into Oracle's Java 11 trap

https://blog.joda.org/2018/09/do-not-fall-into-oracles-java-11-trap.html
797 Upvotes

382 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

11

u/bigmooooo Sep 26 '18

Can you go into more depth how .net core is more open then say python, rust, elixir or other open source languages. I think it would be great to here more about .net cores open initiatives and it's adoption in the world.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

It’s not more open than Python, but it is open source and basically the forward looking evolution of the .NET family (old style .NET Framework legacy apps will be around for a while, maybe forever).

C# is technically an ECMA standard, for whatever that's worth.

12

u/fuckin_ziggurats Sep 26 '18

.NET Core is not more or less open than any of those. The main argument is that .NET Core is more suitable for large enterprise than most of the languages you mentioned. .NET and Java are the kings of enterprise and .NET Core shares a lot of .NET's features and tooling without compromising its viability in the enterprise web & cloud sphere.

6

u/cat_in_the_wall Sep 26 '18

additionally, c# is extremely similar to java, and the clr is very similar to the jvm, so someone who was pissed enough at oracle could hop to using net core with a pretty low barrier to entry. so of all the options out there, switching from java to net core is the smallest change, especially because net core is xplat.

6

u/Holston18 Sep 26 '18

especially because net core is xplat

net core is cross platform but missing a lot of functionality (GUI toolkit among others)

0

u/vielga2 Sep 26 '18

Which no one gives a single shit about because no one in their right mind would create desktop software for platforms other than Windows.

Also, Avalonia, so stfu.

5

u/ArmoredPancake Sep 26 '18

Sorry to burst your bubble, but there's more crossplatform desktop applications than you can count. Also, are you really comparing Avalonia to toolkits like JavaFX and Swing?

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

Python just changed the removed the keywords master and slave due to sjw pressure, so perhaps being too open is not such a good thing after all.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '18

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

[deleted]

1

u/ex_nihilo Sep 28 '18

As a seasoned software engineer, I do not in any way “fail to get” the importance of quality. Quite the opposite. I think perhaps that is not at all what is at issue here. You can care about more than one thing.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

It's insanity because feelings don't matter. We shouldn't 'make people feel' anything, we're not in that business. You're given tools, languages, if you don't like them, make new ones.

1

u/ex_nihilo Sep 27 '18

That's not how open source software works. If you don't like a tool, you change it and issue a PR. Python has many contributors and maintainers. I am not a Python maintainer, but I am a bash maintainer.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

It's up to the owners whether or not to accept pull requests. If I had received a request with any hint at speech police I would never, ever accept it. It is bad, bad on so many levels when thought police enter our lives. Those fascists need to be punished, not catered to!

1

u/ex_nihilo Sep 27 '18

"Policing" implies that those people have any power over you. This isn't you resisting "the man", or fighting against suppression of free speech. This is some people saying "we should try to not be assholes" and you saying "MY RIGHT TO BE AN ASSHOLE TRUMPS YOUR FEEFEES, SNOWFLAKE". You're not cool or special, nobody cares. It costs you nothing to not be a dick.