r/programming • • Oct 21 '17

Using Java 9 Modularization to Ship Zero-Dependency Native Apps

https://steveperkins.com/using-java-9-modularization-to-ship-zero-dependency-native-apps#.Wes5IMWbUWE.reddit
310 Upvotes

109 comments sorted by

View all comments

213

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '17

Can we have a talk about what "native" means?

Maybe I am old fashioned but I don't consider a jar and a jvm together comprising a native application.

77

u/SizzlingVortex Oct 21 '17

From the article, I think the author describes native as:

  • Being able to bundle the JVM (versus having the user install Java separately)

  • Not having to embed a web browser like, for example, Electron -- which is called a web-hybrid app in the article

68

u/BadMoonRosin Oct 21 '17 edited Oct 21 '17

Yup... it's a good discussion topic, and I definitely wrestled with the phrasing. Having studied Pascal back in university, and starting out my career as a C++ dev, I too have always thought of "native" as being "a standalone executable".

However, I would run into issues when playing with cross-platform GUI libraries such as wxWidgets, GTK, or Qt. I always wanted to compile my apps down to a statically linked, standalone executable. I didn't want to have to ship a bunch of shared libs, or depend on them being present on the target machines! Yet more knowledgeable developers would calmly try to explain to me that dynamic linking is often technically superior (or with Qt, necessary due to licensing).

Also, last year I went to a Java conference and sat through a few sessions on profiling and JVM tuning. It was a lightbulb moment, that left me considering the possibility that a runtime VM with a JIT compiler really IS a technically superior approach over full AOT compilation.

So anyway, if you're having to ship to tens of megs of dynamically linked libraries with your "native" app... then is it really THAT far removed from an app that's linked to an embedded runtime? I'm not so sure. And I would strongly argue that you have no less claim to the "native" label than Electron has.

43

u/doom_Oo7 Oct 21 '17

Native == the executable you run is a sequence of ASM instructions for your cpu / os without run-time interpretation of algorithms or code necessary for your software's execution.

Also, you can link Qt (and any lgpl stuff actually) statically, as long as you provide object files (not source) upon request.

7

u/pron98 Oct 21 '17 edited Oct 21 '17

Native == the executable you run is a sequence of ASM instructions for your cpu / os without run-time interpretation of algorithms or code necessary for your software's execution.

Sure, but the line isn't always so clear cut. A browser executes a lot of Javascript code (not just in web pages, but also in extensions); MS office executes VB code; an OS executes a lot of scripts; games' actual content is usually found in script files interpreted at runtime. Most complex software today must interpret/compile some code as it runs, so while you could decide to draw the line somewhere, the distinction is not always very useful.

1

u/doom_Oo7 Oct 21 '17

MS office executes VB code; an OS executes a lot of scripts; games' actual content is usually found in script files interpreted at runtime. Most complex software today must interpret/compile some code as it runs, so while you could decide to draw the line somewhere, the distinction is not very useful.

I'd say that the distinction is : does the software need to interpret code for normal operation ? e.g. you can write plenty of office documents without using VB scripts. Likewise, linux has BPF but you can run entire days without a single interpreted code running. However you can't run unity3D games without C# code running, even though most of the engine is C++, so I'd not call them native.

6

u/pron98 Oct 21 '17

Yeah, but you can't really run Linux normally without (say, init) scripts, and non-Unity games use Lua scripts and others extensively as well. Anyway, I don't doubt that you could find a reasonable point to draw the line. The question is, what difference does it make? Why is the distinction useful?

2

u/doom_Oo7 Oct 21 '17

Yeah, but you can't really run Linux normally without (say, init) scripts,

... uh, what ? of course you can. Plenty of embedded systems run with just the kernel and init=/bin/my_software. Also, systemd doesn't use scripts for instance.

Why is the distinction useful?

It gives a ballpark of what kind of reactivity and throughput you can expect from your system.

1

u/CyclonusRIP Oct 21 '17

OK suppose I write an application in C++. This application defines a data structure and a program that reads that data structure and executes conditionally based on what it reads. Whole thing compiles down to assembly, so I guess it's a native app then?

2

u/schmerm Oct 22 '17

In this case, the interpreter is native and the sequence of instructions defined by the data structure is not.