r/programming • • Dec 05 '15

Microsoft Edge’s JavaScript engine to go open-source

https://blogs.windows.com/msedgedev/2015/12/05/open-source-chakra-core/
1.6k Upvotes

504 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7

u/hansolo669 Dec 06 '15

Correct me if I'm wrong, but wasn't the issue with IE was that it was the dominant browser and Microsoft then used that position to effectively force standards (before letting it rot for years)? Chrome may be the dominant browser right now, but Google is hardly in a position to force standards.

14

u/vinnl Dec 06 '15

Well, yeah, that was one of the issues, and IE was definitely worse than Chrome is.

However, you can force standards even if you're not trying to. By being so dominant, bugs in an implementation can quickly become the standard, and the prioritisation you choose as a browser vendor will become the de factor prioritisation of the entire internet.

On the desktop, it's not that much of a problem (yet, although I'm a bit afraid of Chrome's continuing growth and e.g. Firefox's decline). On mobile, however, the dominance of Blink/Webkit is already problematic, and choosing Firefox (which is a very standards-compliant browser) still often results in a sub-par experience due to websites catering specifically and only to Blink/Webkit.

2

u/hansolo669 Dec 06 '15

I don't necessarily disagree with the majority of your points, however (and I hate anecdotes as much as anyone else) I've yet to come across a non-tech demo site that resulted in a sub par experience on Firefox.

1

u/vinnl Dec 06 '15

Gmail is an example of something many people use and that I miss pretty much. Many Google products don't work that great, to be honest. Facebook has some issues, but mostly works pretty OK.

2

u/shevegen Dec 06 '15

Google of course tries to force things onto people - see the failure of Google+ even though they tried to have everyone use it as a replacement of Facebook. And not everyone is using Facebook either, so that was a double loss.

0

u/hansolo669 Dec 06 '15

forcing things onto people != forcing the creation of standards

You can still access and use Facbook/Twitter/etc when you use Chrome. Microsoft's domination of the internet with IE was so singularly massive that any feature they implemented became a standard. Chrome and Google have far more competition, and a more effective standards body, than Microsoft ever did; and developers today aren't going to build "works best in Chrome" sites simply because they remember the bad old days.

2

u/Recursive_Descent Dec 06 '15

That's completely untrue. Developers today do exactly that. The webkit prefixed things are widely used and other browsers need to mimic chrome's non standard behavior because web devs rely on it.

1

u/ProdigySorcerer Dec 07 '15

Agreed I've seen a lot of small bussines sites look like shit, thought how could they allow this thing to go online then saw it looks good in Chrome.