r/programming • • Jun 19 '15

GitFlow considered harmful

http://endoflineblog.com/gitflow-considered-harmful
13 Upvotes

244 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Cwiddy Jun 19 '15

I am not overly familiar with Git other than simple personal use (still in a SVN shop) but just to clarify for myself in get,

  • you can branch

  • do a bunch of things

  • tag the branch?

  • merge to master

  • delete branch.

So my questions are when you delete a branch you tag you still get the history to that tag, that is what you said above I think.

And then when you branch from a tag it has it's full history to that point?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '15

[deleted]

4

u/fireflash38 Jun 19 '15

People are very angry that someone else's workflow is different than their own workflow.

-1

u/skinny85 Jun 19 '15

The difference is that tags are meant to be immutable, while branches are made to be changed. Not a big difference, but if someone makes a mistake, it might be the difference between "we can rollback to this safe version" and "I have no idea what was on production before we made the release :(".

-1

u/skinny85 Jun 19 '15

Yes. A tag is a pointer to a specific commit. Obviously, every ancestor of that commit is reachable from that tag (that's what creates the history). A branch is just another pointer to a commit (with the difference being that is moves automatically when you create a new commit while on that branch, while tags are (conceptually at least) immutable), so it obviously sees the same history as the tag.

Does that explanation make any sense? :)