r/programming • • Feb 22 '15

Java Makes Programmers Want To Do Absolutely Anything Else With Their Time

http://www.forbes.com/sites/quora/2015/02/21/java-makes-programmers-want-to-do-absolutely-anything-else-with-their-time/
35 Upvotes

636 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/aijoe Feb 22 '15

I like C# but I'd I'd never pay for the licenses needed to run it for personal projects and Mono isn't quite there yet.

Just curious but since you don't mean Mono here(or xamarin thats based on it) what do you mean by needing to pay for licenses to run C#?

1

u/aradil Feb 22 '15

OS licenses. Visual studio licenses.

2

u/aijoe Feb 22 '15

Visual Studio Community Edition is free. This isn't the limited express version. I paid more for my apple mouse pad than I did my Windows 8 license but I really can't fault you if you are that poor.

1

u/aradil Feb 22 '15

Can you sell software written with the community version?

-7

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/aradil Feb 22 '15

Maybe because Microsoft audited our office and made us pay over 6 figures in license fees for VS and Windows server?

You can't sell software that isn't open source made with VS Community edition if you work for an "organization". It's right in their ToS.

2

u/aijoe Feb 22 '15

You can't sell software that isn't open source made with VS Community edition if you work for an "organization". It's right in their ToS

We were specifically talking about "for personal projects" as thats where my question originated. The license allows you to sell software in that regard. The license makes it clear even a personal project of up to five people working on it does not constitute an "organization".

Maybe because Microsoft audited our office and made us pay over 6 figures in license fees for VS and Windows server?

Were they making your office pay for unlicensed copies of the software that your office was running?

1

u/aradil Feb 22 '15

Well, they did an audit, I'm not certain why. The result of which was that we had to pay for a number of licenses we weren't paying for previously. I can only speculate.

0

u/aijoe Feb 22 '15

Well, they did an audit, I'm not certain why. The result of which was that we had to pay for a number of licenses we weren't paying for previously. I can only speculate.

Come on. I just spoke with our software attorney and if it was provable all that all the licenses you were using were legit Microsoft can't have found you responsible for paying anything. It doesn't require speculation. Whether your company has licenses or not is not a subjective piece of information. There is either a record of your license or there is not. If your org ponied up that much rather than fight something they could easily win tells me exactly what I need to know. Either your organization is made up epic imbeciles for not fighting with their evidence of licenses or they know they were caught red handed. I would side with the latter.

The result of which was that we had to pay for a number of licenses we weren't paying for previously.

See. No need to speculate.

1

u/aradil Feb 22 '15

I don't have hard evidence. In fact, the only evidence I have that there was an audit is hearsay. But feel free to keep drawing conclusions on third hand information which isn't relevant to the conversation - that unless you are ripping someone off, running Microsoft stuff at a small company is more expensive than Linux. I don't need to fight with you over the semantic definition of the word speculate.

→ More replies (0)

-3

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/aradil Feb 22 '15

I already told you I'm paying for and using Visual Studio, troll. And that the cost of it comes directly out of money I could be getting paid.

But keep praying to your omnipotent diety Microsoft, for it shall save your soul and bring you to the promised land.

1

u/s73v3r Feb 22 '15

You and I both know that companies wouldn't increase pay to employees if they didn't have to pay for VS.

1

u/aradil Feb 22 '15

Every performance review I have I like to highlight the things that I did that made or saved the company money, in addition to fulfilling my normal duties.

If that isn't what managers want to see, I don't know what is. The bottom line is always money.

-3

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/afrobee Feb 22 '15

Is sad that the most of the important programs that we use to day are writing on Java and not .Net. I mean, you should thanks Java for giving you delicious toasts every morning :)

→ More replies (0)

-1

u/aijoe Feb 22 '15 edited Feb 22 '15

I already told you I'm paying for and using Visual Studio

Your organization or company is paying for Visual Studio right? Because above you tell us that "I'd never pay for the licenses needed to run it for personal projects".

I've worked in many different corporate environments using C++, Java, and C#. Not since I graduated college 20 years ago have I thought the price we pay for alls the tools and hardware we use had to do with us not getting a bonus or a raise. Many of the companies seemed to spend 10x as much a stupid things in other departments that are outside of the tools we needed to have to complete our projects. I'm willing to bet if your organization is big it spends more elsewhere and gets a ROI on you that far outweighs any tools they bought for you. If not, your organization is burning money like a new lotto winner that can't invest and won't be around for long.

1

u/aradil Feb 22 '15

I wrote a proof of concept for a piece of software that we would have spent well over 100k buying in two days. They gave me 2 weeks to implement it, and it's now in production. Of course, it didn't have the full toolset of the 100k software, but it did what we needed.

My bonus that was was pretty healthy. Maybe it would have been the same, but I see a pretty clear correlation where I work and making or saving the company money and compensation.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/concatenated_string Feb 22 '15

You should check out the community edition of VS.

1

u/aradil Feb 22 '15

Good if I'm working by myself, not so good if I want to start up a business with a team... gotta pay then.

-9

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/aradil Feb 22 '15

I use about 4 languages on a day-day basis at work, including both Java and C# in VS and Eclipse.

I also know that we forked out a ton of cash for the licensing to Microsoft, money that could have instead been my bonus.

3

u/s73v3r Feb 22 '15

IntelliJ is also free.

→ More replies (1)