r/programming • • Feb 22 '15

Java Makes Programmers Want To Do Absolutely Anything Else With Their Time

http://www.forbes.com/sites/quora/2015/02/21/java-makes-programmers-want-to-do-absolutely-anything-else-with-their-time/
35 Upvotes

636 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

11

u/tramjoe Feb 22 '15

Warning: You are going to take the hit for many others too, don't take it too personally.

Here is what there is to it:

  • OOP is a butchered paradigm. It has been completely stripped in modern days of the fundationnal properties it had when invented, and has been travestied into something with absolutely none of the industry promises fullfilled.

  • Most of Java and OOP workforce is made of incompetent clones formatted by industry-standard training

  • The point is not C++ vs Java. You should broaden your horizon. The point is Java and C++ and others versus arguably better suited languages and paradigms for the challenges of today and tomorrow, notably concurrent and distributed systems, which are a nightmare to code right in Java or C++.

  • It is not about fun, it is about advancing the industry of computer programming, by picking interesting ideas from research.

  • The "being useful" argument is just leveling the field using the most common (smallest) denominator, staying in your comfort zone (aka stagnating and embracing mediocrity) and accepting to stick to "the way things are" despite the fact that the history of it is one of industrial compromises rather than technical excellence.

You are free to embrace mediocrity and stagnation. You are free to lock yourself voluntarily into a tiny sphere that becomes your IT universe. You are free to ignore attempts to make your field better, and rely on vendors and of-the-shelf corporate offerings.

But don't complain the day you realize that all you've done in your career is follow established rules you don't understand, leading you into obsolescence before you even realize it. And by all means, be my guest, it is only by contrast to the lowly mass of Java grunts that better, innovative, curious and ambitious programmer can shine.

Haaaa... now let the downvotes pour in (I have no illusions, I am attacking far more people in this comment than the group I am going to get a smile from), feels good to vent a bit for a change.

1

u/NightShadow89 Feb 22 '15

I regret that I have but one upvote to give you

0

u/tramjoe Feb 22 '15

I take that for a smile, it's better than incrementing a not-so-important variable on reddit's servers :-)

-2

u/nqd26 Feb 22 '15

Wow, you're full of frustration/hate ... Where does it come from?

5

u/tramjoe Feb 22 '15 edited Feb 22 '15

Hate, no. Frustration, yes. It comes from 20 years of being the almost daily witness of what I described above, over and over again, and preaching in the desert almost 99% of the time to programmers, CTOs, CEOs and founders that it's not because "everyone does it this way" that it's how it should be done. RPC, ORM, PHP, OOP, manual management of locking and memory for complex systems, Merise, heavy waterfall project management for everything, you name it. And most of the time, it boils down to trivial cognitive biases like resistance to changement :-(

edit: I hope you don't assume that everyone ranting on the internet is full of hate. That would be a lot of hate.