r/programming • • Nov 16 '14

PostgreSQL vs. MS SQL Server - A comparison of two relational databases from the point of view of a data analyst

http://www.pg-versus-ms.com/
171 Upvotes

321 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/squareproton Nov 17 '14

Meh, it's pretty funny timing, but it doesn't really invalidate anything I've said. So far all there is is an announcement. Let's see the following things:

  1. Proper support to the open source community from MS

  2. Proper commitment of resources by MS

  3. No fancy new closed-source alternative/competitor framework popping up in the near future

  4. No attempts to hijack/sabotage standards processes like they did with OO XML

  5. MS embracing open source/cross-platform even when it is back to its former glory

Then we'll be getting somewhere.

3

u/ohyesyodo Nov 17 '14

Regarding 1 ... You know Microsoft has released open source stuff for quite some time? Like contributions to git, signalr and other things? What would be "proper" in your eyes?

2

u/Eirenarch Nov 17 '14

Oh come on... no company is embracing open source and cross platform when they are on the top. They do it when they are weak. Look at Google for example. The open Android was very open until they owned the market and now there is the new Google Play service which basically serves as a way to control the platform via all new APIs and is closed source. Open Source is a good thing because it allows newcomers (or weakened companies) to compete on an established market in disruptive ways but companies work for money and not for ideals and this is how it should be. If a company works for something else then it is a scam and they are stealing from their shareholders.

BTW 1 and 2 are already proven by their track record of open sourcing .NET technologies for years and 3 is highly likely considering the MASSIVE investment they did in .NET in recent years (Roslyn, RyuJIT, .NET Native, ASP.NET vNext)

1

u/squareproton Nov 17 '14

companies work for money and not for ideals and this is how it should be. If a company works for something else then it is a scam and they are stealing from their shareholders

Heh. You're not an Ayn Rand fan by any chance, are you?

Plenty of organisations exist for ideals and not money. MS is just not one of them.

1

u/Eirenarch Nov 17 '14

I am an Ayn Rand fan although I have not read any of her books. I was surprised to find (via Wikipedia and the movie adaptation of Atlas Shrugged as well as a bunch of comments like yours) that she basically described the same ideas that always felt natural to me.

Neither I nor Ayn Rand says that organizations do not or should not exist for ideals (Hell, I contribute to some of them with my money). However if an organization calls itself a for profit company (like MS and Google) it should try to make a profit as long as it does so legally. It will be best if they do not try to pretend they are not being evil like that company that likes to pretend they are somehow different. For example I never claimed that Mozilla are doing open source because they are weak since they are not a for profit company.