Compared to cvs/svn it's miles better. Compared to Hg it's mildly more useful for me (private branching) but I could live with hg if I had to. Compared to private tools like CC and what not it's miles better too. It's simpler (you want complicated try installing CC), smaller, open source, and free.
Realistically if git weren't around I would have pushed our team to move from CVS to Hg because CVS is simply not web-scale (hehehe) but really, it's just not suitable for ad-hoc distributed development.
SVN lacks sound branching which is why I'd never touch it.
We were CVS because when the company started that was handy and free (we're talking about 14 years ago). We only moved to Git a year and a bit ago because I got fed up with not being able to save my experimental work without mucking about with tags/branches/etc.
Originally I thought of Git as "yet another fad SCM" but once I learned about the rapid branching I was intrigued to learn more and after using it for a week I was already writing training slides/etc to move the company over.
We actually moved to it just in time too because we're growing rapidly and Git is a lot better suited for project hopping ad-hoc staff growth. People can work on their own branches, save their work, and then push as things warrant it without the pain of having weeks worth of work sitting uncomitted in their home directory.
Sadly all of our new hires have had zero experience with Git so we (re: me) have had to train people. We made things a bit smooth by having a .bashrc file they can source which updates their PS1 string and adds a few shell functions to make using git a bit simpler. But I don't regret the move. It's saved me plenty of time.
CVS served it's purpose but it's really long in the tooth now. New projects that decide to use CVS are grossly behind the times.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '14
Compared to cvs/svn it's miles better. Compared to Hg it's mildly more useful for me (private branching) but I could live with hg if I had to. Compared to private tools like CC and what not it's miles better too. It's simpler (you want complicated try installing CC), smaller, open source, and free.
Realistically if git weren't around I would have pushed our team to move from CVS to Hg because CVS is simply not web-scale (hehehe) but really, it's just not suitable for ad-hoc distributed development.