Is Vim a pussy note taking app because it puts all your actions into the undo tree automatically?
The only thing that doesn't make assumptions about your workflow is a pile of sand. Everything else is valuable precisely because it introduces structure, and structure by definition means excluding some workflows.
I'm implying that it's irrelevant. The guy you're arguing said "Git is a system level tool; not a note taking application" in response to "these commits should be fully automatic and continuous", implying that that's acceptable behaviour in a note taking app, but not a system level tool.
He specifically excluded note taking apps – which text editors are very similar to and you referred to Vim as a note taking app – from the category 'apps that should not make assumptions about your workflow'. Therefore, using Vim as a comparison ("Is Vim a pussy note taking app because it puts all your actions into the undo tree automatically?") is invalid, since it falls into the group 'note taking app', therefore, by his own admission also into the supergroup of 'apps that can acceptably make assumptions about workflow'.
8
u/moor-GAYZ Jun 19 '14
Is Vim a pussy note taking app because it puts all your actions into the undo tree automatically?
The only thing that doesn't make assumptions about your workflow is a pile of sand. Everything else is valuable precisely because it introduces structure, and structure by definition means excluding some workflows.