r/programming • • Jun 19 '14

Reinventing GIT interface

http://tonsky.me/blog/reinventing-git-interface/
221 Upvotes

325 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

27

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '14

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/oursland Jun 19 '14

This is not an instance of the No True Scottsman fallacy. For it to be so would require this to be an unreasoned assertion. I find it reasonable to believe that a professional programmer should be capable of learning and using the Git SCM.

-22

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '14

Any competent software developer should be able to write a reasonable Git clone in a few weeks.

Sorry, but you're a bullshit developer if Git stumps you. Yes it requires learning/experience but nothing more than a couple of weeks of using it.

3

u/s73v3r Jun 19 '14

Mercurial is arguably just as powerful, and doesn't take a couple of weeks to learn it.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '14

agreed though one show stopper for me is that in hg branches are global and not private. I get that you can bookmark commits [like a stash I guess] and then update your branch with upstream commits and what not but that aspect is simpler in git which is why I moved to git [from cvs] in the first place.

And no, if you're used to a centralized tool like CVS using Hg properly still takes a few weeks because it changes how you think about things.

4

u/Guvante Jun 19 '14

Any competent software developer should be able to write a reasonable Git clone in a few weeks.

That is completely immaterial. Everyone agrees that Git's core is fantastic. Writing a new one would be a wasted effort.

If Git's core weren't fantastic we would have posts talking about new alternatives, not how to improve Git.

Sorry, but you're a bullshit developer if Git stumps you.

You are assuming hard to use means stumps. That isn't a good assumption.

-4

u/materialdesigner Jun 19 '14

How I can tell you're probably 17

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '14

I'm 32 and have only been using Git for about 1.5 years now. Before that we were a CVS shop. I got into Git because I was intrigued by the ability to rapidly branch/etc.

I taught myself the basics of Git over a weekend and within a week I had moved my CVS repo over to Git and was working their full time.

Yes, I had to google a few things at first but it was hardly insurmountable.

1

u/cjthomp Jun 19 '14

To be fair, he didn't say "physically" 17.

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '14

To be fair, no adult really considers being called a kid an insult. So uh, you kinda outed yourself buddy.

-2

u/RalphMacchio Jun 19 '14

You are only partially correct here. Babies are cute, so we all like being called a little baby; toddlers are inquisitive and love to explore, which fits the nature of many programmers; grade-school age was the best of times for many of us, when we got our first Commodore 64 (or equivalent beautiful relic), started getting lost in books, and rolled our first D&D character; and next, everyone knows that teenagers are the coolest age group of all. That leaves Tweens. Calling someone a tween can end the strongest of friendships. There is nothing worse than a tween. I feel dirty typing such a derogatory term. I hope everyone here will forgive me.