730
Jun 19 '12
Animals can't read OR write. I'm calling BS on their 'animal research.'
243
61
u/VinnieJJ Jun 19 '12
Gorillas can write.
198
→ More replies (3)13
33
u/AssumeTheFetal Jun 19 '12
Will somebody check this guys name and make sure it doesnt form hitler killing a jew or something on the number pad?
→ More replies (3)67
u/dont_press_ctrl-W Jun 19 '12
If we take his name to be in base 9 and convert it to base 16, we get 1358.
Then we interpret 1358 in decimals as a year, and we take the day his account was made, June 7, and we get the exact date of the death of Ashikaga Takauji, the Japanese dictator.
Interpret it as you may.
→ More replies (2)6
u/CoyoteStark Jun 19 '12
Well it's all standardized testing so most animals can get above a 1200.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (5)2
Jun 19 '12
"I oppose animal testing. They get nervous and get all the answers wrong"
→ More replies (1)
188
u/supframage Jun 19 '12
I think that there is a difference between animal testing for medical purposes and testing on animals for cosmetic reasons.
I am very grateful for the tests done on animals for medical purposes. with out it, i probably wouldn't be here right now. but i can promise you i would survive without beauty products tested on animals. PLENTY of companies don't test on animals (Tresme, Smashbox) and have not burned off my scalp or lost my eyes by using them.
basically medical testing necessary, cosmetic testing unnecessary.
40
u/oshen Jun 19 '12
I completely agree, I have to add-- that guidelines on animal testing for medical purposes are also important because of the ethics and values we hold in our society (also surprisingly it makes good science-- stressed animals are not so good for research). I for one am glad that universities and research facilities are using more stringent controls in animal-testing. Seeing some of the clueless grad students dealing with animals even after training makes me wonder how it would have been if they had not been trained for proper care (specially when dealing with cats/dogs/primates).
Certain animal rights activists made life a living hell for scientists... and I know people traumatized by that shit to this day. I wish the progress we've made hadn't been pushed through/accompanied by that violence though.
13
u/supframage Jun 19 '12
I don't think that people realize there is an entire profession for caring for animals in testing environments. people are so uninformed about animal testing.
→ More replies (3)11
u/oshen Jun 19 '12
Yeah, there is actual people that work in labs ensuring the animals are well-taken care, experiments are done within protocol, and to report any incidents. And they're usually big animal lovers too. At least the technicians I've encountered.
→ More replies (4)44
u/ohrabbits Jun 19 '12
I know comments like mine don't contribute much to the conversation, but I can't fathom why someone would downvote this comment. The distinction between medical research done in supervised labratory environments overseen with strict ethical restrictions by academic institutions and cosmetic testing done by private companies with very little supervision for capital gain is a very important one to note!
14
u/jesusray Jun 19 '12
Downvotes happen. There are bots that downvote, reddit screws with the numbers to discourage bots, people misclick arrows, cats walk on keyboards, and some people are just assholes. Don't overthink them.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)25
u/supframage Jun 19 '12
PETA has so much propaganda its absurd. They bundle everything together and consider medical & cosmetic testing the same. its dumb and just as bad as any government propaganda.
→ More replies (10)→ More replies (26)7
Jun 19 '12
Sorry to break it to you, but most if not all of these 'not tested on animals' products licence patented chemicals and formulae, that were developed in the past using animal testing during the development cycle.
→ More replies (2)
611
u/oboegirl Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 19 '12
This is really vague. What if they are protesting something like cosmetic or household animal testing? There have been methods proven to work for this and the EU has even passed a law that will be in complete effect in 2013 banning the sale of all cosmetic products that have been tested on animals in any stage of production. Right now they are in step 3 of 4 in the ban.
If this is what they're protesting I think the insinuation that these people are stupid and don't know anything is completely off base.
While some animal testing has it's merits, it is over used and abused to the extreme.
edit they banned all cosmetic products, not all products
134
u/WhiteRaven42 Jun 19 '12
The fact that cosmetics are no longer toxic is actually a part of the increase in life span. You are being dismissive of important progress.
122
u/oboegirl Jun 19 '12
While that is true, when most of that was discovered animal testing was the only form of testing available to us. Now that there are alternatives, I think it is unfair to continue to torture animals where there are perfectly viable alternatives that will still get the testing done.
→ More replies (85)13
→ More replies (17)3
u/SOMETHING_POTATO Jun 19 '12
However, I still think if a cosmetics company is so intent on making a mascara that lasts a tiny bit longer that they're willing to blind bunnies, they're pretty big assholes.
→ More replies (1)21
→ More replies (44)2
Jun 19 '12
I don't understand cosmetic testing on animals.
Mmmm that monkey looks fucking sexy with that make-up on, sexy ass monkey. I don't get it.
16
u/KTKins77 Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 19 '12
I knew as soon as I read this it was going to blow up with arguments about use of animals in research.
It's going to get hella buried, but I wanted to share something a researcher I used to work for told me about her feelings on the subject. This lab has been working on new treatment ideas for ALS (aka Lou Gehrig's Disease). It's a super shitty disease where your motor neurons die off over the course of 3-5 years, eventually paralyzingly you completely and requiring you to be hooked up to life support. She met one woman with the disease who had a daughter in high school. There was no way this woman would live to see her daughter graduate.
They use mice to test out potential treatments. A cure isn't even on the radar now, just something to slow the onset. My boss said to me, "If I had to kill 1 million mice to give that woman a chance to see her daughter graduate, I'd do it."
That still shapes how I feel about animal models in research. If a non-animal model is useful, great. Labs are required to justify their use of animals; they don't do it without a good reason. Frankly, they couldn't. Their IACUC (Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee) wouldn't let it fly.
Well that was kind of long and rambling. Not sure where I was going with that, but I think it helps for people to hear what's going on on the science end of animals in research. We're not torturing kittens, I swear!
Edit: one more side note, a lot of these animals have better health care than some humans. There are always staff whose sole purpose is to take care of them, make sure they have clean and comfortable living facilities, manage pain, and report problems to a veterinarian if they get sick.
→ More replies (2)
203
Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 19 '12
That sign is incorrect, they won't live longer. Too late to comment and will get buried, but here I go!
See, this is a huge common misconception. Average life expectancy (ALE) is calculated off the total estimated population and life span. (duh, I know) But it factors in infant mortality rates. So every baby that dies, add a 0. See, ancient civilizations had such a low ALE because infant mortality rates were so high. Additionally, war and disease killed lots before 30. The idea was, if you lived to 30, you will probably make it to 80 or 90. Actually, the elderly where in much better shape because they had made it past most diseases and had a harder, more physically active life that made them healthier and stronger.
Look at country's ALE and then compare it to the infant mortality rate of that country. You will directly see the correlation in almost any country. Animal testing didn't help us like 23 years longer, it helped more babies live period.
Edit: Grammar
27
u/NeilNeilOrangePeel Jun 19 '12
if you lived to 30, you will probably make it to 80 or 90
Well not quite. At least according to Wikipedia in Medieval Britain if you made it to 21 your life expectancy was 64. Going back further to the Upper Paleolithic, if you made it to 15 your life expectancy was 54. Certainly the average life expectancy is misleading if you were to apply it to 20-somethings but "80 or 90"?.. well that's hardly accurate either. Medical science has significantly increased the life expectancy of 20-somethings too.
That being said the biggest improvements such as vaccines, penicillin, sanitation and food security.. well they dwarf the rest of our more advanced medical interventions in terms of 'extra life added'.
→ More replies (2)42
Jun 19 '12
So if I love animals and hate babies....
→ More replies (1)16
28
Jun 19 '12
So a better poster would say something along the lines of "Thanks to Animal Research, x% more people can protest Animal Research. Because without Animal Research, they would have died at birth."
Still a pretty compelling point.
18
Jun 19 '12
I agree, still a compelling argument. Just scientifically inaccurate, ::chuckle:: you know...cause it's in a science lab...he...he...he..
→ More replies (1)46
u/Buhdahl Jun 19 '12
But, but, my smug superiority!
3
12
u/gloomdoom Jun 19 '12
It's OK...it'll be OK. You're on reddit. You are surrounded by smug superiority.
4
u/mrbooze Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 19 '12
That's not always true about life expectancy numbers. Though oversimplified reports can do that, good science doesn't just include infant mortality in overall mortality. You'll more see statistics like listing life expectancy at various ages, like "life expectancy at age 15".
Having said that, I don't see how this 23.5 year claim could be true unless they're fudging like you say. CDC reports the life expectancy in the US at 77.8 years. I'm not sure the life expectancy past adolescence has ever been as low as 54 for humans in reasonably life-supporting environments.
And you are right that I believe there are some solid theories that the longer life span today such as it is compared to early hunter-gatherer societies, is that overall more children live past 15 or so, and a human that makes it past that age (not being killed in childbirth or by disease or war or malnutrition or infanticide, etc) is most likely to live into their 70s at least, even back into pre-history. There has been some increase in life expectancy post-adolescence due to medical advancements, and improvements in food supply/etc, but definitely by far the biggest reason more people live today than back then is because more survive into their teens.
EDIT: Correcting myself here. I realized that "Average Life Expectancy" most often does include infant mortality. I think i'm thinking of "modal age of adult death".
→ More replies (1)2
u/green_tito Jun 19 '12
whoa first day on the job and he's already cracked his first case. You sir are
promotedupvoted.→ More replies (1)2
u/simpersly Jun 19 '12
There is a wiki page that has a chart that discusses what your comment is discussing.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (23)2
6
78
Jun 19 '12
And now we wait for the argumentative shitstorm to arrive.
101
u/BipolarBear0 Jun 19 '12
I don't support animal research because i can't eat the animals they're testing on.
→ More replies (10)15
3
u/Watergems Jun 19 '12
It's not the animal research -- I don't support finding ways to help people live longer.
→ More replies (8)2
u/haddock420 Jun 19 '12
That's the only reason I came to the comments. I love me some reddit drama.
→ More replies (1)
18
u/RaptorPrincess Jun 19 '12
I work in a research lab (nothing fancy- just an animal care tech.) I'm always hesitant to tell people IRL what I do, simply because of the stigma it holds.
I'm all for reducing testing. My lab does no cosmetic tests- most (80% or so) are veterinary procedures or new medications, and the remainder are tests for human medications.
Never mind the fact that most of my lab's tests are veterinary in nature, I still know some people disagree about all forms of animal research. When I point out, "if it wasn't for our lab animals, your dog wouldn't have that heartworm medication, or rabies vaccine," they tend to stop and think about their position a bit.
As long as we have domestic pets, there will always be a need for some form of animal research, even if computer models replace the need for human medications to be tested. I mean, what responsible pet owner would allow an untested new drug to be used on their personal dog, without knowing what likely side effects there are?
→ More replies (6)8
u/discipula_vitae Jun 19 '12
I work in a medical research lab that uses animals as well. I enjoy my rats and love my job, but am very selective with whom I disclose my animal handling as well. I have received too much criticism from undereducated laymen who don't understand the weight of what I have been working on (everything from Alzheimer's to blindness). I wish there were better models to work with beside sacrificing animal lives, but until we perfect growing organs from stem cells in the lab, we will have to work with what we can.
→ More replies (1)
5
Jun 19 '12
Would like to make some points, as rigorously as possible, though some opinion may slip in. This web page points to ATLA, an apparently peer-reviewed journal, which stands for Alternatives to Laboratory Animals. Using my university's online library, I did indeed find ATLA papers dealing with the subject of animal testing.
ATLA is a publication of of FRAME, the Fund for the Replacement of Animals in Medical Experiments. The aim? To reduce the number of animals used in experiments via the development of successful alternatives, while also educating and informing the scientific community, along with industry, of these alternatives. I draw attention to the bolded text here http://www.frame.org.uk/page.php?pg_id=5
FRAME believes that the current scale of animal experimentation is unacceptable, but recognises that the immediate abolition of all laboratory animal use is not possible.
In other words, the organisation recognises that animal testing is, at present, essential to medical research. This is unacceptable if alternatives are available. I believe this. I imagine that many scientists believe this, and that they would immediately adopt an alternative if it was shown to be more effective. In fact, this is more or less certain, since producing high quality research requires the best methodology in order to be taken seriously.
ATLA is all about the alternatives and their effects. Here is a screencap of some titles of the papers they have published: http://i.imgur.com/VyHj8.jpg
As you can see, they list some fairly high-tech alternatives that are being developed to address the concern of animal testing, while simultaneously aiming for a better model.
Ethically, many people would agree that cosmetic or industrial animal testing without any potential benefit to human life is questionable at best. One ATLA article examines the reasons that such testing persists, along with how the winds are changing (ATLA 37, 6, 623-629, 2009).
While statements like 'animal testing added 23.5 years to the average human life' are specious, let's not pretend that animal testing doesn't have applications that are, at present, irreplaceable if medical experimentation is to continue to the same standard. This is the view espoused by a peer-reviewed journal that exists solely for the promotion of alternatives to animal testing.
tl;dr Even a peer-reviewed journal with an anti-animal testing viewpoint recognises that animal testing is an essential part of medical experiments.
2
u/Thrilip Jun 19 '12
Thank you for your well reasoned, calm, and informed argument. I appreciate your dedication to a level-headed discussion...good on you!
→ More replies (1)
9
Jun 19 '12
If you protest animal testing and you eat meat, you are a sick fuck.
Eating meat: Human pleasure>Animal lives
Animal testing: Human lives>Animal pain
edit: this doesn't apply to all animal testing, because sometimes animal testing amounts to "Human pleasure>Animal lives"
→ More replies (8)
4
u/Vikaroo Jun 19 '12
Just because it may be necessary doesn't mean I have to like it, but also just because I don't like it does not mean that it isn't necessary. But fuck vivisection, period.
→ More replies (9)
4
Jun 19 '12
"I think animal testing is cruel. They get all nervous and give silly answers." -Stephen Fry
24
u/Atomic_Frog Jun 19 '12
I live in Boston and it really pains me to walk through Harvard square and see people bemoaning the deaths of animals as if they were killed for no purpose.
To be clear: the people protesting in the picture posted and those I've seen in person are protesting not just the testing of cosmetics on rabbits, but the sacrificing of monkeys and rats during medical testing.
Medical testing on animals is necessary not just for testing the molecular ins and outs of a new drug in an academic setting, but also to get clearance to begin human clinical trials for any new therapy.
If you truly value the life of a monkey or a rat over human lives (let's say one of those lives is your own), then by all means refuse to take any FDA approved medicine or accept and FDA approved procedures. (I'm using the USFDA here since I'm American, but feel free to throw in the EMA or any other regulatory body.) I'd love to see how that works out for you.
→ More replies (7)
213
Jun 19 '12
I could have a similar sign about the Jews. Thanks to torture we took human knowledge into the forefront of modern medical research. Not sure such methods deserve such praise though.
8
u/Syphon8 Jun 19 '12
"I understand. Without condoning, or condemning."
8
Jun 19 '12
It's actually " Without condoning or condemning, I understand."
Either way, what a great book/movie.
→ More replies (2)102
u/magicmanfk Jun 19 '12
my thoughts exactly... this seems to be a "the ends justify the means" argument.
→ More replies (114)23
u/bobtheterminator Jun 19 '12
Were the Nazi experiments that useful? I know there's some information on hypothermia and freezing that know primarily because of those experiments, but it doesn't seem like they made any significant discoveries, and it definitely doesn't seem like that did much that couldn't have been replicated with more humane methods. I could definitely be wrong, so someone correct me if I am.
The point of this sign is that not only are experiments on animals very useful, but they've yielded information that we couldn't have gotten any other way.
→ More replies (8)28
Jun 19 '12
Tl;dr: Yes, they were very useful and we likely would not have gotten this information without fatal testing of our own.
→ More replies (4)47
u/tangerineturtle Jun 19 '12
I don't think it's fair to compare scientists trying their hardest to help humanity with Nazis, or to equate Jews with guinea pigs and lab rats.
→ More replies (5)30
Jun 19 '12
The Nazi scientists weren't trying to help all of humanity, but they were definitely trying to help their own people with the research. I don't think their research was morally correct, but don't make it sound like they did those things for no reason other than to make people suffer.
→ More replies (108)11
u/Ex-Sgt_Wintergreen Jun 19 '12
Actually, almost all of those medical experiments ended up being worthless. The only useful knowledge we gained out of the whole of their testing was how the body reacts to freezing and the effects of phosgene gas.
Hardly the forefront of medical science there.
3
u/Planet-man Jun 19 '12
How the body reacts to freezing and depressurization are extremely fucking important.
→ More replies (1)3
u/ventose Jun 19 '12
Only because the Nazi's chose to conduct unambitious experiments. Using human test subjects instead of animal test subjects will always yield more accurate results in medical research. The point still stands. The argument made by the sign is an evasion. If human test subjects were allowed, you could make the same argument, namely that protestors are hypocritical for protesting research that they benefit from. The real argument is whether great apes, rats, and other intelligent animals deserve rights similar but weaker than those we give to humans.
61
u/Pays4Porn Jun 19 '12
I hate wishy washy wording like that. "animal research models have helped extend the average American life expectancy by 23.5 years." What does that even mean? Take the "helped" out and the statement becomes much stronger.
Give me a strong statement like: American Cancer Society says: “The importance of using animals in research cannot be overstated."
6
u/jewunit Jun 19 '12
Because they realize there's probably a lot more that has gone into helping extend or life expectancy by that much. Maybe the American Cancer society isn't on statement as saying anything about it, or maybe they wanted to include a solid number on the increase. It doesn't take too much critical thinking to figure out why they included "helped" in there.
16
Jun 19 '12
The health sciences try to take credit for this supposed lengthening of the human life span. Common wisdom says that we used to live on average until about 45 to 50 years. This is just not true.. While it is true that we live anywhere from 2 to 10 years longer than we did prior to the 1750's or so, the real reason we seem to live longer is because of the difference in life span calculation that results from infant mortality being factored in. We have seen a dramatic shift from the days when during childbirth there was a 50% chance that either the mother or the baby would die. Now that infant mortality is commonly below 1% our average life span appears to have skyrocketed.
→ More replies (6)17
u/duack Jun 19 '12
Not necessarily true, whilst this may have been the case for some time, in advanced countries the infant mortality rate has stabilised yet life expectancy continues to rise.
Take the US for example, in the 1960s the infant mortality rate was 25 per thousand (or 2.5%). In 2010 it was 7 per thousand (0.7%) with a total of 18 per thousand (1.8%) reduction over this period. Assuming this 1.8% would live to be 75, this would add 1.4 years to the life expectancy. However, the life expectancy has risen by 9 years over this time. The rest of the difference can be attributed to better treatment of late-life diseases like cancer, heart disease, and possibly some reduction in the rate of smoking (not sure about that last one).
TL;DR theres more to life expectancy increase than infant mortality in advanced countries
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (2)2
u/Blindweb Jun 19 '12
I would think scientists would be embarrassed to have such a vague statement on their wall
45 years have been added to the global life expectancy since the Industrial Revolution. Considering the myriad of other advances in society, animal testing obviously contributed a tiny tiny portion to those 45 years
6
u/Shroombie Jun 19 '12
I just wanna say, if you're against animal testing yet eat at places like Mcdonald's, you're a bit a hypocrite.
→ More replies (1)
323
u/JasonMacker Jun 19 '12
Yup, droplets of the latest shampoo into a rabbit's eyes increases people's life expectancy.
Oh, is this an unfair criticism? Well, so is yours of people who are opposed to animal cruelty.
349
u/Renovatio_ Jun 19 '12
Here is what I know.
Without utilizing animal testing we would not be so far advanced in medical science.
Abusing animal testing doesn't advance science either.
The solution lies somewhere in the middle.
129
8
u/heytheredelilahTOR Jun 19 '12
My sister worked in a vivarium (animal research lab) at a very prestigious hospital in Toronto. They're on the forefront of medical research, making import strides everyday.
The thing that people need to realize is that the vast majority of these animals are genetically engineered rats that are expensive. These rats are engineered for whatever condition they are testing for, along with all the different variables. The only other animal that was there was pigs because the researcher had gone far enough in his research to warrant this (not sure of the science or the specific research).
When they needed to euthanize an animal it was done with an injection. If the animal was clearly suffering from its maladies, it was euthanized. Medical researchers aren't in the business of causing animals pain. In fact, they loathe it. It's a necessary evil.
I was born with a rare heart condition, and the operation that they utilized was first performed on animals. There was an alternative available at the time, but it was a temporary fix, that would leave the child with a lifetime of surgeries, quality of life issues, and usually dead by 12. With the surgery I had I'm going to live as long as anyone else. I have a dog to thank for that.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (67)20
u/jeffhughes Jun 19 '12
I agree with you that there is a solution somewhere in the middle there. Non-human animal models are not always useful, but they sometimes are.
But to be honest, I would actually be okay with more human testing without first utilizing animal subjects, at least in select circumstances. In some ways, doing so is more ethical. Humans can consent to participate in research. Animals cannot.
→ More replies (43)→ More replies (146)23
u/EukaryoteZ Jun 19 '12
The Draize test isn't popular with anyone; scientists have been looking for a good replacement for that one for a while. Still, it serves a purpose. I'd rather a thousand rabbits die than a person to go blind.
→ More replies (5)
19
Jun 19 '12
the keyword here is "helped". Animal research didn't raise our life expectancy by 23 and a half years by itself. I mean, I'm sure it has helped us a lot, but it is an over-simplification.
→ More replies (4)
3
3
6
41
u/vamana Jun 19 '12
Straw man argument of course.
They could be protesting about animal testing used on something pointless like make up or shampoo. Nah, it's probably just some hippie faggots.
→ More replies (37)6
u/rumckle Jun 19 '12
They could be, yes, but there definitely do exist people who protest all animal testing regardless of whether it is medical and/or ethical.
→ More replies (3)
24
u/DeathInABottle Jun 19 '12
So ethically questionable acts are justifiable because of progress? That's what the argument boils down to, right? Then maybe we should start questioning our unflagging faith in progress.
→ More replies (17)2
u/Marcob10 Jun 19 '12
Every research project involving animals has to be accepted by a very strict ethical commitee. So as humans, we have decided that the research going right now is ethical.
→ More replies (1)
6
u/DeeepSigh Jun 19 '12
What do you consider animal? What do you consider human? Is humanity derived from intelligence, from emotion, from ability to perceive pain? Is it simply our DNA? Arguably some primates can be smarter than mentally handicapped humans.
In my eyes, the ability to suffer is enough to exclude a life from cruel testing.
→ More replies (3)
31
u/LindySquirrel Jun 19 '12
It's a great sign! For those who are hating on this, my sister (not related to OP) works as a vet overseeing the animal research at a university. To be honest, those animals are treated better than the people waiting in the ER. There are strict guidelines and time spans that an animal can be in distress, much less suffering. Also, whenever possible they don't sack the animals, they put them up for adoption first (obviously if it's safe to). Trust me, my sister is the biggest animal person in the world and did the research on animals before switching to this. They know they're being watched, and they do take care of them!
27
Jun 19 '12
I have to ask, would all of these regulations be in place if there wasn't protests against animal research?
0
29
u/whiskeyonsunday Jun 19 '12
I have to wonder how much of that is relatively recent. Would those changes have taken place without a public outrage at the treatment of research animals?
7
u/TIGGER_WARNING Jun 19 '12
In industry, no. In university research and other public research, yes. The public gets outraged about and supports the easy stuff -- save the cleft lip babies, ban fur, etc. Most of the long-term stuff that matters most is done almost entirely without interest from the public, e.g. the campaign for non-human legal personhood status of certain species.
21
u/thebigbabar Jun 19 '12
It's true. The IACUCs (Institutional Animal Care and Use Committees) are a true pain in the ass when it comes to animal studies. As an animal lover, I love it. As a scientist, I understand it.
3
Jun 19 '12
Not to rain on this parade... they are "strict" but there is plenty of common institutionalized abuses going on thanks to inflexibility of the system. You decide it's best to sack your mice another way after receiving approval? Have fun getting that changed! You decide to change anesthesia? That'll be a few months lost! I know of so many labs that change protocols without informing the IACUC and regularly get away with it... it's just sort of part of doing animal research. Yes, if the IACUC's find out they're pissed... but that almost never happens.
13
u/KosstAmojan Jun 19 '12
Seriously. I'm now a surgeon, but when I was in medical school I did research doing operations on rats. There are more and better regulations on rat surgeries than there are on humans!
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (34)2
u/Alinosburns Jun 19 '12
Though from the regular posts on Reddit about the American health system that doesn't seem very hard.
There's also the argument that this wouldn't have occurred if these people hadn't been protesting.
Since these companies want to keep some sort of public profile, and they want to be able to prove they aren't just pouring acid in animal's eyes for the fun of it.
Much like my grandfather was able to build the home he lived in himself, even though he's not a licensed anything. A Bunch of people do that poorly, people bitch about all these houses falling down and plumbing not working so now you can't do it all yourself.
Complaint creates an overhaul of aspects to the system for the better or worse. To claim that the animals are cared for better than they once would have been doesn't explain why they are. And most likely its because of protesters like this.
2
2
2
2
2
u/uriman Jun 19 '12
Not sure if OP is there or if there are multiple signs everywhere, but there's a copy of this at U of Minnesota, which get regular protests. ALF broke in a decade back took a bunch of rats from their cages and freed them in a field. The Minnesota weather quickly killed them. They also managed to smash up a lot equipment, microscopes and basically trashed the place causing several million dollars in damage. They also destroyed some poor PhD student's (human) cancer cells putting them back a year or two. UofM still has a primate lab (one of very few places that has primates still) and also has really high end security.
2
2
u/apoptoeses Jun 19 '12
There was an ad I found very thought provoking, which had a picture of a young girl in bed with a few stuffed animals, and the caption said "The animals that saved her life are the ones you don't see."
I wish I could find it, I quite liked it.
2
u/rahtin Jun 19 '12
And if we did unethical human testing, that number would probably be closer to 40 by now.
2
2
u/Psychobiologist Jun 19 '12
The best sign in my lab other than the one in the bathroom warning of security cameras.
2
u/DaniVendetta Jun 19 '12
I don't know how well this comment will be received, but I've always wondered why we test on animals when we have a bunch of prisons chalk full with inmates that are either on death row, or facing multiple life sentences without the possibility of parole. In my opinion, they would make much better candidate than animals anyway. If there's no chance they're getting out, why not put them to some use?
2
2
u/Damadawf Jun 19 '12
But if we stop animal research, how will we know which animals are most delicious?
2
u/cbdoc Jun 19 '12
I run a large research lab and the conclusion my colleagues and I have come to is that 95% of animal models are useless. 50 years from now we'll look back at animal experimentation and think about how stupid and cruel it was.
2
u/standard_error Jun 19 '12
What you have to understand about people who oppose research on lab animals is this: for a lot of us, it is a fundamentally morally forbidden to inflict suffering on other living beings, including animals, for whatever reason. Of course we understand that animal research has been very useful for humans and helped make our lives better and longer1. That doesn't matter, because to us it is morally forbidden to use animals in this way.
Almost everyone believes that using humans for these experiments is fundamentally wrong, and thus would never even consider it, no matter how huge the potential benefit to humanity as a whole is. Animal research protesters simply hold the view that this moral right of not being experimented on extends to all animals, or at least to all mammals. Thus, to us, any argument based on the benefits from this research is irrelevant.
Any argument about this must start with a discussion about moral values, and which rights should be extended to which living things. Only after that is settled can any utilitarian considerations be brought in.
1 Lately there has been some debate about whether animal testing is hurting rather than helping science, but that relates to alternative methods that have not been available for that long.
2
u/jumalaw Jun 19 '12
What the fuck is wrong with animal research? I love knowing shit about animals. Who doesn't? That's like saying "archaeology is bad, fuck the dinos!" Dinosaurs are awesome and I want to know about them, too.
Now, if they were protesting pharmaceutical trials of new drugs performed upon animals, we're talking a whole different ball game.
Fucking semantics, how does it work?
2
2
u/bw2002 Jun 19 '12
The research done by German and Japan during WWII was very useful in modern medicine.
I suppose that should continue as well.
4
Jun 19 '12
the best part is a lot of those protestors, hell even some of their leaders, use products created via animal research
→ More replies (3)
7
3
u/Tom_Z Jun 19 '12
Penn and teller had a fantastic episode about PETA and other folks against animal research. It was one of the best episodes they had in my opinion, and definitely worth a watch. Extremely eye opening for me.
4
Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 19 '12
Dammit... I work at a veterinarian hospital and this same exact poster is in my boss's bathroom. When I started about 4 months ago I thought of taking a picture and putting it on Reddit but I figured it would get downvoted. A fool I am.... A FOOOOL!
Edit: spelling.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/Tooby_Snoots Jun 19 '12
I work in a research facility (non-human primates). I treat the monkeys with a great deal of respect and love.
2
u/fotoman Jun 19 '12
to be honest. as someone who is getting up there in age and see the effects of older age on my parents/grandparents (the ones that are still around)...I'm ready to kick things in around 75, I don't want to live to be 97.
2
u/Aspel Jun 19 '12
That doesn't really make it ethical...
No one ever argues that animal research isn't effective, they argue whether it's ethical. We've got a lot of medical knowledge thanks to Nazis torturing Jews and the Japanese using the Chinese like Guinea pigs, but that doesn't mean they should have.
I'm not really on either side of this argument, because frankly it's not something that should be reduced to a good/bad dichotomy, but to say "you live longer because of it" is a stupid argument. You'd think scientists would know better than to use logical fallacies, but then again, you'd be making a fallacy of your own that people who do research are really any more noble or above making such fallacies in the first place.
tl;dr: That's fucking retarded.
2
Jun 19 '12
I used to be very against all animal testing. Protesting and letters and what not. Then I had kids and I was like, "Cut them fuckers up."
2
u/p_U_c_K Jun 19 '12
Here comes the overreaction guy!
We also learned a shit load from the experiments the Nazi's did during the holocaust on undesirables. So.. Let's do that again by this logic.
→ More replies (2)
2
u/Andrenator Jun 19 '12
Fuck inhumane animal testing. And I wonder who's interest estimated those 23.5 years.
2
2
2
u/coolestguy1234 Jun 19 '12
why not just test on life prisoners and gang members
→ More replies (7)7
u/ResidualToast Jun 19 '12
Because then it creates a perverse economic incentive to get new test subjects/prisoners?
2
u/rageking5 Jun 19 '12
Studying the human genome is only one step in the process. Animal testing is vital for many new advances, an example being most of the drugs to treat cancer and basically all vaccines that are out. If someone has a better option than animal testing then please share.
→ More replies (5)
2
u/Skyrmir Jun 19 '12
I'd be real damn skeptical of a 23.5 year life extension. More likely it's around 6 to 7 years if even that much. Simply because something was tested on an animal, doesn't mean we owe it's existence to animal testing. All it really means is that we aren't using prisoner or volunteer testing nearly as much.
→ More replies (3)2
u/UptownShenanigans Jun 19 '12
What it's really saying is that fetal death is down which brings the average way up. The drugs/techniques used to make those advances were done by the sacrifice of animals. Am I proud of this? SImple answer, yes.
1
1
1
1
1
u/MickiFreeIsNotAGirl Jun 19 '12
I think it's a case of whether the ends justify the means.
I know of many serial killers who we could use to test upon, rather than some unlucky mouse who's only mistake was getting born by the wrong mother.
Maybe that sounds barbaric to you, but some of these people I hear about are less than animals. Sociopaths should all be used for testing, I don't care about their human rights. They gave those up the day they violated others.
2
Jun 19 '12
Eh... Honestly? Humans would make pretty lousy research subjects. Generational time is too long, and there are still way too many unknowns about our system. One of the reasons we use animal models is because we know so much more about how they work, and can infer more data about different techniques/drugs and the like from them.
→ More replies (2)
1
1
1
1
u/uRabbit Jun 19 '12
I am okay with the studying and use of animals for testing drugs and what-not to an extent. When it comes to stringing monkeys up by all four limbs, or other foul treatment, I cannot be for that.
1
1
1
1
Jun 19 '12
I remember seeing this about 10 years ago in a building in the Oklahoma University Health Sciences Center
1
1
1
1
Jun 19 '12
At this point in time, it is unnecessary to conduct animal testing on cosmetic/hygienic products and ingredients since all these tests have already been exhausted to shit....
1
1
1
Jun 19 '12
Yes, I imagine you'd need something, however logically fallacious, to salve your conscience.
1
u/chicagogam Jun 19 '12
well, maybe they mean lipstick and mascara research..they should put that on their signs if they do..did..
1
1
1
Jun 19 '12
Don't forget the second in command at Peta uses insulin and says it's alright cause it helps her further their cause and all that....yeah
1
1
u/SecretAsianMann Jun 19 '12
Guy to the right of the girl holding the sign (our right, her left) reminds me of Kevin Rose.
1
1
1
u/DrNonathon Jun 19 '12
This is hanging up at the University of Louisville Research Lab I used to work at.
1
1
Jun 19 '12
I need to see a source other than US Health and Human Services. That's a fairly random number...23.5 years.
1
Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 19 '12
One time I met a guy at a bar who proudly told me about all the research he did on animals. Like, he didn't seem to think of it as a necessary evil but rather something super awesome he got to do every day.
I accidentally stuck him with the tab for the whole table and I don't regret it whatsoever.
1
Jun 19 '12
I don't think humans are inherently more valuable than animals, just more self-aware. I don't care; I don't want any animal hurt for my sake whatsoever.
1
u/Mr0range Jun 19 '12
Where exactly is this 23.5 years coming from? What are they comparing it too? Before modern medical technology people actually lived quite long if they got passed the age of five. That is why those figures are skewed so much.
1
u/Mr0range Jun 19 '12
If the difference between the life of a human and that of an animal is our ability for higher thought, then what separates an animal from, say, that of a mentally handicapped person?
1
1
1
u/AssRainbows Jun 19 '12
I like this because I am going to college next year and I am going to study Biomedical Research as a major, with a minor of animal experiments.
1
u/soapgoat Jun 19 '12
foundation for biomedical research: fighting sensationalist propaganda with more propaganda
1
1
1
u/peter-pickle Jun 19 '12
I'm not against all animal research but playing devil's advocate:
Some of that 23.5 year progress could have been done without animal research... just more expensive - right?
Some of those people might know they're giving up some health but would rather have a clean conscience.
Odd language "animal research has helped extend". That's a hell of a weak/meaningless/unverifiable statement coming from a research advocacy organization.
1
1
u/SaltFrog Jun 19 '12
I used to be obsessed with protecting animal rights, insisting that the testing that happened on them was cruel and unusual. A boy named Laurie Pycroft changed my mind about a year ago. Strange how those things happen.
1
1
1
1
u/m0llusk Jun 19 '12
A more mature approach would be to explain exactly why any particular animal testing is reasonable. It helps to acknowledge that our culture is changing dramatically in its empathy toward animals. There are examples in the past of animals being treated with unnecessary cruelty and then discarded, and it makes sense to confront that directly, come clean through disclosure, and set a reasonable and consistent standard for how animals should be treated and what kind of science is relevant enough to involve animals and how all that is decided and reviewed. Don't let protesters turn what should be scientific into a shouting match.
1
Jun 19 '12
Yes, heaven forfend that people aren't cool with the idea of forcing unwilling subjects into horrible deaths. Modern medicine is built on a foundation of torture for both animals AND humans.
I'm so glad our meaningless lives have been extended.
1
Jun 19 '12
We could learn a lot if we just gave up our moral obligations to the suffering of other animals including humans but we don't because it isn't worth it.
1
1
u/Mycateatspotatoes Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 19 '12
You see, I wouldn't have too much of a problem with living only to round about 50 if people would stop animal research. Why I'm against it? Been there, no, not done that, but seen it. It's not nice. It's absolutely not nice seeing how some people don't give a shit about living things suffering as in "no we don't kill it with poison, it'll ruin our measurement, let it bleed out" or "yes, we do need to inject another 20 rats with tumour cells so that they die painfully so that you may perform some measurements that are basically only required to confirm previous measurements, which where confirmed only about times already".
Please do away with any ideas of "animals used for testing die a quick painless death and then its okay". More often than not, they don't. Anaesthetics cost money and might also screw up the results, so no anaesthetics for most lab animals, but instead some week-long treatment with whatever is up for research in the lab, basically translating to a shitload of pain for some poor fuckers who didn't chose the tests that people have in mind for them.
There is a thing called vibratome, slices live tissue which then can be uses as a substitue model. So you are basically able to chop up whatever tissue you can get and try treatments on that. We do that in our lab with human tumours and the results are much more accurate than for any mice test data I have seen (as in: drugs work the way the should). Why isn't this around, well basically everyhwere? Because fuck-up scientists all over the world "do not see the benefit" and journals mostly demand the research done on rats or mice for easy verification. Because people do not seem to care about anything that will not be able to kill you if you try to kill it.
In my humble opinion people who are in favour of animal research, where not absofuckinglutely necessary, should be given a syringe and try to apply a barbiturate to a live tiger before allowed anyhwere near a lab. With the technology that's around and allows us to skip past most of the animal testing you people seriously need to adjust your working ethics.
(I work in cancer research.)
tl;dr: that view is not only outdated but pretty much fucked up.
Edit: spelling.
Edit 2: Fun fact for the cat loving redditors who upvoted OP: yes, there are kittens dying because of this attitude.
356
u/Journalisto Jun 18 '12
I love how the photo looks 23.5 years old.