r/pics • u/[deleted] • Jun 15 '12
Just found out why my bus was late this morning
http://imgur.com/MzvP1205
u/Noek Jun 15 '12
I have never seen a schoolbus go THAT fast in reverse O.o
25
Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12
Friends told me that it was the truck that went fast enough to get under.
Edit. Bus backed up on himThe guy who took the photo told me this ( I don't believe him though)
94
u/Noek Jun 15 '12
Not sure if you'r being sarcastic, or not getting my sarcasm :)
20
u/FuckYeaTitties Jun 15 '12
Maybe just tipsy
51
22
19
u/patman9 Jun 15 '12
The guy definetly slammed into the bus; you can see the skid marks. As to whether or not the bus moved 80 feet depends on if they were slowing down to stop and pick up a kid or if the bus was slowing accelerating after picking up the kid. Only the latter would result in the bus actually moving anywhere.
→ More replies (9)8
u/Redsox933 Jun 15 '12
The bus probably out weighs the truck by a minimun of 10 tons, so I doubt that last bit is true
60
u/Mixed-Signals Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12
It could be, just needs to be fast enough.
Assumptions:
Bus is at rest
Rubber to asphalt friction coefficient = 0.75
School bus weight = 30000 lbf (mass Mb = 932 slugs)
Pickup weight = 5000 lbf (mass Mp = 155.3 slugs)
Work required to move 80ft = (30000 * 0.75) * 80 = 1,800,000 lbf-ft
Kinetic energy of pickup = (1/2) Mp Vp2
Vp = sqrt( 1,800,000 * 2 / Mp ) = 152 ft/s = 104 mph
EDIT: Actually, probably not right because the two object sticks together causing energy loss. Meh, I'll fix it later.
EDIT2:
Conserving momentum after the two objects merge, MV of system should be constant. Using subscript 'c' for 'combined':
( Mp * Vp ) = ( Mc * Vc )
To move Mc ( 155.3 + 932 slugs ) eighty feet, the work is:
W = 0.75 * ( 35000 lbf * 80 ft ) = 2,100,000 lbf-ft
So the kinetic energy immediately after impact is the same as W, using 1/2 Mc Vc2 = K, we find that:
Vc = sqrt( 2 W / Mc ) = 62.2 ft/s
Knowing Mp, Mc, and Vc, we can calculate Vp from conservation of momentum:
( 155.3 * Vp ) = ( 155.3 + 932 ) * ( 62.2 )
Vp = 435.5 ft/s = 297 mph (or Mach 0.38)
10
u/GreenDaemon Jun 15 '12
297mph? that's a fast truck
16
4
16
u/Its_Phobos Jun 15 '12
Random fact that I remember from high school for no real reason: school buses weigh 29,000 lbs.
42
u/angrymonkeyz Jun 15 '12
In today's North America, the kids are fatter. 30k it is.
4
u/Full_Of_Win Jun 15 '12
Sad but true.
3
u/Wirenutt Jun 16 '12
The school buses I drive are capable of 70 children (normal has always been 66) and weigh 31,000 lbs.
This is the model bus I drive, Thomas Saf-T-Liner C2. Note the available capacity is up to 81 and can weigh up to 33,000 lbs.
2
4
u/tm_helloreddit Jun 15 '12
obligatory: wtf are lbf and slugs
9
0
Jun 15 '12
[deleted]
4
u/FortunaExSanguine Jun 15 '12
And to add to that, if you're using lbs as a unit of force, I.e. lbf, you should use slugs as the unit of mass. This gives you the equation of F=ma(c) where the constant of proportionality, c, is 1.
If you're using both the pound force and pound mass in the same system of units, the constant of proportionality is not 1.
This shit kills people. Stop it, please.
3
3
u/arcanition Jun 16 '12
To physics peeps, lbf (pounds-force) is just weight (measured in newtons) which is equal to an objects mass times the force of gravity. Lbm is mass (measured in kilograms).
tl;dr: use the fucking metric system.
1
Jun 15 '12
It looks like the bus didn't skid. So probably a bit less friction. That impact looks like 90 mph or so to me.
2
u/new_math Jun 15 '12
Most people don't know this but buses are built like tanks; you might as well be hitting a concrete barrier. That's a bit of an exaggeration but they do have solid steel rails installed to prevent crumbling like you see in normal vehicles (you can read more on the bus wiki page).
He was going pretty fast to ruin that truck, but probably not quite 90 mph.
1
u/arcanition Jun 16 '12
The sad part is that I knew everything you just talked about.
Another sad part is that you didn't use the metric system :(
1
u/Mixed-Signals Jun 16 '12
I knew I could do it in metric (since it's a better system), so I thought I'd practice Imperial. Might help prevent thousands of deaths in the future, when I'm told to engineer something in Imperial units. You never know :)
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)1
u/gormhornbori Jun 16 '12
You can't use the Rubber to asphalt friction coefficient (static even?), as the wheels of the bus can turn. The bus wouldn't have the main brakes applied, probably only parking brake, or no brake at all. I'd say it's plausible.
9
2
u/mayonnnnaise Jun 15 '12
I've been in a wreck like this. I was a low sitting car and rear ended a truck. I ended up underneath the truck. Fortunately I wasn't going fast enough to submerge myself like this truck, but from my experience rear ending someone in the rain, this explanation seems pretty plausible.
1
u/Laahrik Jun 15 '12
Ya, I was in that same situation but was driving the truck, which had a 3 inch lift (bought it like that). The trailer hitch ripped her engine apart and my bumper had to be replaced, but she was fine. I was stopped at a light, and I couldn't have moved more than a couple inches.
1
u/ohfail Jun 15 '12
An impact like that can do a surprising amount of kinetic displacement to a large vehicle. I had my parked truck rear-ended once by a sedan, and it shoved the whole truck forward about 10 feet. The collision must have occurred around 30 mph, and was a "quarter-panel" collision; ie: only the right front of his car hit the left rear of my truck. Seeing as how this is a straight-up rear end collision, it's possible that it pushed the bus quite a ways. Especially if the speed limit is high on that road.
-3
154
2
42
u/gunitsoldier1991 Jun 15 '12
The real question is, you're not on summer vacation yet?
25
Jun 15 '12
Actually, today was my first exam. I have 3 others monday, tuesday and wednesday
→ More replies (1)28
Jun 15 '12
Wow. High school's here finished May 26th.
2
2
u/sarahjanerobyn Jun 15 '12
I was going to downvote you because I envy you, but I chose not to. You're welcome.
2
2
→ More replies (5)1
1
8
u/gtphoon Jun 15 '12
It amazes me just how strong buses are, when you cant really tell just by looking at them
14
Jun 15 '12
If you look closely, the wheel in the back is actually the truck's wheel. Look how far appart it is from the back wheels.
3
2
u/UnoriginalGuy Jun 15 '12
I wonder how fast that truck must have been going to embed itself that far into the school bus?
Even if the school bus jammed on its breaks going let's say 30 MpH I cannot see that happening.
2
Jun 15 '12
I edited it. Apparently the bus backed up
→ More replies (3)7
u/DaSchultz Jun 15 '12
I have a hard time believing that.
1
Jun 15 '12
http://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/v3fys/just_found_out_why_my_bus_was_late_this_morning/c50z5ir
From the guy who took the picture
6
u/afsdjkll Jun 15 '12
How old are people on reddit?
4
Jun 15 '12
I'm 17, finishing 11th grade (next week)
1
Jun 15 '12
Teens getting downvoted for being young? Come on. There are a lot of who are dumb but surprisingly enough we have to capacity to be mature.
2
u/Wirenutt Jun 16 '12
I get downvoted to hell for being 54. Or for possessing the opinions of a person my age. Not sure which...
→ More replies (1)6
u/Vessix Jun 15 '12
There are many ages, though there seems to be an influx of youngsters recently... or I could just be caring more for some reason.
2
u/MrGonz Jun 15 '12
I'm right there with you. I feel an exodus of older redditors coming soon as the college and now high schoolers take over this summer with endless memes, reposts and AskReddit, "My girlfriend dumped what should I do to retaliate?" post wash over us. oh wait, I guess that's already how it is.
1
u/afsdjkll Jun 15 '12
I'm not even complaining. It is what it is and I love it. I was hoping someone would swoop in with some link to some age analysis from some survey or something.
19
u/JSchook92 Jun 15 '12
People get decapitated in these kinds of wrecks. The guy in the truck is very lucky he's not dead.
9
u/Narissis Jun 15 '12
Dear drivers:
In a match between your vehicle and a school bus, the school bus will win.
2
29
2
13
5
u/Jay_Normous Jun 15 '12
A lot of times when you look at accidents, it's hard to tell who is at fault, or what the circumstances of the accident are.
This is not one of those accidents. This is the result of a complete tool driving WAY too fast.
4
3
u/Stalejokesbakedfresh Jun 15 '12
I'm a bit curious about just how fast you have to be going to force half of the truck under the bus.
1
u/DoubleStuffedCheezIt Jun 16 '12
((Weight of the car + weight of the bus)/(friction between the bus tires & road * friction between truck tires and road))* 2a a=acceleration of the car.
Total = hella fast
4
u/deesnuts Jun 15 '12
Just found out why my handy-man was late this morning
4
u/milkshakeyard Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12
i just pictured handy mandy all mangled up and dead. with his surviving tools screaming in the back of the truck.
3
Jun 15 '12
Lived that before.
It was a cold winter morning, while on the school bus, at the next stop after mine, the kids got on, the door closed and bus started driving forward while the kids were walking down the aisle.
Then everything felt like it was in slow motion.
A huge bang and crash from the rear of the bus. The sound of crunching and scraping metal, breaking glass and kids screaming. My head was thrown into the padded seat in front of me as I see the kids in the aisle be thrown back.
I looked to the back of the bus and saw the driver of a flatbed truck slumped over his steering wheel, bleeding, the back windows of the bus were broken and the truck's windshield was cracked. One kid had tumbled down the staircase, others were crying. One kid at the back of the bus was looking out the window and screamed and yelled at everyone to get off the bus.
Everyone filed out of the bus quickly on their own, the driver was elderly and wasn't of any use to help the students off the bus. She just radioed for help and exited the bus leaving the students to fend for themselves. She stood outside smoking a cigarette and seemed angry/annoyed.
Outside the bus, there was a 4-door car squished under the tailgate of the bus at a 90º angle. The force of the truck slammed the car under the tailgate. After standing in the cold for 5 minutes, another smaller bus showed up and picked us up to take us all home. It was weird since they seemed to want to rush us out of there before any police or EMTs showed up.
I never knew what happened to anyone in that car.
3
u/mtux96 Jun 15 '12
They died.
1
2
u/okiedawg Jun 15 '12
I maybe an asshole, but I'm assuming texting was involved
5
u/brewdad Jun 15 '12
To be fair, you can't really expect the driver to see a huge, bright yellow vehicle with flashing lights all over it directly in front of him can you?
1
u/Wirenutt Jun 16 '12
I am a school bus driver, and I think I have more people not seeing me, pulling out in front of me, cutting me off, and doing other stupid shit to me in the bus than I do in my car. It's the strangest phenomenon I have ever seen. It's almost like people have learned to tune out school buses.
2
2
2
2
u/CJSteves Jun 15 '12
This is the third time in my life I've seen this same situation with school busses and rear end collisions. You think they'd put those extended bumpers on them by now for as many times as it seems like this happens.
3
u/cosworth99 Jun 15 '12
They are called Mansfield bars. They work, but are only legislated to certain bumper heights that busses do not require.
Google Jayne Mansfield and her daughter Mariska.
1
u/CJSteves Jun 15 '12
I will do that, many thanks for the info! It just seems strange that semi trailers have them on the back of them, and that the school busses don't. What's the standard height on a flatbed, 60-62 inches maybe? And the bumper height to the bottom of a bus bumper, maybe 36 inches? I guess that's a sizable difference but man, it seems like it'd be worth it to save a few lives. Sorry for ranting!
3
u/howisthisnottaken Jun 15 '12
You'd think the giant yellow bus would be a sufficient deterrent but apparently not.
1
u/CJSteves Jun 15 '12
When I was in high school, just after I got my drivers license, I was following a bus, about two cars behind it. We crested a hill and the sun was beaming in our eyes. The bus hit it's brakes and the car directly behind it didn't see the brake lights and went under the rear end of the bus. The driver was a student a few grades ahead of me. He died in the wreck.
It didn't make a difference what color the bus was.
2
u/howisthisnottaken Jun 15 '12
I've driven behind buses before and I've had them stop. Granted I prefer being alive to dead so following too closely isn't for me but you're right when you're going to violate traffic laws the color of the bus probably won't help you avoid it.
2
u/CJSteves Jun 15 '12
I understand your position, and also understand that it's easy to make the assumption he was following too closely. However, if you can't see the bus it makes no difference how closely you're following. Even at a safe distance, it's quite possible to hit the preceding vehicle, and if you stop dead in the road, I suppose you'd be just as susceptible to being hit yourself. But this is all hearsay. Just the expression of my thoughts on the subject.
1
u/howisthisnottaken Jun 15 '12
The rules are when visibility is impaired you need to slow down until it's not. Driving blind isn't ok, ever. I know that's hard to reconcile as when you crest a hill you might be blinded for a second and it might be fleeting enough to never prepare for it. It might be one of those situations that isn't really avoidable and that blows.
I'm not saying I'm glad your friend is dead because that sucks. I'm saying that rear ending someone is something that really should be something we all focus on avoiding.
2
u/CJSteves Jun 15 '12
I agree, in a perfect world we'd all make the best possible decisions for every possible situation. I understand the rules, I'm just conveying the story and stating how a few dollars worth of steel and a few more dollars worth of manhours seems like a small price to pay for the benefit. Seeing all of the responses with folks who've seen or experienced the same things (although circumstantial evidence, of course) it would seem that this is a fairly widespread issue.
Also agree that collisions on all levels are best avoided, hopefully awareness, education, and a more sincere approach to following best practices will help prevent future collisions such as this.
→ More replies (1)1
1
2
Jun 15 '12
The person in the truck probably died. We shouldn't take this so lightly.
edit: gender neutrality
2
2
2
2
u/straight_whiskey Jun 15 '12
Your Reddit name is Tipsy yet you ride the bus to school, I am simply at a loss.
2
2
2
2
3
u/yismeicha Jun 15 '12
Doesn't look like there are any skid marks. He was probably passed out before this happened.
22
0
2
1
1
u/officialchocolateman Jun 15 '12
That's what happens when you tailgate a bus.
1
Jun 15 '12
No way the bus could have stopped fast enough for a truck traveling the same speed as it to become that wedged under it. The truck was moving much faster then the bus.
1
u/wild-tangent Jun 15 '12
SUV's and Pickups: Making you think you're safe.
1
u/MollyBloom11 Jun 16 '12
Well, OP says the driver apparently survived, so it does sort of pass the safety test.
1
u/wild-tangent Jun 16 '12
Survived isn't the same as "came out okay." Breathing through a tube or broken bones is a sign of safety failure.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
u/AwesomGH Jun 15 '12
I'm pretty sure he ran into it, considering that some of the back lights and rear door window are smashed and the back door is bent up at the bottom like that.
1
1
1
1
Jun 15 '12
you'd think that you'd figure out the bus was late if you rear-ended it like that. maybe you just woke up from it and that's why you just figured it out. yeah. maybe.
1
Jun 15 '12
There was a really similar accident at my school about a month ago. There were 3 kids in the car, and one of them died. If you saw the wreck, though, it's a miracle anyone walked out of it.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/murlyy Jun 15 '12
Where was this too? There was a bus accident in a town an hour away from me where the driver was killed. By the looks of the license plate I doubt you're near me, but I'm not %100 sure.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/jklasdlkjdasljk Jun 16 '12
Similar accident happened here 4 months ago, the teenage siblings in the car both died:
http://austin.ynn.com/content/283250/2-siblings-die-after-car-hits-burnet-school-bus
1
1
1
1
Jun 16 '12
And somebody else just found out why their loved one isn't coming home ...late or otherwise.
1
u/draxxil Jun 16 '12
I was on a school bus when that EXACT thing happened. The bus was freakin' STOPPED and the driver (of a pick-up, just like in the picture) slammed into the bus at 25mph with no breaks. The bus was fine. The truck was mostly just a truck bed. Amazingly the driver was OK, but the passenger side of the pick-up was just flattened.
1
1
1
u/secretly_a_zombie Jun 16 '12
Something similar happened to my step-father, though not to this magnitude and probably at lower speeds.
Basically it was a big road he'd driven many times before, so he's spacing out behind the bus, bus slows down to stop at the bus-stop, he notices way too late and slams into the back of it.
He got horrid whiplash which still affects him today and he's getting painkillers for like 15 years later, but otherwise he was and is fine.
So yeah, pay attention when you're driving.
1
1
1
1
1
u/lejade Jun 16 '12
Lucky this is a left hand drive car, if this was in Australia that person would have been a pancake.
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
-2
Jun 15 '12
Why are you on reddit if you are young enough to be taking the bus? Where are your parents? Someone call the internet police. This child is lost.
1
Jun 16 '12
Look what happened to my bus. Do you think I would be at school?
Also, I'm in 11th grade. Is there something wrong with a 17 (almost 18) year old on reddit?
3
-1
-3
-1
0
0
0
0
0
0
u/Talamant3z Jun 15 '12
As a person who drove a school bus this happens so often. Most of the time at railroad stops where we are required to stop and check both ways. Really sucks for us because even if we had no fault we get points on our license and after 10 you have to go through a bunch to drive a commercial vehicle again
0
0
0
0
u/the3r1c Jun 15 '12
Uh oh, I know the logo that's on the truck, reddit is starting to blend with real life.
0
0
0
-2
Jun 15 '12
I was once in the car with my mom when we passed an accident like this. Convertible had parked behind an 18 wheeler at night, another 18 wheeler came into layby didnt see car and parked in same spot, sending it under the first.
Yes i saw the detached head
0
28
u/dhdsrcool Jun 15 '12
Is this the crash?