r/pics • u/KatelynnLynn • May 16 '12
My old high school elected this brain damaged, wheelchair-bound young woman as prom queen this weekend. This is the look of pure joy as she dances with her mother.
773
u/hawkens85 May 16 '12
Please stop these posts.
8
u/hawkens85 May 16 '12
Let me clarify - there is a VERY special place in my heart for people who are developmentally and/or learning disabled. They deserve so much love, and despite all my cynicism, I have a tender spot for those who are disabled.
That being said, the recent trend to post a picture of someone who's developmentally disabled at prom has me feeling kind of torn. On on hand, I think it's GREAT that the kids of the school were so selfless and weren't so consumed about who the "coolest, hottest" people were to vote for them. I'm sure these special people felt like a million dollars getting all that attention and love. But the love shouldn't stop there. Take time out of your day and spend it with someone who's disabled. They need your love.
On the other hand, what was a local celebration to be enjoyed by a few hundred turns into some kind of parade of "LOOK HOW SELFLESS WE ARE" and asks for validation. And we all know the instant you start bragging about how selfless you are, you are in fact, very proud and selfish.
Not to mention the fact that cyntiadangus mentioned that the title alone of these posts has gotten taken on a less loving tone and more of a hostile one. That's what really messed me up when I saw this. Her prom was a reason for her and her real friends to rejoice, not a time for you to exploit her happiness in a wave of 2-day Reddit popularity.
1
May 16 '12
You deserve much more then the points you already have. I'd give you a boatload of upvotes for your commentary.
4
u/spunkyweazle May 16 '12
You'd think with the top comments of the other 2 posts (at least that I saw) scolding the poster that the message would be sent.
16
u/whoneedsusernames May 16 '12
Please downvote these types of posts people, and don't feel guilty for doing it
15
May 16 '12
I agree with this person.
15
u/SoAwkward_ May 16 '12
And I agree with this person. If I were handicapped, I definitely wouldn't want pity from anyone. The only reason people voted for her was either because they felt bad, or they felt that they had to in order to be a better person. I bet no one was best friends with this girl and sincerely wanted it for her.
8
u/Valiturus May 16 '12
I like how you magically can glean what people were thinking. OP mentioned he is from a small town. In a small town everyone knows everyone else. I expect their values and attitudes are quite different from those you just espoused. I'm pretty confident that you're dead wrong here.
7
May 16 '12
As someone who grew up in a small town, people are the same all over the world.
And they're all selfish assholes.
4
→ More replies (48)2
258
May 16 '12
Seems patronizing.
5
u/zombieslaya1138 May 16 '12
In my high school nobody tool these things seriously. They would always vote for the strangest looking couple. So I am a little uneasy when it comes to things like this. With it being a highschool event I believe it was more done as a cruel joke rather than a nice gesture.
1
3
26
u/missstar May 16 '12
I see where you're coming from, but don't discount the fact that she might also be an awesome person, deserving of 'prom queen'.
66
u/dubnine May 16 '12
The title of this post is patronizing, not the action of being prom queen...in my opinion.
13
u/divinemomentumtruth May 16 '12
Agreed. Nothing wrong with giving someone a chance to feel special, though I don't care for the title.
9
May 16 '12
Agreed and disagreed. It's nice she got to be prom queen, but being posted on Reddit probably does nothing for her.
17
u/pants_full_of_pants May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12
There is also the possibility that her cognitive abilities are not adequate for reading that far into the situation to find malintent. In any case, she looks genuinely happy in the photos so I'm glad for it having happened.
5
u/Polamolecules May 16 '12
Hahaha, you think being prom queen is about being a good person, that's adorable.
0
13
May 16 '12
It would be patronizing if they made up an award to give to her. Someone's going to be prom queen. Is it not patronizing for anyone else elected prom queen? The students choose who they want to wear the crown, this time they choose this chick. Because she's brain damaged she must not actually deserve to wear a plastic crown for a day? They like her, they voted for her, everyone's happy.
15
May 16 '12
They are giving her the attention because they feel sorry for her, not because of the typical reasons we treat prom queens as such. That is what is patronizing.
-3
May 16 '12
You're assuming things. I don't agree with your assumptions.
8
May 16 '12
You don't think they are doing it out of pity?
How cute. How is life so far, having been born yesterday?
2
May 16 '12
I'm feeling like maybe you don't spend much time with people with disabilities. They're just as likely to be cool (or assholes) as anyone else. They're just as worthy of things like being voted prom queen as any other person.
Jesus, dude, they're just people.
→ More replies (3)2
u/Xani May 16 '12
Gotta say, I agree with you my friend.
My dad used to work with special needs people and I met one of his students who had down syndrome. So. Fucking. Lovely.
People need to look past the strange appearance and "brain damage" or whatever and find the humanity behind it. Sure, they could have done it out of pity, but I like to think a whole bunch of high school kids aren't all that bad.
0
u/LettersFromTheSky May 16 '12
How so?
47
u/Magzter May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12
"Let's give the brain damaged girl prom queen, it'll make her feel good and make us look good".
Edit: Before you reply, I propose the question: Is it okay to lie to someone to make them feel good?
15
May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12
Even if that's why they did it, I don't really see the issue. They probably felt good about themselves for doing a good deed- and look at the girl in the picture. This might have been the best night of her life. Good on them for making her feel like a princess.
Edit: in response to your edit. For one thing, she may well have deserved to be prom queen. She could be a wonderful girl, and on top of that she's had a hard life and will face a lot of struggles due to her disability. Who's to say this is a lie at all? She's probably way more deserving than the chick who won prom queen at my high school.
As for the question of whether it's okay, I would pose another question: Who is this hurting? If she had a fantastic evening and a bunch of kids felt good for making her happy- I see no victim. If this is a lie, it was told with good intent and had a great outcome.
7
u/quazimoto69 May 16 '12
It's just fucking annoying because there's been one of these per day since prom season started, not to mention the fact that dumbass OP titled it as if to say "HEY EVERYONE LOOK HOW MANY PROBLEMS SHE HAS." Completely insensitive, as well as karma whoring at its finest.
5
May 16 '12
I totally agree that OP was using the woman's disabilities to karma-whore. If this were not the case, OP would have used person-first language. However, i have no problem with the kids at the high school. It's a nice thing they did that should be celebrated. It isn't their fault OP used their good deed for imaginary internet points.
And again, if OP was really trying to spread a nice story- person-first language next time!
2
u/wherearemyshoes May 16 '12
There's loads of indirect victims. It completely perpetuates the idea that people with severe disabilities should be pitied and treated differently. My little sister is in a wheelchair. I just want her to be treated like a normal human being. She's not special. She doesn't "deserve" to be prom queen.
I can almost guarantee the thought process here was more along the lines of, "let's vote for the disabled girl," rather than, "let's vote for [X] she's an awesome person." I wonder how many people voted for that girl that had never talk to her before. Probably avoided her, even. Some of them had probably made fun of her at some point or another. If her classmates were anything like the people I went to high school with, they likely didn't even have the decency to hold the door open for her on her way into the building. But let's vote for her for prom queen. It's a sick, offensive joke, whether the girl realizes it or not.
15
u/ScaredToSpeak May 16 '12
That's a selfish way of looking at it tbh...
Personally, I feel that you're overlooking the appreciation and happiness that a compassionate act like this one can inspire in an individual who has felt irregular and/or left out for some, most of, or even the entirety of their life...
It's about her, not the people doing the deed...that's kind of the fucking point, actually.
4
May 16 '12
This is not a "compassionate" act. This is a circlejerk. Why don't we elect a special needs person President so we can all feel really good about how compassionate and benevolent we all are for a week or two?
1
u/ay8ny6wg May 16 '12
They aren't doing it for her their doing it for themselves. That's the problem.
14
u/SketchyLogic May 16 '12
it'll make her feel good
The fucking nerve of those patronizing bastards! Making another human being feel good...
I get the impression that we can't win here. If the most popular and prettiest girl had been made prom queen, we would roll our eyes at the blatant pandering to Miss Popular. Since the disabled girl won, we roll our eyes and say that she was only voted to make the attendees feel good about themselves. If the prom queen had been decided by a detailed checklist of virtues as defined by Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics and a panel of the World's most renowned moral philosophers, we would roll our eyes and find another reason to pick at the ridiculous contest.
At least the highschoolers realized that the whole thing is a little farsical, and decided to make someone who was never in the limelight feel good.
7
→ More replies (2)1
3
u/ironjamesflint May 16 '12
A series of events occurred. An unquantifiable number of variables have led to her being prom queen. An overbearing mother perhaps, or maybee a motivated teacher. Whatever the case may be she seemed to have some advocate. We don't know the details and shouldn't presume to judge the intent of any involved. It is what it is. There is no known reason to judge this good or bad.
1
u/Magzter May 16 '12
Well said, I'm merely operating under the assumption that it was sympathy that got her there for discussion purposes.
5
u/LettersFromTheSky May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12
Normally I'm pretty cynical, but I think you overestimate the capability of teenagers to act cohesively to produce an desired outcome.
Just saw your edit
Edit: My answer to your question is no. But what are the students lying about by electing her as Prom Queen?
→ More replies (12)3
u/Loopyprawn May 16 '12
I lie to my wife all the time to make her feel good. What the fuck do I care? Did she smile? Did it make her happy? Then who the hell cares? Even if that was the case, who does it hurt? Not a god damn person. The girl felt amazing, the mother was happy as hell I'm sure, and everyone else got to feel good for doing something nice? Where's the bad?
3
u/Magzter May 16 '12
Tell the person you're lying to that you were originally lying, then tell me that there is no bad.
It's a fickle thing, it hurts no one except the person you're trying to do good for once they find out.
0
May 16 '12
[deleted]
2
u/Loopyprawn May 16 '12
Because "Your hair looks beautiful today" is a terrible answer to "Do these pants show too much muffin top?"
66
u/odd7 May 16 '12
I hope everyone felt super good about it.
46
May 16 '12
They felt great about it but still no one would dance with her so she had to dance with her mom.
22
u/jsellout May 16 '12
I wouldn't trust anyone else to hold up my daughter who can't stand on her own.
4
7
0
45
u/complex_reduction May 16 '12
What the fuck is going on lately? Is 2012 the Year of the Pity Prom? It's bullshit that your schools are patronising these people with fake awards and it's bullshit that you are whoring karma out of it.
6
u/ksneakers May 16 '12
Exactly. I'm curious to know how many of these people who pity voted for the kings/queens actually went out of their way to get to know them during the rest of the year.
3
u/ay8ny6wg May 16 '12
I'll bet 90% of the people who voted for her wouldn't talk to her given the choice. But the other 10% who actually voted for her because they thought she was awesome and deserved that title are in my eyes good people.
2
4
u/Scott555 May 16 '12
Actual achievement is shameful. You are only to be judged by your intentions.
Selecting someone with serious disadvantages to hold some honorary position is an easy way for a large number of people to feel good about themselves.
3
May 16 '12
Oh, my high school back in the day did the exact same thing, except, for Prom King, they elected the kid they would always make fun of. It was really sickening seeing him get elected, then seeing the girl, seeing them dance, and watching everyone around snicker with glee. I don't think he was very appreciative, but maybe I'm wrong....
28
May 16 '12
I can't tell if this post is serious, or making fun of all the other "my high school elected _______" posts...
5
u/RedSolution May 16 '12
I was certain it was mocking those other prom posts because she wasn't in a wheelchair, but the OP produced pictures of her confined to a wheelchair. My upvote morphed into a downvote.
36
18
May 16 '12
Screw you OP for how you titled this. No, Fuck you.
3
16
19
5
May 16 '12
When I read the title I 100% thought this was a Circle Jerk post.
That's how ashamed OP should be.
5
4
u/parrotkeet May 16 '12
aww, do you feel good about yourself? Yes?
You shouldn't. Because you posted it on here like you're an amazing person for being so nice to the "brain damaged wheel chair bound woman". HEY LOOK REDDIT, MY SCHOOL PITIED THE DISABLED KARMAKARMAKARMAKARMA
At least try to cover up your insincerity by giving it a better title.
3
3
3
u/HyzerFlip May 16 '12
Person first disability second.
Also what is with the men at these functions? Go dance within your fucking prom queen you pussies!
3
3
u/bigfig May 16 '12
Question:
Would most of the people who voted to make her prom queen seek out her company on any other day? I can't answer that, but therein lies the difference between true well wishing and pity.
1
5
u/MonGorTheMad May 16 '12
Whenever I see titles like this, my first thought is that /r/circlejerk made it to the front page again.
4
4
May 16 '12
Slave morality. I HAVE AN IDEA! let's vote for the under-dog to make us feel good about ourselves for a little while. YAY! So worthless. Somewhere, a very hot and popular cheerleader is very sad.
8
8
u/slartbarg May 16 '12
We voted the most bucktoothed mother fucking redneck in our middle school as "best smile" in the 8th grade.
2
2
u/bethyanne May 16 '12
I'm so glad they did the political correct thing and didn't you know award it to someone who had done something all year for the school who got robbed of a reward for some national publicity.
1
1
2
u/AutisticTroll May 16 '12
So tired of shit getting upvoted just because the title says "autistic" or "retarded" or whatever.
2
2
2
u/ihatemeatballs May 16 '12
Kids weren't this nice when I was in high school...and that was only 11 years ago. I am questioning the truth of these posts I'm finding on here!
2
u/Enjoiissweet May 16 '12
Thats great, but how would the girl who tried really hard to look her best feel that night? It's like a pity party, electing this girl as prom queen just because of her disability.
2
2
2
u/Aloysius2012 May 18 '12
"wheelchair-bound", looking at the picture, I don't think that means what you think it does.
2
May 19 '12
There's a lot of hate on this post. I just like that she looks like she's having the time of her life. That's pretty badass.
5
4
2
2
2
u/Hachibeechu May 16 '12
I don't give a fuck about OP's intentions, about the number of similar pictures, or any other over-thought, insignificant crap relating to how this website functions on an unspoken bed of self-important, opinionated in-fighting. I upvote for content of picture, to get content MORE views by bumping it up the list, to maybe affect more people with some great examples of human decency. Which is what this picture displays, regardless of who posted it or what it's titled or any other over analyzed petty thing. Or are we just simply irritated that the special needs girl was treated as anything more than a special needs girl?
Also, how is this less interesting than a close-up of some random teenage girl's eyeball and one part freckled cheek, or another fucking Bill Nye sighting? Stop those posts before trying to down play pictures of mass public acts of kindness just because you've personally seen 'a bunch of those kinds of photos this week'. Jesus fucking Christ. Get over it, accept the good picture of a good thing. Please.
2
u/barium111 May 16 '12
Yawn...
Next up: Kid with no legs, arms or... whait for it... TORSO! gets elected
2
2
May 16 '12
My old high school also elected a wheelchair bound guy for prom king, he teared up on the stage. It was a great night.
18
u/TheProphetMuhammad May 16 '12
Q: What turns a good night into a great night?
A: A cripple crying on stage.
2
2
2
u/Marzipan86 May 16 '12
That's awesome. My old high school just banned a lesbian couple from attending prom. :(
15
u/ryedha May 16 '12
Put a picture up of the empty space for karma.
6
u/quazimoto69 May 16 '12
Be sure to provide unnecessary details about how mentally handicapped they are in the title for extra karma.
1
1
1
u/oxymoronused May 16 '12
Post Upvoted to the Frontpage, top comment hating on the fact that it made the frontpage. Reddit in a nutshell.
1
1
1
1
1
u/DrMcAutopsy May 16 '12
I came here to ask if any of the students asked her to dance, but now that it's been pointed out, this whole thing seems like some kind of exploitation for internet points. Really fucked up.
Still upvoting because she looks really happy.
1
1
u/ArchieBunkerWasRight May 16 '12
As the crown is placed on Carrie's head, Chris pulls the rope and Carrie is drenched in pig's blood.
"They're all gonna laugh at you!"
1
1
u/AttackTribble May 16 '12
Regardless of the semantics, you guys did a nice thing for that young lady. You deserve credit for that.
1
1
u/WhenSnowDies May 16 '12
I keep seeing these threads. Looks like they got their message across and it's catching on.
1
u/miss_kitty_cat May 20 '12
Good for them. We all know that what wheelchair users really need is meaningless titles, as opposed to curb cuts, enforcement of the ADA, accessible public transportation, and a little dignity.
1
0
u/redditorchic May 16 '12
This made me smile.
-12
u/chingchong_meow_meow May 16 '12
I don't know man but it made me cry. She doesn't like queen to me.
0
-1
u/Paultimate79 May 16 '12
What is with titles these days? I can feel the spite dripping from this.
You cant just say special needs or something? What happened to tact?
-3
u/SgtSausage May 16 '12
What's with folks this last 30 years or so that they can't call a spade a 'spade'?
The fact is, she is 'brain damaged, wheelchair bound' - it's not like he called her a ”fucking 'tard cripple”, now is it?
A 'spade' is a spade, not a 'special dirt removing implement'
Get the fuck over yourself,would ya?
3
u/Paultimate79 May 16 '12
Ah, so your line of logic is that she didn't say something MORE offensive, so its alright. Nice work, Einstein.
0
u/SgtSausage May 16 '12
Facts are not offensive, dumbass.
3
u/Salva_Veritate May 16 '12
"Have you seen my friend?"
"What does your friend look like?"
"Oh, well he's black--"
"TOO FAR, MAN! TOO FUCKING FAR!"
1
1
u/Paultimate79 May 16 '12
I see. So if you walked up to that girl, called her a "brain damaged, wheel-bound" girl to her face, that's not offensive to you?
You must impress all the ladies with that sort of charm.
1
u/SgtSausage May 16 '12
I'd be more likely to walk up to her and call her a "fucking 'tard cripple", but that's just me.
→ More replies (2)
1
u/HEY_YOU_BLUE_MAN May 16 '12
these pictures depress me. reddit this is my happy time. shes in the cornr dancing with her mom :(
1
1
1
1
u/MKT17 May 17 '12
Im going to be honest, if your retarded im going to take the piss out of you. If you are not retarded im going to take the piss out of you.
I dont have boundaries
0
-9
u/MechanicalGun May 16 '12
My old high school elected this brain damaged, wheelchair-bound young woman as prom queen this weekend.
Get ready for the droves of angry teen Redditors claiming "this is bullshit, she only got this because she is disabled," or some shit.
In all seriousness, she looks very happy and I hope she had a wonderful night. Good picture.
13
May 16 '12
But that is the only reason.
8
u/NELCgeek May 16 '12
What's a GOOD reason?
Perhaps the hours of community service that I'm sure all prom kings/queens put in? Is it the number of meals they have handed out to homeless people?
Oh, right..no, that's not it. It's popularity. In that case, fuck the handicapped. They're not popular.
4
May 16 '12
My cousin (who's not disabled) won a year ago because, out of those running, she pissed off the least amount of people in her high school years.
3
May 16 '12
It's not about a reason. It's about the ulterior motive of electing the person.
"Lets elect señior tardface for Prom King! Well, not because we know him (or really like him...he smells like soup), but because it will make us seem like upstanding students! Huzzah! Free back pats and handies for everybody...what great people we are!"
Want to make a difference in a mentally disabled persons life?
Volunteer, motherfucker
→ More replies (1)1
May 16 '12
Fucking this.
The reason this isn't ok is because it lets people get all holier-than-thou "oh well I wasn't prom king because there's this really nice mentally challenged guy, and we all wanted him to win".
-2
u/Darthchicken May 16 '12
My class elected a black girl as prom queen and a gay guy as prom king I was blessed with an open minded class. FYI my school was 95% white.
→ More replies (4)5
u/Number127 May 16 '12
My class elected the ultra-conservative Young Republican as prom king, and the gay guy who came in drag as prom queen. It was awesome.
0
0
0
0
May 16 '12
This is the look of pure joy as she dances with her mother.
Yes. Yes it is. All the people (which is most of the posts) who don't like it, I disagree with you.
-6
u/rastashark May 16 '12
Sometimes, all you can do is upvote. This is truly awesome-- thank you for sharing.
0
0
0
0
u/wolfie1010 May 16 '12
Please let's stop glorifying brain damaged peoples every underwhelming life event as if its some sort of wonderful moment.
0
0
May 16 '12
I love this shit. God bless the students for giving a girl with a lifetime of grief a few minutes of pure happiness.
1
u/ay8ny6wg May 16 '12
Why does she have to have a lifetime of grief why can't a disabled person be happy?
0
0
0
-3
u/k4hill May 16 '12
I think it's fantastic. This lovely young woman, I'm sure, knows more about life and it's challenges than any typical prom queen elected by "popularity" (=bimbo). Congratulations!
4
u/FraterEAO May 16 '12
You had me until the "=bimbo" part. Just because someone is popular doesn't mean they automatically earned it through seedy means (pun intended).
-1
-5
49
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
wheelchair-bound you say?