r/pics • u/I_FISTED_VOLDEMORT • May 14 '12
A mountain during sunrise. This photo has not been edited.
66
u/Ewan_Whosearmy May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12
This is a great photo, and yes, it has definitely been "edited".
At the very least, the shadow parts in the foreground have been lightened, although this could even be a well done HDR made out of 2 exposures. Also, the reflection would normally be a lot darker than the real mountain. He either used a graduated ND filter, or dodge and burn. Also, you won't find many pro photographers worth their money who wouldn't do some color correction and other enhancements to a shot like this.
Photography is art, and a good photographer will use whatever means he can to make the image convey what he experienced when he actually stood there. Landscape photography is not about making a copy of what you see (which is impossible anyways), but about getting the mood of the scene across to the viewer. It has always been like that, even back in the days when there was no digital. Most people draw a line when it comes to cloning parts in and out of an image, at which point it (to me) is no longer a photograph.
p.s.: cropping the photographers water mark out is a real asshole thing to do.
10
-2
u/arachnophilia May 15 '12
and there's really no such thing a photo that hasn't been edited. just the acts of composition, timing, and selection are editorial. and any output has been modified somehow, if only for display. if the artist isn't making those edits, then the camera is.
10
u/saf3 May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12
Eh, cmon, that's arguing technicalities.
Edited is referring to post-processing. Not edited means out of camera. By your standards what the heck is an unedited photo?
EDIT: In retrospect, I should have never posted this. I opened the flood gates for a bunch of pedantic assholes to come through and argue that everything, even your own vision, is edited.
Jesus people, how can anyone put up with you? You are so incredulous I can't imagine anyone wanting to be your friend because any conversation turns into how you can't possibly be wrong. Grow up.
6
u/Ewan_Whosearmy May 15 '12
People always think of an "unedited" photo as if it was something true, something that depicts reality, which makes it somehow more worthy than an "edited" photo. There is no such thing. First of all, human vision is way to complex to be captured by a camera sensor and displayed on paper or a monitor. Second, looking at the technical aspects of taking a photo: If it's not the camera's jpg processor that's applying curves, sharpening and saturation, then it'll be the raw convertor on your computer. Both are usually adjustable. If you are thinking "film = unedited", have a look at this: http://i166.photobucket.com/albums/u98/cibi1/Avedons-instructions-to-the-printer.jpg - That's a portrait by Avedon with instructions to his printer...
If you just print or upload an image straight out of camera, well guess what - your image is still edited. The editing has just been pre-determined by some engineer who programmed your camera, rather than by you. No good photographer would be happy with that (other than maybe news shooters, who sometimes have to place speed over quality).
In that sense, boasting "straight out of camera" sounds more like laziness rather than an achievement.
2
u/arachnophilia May 15 '12
If you are thinking "film = unedited", have a look at this: [1] http://i166.photobucket.com/albums/u98/cibi1/Avedons-instructions-to-the-printer.jpg - That's a portrait by Avedon with instructions to his printer...
right, pretty much everything in photoshop came from technique used in film darkrooms...
for those reading along, those are dodge and burn instruction.
-2
May 15 '12 edited Jul 10 '15
Remember to lock up on the way out!
4
u/Ewan_Whosearmy May 15 '12
Even if you take a film shot and "just put it on paper" you have to make post processing decisions (or let Costco make the decision for you, which is sort of the equivalent of a camera jpg) What developer? How long? What paper? The differences can be tremendous. You could even say the choice of film belongs in that list - take the same shot with Kodak Ektar and then with Fuji Velvia for example. You'd have to move a lot of sliders in PS to recreate the difference between those two popular films. There is no standard, there is no baseline. Again, there is no un-edited photo. There are just photos were the post processing wasn't done by the photographer.
Edit: sp.
1
u/arachnophilia May 15 '12
Not edited means out of camera.
right, and that's a myth. the camera applies editing. it has settings that it uses that manipulate the picture. the sensor outputs basic data, and there is processing that goes on either inside the camera (JPEG) or in the computer, under the control of the photographer (raw). just because the photographer hasn't done anything beside hit a button doesn't mean that there hasn't been any editing.
in the film days, how the film was developed, and how that negative or slide was printed controlled how the photo looked. there are analogous processes in digital photography.
By your standards what the heck is an unedited photo?
as i said, there's no such thing.
what ewan_whosearmy says is true: photography doesn't depict reality, and just because the process has been relatively "straight" doesn't mean that the photo bears much resemblance to reality.
3
8
u/I_FISTED_VOLDEMORT May 14 '12
Here is the photographer's website
73
u/usernameblank May 15 '12
Direct-link to this image (with the guy's watermark not cropped out...) ಠ_ಠ
17
May 15 '12
upvote this. shit on the OP
2
u/I_FISTED_VOLDEMORT May 15 '12
I actually didn't get it directly from the website, so the watermark wasn't there in the first place. Anyway, you can shit on me if you want to though
2
1
u/flcknzwrg May 15 '12
Just to reiterate:
you knew that he used only one exposure (which you put as "has not been edited" in the title) - that's information on his website.
you linked to his website in the comments very soon after posting.
But why, then, didn't you take the picture, complete with watermark, from his website? Why a version where somebody cropped - hehe, edited - the watermark out?
4
May 15 '12
Well, even if it was a shit move to cut out the watermark, at least he did provide the source.
9
u/saf3 May 15 '12
Wow, fuck you to whoever cropped out the watermark and didn't link straight to his site. Really, what does that accomplish?
Also, looking at the pic on the photog's site, it's clear this is edited compared to the original on the site.
Downvote this crap reddit.
5
u/flcknzwrg May 15 '12
And it states:
This competition required that the image be a single capture - no exposure blending, HDR, or focal blends. I used a 2 stop grad ND filter with movement to balance the bright red peak and sky with the shadow areas.
So he used a single exposure and an optical filter (a grad ND is basically one that makes the upper half of the image darker so that skies don't get blown out). No word on whether he shopped the pic or not - why wouldn't he?
And why did you crop out the watermark!?
75
u/d41d8cd May 15 '12
Not edited besides the contrast has been upped a ton.
5
u/Agehn May 15 '12
That and a lot more. The fact that the land and the sky both seem to be shot with perfect exposure imply some kind of HDR technique or a composite image or something.
4
u/poon-is-food May 15 '12
if shot from raw, you can just adjust the brightness of dark areas to suit. its not HDR, because it doesnt look like shit.
He was probably using a graduated neutral density filter on the lens for this shot. its standard to use in early morning/late evening shooting.
9
u/flcknzwrg May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12
Maybe the camera did that (if the photographer chose a "vivid" color setting while shooting or something like that).
Which is of course processing / editing. Therefore it might have been more adequate to say "i didn't shop this, this is how my camera made it".
10
u/Paradox May 15 '12
Its an Canon EOS 5D…there is no "vivid". You just shoot in bloody raw and up the saturation/luminosity if you want that
7
u/flcknzwrg May 15 '12
You can not look at sensor raw data. There is always processing involved to rasterize raw data into something visible... gradation curve, white balance and whatnot must be applied. Whether this process is done in-camera or on another computer makes no matter, image processing can not be avoided. (And it should not be - if you only apply the absolute minimum of processing to sensor data to make it visible, it will certainly look awful)
So it doesn't matter if he shot with neutral or punchy or vivid or whatever on-camera processing settings (Canon dslrs have those of course), or whether he processed a raw file later on his workstation with whatever processing settings he chose - there's always a bunch of image processing involved.
And in any case, the photographer stated nowhere that he did not postprocess this shot (like tune contrast and colors) - and why shouldn't he? The only thing he said was that this picture was made from one exposure, to qualify for some contest.
3
u/Paradox May 15 '12
OP, however, claims it was un-edited
1
u/flcknzwrg May 15 '12
Which is totally wrong. First, because there is no such thing as unedited, ever (that's what i was argumenting). Second, because the photographer himself does not say this on his website (he only says it was a single exposure, nothing else).
-1
May 15 '12
*a Canon
I'm sorry, my OCD made me do it.
2
u/eydryan May 15 '12
Would be more interesting if you substitute Canon with cannon!
Otherwise this is totally an edited shot, there is no way the lake and the sky have the same exposure even with an nd filter. Furthermore, the colour on the mountain is way too powerful to be natural. So basically the photo wasn't repainted but it was heavily edited. But so what? Why does OP care whether it was edited?
39
6
u/dodadoo May 15 '12
I can confirm that this image is unedited, during sunrise the suns rays reflecting off a hillside will appear very orange http://youtu.be/HJPObB9GmIo?hd=1&t=2m13s
1
27
u/Un-needed_Edit May 15 '12
18
u/SantiagoAndDunbar May 15 '12
needs more contrast
21
u/leon220 May 15 '12
Here you go, good sir.
I also used my own creative license to fix the lack of compression artifacts in the original.
6
u/Fireyedwindsurfer May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12
14
5
u/brightsizedlife May 15 '12
Rocks and water look good. Way too much red on the mountain though - lose of lot of detail.
11
11
u/julianf0918 May 15 '12
For the skeptics among us. This is a phenomenon known as alpenglo
During sunrise and sunset in the mountains, there are times when significant portions of a valley will be in the shade while a ridge or peak will be in the sun. Much like the colors of a sunrise and sunset, these colors shine onto the parts of the mountains exposed to the sun leaving the surrounding darker with cooler colors. This is an extreme case, however it is likely that there were already some red rocks or dust on the mountain side and the light from the sun only increase the amount of red light reflecting off the mountain. THIS is why this is very likely not edited.
8
u/jlhw May 15 '12
This. Living in Portland, OR, you can see this phenomenon displayed on Mt. Hood, 50 miles to the east of town. It's pretty spectacular sometimes. The mountain is typically white or brown, depending on the snow level, but alpenglo can cause it to give off a bright orange/red/pink glow at dusk.
4
4
u/devedander May 15 '12
I don't think I have ever seen this effect have such a dramatic and deliniated as well as evently dispersed effect...
You can pretty much rule out red dust or dirt when you note the trees thsemselves take on the exact same red hue as the mountain. Then there is the fact it's a very flat even red the whole way round... the shadows from the rocks on the mountain suggest a low light source to the left yet there is no evidence the shape of the mountains curvature creates a lessening of the effect on the right side which one would think would be prominent in this case.
The deliniation of the colorshift along the treenline also looks incredibly odd and while I suppose not impossible is extremely unlikely in appearance.
Also of question is the weird pink smearing on the mountains in the background...
I can't prove it didn't happen exactly like this in real life, but it just feels incredibly faked on so many fronts...
When looking to see if a photo has been shopped it's important not to juts limit yourself to the single most obvious issue to overcome, but all the details...
In the comment below referencing mount hood, you can clearly see the features I am talking about... it's much less pronounced, much less even, much less dramatic and generally much more soft and natural looking.
Certainly a reddening during low sun is to be seen, but much like the recent bright orange moon over the sierra nevada photo taht made the rounds, it's almost impossible it actulaly happened naturally to anywhere near this extent.
3
u/harrysplinkett May 15 '12
the orange colored trees on the left pretty much tell you it's edited. no matter how orange you sunlight is, the trees will never be the same color as the god damn red rocks.
14
u/Rgplmr May 15 '12
truly beautiful photography, only from I_FISTED_VOLDEMORT... keep your eyes out for his next series of beautiful artwork
1
u/flcknzwrg May 15 '12
It's not his artwork. He took this from the photographer's website and cropped out the photographer's watermark, clearly ripping him off.
1
u/shoegarbagebiology May 14 '12
earthporn?
-3
u/I_FISTED_VOLDEMORT May 14 '12
Haha! X-post it if you want to
2
u/shoegarbagebiology May 14 '12
I just might. your username is one of the best.
-2
u/I_FISTED_VOLDEMORT May 14 '12
Why thank you ;)
2
u/shoegarbagebiology May 15 '12
That winky face made me uncomfortable
2
2
u/aazav May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12
Yeah, but the JPEG settings are set on vivid. Saturation's a bit high. Look at the stones on the foreground.
2
u/liamdapyro May 15 '12
I don't care about the editing or the lack thereof. I want to know which mountain this is.
2
u/Paradox May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12
Its in Glacier National Park, I believe.
Ninja-Edit: Yes it is, I took some pictures of it:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/paradox460/7201615350/in/set-72157629736262028
http://www.flickr.com/photos/paradox460/7201639154/in/set-72157629736262028
http://www.flickr.com/photos/paradox460/7201646372/in/set-72157629736262028
http://www.flickr.com/photos/paradox460/7201693134/in/set-72157629736262028
http://www.flickr.com/photos/paradox460/7201694994/in/set-72157629736262028
Edit again:Flickr fucked up somehow and duped my photos everywhere, so I'm currently reuploading. I'll make those links work as the uploads finish1
1
u/rowdiness May 15 '12
oh, bugger. I got lost in the romance that it the photographer had trekked all night to set up a shot on the shores of some far-remote lake and set up his tripod to wait for dawn, snap a bunch of shots, then trekked back to the car.
0
u/Paradox May 15 '12
Fun fact about the lodge there.The road that approaches it and continues up the mountain, calle "Going to the sun road," was used in the opening shot of the Shining.
The specific lodge is the Swiftcurrent Lodge. And the mountain in question is the Sinopah mountain
0
May 15 '12
[deleted]
1
u/Paradox May 15 '12
Yeah, you're right. I wrote that around 3 AM so i probably wasn't in the best mindset
2
u/TimCurrysLoveChild May 15 '12
Looks exactly like a subliminal up vote. Which I just gave ya a few seconds ago without realizing why until now.
2
2
u/flcknzwrg May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12
Even straight from the camera is processed... by the camera - there is no such thing as "no processing/editing" with photos, ever.
Not in the analog era where you at least chose a film with a certain color rendition.
Nor in the digital era where software on the cam or another computer interprets raw data from the camera's sensor into color information in some (ie not always the same) way.
2
2
May 15 '12
You can quite easily see the artifacts from the color gain being turned way up. In other words, the dude went crazy on the saturation slider.
2
May 15 '12
Maybe not shooped, but definitely tweaked. Probably in camera, most likely a Canon. Lot's of contrast and saturation.
2
u/downvoteme4sex May 15 '12
the thumbnail looks like a feeble attempt at a subliminal upvote. I'M ON TO YOU.
2
3
May 15 '12
This is preposterous. The photograph has been converted to a JPG from a CR2 and has thus had the color temperature modified. There is no way not to modify the color temperature while converting to a JPG. It's impossible. Stop saying it hasn't been "edited" if you don't have the first clue how cameras work. Thanks.
2
1
u/Reddit_III May 14 '12
Since this photo is unedited, could someone explain the physics of what is going on?
42
u/jakenice1 May 14 '12
1
u/fckdup May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12
While I like the infographic (& copied it for future use, thank you), you lost me at step 2. Does the angle of the mountain's slope mean it only reflects the orange/red in the spectrum of refracted light? Like part of a rainbow?
edit: the reflective surface is ice & water in the air.
2
1
1
1
1
1
u/Volsunga May 15 '12
there's at least a crop job done here, so saying it's unedited is not completely true. It also looks like someone messed with the color balance.
1
1
1
u/Ken_Thomas May 15 '12
Just for the record, the mountain is Grinnel, and the view is from the Many Glacier Hotel in Glacier National Park, looking across Swiftcurrent Lake.
1
u/alienufosarereal May 15 '12
Depends if you consider HDR a modification or not. You can tell that it is an HDR photograph because of the "glow" around the ridge of the mountain..
1
u/7-methyltheophylline May 15 '12
From the photographer's website : "This image received the 2011 Highly Honored Recognition Award from Nature's Best International Competition. This competition required that the image be a single capture - no exposure blending, HDR, or focal blends."
A lot of things could cause that halo : sharpening, contrast changes, etc.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Paradox May 15 '12
Looking at the EXIF data on this photo from the actual photographer's website, this photo was edited, quite a bit.
First of all, this was shot on a Canon EOS 5D Mark II, in RAW. This means that it has to be converted to the JPEG you see. This is editing. Furthermore, it makes use of a modified sRGB color space, which can make particular colors pop out more than they would in the original photo. Finally, its got Adobe Lightroom flags on it, meaning it spent some time in Lightroom, and no doubt had some attention devoted to it in the "Develop" panel.
In short, this photo has been edited, OP stole it, cropped out the watermark, and posted to reddit.
1
1
u/GreatBosh May 15 '12
Photography is quirky. Even in film photography there were some darkroom decisions that had to be made that could affect the outcome of the photo but wouldn't be considered 'shopped' by our current standards. This can now basically be done in camera on most pro-sumer DSLRs. Even just changing the white balance can dramatically alter the product.
In this case, if you follow the original you'll see that there is a section that asks if the photo was manipulated. There is also a link that explains that particular websites definition of manipulation. This is generally acceptable, but I'd like to see the original just as a comparison. But even then, just as some in-camera adjustments can make your photo look 'better,' it can go the other way and look nothing like what you thought, in the worst way.
1
1
1
1
May 15 '12
Beautiful picture, but it's kind of hard to take you seriously with that badass user name.
1
u/hurley21 May 15 '12
I absolutely love stuff like this, is there a whole sub-reddit based on this shit? (im a bit of a reddit rookie)
1
1
u/nepnepfickle May 15 '12
With a proper reimaging software used to zoom only, not edit, I am pretty sure The Thing from Fantastic Four is near the mountain. By the ripples in the water it is possible he is screaming "it's clobberin time". Although a little skeptical, joking aside, I would be amazed if that is what the human eye would see at that location.
1
1
1
1
1
May 15 '12
Sinopah Mountain in Glacier National Park! My family used to go to a campground near this lake for a week or two over the summer. Possibly the most beautiful place on earth. Lots of bears though, so watch the fuck out
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/theycallmejerzee May 15 '12
What do you mean "it's not edited"? This is clearly a Dorito shopped into a nature scene.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/rcpopart May 15 '12
it has been edited. If the photographer used a graduated filter then the mountains in the background would have the same gradual shift to darkness evenly along the top. Instead the shift to dark is along the edges of the tops of the nearby mountains. This is most likely due to them using the fill light and then bringing down the exposure or something similar along with a slight bump in contrast (as can be seen in clarity of the rocks and water) and saturation.
I am a professional photographer and I use both graduated neutral density filters, as well as lightroom and photoshop on all my photos.
1
1
1
1
May 15 '12
God some of these comments are annoying. I have a camera, I take pictures. Sometimes they look good right off the camera, sometimes I use photoshop to make them look good.
Who the fuck cares?
1
u/penguinv May 15 '12
Edited to remove photographer's signature.
If I has RES you would have a flair that said "dildo".
edit: to be perfectly clear: here's a repeat link to the photographer's website
1
u/Boomboomtittyfuck May 16 '12
Sometimes I look good when I don't take a shower, but I generally don't feel the need to tell people that.
1
u/aazav May 15 '12
Neither has this video. Taken 3 years ago at 5:30 AM in Namibia.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mi5s5buE3Ks&list=UUKLnLVMlqVG2rgLYz16LdCQ&index=1&feature=plcp
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
May 15 '12
[deleted]
-2
u/aazav May 15 '12
In camera settings. Pro cameras have them.
1
1
u/ThatOneDan May 15 '12
I have a "pro camera". You can set different color profiles, but the amount of dynamic range and contrast (along with color saturation) implies that this was shot in RAW then enhanced in Photoshop.
0
190
u/scratchhappy May 15 '12
What makes you think this is not edited (i.e. straight from the camera)?