r/pics • u/c00lwhip • May 14 '12
Photoshop in the 1950's: Pin-Up Girls before and after [SFW] NSFW
http://imgur.com/a/sy6D7246
May 14 '12
Why am I thirsty for a coke now?
→ More replies (3)312
u/Stillflying May 14 '12
Why are they all making duck faces... I did not realise how far back this trend went
36
May 15 '12
Not a duck face. Their mouths are more rounded rather than billed like a duck. Though it looks funny, it is NOT a duckface, though it has a similar effect to a duckface by bringing the girl's cheeks in (the point of a duckface)
→ More replies (6)100
25
u/keeping_it_a_mystery May 14 '12
I was thinking the same thing. Maybe all the girls who do the duck face actually want to look like pin-up girls.
→ More replies (7)21
u/Fireball445 May 15 '12
It goes back forever, because DUCK FACING MAKES SENSE.
How do people not realize this? As you make the duck face, it pushes your cheek bones to the prominent position, giving your face the illusion of being thinner, gaunter, and giving the distinguished look of high and prominent cheek bones.
Next time you see Kim Kardashina duck face, look at her cheek bones. absolutely flawless line, gorgeous. Then look at some retard girl doing it on facebook and see how she fails? That's because it's not about the lips, it's about the cheek bones. If you don't know that, you do it wrong.
→ More replies (12)11
u/galexanderj May 14 '12
Pucker != duck face
14
u/TheMauveAvenger May 14 '12
It's the difference between a few centimeters of lip movement...but what a difference it makes.
→ More replies (2)13
→ More replies (12)3
May 15 '12
I knew duck face comments would be prominent here. Call me crazy, I find people complaining about and/or mocking duck faces far more annoying than the duck face itself.
→ More replies (1)
652
u/justsomeguy_youknow May 14 '12
Criminy fellas, will you look at those gams!
331
u/bthoman2 May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Boy will I say. Too bad though fellas, I was beating my gums with one of those birds and she told me the bank was closed!
→ More replies (3)293
u/drakanwolf May 14 '12
Figures. Mooks like us don't stand a chance. Dolls like that only swing for high-rollers!
→ More replies (2)229
u/CMacLaren May 14 '12
That really rustles my jimmies, maybe one day I'll be a hot-shot at the top.
→ More replies (11)199
May 14 '12
Jeepers, these dames are the bees knees, I tell you.
41
→ More replies (1)39
u/strangesonia May 14 '12
I read both of these in Jimmy Stewart's voice.
10
u/TomatoManTM May 15 '12
Read the newspaper in Jimmy Stewart's voice. Get really into it. It actually makes you care about things.
→ More replies (2)16
24
u/DingoSuavez May 14 '12
Them gams are just giving me the vapors!
17
u/natophonic May 14 '12
Hey sweetheart, you don't happen to be one of those lesbians I've heard about, do ya?
→ More replies (13)2
101
u/enxenogen May 14 '12
Are they using the original photos just as inspiration for a completely from-scratch painting? Or are they painting on top of the photos?
I'd like to re-create a modern version of this.. but not sure I have that skill in me. Just a photographer here..
156
May 14 '12
the illustrator who did this is a guy named Gil Elvrgen. He painted from photo reference as did Norman Rockwell and most if not all well known artist did. The idea of an artist painting something like that just from pure imagination is not accurate at all. Artists need excellent reference to create good art.
13
u/turbie May 14 '12
I always wondered about that. Because a good painting cannot be done in just an hour, and most people would forget their vision by the time they finished.
→ More replies (6)30
u/Black_Wolf May 14 '12
Yea, and it gets expensive paying people to sit for hours on end. Van Gogh would get money from his brother for food and spend it on models.
→ More replies (2)4
u/tgunter May 14 '12
I strongly recommend the book "Norman Rockwell: Behind The Camera", which shows the reference photos Rockwell used for his paintings next to the final pieces.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (9)3
u/tribal_feline2012 May 15 '12
"Artists need excellent reference to create good art."
True that it is helpful, I do not think that is an absolute that applies to all artists. Imagination alone, with previous knowledge and/or skill, can create wonderful art.
→ More replies (1)2
527
167
May 14 '12
I'll never ever get tired of a beautiful woman wearing a garter belt and stockings.
34
u/lister88 May 14 '12
The world was a better place when garters were a common piece of women's undergarments.
28
u/Margatron May 14 '12
It's almost impossible to find non-lacey, "regular" ones. Otherwise I think more ladies would wear them.
29
u/MdmeLibrarian May 14 '12
Yep. The tops stay hidden underneath the lower waistline of modern skirts, but don't fall down like elastic topped thigh-highs. Also, it's like a sexy little secret that NOBODY KNOWS BUT YOU.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (8)7
u/BurnToAdore May 15 '12
This is not true! Lacy ones tend to be hold-ups, with an elastic/somewhat-adhesive band inside. The stockings that are hooked to the garter belts are usually not lacy, just simple solid bands with plain leg (and back-seam if you prefer... mmmm). At least that's how it is in Europe, where I live.
edit: I think less people wear them now because they are quite fussy. I probably wear garter belts + stockings more often (a couple times a month) than the average girl, but hold-ups/tights are easier by far.
→ More replies (7)→ More replies (4)5
May 15 '12
Says someone who is not a woman... those things are a serious pain. Science has brought us more comfy legwear, but most of us will garter up upon special request.
931
u/fuckYOUswan May 14 '12
Duckfaces through history!
27
258
u/Miffed_Kitty May 14 '12
Since it was done properly back then, it was called a "pout" or "moue."
33
May 14 '12
Actually, the pouts in the photographs look just like modern duckfaces to me. It's just that Elvgren (the artist) somehow managed to soften the expression to look more like a natural pout and less like a contrived duckface. I love his work.
18
8
u/frickindeal May 15 '12
Duckface is a flattening of the lips together to make the classic "duck bill" shape. The examples in the submission express the "oh" or "ooh" sound, as the women are supposed to be surprised at whatever incident has occurred to cause the reveal of too much skin.
124
u/Diels_Alder May 14 '12
Properly?
→ More replies (20)25
u/saptsen May 14 '12
Yes, as in properly old enough to where I can claim it's legitimate, unlike everything nowadays. Rabble rabble get off my lawn
13
u/Xeshema May 15 '12
I believe the ones here have more pursed lips, as if one was to kiss the others cheek, as opposed to the "duck lips", where they are pressed flat and then pushed out like a drunk's lips wedged between a vice.
→ More replies (2)56
May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
I googled "moue" to see images of the properly done expression, and came across this lady, who is a dead ringer for Nicolas Cage:
http://www.hdmedspaclinic.com/images/moue.jpg
Edit: I guess Nicolas Cage with some lip collagen injections.
→ More replies (12)25
u/Blue_no_Yellow May 14 '12
and even back then it looked bad, at least for the actual photographs
→ More replies (2)18
u/Lolwat420 May 14 '12
and here i was thinking girls in my generation made it up for attention. turns out it's existed since cameras, fuck.
41
→ More replies (11)2
45
u/RedactedDude May 14 '12
American Pinup art? Check.
All are Gil Elvgren paintings? Check.
4
May 14 '12
So many iconic images by Elvgren. It's amazing how his work changes with the style between the 50s - 70-s.
→ More replies (2)
319
u/sectorfour May 14 '12
I don't see this as early image manipulation or photoshop. I see this as basing an original image off of a live model (or photographed, in this case). It's the same as taking a life drawing class.
They did airbrush real photos back then for advertising, and this is not that. Cool gallery, though.
21
→ More replies (4)102
u/jsellout May 14 '12
Oh come on, you know what they meant. Obviously they're not trying to draw the photograph exactly as it is; they're trying to make the women prettier and more shapely. This is the same idea behind photoshop.
18
May 14 '12
These are just artist's reference photos.
If they were intended to be edited but essentially as-is, they would have the correct props and scenes.
→ More replies (1)52
u/Ugbrog May 14 '12
Photoshop intends to be considered as an actual photograph. Lately they've been called out, so I may be wrong. But I feel when it was originally used, they wanted to be considered as good as the real thing.
Much different than how these are all obvious drawings.
→ More replies (5)19
u/mmmsoap May 14 '12
Photoshop can be used to create original content, or it can be used to manipulate existing photographs. Don't confuse those two things.
I don't think anyone intends the right side images to look like photos. I think it's supposed to be a commentary on how we expect our modern "pinup girls" to look like--much more slender, perfect, blemish free--due to how Photoshop is used on magazine photos these days.
→ More replies (3)
11
u/The_Sleepy_Fapper May 14 '12
five foot two eyes of blue
oh what those five foot could do
has anybody seen my gaaaaaaaaaal
→ More replies (1)2
175
u/Vahnya May 14 '12 edited May 15 '12
ITT: People who don't know the difference between duckfaces and kissing/surprised faces.
Duckfaces look like you have a bill. The lips aren't pursed, but they're strained. (Usually paired with an 'attitude' face and some sort of gang sign.) Back then, kissy faces were romantic. Yes, these days they're both on the same annoying level of "oh look I'm so quirky and cute", but they're very different faces.
Edit : Duckface comparison for those who still seem to think the faces in OP's gallery are the same.
141
May 14 '12
I think he last one is my sister :(
90
u/Vahnya May 14 '12
Congrats! She made it on a list of 25 worst cases of duckfaces.
random place on the internet where I grabbed these photos.
36
→ More replies (7)20
→ More replies (17)28
u/MyaaahKitty May 14 '12
If I may, some of those don't strike me as kissy faces, but surprised "oooh!" faces. "oooh, the popcorn is popping, it startled me!" and "oooh! where did that pelican come from?" and "oooh! oh my, the sprinkler just started out of the blue and my skirt is all up in the air, and I am so surprised by the fact that you caught me just in this exact moment!" . The wide eyes and the raised eyebrows of startled surprise make all the difference.
Also, still not duckace.
→ More replies (2)
30
u/Salanderfan May 14 '12
I'm a fan of Gil Elvgren's work but it's not fair to call this the "photoshop of 50s". He didn't paint over the photos or manipulate them in any way, he had women pose so he could oil paint based on the reference. Alex Ross does the same thing for his paintings of super-heroes.
Also, if anyone's interested in getting a cheap book full of Elvgren's work, this is a good one: http://www.amazon.com/Gil-Elvgren-Glamorous-American-Anniversary/dp/3836503050/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1337028757&sr=8-1
Fun fact: He did the Coca-Cola Santa ads and is cited as helping popularize the modern day big bellied, long white bearded version of Saint Nick.
9
u/Krispyz May 14 '12
I think the point of comparison was in how the paintings made the models slimmer, "prettier", and clearer (no blemishes or anything). It doesn't bother me because he's not trying to pass them off as the same person, whereas "photoshopping" is used to pass an actress or other celebrity off as different than they are.
To clarify: I'm agreeing with you :)
14
u/RCPMHawkeye May 14 '12
I've always been attracted to Little Debbie, I was unaware of why until now.
25
6
8
3
3
3
u/Kozality May 15 '12
These are reference photos next to the finished illustrated work.
Most professional illustrators do not work by simply drawing outright. Photographic references are an important part of the process, getting together a model, scenery (or stand-in scenery and substitutions) and lighting together to resemble something similar to what the illustrator wants to portray. That gives them a real-world example for how light and shadow will be cast around their subject, the effects of various materials and reflections, etc.
Awesome nonetheless, but they're not "photoshops" The illustration on the right is not a modification of the original image. It's an illustration that used the image on the left as a reference.
10
u/Miffed_Kitty May 14 '12
Repeating myself here, since I replied to the first "duckface" comment I saw and then saw all the "duckface" comments. These women are not making "duckface"! They are pouting or making a moue.
→ More replies (3)
5
u/Navevan May 14 '12
picture 17
Metal \m/
2
u/HarlequinValentine May 14 '12
She appears to be doing the horns at a pelican. Interesting...
→ More replies (1)
21
u/ellopollyyy May 14 '12
I love seeing so many differently shaped women being sexy. I think the original pictures are awesome. :]
17
u/nox_fox May 14 '12
"Different shaped women" meaning you think those girls are fat but you are "ok" with that. Because those aren't different shaped women, that's the normal shape of women.
12
4
u/BitchesLove May 15 '12
There isn't a normal shape for women. I know plenty of smaller and larger girls.
→ More replies (1)23
u/ellopollyyy May 14 '12
Please notice I said "differently" as in women who are a variety of shapes. There are skinny, curved etc. shaped women in those pictures and they all look sexy.
32
u/legal_beagle May 14 '12
Many of those pictures are the same woman - Janet Rae. She posed for a fair amount of Gil Elvgren's work.
→ More replies (2)
2
u/Ptylerdactyl May 14 '12
Something something something, body image, something something, endemic sexism of the '50s, something.
That said, before duckface apparently there was lemonface.
2
2
2
u/lizardking99 May 14 '12
It really says something about sexuality that these images are considered SFW now, whereas they sure as hell wouldn't have been 60 years ago
2
2
u/WiseCynic May 14 '12
Most if not all of these images were drawn by a master of pin-up art, Gil Elvgren.
He done nice woik, eh fellas?
2
2
u/Thermodynamicist May 14 '12
DAE think that the swing in #10 just looks wrong?
I mean, the seat looks as though it's a fairly smooth bit of wood, so it seems very unlikely that her heels could provide the necessary grip - but if she put a lot of weight on her toes then the seat would flip over.
If you'll excuse me, I'll be at my desk, drawing a free body diagram (yes ladies, I am single; please form an orderly queue).
2
2
u/TheBaltimoron May 14 '12
The girls are more attractive in the paintings for two reasons:
They have longer hair in them. It makes a big difference.
They're fucking paintings.
2
2
u/doctorbaronking May 15 '12
More of the same (some new, some repeats) I posted a few months ago. Love this suff.
2
u/RPBiohazard May 15 '12
I think I just heard the white knight's perceptions of "naturally beautiful women" shatter
2
u/Poup May 15 '12
It took no time at all for my mind to shift from thinking how deceptive it is to alter depictions of the female form in such a way to damnit damnit damnIT damnIT DAMNIT GADFUCKINGHELLDAMN WHY DUCKFACE WAAAAIII?! >:|
2
2
2
2
u/lilfeather May 15 '12
This probably wont even be seen but I got fired at work today because my boss walked by and saw this. Apparently he didnt think it was safe for work.. he may also have been mad I wasnt working.
2
2
3
3
3
3
May 14 '12
I wish I would have grown up fapping to these pictures. I'm pretty sure my sex life and outlook would be a little healthier.
4
3
-1
u/tklibe May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Good lord, they all look so HEALTHY
Edit: Look, I'm not trying to say that women who aren't curvy aren't "real women" or any of that. I've seen enough of the "all women are beautiful in their own way" arguments. All I'm saying is these women are positively glowing with good health.
30
u/stufff May 14 '12
Most women you see modeling today are perfectly healthy. Stop pretending it has anything to do with health. You like women who aren't skinny? Fine. Skinny doesn't mean unhealthy.
→ More replies (2)22
May 14 '12
From a girl who is of normal weight, who has been told she was unhealthy because she wasn't curvy, thank you.
42
→ More replies (1)8
u/Elyezabeth May 14 '12
I don't know why everyone is reacting so negatively. Thin girls seem to want to think that anyone who doesn't think being stick thin (naturally other otherwise) is the epitome of beauty is hateful and rude. I'm thin myself and I find it ridiculous. Let people enjoy whatever body type(s) they want.
6
u/scouser916 May 14 '12
The opposite is true too though. "Curvy" girls and the people that like them, want everyone to think that being thin is unhealthy or bad (see: "Eat a sandwich!" and "sharp knees omg!" comments on pictures of thin girls)
Everyone's body type is different, all that matters is that you live healthily.
2
2
2
u/garrettmikesmith May 15 '12
duckface, smiley duckface, duckface, surprised duckface, duckface, GENUINE SMILE, GENUINE SMILE, duckface, duckface, smile, duckface, smile, GENUINE SMILE, smile, half-ass duckface, duckface, duckface, GENUINE SMILE.
TIL duckface predates my father.
2
u/Handout May 14 '12
That's the face that girls are trying to make nowadays, but we've apparently lost all appeal and can only come out with duck face.
1
1
1
1
1
u/captaincream May 14 '12
I love Gil Elvgren's paintings but I can't seem to find many HR wallpapers :c
1
u/ddhboy May 14 '12
Its actually just reference poses for illustrators. Then modernism happened in europe, the designers ended up in America and all the hokey illustration shit was killed by photography and the want to look clean about a decade later.
1
1
u/Duarch May 14 '12
Is it just me or do their ankles really creep you out? There's a giant bump there the way they're all posing...
1
u/mikejam1958 May 14 '12
Better be careful with dames like that fellas. A mug could end up dripping Harvey's Bristol Creme out of his Jimmy.
1
1
u/Chicago63 May 14 '12
I'm so confused. Your post is tagged as NSFW, but you tagged the title itself as SFW?
1
u/3p1c_Kelly May 14 '12
Reddit, what is going on? The title says "SFW", yet theres a "NSFW" tag. Can we get some clarification on what is "NSFW"!?!?!?!
1
1
1
1
u/baileykm May 14 '12
What makes the almost cartoon like effect on the after side? are they drawn after the photo is taken and colored?
1
May 14 '12
haha first, drawn to post with "NSFW" tag, then title claims "SFW", didn't matter, still awesome
1
1
u/isuckatmakingnames May 14 '12
SFW in title.... Tagged NSFW. What am I to believe?
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/wurtis16 May 15 '12
http://imgur.com/a/sy6D7#yXhVA
this picture gave me an instant boner, the actual picture.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/sweetthang1972 May 15 '12
Even then it seemed they shaved just a little weight off of many of them.
1
u/crknut May 15 '12
Well slap my ass and call me a chubby chaser, but I like the before waaaay better!!!
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
May 15 '12
Some of those lady's hairdo's are really really ugly... most of the super short ones do not look attractive at all. Short hair on girls can be just as attractive, but these ones are not.
Also, this isn't so much photo alteration as it is just drawing them different than the original picture...
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
May 15 '12
Almost positive those second ones are just drawings based on the pictures. Looked at the 3rd one, her legs are positioned different, head is positioned different.
1
1
1
1
1
May 15 '12
The beauty of the subject matter aside, the artists who drew these are absolutely incredible.
109
u/Alorenei May 14 '12
Not saying that this should be labeled NSFW, but I definitely don't think it should be labeled explicitly as SFW