r/pics • u/tajgogiants • May 14 '12
Fallingwater: most beautiful home in America? Visited yesterday.
9
u/btravis72 May 14 '12
You know, my whole life I've lived about an hour from Fallingwater, and for the last 13 years I've lived not 20 minutes from it. I have never been to see it in person.
Sounds like something to do this weekend.
1
u/tajgogiants May 14 '12
Buy a ticket for the earliest tour possible, and then show up early. They say the tours can get backed up as the day goes on. Try to pick a good weather morning, too.
2
u/WiseCynic May 15 '12
I'm not far from there, and I've been through the house 3 times.
I'm going again this summer.
Take the "standard" one-hour tour first. Save the extended tour for your second or third visit - if you liked it the first time around.
6
u/Thater May 14 '12
3
2
2
u/sir_weasel May 15 '12
I must play this map. When I visited here years ago with my family all I could think about was how great the property would be as a map in any fps. There's even a guest house that could act as a starting point for an assault or ctf gametype.
11
u/philament May 14 '12
as far as location, it's tough to beat and it's a stunning, beautiful house. i still prefer the Robie House in Chicago, and once did a shoot at a Van Der Rohe house in CT that was beyond stunning.
how did you get to see it? were you on a tour? or just stumbled by?
5
u/tajgogiants May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Bought a ticket for a house tour, then made the trip.
→ More replies (1)2
u/hypno_tode May 15 '12
Did you do the regular or extended tour? I Loved the house tour so much I went back for the smaller group photography tour. Very well worth it, plus you get to see some extra rooms.
1
u/tajgogiants May 15 '12
First time, so did the regular tour. Can imagine returning. Were you allowed to take pictures inside the house on the photography tour?
2
u/hypno_tode May 15 '12
Yes, that's the beautiful thing. Photography allowed though out, and the guides give you plenty of time to take pics.
2
u/tajgogiants May 15 '12
Cool! I figured the main reason they don't want cameras on the regular tour is that the tours would be backed up even more. Secondly, people with cameras in close quarters sometimes lose their balance, knock stuff over, break stuff...
→ More replies (1)10
u/CaffiendCA May 14 '12
My Dad lived in the Robie house as a student at the University of Chicago, when it was used as a dorm. It was nice, but would have been better as a house!
The University had plans to tear it down on two occasions. Thankfully that didn't happen.
5
May 14 '12
FLW is basically in the middle of nowhere- I can't imagine anyone "stumbling upon it."
Incidentally- Kaufman's original plans for falling water were to locate it below the falls so they could look up to them from the house. Wright built the house on the falls and that made a huge difference in the final product.
4
u/kentoss May 15 '12
I remade this in minecraft a while ago.
It's still up on my private server if anyone wants to see more pics.
1
13
u/midnightrider May 14 '12
Hey, here's your photo with a few retouches and filters. I thought it deserved some tweaking. Amazing house. http://imgur.com/WtTRf
2
3
u/stereostaticxx May 14 '12
I'm definitely going to have to make a trip here this summer. I've seen so many other Wright houses living in Buffalo, but this is in a field of it's own.
4
u/tajgogiants May 14 '12
Buy a ticket for the earliest tour in the morning and show up early: they say the tours can get backed up as the day goes on. Lots to do in the area, so plan ahead. I spent the afternoon at Ohiopyle State Park next door. Saw six waterfalls. Represent, Buffalo.
4
May 14 '12
Ohiopyle is awesome, going rafting is so much fun! I really want to try the natural waterslides sometime..
1
u/tajgogiants May 14 '12
Got some great pics standing right over the natural waterslides. That looked so scary and unsafe! WHAT?! Maybe if I saw other people doing it first. Lots of other people. Hmm, it is spring, so maybe it's safer in the summer.
→ More replies (2)4
4
u/illyquilly May 14 '12
Kentuck Knob, another FLW building near Falling Water is worth checking out too. It was cool compare and contrast the two building in the same day.
3
u/LeonardoFibonacci May 14 '12
You're kidding. I was there yesterday too. You wouldn't remember your tour guide's name, would you?
1
u/tajgogiants May 14 '12
Nah, but I do remember the group number, which is more specific. They mentioned 600 tickets were presold yesterday, so doubtful you were in my little group of 10 or so. Oh, forgot this is reddit: 1.67% chance you were in my group (not counting walk-ins, so probably even less). Besides, you would know if I were in your group because it is impossible to forget the most handsome guy you've ever seen.
→ More replies (1)
2
May 15 '12
Did they finish renovations and open up all the rooms?
1
u/tajgogiants May 15 '12
Renovations finished currently, but Fallingwater upkeep is a continuous necessity so will go on occasionally forever. I didn't notice any rooms closed off.
1
May 15 '12
I'd like to go but it's something over a four hour drive and it doesn't look like theirs much else going on down there except maybe for some camping.
2
u/tajgogiants May 15 '12
Actually, the area is a major attraction for outdoor activities. I spent the morning at Fallingwater and the afternoon hiking for waterfalls at Ohiopyle State Park next door. Skiing nearby, too. Of course, with a 4-hour drive, you'd want to stay overnight.
2
u/Kremm May 15 '12
agreed, I've gone to this location every season and it has this way of redesigning itself. Absolutely amazing house with a lot of priceless artwork.
1
73
May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
For those wondering:
Architect: Frank Lloyd Wright
Building: Falling Water
Location: Mill Run, PA
Website: Falling Water House
*edit to correct information, doh *
27
u/Samuel_Gompers May 15 '12
What is more impressive is that it was designed in 1935.
→ More replies (4)33
u/syzbo May 14 '12
Proud to be a Wisconsinite.
→ More replies (1)24
u/borkedhelix May 15 '12
For all those who intend to downvote:
Born Frank Lincoln Wright
June 8, 1867
Richland Center, Wisconsin
→ More replies (1)5
u/evozoku May 15 '12
And his famous (and somewhat infamous) studio, Taliesin, is in Spring Green, Wisconsin.
→ More replies (1)7
4
u/TheySeeMeLearnin May 14 '12
Came here to say this. My favorite picture books as a kid were books on architecture, so by 9 this guy was my idol.
→ More replies (2)4
→ More replies (2)2
u/Xani May 15 '12
Dammit! For once, I thought my art history A-level would come in handy (I studied this building) and could look all smart on the internet, but you outright stole my thunder! :p
94
u/Aardvark52 May 14 '12
I went on this tour when I lived in Pittsburgh. I thought it was fairly cool, but comfort was not on Frank's mind at all. The hallways were about 2 feet wide and Frank ignored his Engineering advisors forcing the cantilevered portion of the house to have to undergo a very expensive repair. Like I said, there were some good things too, such as the corner-less windows and setting the house into the mountain using the bedrock as the floor. Frank would have been able to make some awesome houses if he was not as pig-headed as he was and actually listened to his advisors.
52
u/Zisteau May 14 '12
Keep in mind this house was made in the 30's. Nothing like it had ever been made before. It was seriously decades ahead of its time.
49
u/stereophillips May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Well, yeah, but Fallingwater is hardly beyond criticism. To me, like much of Wright's architecture, it's too dark. Because of its ceiling height, it feels cramped. Those cornerless windows are prone to rot. And Wright was so disdainful of his clients' taste that he demanded veto power over their possessions--including art--so that nothing they owned could detract from his vision. That, in turn, led to his over-reliance upon certain visual motifs. One reason so many of Wright's buildings wound up being sold by the people who commissioned them is that it's hard to ever feel as though a Wright design is yours--it'll always be his.
31
May 14 '12
Because of its ceiling height, it feels cramped.
Falling Water was specifically meant to feel like a cave in areas. The entrance itself is behind stone facades to make it feel more like you are entering a cave. That's part of the reason it is built into the hillside the way it is.
Those cornerless windows are prone to rot.
That's a failure of the technology available at the time. Those windows could easily be created today without leaking or causing rot.
FLW was an arrogant ass a lot of the time- but I don't think these are the best examples. The rest of your criticisms are perfectly valid.
→ More replies (3)4
May 14 '12
That last line gave me a lot of Fountainhead. Sounds like Wright was the Anti-Roark :)
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (2)4
May 15 '12
He did the veto thing over his clients' furniture. The only exception was his wife. I remember while visiting Fallingwater, the tour guide pointed out a set of chairs that FLW's wife selected. FLW's own chairs were too uncomfortable for her.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)10
u/hertzsae May 14 '12
His designs were ahead of his time. His engineering was not.
His apprentices often knew better and at times were able to hide extra engineering here and there. If he had listened to more people, he probably could have made much physically better structures. However, a personality that listens to others might have prevented some of his brilliance.
→ More replies (5)8
May 14 '12
Actually his apprentices got it wrong just as often as they got it right. One reason for the failure of the cantilevers is that his apprentices added extra steel because Kaufman's engineers said it was necessary. The extra steel prevented the concrete from filling the forms properly and added a lot of extra weight.
He was definitely pig headed, and I've never been to Falling Water, but every other FLW house I've visited has been amazing. Small things I would change here or there- but light years ahead of other architects at the time.
6
u/Diosjenin May 15 '12
The small hallway width (and low height) was completely intentional, and was a feature that Wright implemented often. The idea is that if you force a person to navigate through a small space, the area it opens up into will feel much bigger than it actually is. And let me tell you - after touring a couple of Wright houses, it's amazing how well it works.
I remember one in a Chicago suburb that had a typical Wright hallway leading into an octagonally-shaped study area. The hallway was maybe two feet wide and six and a half, maybe seven feet high, no windows - borderline claustrophobic. Then you step foot into the study, and it seriously feels like surfacing for a breath of air after being underwater for too long. Vaulted ceiling, natural light pouring through windows on all sides, recessed bookshelves, a surround desk built into the walls, and still enough space to walk around in. You look around in awe and think to yourself that you could practically build a nest and live the rest of your days out of this one room.
But if you explicitly try to shake off the feeling of spaciousness and look at it purely objectively, you begin to realize that it's actually quite small. The desk is shallow, maybe fourteen inches deep. The room itself is probably only ten or eleven feet in diameter, not counting the desk. It's basically an indoor gazebo with a lot of built-in furniture. But the contrast provided by that horribly cramped hallway really makes the study feel like a space instead of just a room.
5
u/Zenphobia May 14 '12
Wright said in interviews that he often designed furniture specifically for the houses that he designed, and that he would design the house in such a way that his furniture could not be taken out. Furniture would be assembled in the rooms that they were meant for, and that was it. They couldn't fit out the doorways or down the halls.
2
u/Megatron_McLargeHuge May 14 '12
It was also insanely overbudget. Not even close to what he was asked to produce.
→ More replies (26)2
u/dunomaybe May 15 '12
They skipped mentioning this on the tour, something that was stressed alot when I visited Taliesin West: FLW often uses a technique that I've heard called "catch and release". Many of his entryways and halls are very small and cramped, to give you that edgy, uneasy feeling, with entrances into large open rooms. This is mean't to keep you out of non-functional places and stay where he intended you to.
3
u/civilengineer May 14 '12
WOW 50 ft wetland buffer dude. WTF man.
1
u/ShakeyBobWillis May 14 '12
Environmental Planner popping in to let you know your humor has been noted and appreciated.
1
u/civilengineer May 14 '12
Its alright this house was built in the 70s and nature was stronger back then.
3
14
u/Yesterdays_Fish May 14 '12
If you're still in the area, stop by Kentuck Knob. It's not as breathtaking as Falling Water but it's close by and still worth a look. There are sculptures scattered around the grounds and if you go on the tour, I recommend you skip the return shuttle and take the walking path back to the entrance. If you do this, you'll pass more art that isn't mentioned in the tour.
EDIT: Also, keep an eye out for a piece of the Berlin Wall.
10
u/necron May 14 '12
I can't agree with this enough. I visited both houses when I was a river guide in Ohiopyle and I have to say that the outside of Falling Water is nice, but the INSIDE of Kentuck Knob beats the inside of Falling Water any day.
3
u/sillyhippo May 15 '12
upboat from a former river guide there too with laurel highlands
→ More replies (1)
20
2
u/ohlyss May 14 '12
One of my professors mentioned that in order to get a photo like that, you have to venture out into the woods or something because that isn't the front of the house. Like, it's not an easy photo to get. Is that true?
6
u/tajgogiants May 14 '12
It was very easy to take, actually. In the woods, but the established clearing is a short walk on a very well-maintained path. The hardest part was finding a moment when no tour groups were on any of the balconies.
2
15
u/SirRosie May 14 '12
Gotta visit one day, before they stop restoring it and it falls apart. Wright was an amazing architect, but not an amazing engineer.
7
u/supersoldier May 14 '12
Ironically enough, that picture was on the front of one of my sophomore engineering class textbooks: Mechanics of Materials
→ More replies (1)
1
5
u/normalville May 14 '12
less than 10 miles from my house. Been there once, its very nice. Stop by next time we can do something
4
5
5
May 14 '12
This looks like it could be made in MineCraft, so I'm gunna make it in MineCraft!
→ More replies (1)
4
4
u/jt32470 May 15 '12
i personally prefer the millard house / la miniatura simply beautiful . up for sale for 4.5 million. I can't believe it hasn't been snatched up. I swear athletes, movie stars i guess would rather have a mega-compound built instead of something as simple, and beautiful as this house.
1
May 14 '12
Most beautiful "home". No one lives in it and people tour it all the time.
1
u/tajgogiants May 14 '12 edited May 15 '12
It was initially designed and used as a private weekend home for decades.
1
6
u/Calapaisio May 14 '12
I think it should be well noted that Frank Lloyd Wright was a beautiful architect, but considering the Robie House, it should also be noted that his general discontent with women came to light during the build. The wife of Mr. Robie insisted on having a bigger kitchen for herself, and Wright had a heated debate with her about it. In the end she lost out. Also, note that the Billiards Room (The Man's Room) and the children's playroom were gigantic, while the kitchen is dismal. There is no space for the Wife in any of his homes.
Thank you art history class.
6
u/stereophillips May 14 '12
It wasn't just women--Wright was pretty contemptuous of worker-drones, too. He designed the Johnson Wax building with frosted glass on the grounds that a view would distract workers from their jobs.
3
u/Calapaisio May 14 '12
True, but you have to admit, the servants quarters in the Robie house were pretty big. While he may have been a visionary in architecture, he was behind the times in values.
→ More replies (4)4
u/hertzsae May 14 '12
Wright was so far ahead of his time that he knew that a woman's place was not in the kitchen.
→ More replies (1)
3
3
u/QueenofNerds May 14 '12
I went there for a fieldtrip in 7th grade. I should go back, I only like 2 hours away.
→ More replies (1)
3
May 14 '12
I went to his studio in Chicago last year, it is a couple of blocks away from The Robie House. It was awesome and the story behind the house was amazing as well
3
May 14 '12
i redesigned this house in my architecture class, the damn thing is incredible on the inside
3
u/bladeballerina May 14 '12
I took a picture from that exact spot only my parents were in it. Now I feel like Marty McFly.
3
3
3
u/verifex May 14 '12
My own trip to fallingwater was awesome. I love the area, it's deep in the woods too, would have been an amazing place to get away from it all for sure when it was built.
3
u/live3orfry May 14 '12
Sooooooooo Loooooooong Frank Lloyd Wright
I can't believe your song is gone so soon
3
May 15 '12
As a interesting fact, this house's plans were drawn 3 hours before the deadline to the project itself. He called the owner of the land and told him they were waiting for him, he was in a 3hr drive from the office of Mr. Wright and all he had were blank pieces of paper, when the owner arrived he had drawn the whole house for him... obviously hand-drawn by Frank Lloyd Wright... pretty impressive if you ask me.
3
u/Maiasaur May 15 '12
I almost died here by accidentally slipping and falling into the waterfall. I was 7.
→ More replies (2)
3
7
u/Ssyphon May 14 '12
too bad the architect was a complete ass. Liked because it is an amazing house.
→ More replies (6)
2
u/Bilbo63 May 14 '12
Yes, it's beautiful for sure. I took my kids there about 9 years ago. definitely worth the trip if you are able.
2
2
u/mrman122 May 14 '12
My dad's side of the family lives in Scottdale, maybe 45 mins. away. (I'm not sure exactly) But we would always stop by there as a kid, to this day it is my favorite house.
2
u/tombombcrongadil May 14 '12
FLW did a lot of work at a college in my hometown. Every time I visit the campus I feel like I'm about to hit my head on something. Dude musta been super short or something.
2
2
2
u/skintigh May 14 '12
I am 6'0" and found I had to stoop in many rooms and duck through doorways. At least the occupants didn't get drenched when it rained like in some of his other buildings.
FLW was the PT Barnum of architecture.
2
u/ShakeyBobWillis May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
In the abstract, just looking at the form in it's site specific location it's awesome. From a functional and construction standpoint kind of a hot mess. While one of the most visually striking of his homes, not what I would consider his best work.
Funny how, at the time it was revolutionary design, now it's also reminiscent of drab cement slab architecture of the 50s and 60s.
2
u/sube_fresh May 14 '12
I live near the area. I actually toured 3 other FLW houses/style houses. Built by his apprentice, we almost got married here.
2
2
2
u/Luminox May 15 '12
I love this house! He made beautiful homes, although from what I've read they are structurally a mess! Nice though!
2
u/moogoo2 May 15 '12
I just finished reading Endymion by Dan Simmons. Thank you for your appropriate timing in helping me picture the end of the book.
2
May 15 '12
Yes! This is an architectural masterpiece! Its a wonderful example of creative interaction between nature and construction. I'd check this out if I could!
2
May 15 '12
I had a class, The Making of the Modern Mind, and it covered Frank Lloyd Wright's works. You should check him and his other ideas out, this guy was a visionary, there hasn't been another architect in the world quite like him.
2
2
2
u/vonHindenburg May 15 '12
If you're into hiking, the Bear Run Nature Reserve which surrounds the house has great trails and free camping spots. Just don't camp right over the river! There's an active rail line below them and a freight train every 20 minutes isn't conducive to a peaceful night in the woods.
2
u/Mechbowser May 15 '12
Agreed by most architects, FLW is absolutely fantastic. And this is one of my personal favorite houses.
2
u/popojijo May 15 '12
I was born and raised about 30 min away from falling water. I still haven't been to it. I suck.
2
2
2
2
2
May 15 '12
i love that I can see a Frank Lloyd Wright home and immediately know it is his work. He was an incredibly gifted man
2
2
2
u/ASmellyFrostTroll May 15 '12
Is this falling water generating electricity? If so it would be beautiful AND self-sustaining, a true home of the future.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/rumbar May 15 '12
i'm from ohio but i go on canoeing trips on the alleghany river often. i've passed the turn off for this house many times and still have never been. gotta make it there this year.
2
2
u/kamiikoneko May 15 '12
At the time, yes, but not anymore. There are tons of more beautiful homes now. However, most spider-covered home in America? Probably.
2
u/beefy6 May 15 '12
Agreed. Took a tour of Fallingwater a couple of summers ago. Awesome place to visit and I am glad to have gone. My dad's side of the family actually lives in Mill Run, PA and that is where my grew up. Turns out that my Pap (Dad's dad, my grandpa) who was a very skilled tradesmen, helped do some masonry work on the guest house that actually appears behind the main house shown in the picture.
2
2
u/I_heartily_agree May 15 '12
FLW was WAY ahead of his time. We visited Taliesin West some years ago and thoroughly enjoyed it.
2
2
u/Flashman_H May 15 '12
I read somewhere that the builders thought Wright hadn't designed enough strength into the cantilevers and added a bunch of rebar to it, which added unplanned for weight and made them droop. Wright was pissed.
Then later they still weren't sure it was going to hold and were afraid to remove the wooden supports underneath (maybe due to the concrete not being cured yet, can't remember.) Wright showed up, got pissed again, and personally went over and kicked the supports out while underneath the cantilevers.
2
2
u/lynnmo May 15 '12
I have a book about Wright that explains his works and a lot of blueprints/photos of his work. he's built some pretty interesting buildings.
2
2
u/cr1sis77 May 15 '12
Frank Lloyd Wright is amazing. However, this place was recently renovated because the concrete was sagging over time.
2
u/sazerac1 May 15 '12
Ugh Wright as one of the first staritects...and his designs much like gehry's today...are just bad design for living IMHO
2
u/smithsknits May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12
Did you happen to check out Kentuck Knob? It's another FLW house nearby and is also spectacular. I highly recommend! It has a grest view on the backside of the house down into the valley. It's much smaller than Fallingwater but just as awesome.
Edit: I accidentally an extra letter.
2
3
3
4
u/sassooooo May 14 '12
not pictured: red ferrari crashed out of back window.
13
u/dorianb May 14 '12
Wrong house. That was the Ben Rose house. Was for sale late last decade for around $3 million.
→ More replies (1)10
3
u/SgianDubh May 14 '12
Very much no, IMO. It is a nice location, and it was a novel concept at the time, but that's about it. Those big, beige slabs are hideous!
→ More replies (9)
0
u/didshereallysaythat May 14 '12
Is this in Massachusetts near Weston.
2
u/tajgogiants May 14 '12
Mill Run, PA. SE of Pittsburgh.
1
u/didshereallysaythat May 14 '12
:(. There is a house that looks exactly like this one near or in Weston MA.
1
2
2
1
May 14 '12
i think this was done by the same guy who did the house at the end of Hitchcocks 'North by Northwest'
Yep, Frank Lloyd Wright the architect
reminds me of the kind of buildings in thunderbirds, too
→ More replies (2)
1
1
u/noorhassan May 14 '12
I would appreciate this image more if it weren't the cover of the book for the engineering class I almost failed this semester
1
1
u/TheOneWeirdGuy May 14 '12
I used to see this picture all the time in one of my high school math textbooks.
1
u/mycatisnoob May 14 '12
In one of the computer labs at my school, we have a picture of this hanging up. It said it was drawn in the 30's.
1
May 14 '12
Most Beautiful home in America - Fixed
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Biltmore_Estate_-_front_facade.JPG
1
1
u/leadnpotatoes May 14 '12
Beautiful sure, but I would vote it most unsafe. Wiring is horrendous and the railings have more in common with curbs.
1
1
u/Bioluminescence May 14 '12
I have no doubt it was utterly groundbreaking at the time (late 1930's) but (likely due to the horrible abuses of the concrete-obsessions of the 70's) I really can't bring myself to like Modern Architecture. I admit, part of that may be more Brutalist Architecture that repulses me, but I am not knowledgeable enough to be able to instantly tell them apart.
My apologies to the architecture fans in the thread.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
1
u/aggregatecture May 15 '12
the irony is that it needs constant repairs or the roof leaks. "falling water"
1
1
u/Bagtackles May 15 '12
I think it looks different and interesting, but I wouldn't call it beautiful.
1
u/GreenGlassDrgn May 15 '12
Went there as a kid. Was seriously unimpressed. Don't tell your kid you are going to a 'house of the future' if it was built for 'boring old people' who liked brown nuances, and smells like retirement home.
Got older, acquired an appreciation for design. Now this place is my pet peeve on a pedestal.
1
u/sofa_king_awesome May 15 '12
For you Wisconsinites, I thought this was House on the Rock. Looks similar. That is an impressive house.
Edit: For people that don't know what I'm talking about here's the Sauce
1
1
1
May 15 '12
Take that house and put it on an average street and it would be ugly. The only nice thing is its location.
97
u/magicbullets May 14 '12
It's beautiful. Frank Lloyd Wright was well ahead of his time.
I keep meaning to buy the LEGO version: http://shop.lego.com/en-US/Fallingwater-21005