r/pics • • May 14 '12

Body Size Stereotypes based on Glamour Magazine Survey NSFW

Post image
906 Upvotes

537 comments sorted by

148

u/funkme1ster May 14 '12

Words on the slender girl: vain, bitchy, superficial, ambitious, conceited, confident, mean

Words on the fat girl: lazy, giving, insecure, undisciplined, careless, passive

I find it highly interesting that the slender girl is perceived as a threat (described with things that are active, transitive properties or actions, presumably things she's doing to you that you don't like) whereas the fat girl is perceived as inferior (described with things that are passive, intransitive properties or actions, things she does that you don't respect).

I don't fully understand the context/methodology here, but it seems to be that people who answered this survey predominantly are of the stance that women that look better than they do are their enemy, and women who look worse than they do are not worth their attention.

That kinda makes sense.

Further, the ONE positive word on each... the slender girl is confident and the fat girl is giving. The implication here is that the slender girl is self-reliant whereas the fat girl works with others. That is also very interesting.

12

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Your threat vs inferior analysis needs way more upvotes. It sounds like a potential reflection of the values portrayed by the magazine to its readers right?

3

u/funkme1ster May 14 '12

I have no idea what Glamour magazine is like or what demographic it's geared towards (I'm assuming women 18-39, though).

I also wish I knew what the survey was. I don't understand why they only really had negative words.

14

u/JLW09 May 14 '12

They are all negative words because that's how alot of women think of themselves and others unfortunately.

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

This is the original article that accompanies the picture, if you were curious. It gives a bit more insight than just the picture.

3

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Yep, Glamour's just a typical women's fashion and lifestyle magazine. It's not as bad as some for promoting poor images of women (like it doesn't tend to run features slating normal-sized celebs for being fat like some other women's mags) but it still blatently promotes the ideal of thin-is-beautiful.

0

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

[deleted]

2

u/testerizer May 15 '12

Do you how many other words not presented in the picture were available?

1

u/jbg830 May 15 '12

Exactly my feelings. These women feel that this is their truth, though truth's are heavily made depending on what the media and culture has influenced people to think. So it is just the women restating notions that they have subconsciously took in as their own which have been given by outlets such as Glamour magazine. Similar statements may be made for almost all judgments all people make of all others.

9

u/brningpyre May 14 '12

These are opinions given to a women's magazine, hence why the opinions view the thinner woman as a threat.

I hate to stereotype, but women do do this all the time (in my personal experience).

3

u/forgot_ma_password May 14 '12

Skinny girl has two positive words: confident and ambitious.

4

u/cappiebara May 14 '12

I agree with you completely, although I would say there are two positive words on the thin girl: ambitious.

5

u/funkme1ster May 14 '12

Is ambitious really a positive word when used to describe someone else?

When I'm in a state where I'd describe myself as ambitions, I'm in control and taking decisive action.

When I describe someone else as ambitious, it's usually mixed in with a flavour of skepticism and reservation. For me, it carries the implication of someone trying to go for more than they should.

2

u/cappiebara May 14 '12

"Having or showing a strong desire and determination to succeed." I personally love to be seen as ambitious. I can see what you are saying, but to me ambitious is nothing but positive. I look for ambition in men, because I find ambition a turn on that I respect and admire.

0

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Makes sense if you think about it, a healthy women is seen as beautiful. The overweight women , is seen as having health issues or health issues in the future.

The fat women is undisciplined, otherwise she would work out and eat healthy (unless she has a medical issue) Often fat people are lazy, if they were highly active, like a marathon runner they probably would not be fat.

-1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

The slender girl is looking defensively at the chubbier girl, while the chubbier one is looking confidently directly at the camera. Maybe that's the point, but it seems to show that 99% of the time, the stereotypes are wrong. The slender girl is perceived as vain, conceited, confident, yet not only does she have a defensive look on her face (suggesting lack of confidence), she is also reluctant to look straight forward, (perhaps she is ashamed of her body?) whereas the chubbier woman who is perceived as insecure, passive, undisciplined is giving a very strong and confident look, almost straight into you, the viewer's, eyes.

Not that the stereotypes are backwards, but that a woman's body shape does not define her personality or level of confidence. Or maybe I'm just reading too much into it.

3

u/funkme1ster May 15 '12

I think you're reading too far into it.

I have no idea what this survey is, but I'm operating under the assumption that the words are highest frequency that readers would use to describe the respective body types, and that the models depicted are just for visual cue without meaning anything deeper.

97

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

And yet both are still photoshopped.

75

u/nemec May 14 '12

Well I wouldn't want a tattoo of "conceited" on my arm.

10

u/Vahnya May 14 '12

Yeah, that font is way too perfect.

81

u/burningrobot May 14 '12

They photoshopped the blemishes off both of their bodies, smoothing out the skin.

→ More replies (19)

70

u/heathn May 14 '12

Would be interesting to see if it was two men of the same size/type how the adjectives would change... hint "Jolly/funny" would be on the fat one...

61

u/edenite May 14 '12

Talking to a few pretentious people at a party this past week, i gathered the following.

Nice = ugly Funny = fat.

13

u/ZeMilkman May 14 '12

It was so nice of you to tell us. It really made me laugh.

11

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I used to think fat people were jolly. Until I got my first job at a fast food place when I was 16. Then I found out just how terrible those gluttons are.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Paranoidexboyfriend May 14 '12

depends on their outlook. a positive fat person is jolly or funny. a bitter one is just a loser neckbeard. Women tend to go the bitter route alot more frequently and for good reason.

→ More replies (2)

56

u/dreamqueen9103 May 14 '12

Yup. Because there are only two female body types.

1

u/MrsReznor May 15 '12

This image is taken out of context. The survey asked women to picture a slender woman and an overweight woman. It was specifically going for the two ends of the spectrum, not everyone in the middle.

17

u/NeverMeant125 May 14 '12

As a 21yr old girl who's 5'9 and about 145 pounds this kind of stuff has always interested me. In high school all my friends would joke that I was too tall ect. What women find phsycially attractive (in regards to themselves and other woman) is often very different than what straight men find attractive in women.

9

u/pantsoffire May 14 '12

yeah, chick hot is a little bit ... different.

6

u/NeverMeant125 May 14 '12

Definitely an interesting conversation to have.

2

u/cuban May 14 '12

As a man, I was not aware that female attractiveness differed between men and women. Would you care to elaborate? Thanks.

5

u/NeverMeant125 May 14 '12

Well first off I think that women are more critical of themselves and other women compared to men. In most cases that I see, women desire to be thinner than what men usually desire them to be. Just something on the top of my head as I type this on my phone.

2

u/cumbersomecucumber May 14 '12

I'm not sure if this is exactly what she meant but from my experience women tend to be much more judgmental about other women's looks compared to men. An example - If I'm going out with a guy I'm dating I keep my makeup minimal, hair natural, and my clothing/accessories simple but sexy. If I'm going out with my girl friends I will spend much more time on my hair, makeup, and dress up/accessorize more than usual.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

19 yr old 6'5" male saying no such thing as too tall. If I don't have to break my neck to make eye contact, that is a pro in my book.

10

u/[deleted] May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

Absolutely nobody in the entire world looks like either of these 2.

These models lack cellulite, body hair, blotches, moles, stretch marks, nipples, VEINS. the list goes on.

25

u/jemappellesarah May 14 '12

This is true. While people who are overweight have it worse, as someone who's naturally really thin people assume things about you all the time.

9

u/joyous_genitals May 14 '12

I feel especially sorry for tall girls. I come from an excessively tall family, so I tend to be attracted to taller girls. If a girl is over 6' and is not overweight, she is automatically considered anorexic. There is really no weight they can be and be considered healthy by society.

5

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

6'5" dude, checking in to say that I love tall women, but they probably have a hard time of it. Theres a small line between overweight looking and healthy looking, and the taller you are, the more difficult it gets.

2

u/pr1ntscreen May 14 '12

naturally thin

Does this even exist? Honset question. Isn't it all about food and exercise?

16

u/MPLS_MN May 14 '12

Some people (like myself) are genetically more likely to be thin. I come from a long line of bean poles and despite having a semi-unhealthy diet (an addiction to soda and a love for all foods with grease and cheese) I have always been thin.

I have always wondered if I wouldn't be thin if I hadn't played a ton of sports as a child though. I've become less active, but I feel like my athleticism as a child helped me develop a fast-metabolism that keeps me thinner now that I'm kind of lazy (but still thin!)

8

u/pr1ntscreen May 14 '12

I was also able to churn down whatever I wanted. Chips, pizza, burgers et.c. Then I turned 24. Now I have to watch out and work out.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/nickiter May 14 '12

Yes. People with healthy metabolisms tend to resist fat accumulation and remain thin, even without food restriction or exercise (and in some cases, even with a huge excess of calories). The American diet has gotten so bad, however, that people with healthy metabolisms are fairly rare.... Most of us develop some degree of insulin resistance by our mid-20s at the latest because we eat so much sugar and starch.

4

u/RosieJo May 14 '12

Nah, I have a friend who has a fridge specifically for chocolate and fizzy drinks, as well as maintaining a diet consisting of every fried food on the planet. She does no exercise, yet stays around a steady 90lb.

2

u/jemappellesarah May 14 '12

Yes it is possible hahaha. I've always been extremely thin, like started puberty later than everyone else, etc, etc. Some people just have a faster metabolism than others.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Yes it does, and it sucks when your a guy and constantly picked on because being skinny is seen as being weak or womanly. I've been to doctors, nutritionists, and trainers but I think the only thing that could bulk me up is the Super Solider Serum.

1

u/moldy912 May 14 '12

I would say natural thinness has to do with metabolism. Metabolism can change by diet and habits, but if it's always generally high, then you will stay thin despite junk food and all.

1

u/midri May 14 '12

Not sure if I'd fall into this category, but I lack the hunger mechanism in my brain for some reason. I don't know I need food until my body is starting to get physically weak if I don't keep track of my food intake. Which leads me to be generally calorie deficient slightly or neutral, since I only eat as much as I need not to feel weak.

All of this has lead me to snack a LOT, I don't really eat structured meals so much as snack the amount of calories I think I will be needing in the near future.

1

u/-smiles May 15 '12

Personally, I get extremely nauseous if I eat a certain amount (typically, it's not a lot). No idea why, it just happens... Was never bulimic and, so far, no doctor has given me an adequate answer. My body just hates me.

Or it's all psychological. Hm. Strange, I've never had a problem with gaining weight. I've always been skinny, which was annoying--EVERYONE thought I had an eating disorder. :(

1

u/Allycia May 15 '12

I dated a guy who would eat and eat and eat and eat, healthy..crappy..in between, and worked out, but he wouldn't gain or lose a pound. Everyone in his family is really skinny.

2

u/MarshManOriginal May 15 '12

Basically, you can't win.

4

u/Therealsebastiandior May 14 '12

I say this needs further research, put them and me in the same room for a few hours.

34

u/graffiti81 May 14 '12

No offense, ladies, but these all sound like adjectives that women would use to describe these women.

I'd be interested to see what men would use to describe the two of them.

75

u/Awfy May 14 '12

Man: "Are they both straight?"

Surveyor: "Yes."

Man: "Do you happen to have the skinny one's number?"

Surveyor: "No."

Man "The fat one's?"

2

u/brningpyre May 14 '12

This is why women are insanely lucky when it comes to dating. No matter what body type they have, there is some guy out there who's into that.

You just might have to look a little harder, but the internet makes things too easy.

8

u/mevanarie May 14 '12

If more guys stopped believing this, then maybe they'd have sex more often.

7

u/XYAgain May 14 '12

Also this phenomenon:

Man: Sexytimes?

Woman: GASP! slaps


Woman: Sexytimes?

Man: pants already off

→ More replies (1)

8

u/thatsamesong May 14 '12

Well it is a Glamour magazine survey, so that makes sense. I would also be interested to see a male perspective though.

5

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

On the left: nice curves on her hour glass figure, however she's on the 'hot' side so probably lazy in the sack.

On the right: while she doesn't have the smallest waist she does have a pretty face, the head will more than likely be outstanding though.

Yes, I am a guy and this is how I see the differences in weight. 'Hot' girls tend to be lazier and some of the better sex I've had is with girls who had a little pudge to them.

5

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

There is actually science behind heavier people having better sex. I'd provide a source but i'm afraid looking for one would result in a shit ton of naked morbidly obese people.

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Science? No. They just try harder, it seems.

2

u/icannotfly May 14 '12

fat, skinny, black, asian, white, whatever... they're all pink on the inside.

11

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Naked, fat, blonde, and 'shopped.

3

u/nickiter May 14 '12

I agree - I'm struck by how negative the words are for both women.

0

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I would describe left as average and right one as overweight.

0

u/Master_Qief May 14 '12

Unhealthy is all I care about

→ More replies (1)

13

u/pantsoffire May 14 '12

ZOMG. Women with different body types are bitchy to each other?! Quick, somebody call the internet!!

10

u/Juus May 14 '12

This is so airbrushed i thought the thumbnail was animated

26

u/Stuntmanmike0351 May 14 '12

I find it interesting that our country is simultaneously trying to figure out how to turn around our "obesity epidemic" while at the same time telling be people to "accept your body the way it is" and that it is ok to be fat/obese.

The woman on the right has a highly increased risk of Diabetes and heart disease, for starters.

5

u/RosieJo May 14 '12

If she was hourglass or pear shaped she probably wouldn't be at very high risk. But she is quite obviously apple shaped, meaning she gains most of her weight around her midriff, putting pressure of the internal organs, and giving her one of the least physically attractive ways that fat can be distributed on a womans body. Which sucks for her.

10

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Yes, thank you for pointing that out. Just one of the many hypocritical things we deal with on a daily basis: We have an epidemic of obesity but if you are over weight you should accept it and love the skin you are in!

0

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

[deleted]

9

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Good luck encouraging someone to lose weight while not coming off as a sexist, pervert, asshole, stereotype-spreader, or any other number of things.

2

u/akong_supern00b May 14 '12

How is that different from everyday constructive criticism? There's a time and place for that kinda stuff, unless you lack some social aptitude...

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Apparently, there is neither a time nor a place for this talk. No matter how close I've been to someone, trying to encourage them to work out/exercise with me has led to someone being offended.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/nickiter May 14 '12

Self-hate doesn't make you thin; in fact, negative outlook is associated with weight gain.

0

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Also, that many of the people who are pro 'accept your body the way it is' absolutely hate everything skinny. ('Men want curves, dogs want bones!' Is a much heard phrase among them.)

208

u/[deleted] May 14 '12 edited May 15 '12

Downvote me all you want, but i'm sick and tired of women who don't make effort to lose weight complain about how unfair society is to them. If your appearance is the most important thing in your life, then change it.

EDIT: If it's not, then pay no attention to what society says.

419

u/KumbajaMyLord May 14 '12

I think that's their point. It isn't the most important thing in their life, but it is to others, who in turn treat them with disrespect.

I don't think many overweight people would deny that they are overweight. What they object to is being called lazy, careless, undisciplined, etc.

116

u/Web3d May 14 '12

I'm quite overweight, and it's because I'm lazy and undisciplined. Obviously not always going to be the case, but I think it stands to reason it makes up for the majority.

44

u/whiskeyonsunday May 14 '12

Hmm, not in my experience. I was overweight because I used overeating as a crutch in dealing with a terrible home life. Once I was in a safe environment where I could deal with my issues I was able to make changes in my lifestyle. I'm not a lazy or undisciplined person, which is why I was able to lose a serious amount of weight once I had the help I needed with my emotional problems.

Granted, this is a case of anecdote going up against anecdote, but the point is you can't tell just by looking at someone what their story is, so try not to be a judgmental douchenozzle.

5

u/NoontideDemon May 14 '12

Hmmmmm, anecdote wars. I have to go write a pilot script...

6

u/whiskeyonsunday May 14 '12

A&E will be in touch shortly.

→ More replies (13)

35

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

But you are free to be lazy and undisciplined; it does not give others the right to trash talk you.

11

u/TooHappyFappy May 14 '12

People have the right to trash talk anyone they want. Every person in the world would be talked about badly by someone else in the world for something.

It's their right to trash talk. It makes them bad people, in my opinion, but they have that right.

You also have the right to not listen to it or care what they say, the right to ignore them. People are so desperate for everyone else's approval, when all they should be concerned with is how they view themselves.

8

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

They have the legal right, yes.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Nerdlinger May 14 '12

People have the right to trash talk you regardless of what you do (so long as it doesn't cross the line into something like slander).

→ More replies (6)

34

u/KumbajaMyLord May 14 '12

First, upvote for honesty. Second, are you lazy and undisciplined at your job, in your relationship or with your hobbys, too? If not I'd say that your weight just isn't as important to you as those other things.

Of course people who care about their weight and want to be lean and well-build but are not, probably aren't very disciplined, because for 99.9% of us, there isn't such a thing as a "bad genes" that keep us from losing weight.

7

u/bw2002 May 14 '12

If not I'd say that your weight just isn't as important to you as those other things.

If health isn't near the top of someone's list, it's fair to say that they have fucked up priorities or are simply ignorant.

27

u/JLContessa May 14 '12

You can be quite healthy and not be magazine-model skinny, or even lean. It honestly depends on what we’re talking about when we classify “skinny” and “fat.”

For instance, I am probably similar in size to this, though a bit leaner in the arms, and I would not be classified as skinny. But I run 6+ miles 5-7 days a week, and watch what I eat very carefully (with weekly deviations for chocolate :) ). I am extremely ambitious, work very hard, and my efforts are coming to fruition in terms of my career out of talent through practice and pure tenacity.

The only time in my life that I was a size 6, was a time when I was obsessed with food, and was so strict with my intake that a friend sent me to a high school counselor (I was 16 at the time), thinking I’d stopped eating entirely. I would work out until I was white in the face, and not eat again until morning. I ate nothing that had any fat in it at all (I was not, at the time, very well informed on what food would help you lose weight in a healthy way). Clearly not healthy. But I got more compliments during that time than I ever had before in my life.

There will always be people who consider me unattractively thick, because I’m not shaped like Kate Hudson, at least not without massive, unsustainable deprivation. That does not make me lazy, that does not mean I don’t try. I try harder than many fat AND skinny people I know.

If you make knee-jerk assessments of peoples’ character based on their size, I guess I’d just ask that you leave room for the idea that you might be wrong. I know people can’t help their initial reactions to how another person looks, but at least give people the benefit of the doubt.

10

u/Raidicus May 14 '12

Maybe it's just me, but I can always tell the thicker girls who exercise apart from the girls who just don't ever get off their asses. I find healthiness attractive, and healthiness is something that goes beyond just the basic size stats that most people cite to describe healthy bodies.

But then again, maybe that's the problem. We focus on numbers, not lifestyle choices.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (23)

3

u/DMCoolen May 14 '12

As a normal sized guy and apparently attractive from what i have been told.....I love pretty fat chicks!!!

-6

u/Bohica69 May 14 '12

What I find especially ironic, and funny, is the number of fat people who claim it's due to a thyroid problem. Only 1 of every 4200 people have hypothyroidism and yet it seems that ALL fat people have the thyroid/genetic claim they make to justify their obesity. Facepalm. It's simple chemistry/physics/math. You take in less calories than you consume which leads to weight loss. Lol

12

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

On a side note regarding calories in/calories out law of thermodynamics: on paper it makes perfect sense, but in execution and study of metabolic function there are many more variables than caloric management.... Like thyroid function :)

→ More replies (3)

6

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Its not as simple as calories in/out. One of the biggest problems is misinformation.

4

u/PigDog4 May 14 '12

Then would you please enlighten me how you can gain weight while eating under maintenance? Where does your body generate the extra weight from?

→ More replies (5)

7

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

As a fitness professional, whom is married to someone with a thyroid problem (graves disease), this is too prevalent in feminine culture. No, Mrs. Moneybags, you are not fat because you have a thyroid problem.iin fact, you have a thyroid problem because you are fat. But I'm not allowed to say that. :(

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

[deleted]

35

u/BZenMojo May 14 '12

Genes aren't fair.

The basal metabolic rate varies between individuals. One study of 150 adults representative of the population in Scotland reported basal metabolic rates from as low as 1027 kcal per day (4301 kJ) to as high as 2499 kcal (10455 kJ); with a mean BMR of 1500 kcal (6279 kJ). Statistically, the researchers calculated that 62.3 % of this variation was explained by differences in fat free mass. Other factors explaining the variation included fat mass (6.7 %), age (1.7%), and experimental error including within-subject difference (2 %). The rest of the variation (26.7 %) was unexplained. This remaining difference was not explained by sex nor by differing tissue sized of highly energetic organs such as the brain.[6]

Thus there are differences in BMR even when comparing two subjects with the same lean body mass. The top 5% of people are metabolizing energy 28-32% faster than individuals with the lowest 5% BMR.[7] For instance, one study reported an extreme case where two individuals with the same lean body mass of 43 kg had BMRs of 1075 kcal/day (4.5 MJ) and 1790 kcal/day (7.5 MJ). This difference of 715 kcal (67%) is equivalent to one of the individuals completing a 10 kilometer run every day.[7]

Just something to think about next time someone calls a fat person lazy.

15

u/jk147 May 15 '12

This, I have two exes and one is considered "out of shape" and she recently just ran a marathon. And perhaps is THE most fit person I have ever met, but by looking at her you would've never guessed she is in that shape to run 26 miles. Now my recent ex is skinny, eats like a pig and can't even run half a mile without huffing and puffing. But she is thin and most people think she works out to keep that shape, genetics is a bitch. A person's fit level has nothing to do with his/her body shape.

7

u/Magnusson May 15 '12

I'm skeptical of the info in that wikipedia article. The study cited in reference 7 was performed on mice, and I can only see the abstract, which doesn't contain the facts cited in the article.

Meanwhile, here is a review of studies on energy expenditure in humans, which states that "the coefficient of variation in the components of total daily energy expenditure is around 5-8% for resting metabolic rate." It's referenced in this examine.com article, which explains the results thusly:

This means that 68% of the population is within 5-8% of the average RMR, and 96% is within 10-16% of the average RMR.
If we take the average RMR to be 2000 calories a day, that means the slowest metabolism gets you at roughly 1700-1800 a day. The fastest metabolism gets you to 2200-2300 a day.
If your metabolism is so slow that roughly 98% of the population has a faster metabolism than you, it means you need to eat about 300 calories a day less.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

3

u/MrsReznor May 15 '12

Thanks for bringing this up. So many of my slender friends are that way just because of their metabolism. They eat cookies and pizza and all sorts of crap daily. I grew up eating lots of veggies and fruits and was always told "clean your plate, there are starving kids in Africa!" So I grew up overeating. As an adult now I'm taking steps to try to correct my habits just so I don't get type 2 diabetes later on. Other than my risk for that, I'm quite healthy and active.

It pisses me off that some people automatically assume that I'm lazy just because I have an extra 40lbs on me. So, thank you, really, for bringing up that thin people can at times be lazier and less healthy than us overweight folk.

→ More replies (3)

41

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I'm absolutely honest here and you can downvote me, too, if you want to, however:

  1. Yes, I find the left woman significantly more attractive.

  2. Yes, I will treat attractive people differently than non-attractive people.

I'm not "disrespectful" to those I'm not attracted at all, though. Simply because I will put less effort into a relationship with people I find less attractive doesn't mean I hate them or want to make them feel bad. Them feeling bad because I treat other people better than them doesn't mean I don't respect them. It means I care more about other people than them.

What they object to is being called lazy, careless, undisciplined, etc.

I only call lazy, careless or undisciplined people lazy, careless or undisciplined.

Just because a greater number of people that these attributes apply to also happen to be fat (which can simply very easily be a consequence of being lazy, careless and undisciplined) and therefore will be given these attributes by me doesn't mean I think all fat people are.

6

u/pantsoffire May 14 '12

You are a normal. Humanity is attracted to art, beauty in all it's forms of expression. Man and Nature made. The Psych tests on which child gets more attention, RE: Attractive vs. Plain, gets all parents well upset. Also, both genders are susceptible. It's human nature. Get over it.

3

u/drkyle54 May 15 '12

What makes you think a greater number of people that are lazy careless and undisciplined also happen to be fat? What evidence you have of that? If anything, the opposite is likely true. Poor people are much more likely to be obsese. This is because they can't afford healthy food, must work long hours and multiple jobs to support themselves and their family, so there's not much time to work out, can't afford a gym, and may not live in a safe area where they can jog outside.

How can you say these people are lazy verses someone who was born into a well off family and can afford a lot of leisure time (which includes exercise) and good healthy food?

You're making a hell of a lot of assumptions.

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

his is because they can't afford healthy food, must work long hours and multiple jobs to support themselves and their family

In my country people who work multiple jobs are a lot of things but definitely not poor. What the heck?

Also: Where I come from "healthy" food is cheaper than unhealthy food. There's nothing cheaper than bread, vegetables and cheap sausages/cheese.

People here are fat because they eat too much and move too little. And yes, poor people more often fat... that's because poor people eat too much and move too little.

0

u/TuriGuiliano May 15 '12

It's one thing to say "I'm fat because I eat shit and I'm lazy" because you realize it's your fault and you're taking responsibility. That people can handle and respect

It's another thing to say "I have a metabolic problem" while shoving in McDonalds. They are full of shit and people call them out on it.

-8

u/bw2002 May 14 '12

What they object to is being called lazy, careless, undisciplined, etc.

Truths.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (51)

16

u/iluvgoodburger May 14 '12

The problem isn't anyone's appearance, it's the emphasis put on appearance by society. Hope that makes more sense.

-2

u/cuban May 14 '12 edited May 15 '12

Perhaps our animalistic love of cheap, good burgers is to blame as well.

Edit: Not sure why I'm being down voted, just stating that our easy access to calories is wrecking our waistlines while also punning on iluvgoodburger's name.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Or celebrity women who, after gaining weight, go on these publicity tours about "loving my body" and "being big is O.K"

3 months later they appear on some magazine in a string bikini giving their interviews about how they got sexy again.

2

u/Vahnya May 14 '12

You just summed up every celeb gossip magazine.

That and how BRAD IS CHEATING ON ANGELINA. HER EXCLUSIVE OUTRAGE ON PAGE 50.

52

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

While we're at it, I'm also sick and tired of people who don't make an effort to get a high-paying job complain about how unfair society is to them. If money is the most important thing in your life, then earn it.

35

u/RedAnarchist May 14 '12

As someone pointed out in another thread, a high paying job is much more of a social construct. Someone has to choose to give you money.

No one can choose to give (or take away) fat and health from you. It is in your hands.

24

u/nickiter May 14 '12

It's interesting that you use the term "social construct" there. If it's true that obesity is not related to social influences, then we ought not be able to effectively subgroup people to predict their chances of getting fat. The fact that we can indicates that obesity is, in fact, influenced by social factors such as income.

→ More replies (28)

3

u/TeamPupNSudz May 14 '12

As someone pointed out in another thread, a high paying job is much more of a social construct. Someone has to choose to give you money.

Yes, but a lot of it just rests on whether you choose to "play the game". Being buddy-buddy with your boss, getting in early, leaving late, dressing to impress. Those things go a long way, and yet some people choose to not do them. You have a lot more control over it than simply someone else giving you the money.

1

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

As I noted elsewhere but will expand on very slightly here: genetics, injury, chronic diseases, stress, multiple jobs, sedentary desk jobs are among the things that say "hi" when you say that it's totally in your control there.

12

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

What's funny here is, if you are an attractive person, success is more easily handed to you.

3

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Opportunity, yes. Success? Not necessarily.

5

u/polandpower May 14 '12

I agree but I also disagree. I agree that you have to work hard for it and what you're doing should have meaning for whatever company you work for. On the other hand, I do think some jobs pay unproportionally high to what effort it requires. And don't get me started on bonuses for CEOs who fucked up. But it happens. And theb there's an outrage, and a day later everyone forgot about it. The ex-boss got 2 M$ for fucking up while you're negotiating for dear life to get that 2% raise.

-2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I can't tell if you're kidding or not but this has got to be the worst analogy I have ever seen someone make.

→ More replies (4)

34

u/fifthfiend May 14 '12
  1. openly declare bigotry

  2. declare you don't care about the consequences to yourself of taking this CONTROVERSIAL and SOCIETY-OPPOSING stand

  3. reddit rewards with upvotes, continues to be hive of misogyny.

16

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

It's almost like a society that leads people to value women on appearance is going to breed shitlords like that dude who attack women for not fitting what they want women to be.

And then they go on the internet and ruin the site where I try and read about graphic design...

3

u/fifthfiend May 14 '12

I'm waiting for r/gd to turn into top to bottom posts about 'yo who designed this chicks ASS, amirite?', then I can unsubscribe to everything forever.

2

u/zoomzoomz May 15 '12

Have you tried crying about it?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/chris-martin May 15 '12

If it's not, then pay no attention to what society says.

That seems a bit like telling members of a subjugated ethnic group to "pay no attention to" racism.

1

u/godito May 14 '12

You do realise some people have real problems losing weight, and others are literally big boned, hipped and breasted?

9

u/Awfy May 14 '12

Big boned isn't a thing by the way, you can have a large build but your bones won't make you fat. There's a vast difference between being overweight, like the woman on the right, and having a large frame or build.

7

u/godito May 14 '12

I know, but I cannot get any thinner than my bones will allow, if I have broad shoulders or hips. The flechy parts you can control, but not everyone can get to be a walking skeleton like those top models.

I for one like a littl meat on my bones

4

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

There's a lot of really big boned players in the NBA who aren't fat... not saying you are a super athlete but you can still be fit and of greater stature

8

u/PigDog4 May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

Bones don't give you cellulite hugeass thunderthighs and make your fat ass jiggle. Bones don't give you love handles that hang over your muffin top. Bones don't give you shoulder fat. Bones don't make your fat arms do that disgusting flappy tricep thing. Bones don't make your stomach hang over your pelvis. Bones don't give you a third chin.

7

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Agree with you that big bones don't give you excess flesh. But weight has no bearing on whether or not you have cellulite. That's a hormonal thing that concerns connective tissues (which is why you see it much more on women -- and why you sometimes see it on supermodels, even).

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/ave_maria99 May 14 '12

as someone who struggles with weight issues i can 100% attest to this. i feel worse when i'm overweight because i'm eating unhealthy and generally being lazy and gluttonous. when i'm thinner i feel better about myself and thus my self esteem goes up because i am exercising and eating right. society likes pretty people. it may not be fair but that's life

2

u/NotlimTheGreat May 14 '12

Why is the top rated comment here have almost no bearing whatsoever on the content, and zero bearing on the message.

-3

u/Bohica69 May 14 '12

And you would be right. When 40% of American's are obese they have only 1 person to blame, themselves. It takes work and personal commitment to become a lardass like that.

4

u/my_name_is_stupid May 14 '12

That's profoundly irrational. When 30% (closer to the actual figure) of Americans develop a serious chronic medical condition in a relatively short period of time, you investigate other epidemiological possibilities to try and discover what will probably be a very complex pathology. The likelihood that a third of Americans spontaneously became extremely lazy over the last thirty years, with absolutely no other contributing factors, is pretty much nil.

1

u/Bohica69 May 14 '12

Sorry, what they are putting in their mouth is their fault. Their sedentary lifestyle is their fault. Not only is quite rational, the actual empirical, statistical peer reviewed data supports my position. They're Darwin Awards winners. Let 'em die.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Downvote me all you want

450 upvotes

1

u/zoomzoomz May 15 '12

No, don't you see, it is everyonelse's job to change to suit me. /s

→ More replies (13)

7

u/Skizorbit May 14 '12

As a currently overweight woman that has suffered for years with eating disorders, weight fluctuating by hundreds of pounds, everything about this post makes me nauseous.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/awesimo May 15 '12

Do not read beauty magazines they will only make you feel ugly.

5

u/WeedNinja May 14 '12

What if i told you...

That some fat people are undisciplined and lazy

7

u/SheriffBart42 May 14 '12

This creature 'Society' you speak of is actually women. Men only see varying degrees of fuckability based on preferences. Women do all the judging, ridiculing, and ostracizing.

7

u/dr_nostrand May 14 '12

I think that body acceptance is important yet it seems that some of the time it used by obese people to justify their weight while ignoring just how unhealthy it is. There is a big difference between hating yourself because you feel 15 or 20 lbs overweight and thinking that having a BMI over 30 is natural and healthy.

2

u/All-American-Bot May 14 '12

(For our friends outside the USA... 20 lbs -> 9.1 kg) - Yeehaw!

1

u/Aiskhulos May 14 '12

BMI is a horrible measure of health overall, and of actual body fat percentage as well. Someone can be 35 BMI and still look be skinny, or be 20 BMI and look fat.

1

u/ddfreedom May 15 '12

for most people who don't work out, it is a good barometer...unless you suggest something else that is as easy to do and gives better results.

1

u/MrsReznor May 15 '12

I can't remember the name of it but there is a more accurate screening tool (BMI is a screening tool) that takes into account your height, weight, and waist circumference. Maybe some other measurement too. The idea is that it helps address the issue of build that BMI totally misses.

1

u/dr_nostrand May 14 '12

You are right that the BMI has terrible pitfalls but your criticisms are off point. Someone with a BMI of 35 who is not obese would have considerable muscle mass and therefore would not be considered skinny. Thus, the BMI is useless for determining muscle to fat ratio, resulting in people with large amounts of muscle mass and low body fat as being labeled by the BMI as overweight or obese. However for the average, non-athlete, a BMI is a generally an accepted method of determining appropriate weight.

4

u/monkat May 14 '12

People think that fat people are generous? I tend to assume the opposite.

1

u/[deleted] May 15 '12 edited May 16 '12

Get your own fucking bread sticks ya filthy bitch

3

u/pig-newton May 14 '12

I just love how everyone on this thread is agreeing with perception that fat people are lazy and undisciplined while none (that I've seen) have made any mention of the characteristics associated with the skinnier woman. Are they all vain bitches?

6

u/bjorn_hammerhock May 14 '12

Looks about right.

3

u/santanabanana May 14 '12

The larger body still looks perfect..

2

u/FUCITADEL May 14 '12

So it's one of those damned if you do, damned if you don't kind of things

1

u/formation May 14 '12

TBH that fat lady's body is EXTREMELY unattractive. I would rather sleep with a twink.

2

u/apriloneil May 15 '12

Um. Good for you?

1

u/CodeandOptics May 14 '12

FSM save us if the statists ever learn to redistribute fat.

1

u/grinr May 15 '12

Sounds about right.

1

u/smiddereens May 15 '12

Man, women just hate each other.

-1

u/adamwizzy May 14 '12

Sorry, but with me it's left: bangable; right: not bangable. Who actually thinks these things?

1

u/tankfox May 14 '12

I'd hit the one on the right first. Never forget that everyone is here because someone decided to get busy with their moms. The body types that nobody wants to bang tend not to be prevalent (guts on the outside, cyclops, putrid natural odor, seven legs).

If nobody ever got horned up over fat people there wouldn't be any fat people no matter how much pizza humans eat.

→ More replies (4)

0

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

1

u/MustardMcguff May 14 '12

I was interested to see if there was any original fat-shaming on this thread, or the standard douchey Reddit fair. You guys have disappointed me with your lack of creatively being assholes.

-13

u/calonord May 14 '12

fat is ugly, its true

it's also preventable, so it is justified to ridicule

14

u/papabusche May 14 '12

"justified" he says.

I'm not sure making someone else's business your business is ever justified.

→ More replies (24)

8

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

How old are you? This sounds like the mentality of my 7 year old niece.

0

u/calonord May 14 '12

you have the mentality of a carebear, go jump in a affected kindness lake and never come out

7

u/supersnuffy May 14 '12

Ridicule? So you think that making fun of somebody else because of their body type is completely justified? :/

1

u/calonord May 14 '12

yea, actually it helped me lose a lot of weight and get fit

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

fat is ugly, its true

What about people who think that overweight women are attractive? A better statement would be "most people think fat people are ugly, it's true". Beauty is entirely subjective. Fat is unhealthy, that's true. But it isn't inherently ugly.

Also, being fat doesn't make you a bad person. Making fun of people for things that do not influence you in the slightest makes you a bad person. People do not have to be pretty for you. If someone is comfortable with their lifestyle and it is not an impediment to your life, just let them be. That's like saying that it's okay to ridicule people with crooked teeth. Because, after all, they can get braces, and it is unattractive.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/RikF May 14 '12

Of course, beauty is subjective, and to suggest anything else would be ignorant. You aren't ignorant, are you? I mean, if you were ignorant, which is preventable, ridiculing you would be justified...

→ More replies (9)

-1

u/Web3d May 14 '12

As a fat person, yeah, you're right.

0

u/Silvercumulus May 14 '12

So is being an asshole, but you choose to be. Therefore you deserve ridicule.

→ More replies (1)

-14

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

How could you assume that someone is undisciplined just because she can't stop herself from shoving food down her gullet? IT'S GENETICKS GUIZE

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

the case for me was that I was too damned lazy and ate fast food all the time. Started cooking for myself and exercising and lost 65 pounds and I'm a normal healthy weight now. It's especially difficult for me to feel sympathetic, being as I have said no to sweets and junk food a TON in favor of healthier options... Sorry most fat people - its because you eat too much unhealthy stuff.

2

u/MrsReznor May 15 '12

Your experience is your experience. Not everyone becomes overweight simply because they aren't making healthy choices. I really doubt that most overweight and obese people got that way entirely by their own fault. That's not to say that there isn't personal accountability that should be addressed, but it often is a much more complex problem.

1

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

how often do you think it's a more complex problem? I would concede on 10 - 15% of cases tops (thats with zero education on the matter). But I feel like the all around eating habits and sedentary lifestyles should explain the vast majority.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/gabbagool May 15 '12

fuck glamour magazine!!!

even if the survey participants weren't readers of glamour magazine, fashion and "women's" magazines are among the most pernicious influences on women and their self image issues and commodification of beauty.

no shit sherlock, it's your fucking fault these stereotypes exist.

-5

u/bobbydigitalFTW May 14 '12

DAT LACK OF ASS

1

u/UltraJake May 14 '12

She's skinny, but I can't see her ribs or anything...

Where is the median supposed to be?

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I'd be okay with people stereotyping me as "confident".

0

u/willyolio May 14 '12

obviously guys didn't take part in this survey. it would be:

Left: hot

right: not

0

u/organicfunk May 14 '12

Fat and lazy do kind of go hand in hand...except for the rare occasion of an actual genetic disease.

-6

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I'm so sorry that I am genetically predisposed to want to mate with the most ideal reproductive candidate. Rail thin girls and overweight girls just don't fit that bill.

→ More replies (1)

-1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

It never ceases to amuse me how contrived the poses are to satisfy the prudes in some country.

→ More replies (1)

-1

u/EthicalReasoning May 14 '12

if women werent so fat these days they wouldnt loathe those who are in shape quite so much

-10

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

The one on the right is fucking disgusting.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/andiW May 14 '12

ya can't win.

0

u/Bohica69 May 16 '12

The fat one has to wash with a rag on a stick. Gag, vomit, convulse, pass out.

-1

u/pro_skub May 14 '12

The right hand side one must produce dolphin-sized turds

-7

u/conspiracy_thug May 14 '12

THEY FORGOT TO MENTION THAT THE BITCH ON THE RIGHT IS FAT.

-10

u/Bohica69 May 14 '12

The fat chick has a smile on her face because there is a 2-for-1 double special at Dominoe's Pizza currently running. It's like christmas all over again when they gave her a lifetime supply of snickers bars.

-11

u/InvalidWhistle May 14 '12

I do not understand this comparison, they both look overweight and out of shape.