r/pics • u/foureveraloan • May 14 '12
Leavin for Afghanistan tomorrow..I think I'm ready..
3
u/foureveraloan May 14 '12
i know ive been a redditor for a short while but ive known about the site for a while..i was always too lazy or didnt care enough to make one..but im glad i did..some of y'all are awesome. i appreciate the wishes and prayers.
13
u/Eifandil May 14 '12
Ahahaha, you're gonna use MAYBE half that shit.
(pro-tip: if your unit allows it, ship the shit you know you'll never use home early, so the plane ride back is relatively smooth.)
3
u/foureveraloan May 14 '12
thanks!
2
u/Eifandil May 14 '12
Yup. It's a bit spendy, but it's definitely worth it, and you don't have to keep track of your obscene amount of gear and other shit among a sea of other joe's shit.
2
1
3
3
u/Flinkgutt May 14 '12
May your time be incredibly boring and the moments of sheer terror be few..
1
65
May 14 '12
You won't need most of that.
10
2
u/JWang524 May 16 '12
This goes through my mind every time I see pics like these
But thank you for your service, and stay safe.
Edit: Formatting
1
May 14 '12
He will, plus ammo (about 210 5.56 rounds dependent on role) body armor (osprey body Armor in the UK, not sure what you yanks have) weighing around 13kg if i remember correctly. However a lot of his kit e.g the E.C.M (electronic counter measures) should only be used on patrol, however i could be talking out of my arse as i haven't been deployed for the past 9 years.
10
May 14 '12
I deployed 2010-2011 with a load similar to OP's. 75% of it stayed under my bed the entire deployment.
2
May 14 '12
What kind gear we talking about here? Hexi block stoves and the like or spare clothes? I never went to afghan so i wouldn't know what you need out there.
3
May 14 '12
The full cold weather gear kit (it's enormous), MOPP gear, spare clothes, things like that. Don't remember exactly what all was in there, but I had two full duffles of stuff I never touched. Doesn't help that you keep getting more stuff throughout the deployment, and thus have MORE to lug back on the way home.
EDIT - stuff that's irrelevant and/or unnecessary in that particular theatre.
1
u/rcordova May 15 '12
And you packed carefully to get all the shit out there, you had hardly any room, but then on the way back, your shit is tossed and you get rushed out of customs so you have to cram MORE stuff into the same space but without the luxury of careful packing.
0
92
u/vial May 14 '12
Stay safe dude.
-118
u/Danielcdo May 14 '12
I hope he dies
16
May 14 '12
get the fuck out of reddit.
-8
May 14 '12
Why? So your every opinion is right and you are allowed to stay here?
4
u/DeltaLambda May 14 '12
Learn grammar.
1
May 15 '12
Not everyone is native speaker of English. For a cunt like you coming from America, that comment is not surprising.
1
u/DeltaLambda May 15 '12
Also, you have your own oppinions. OKay, I'm fine with that.. But don't be an asshole about them.
15
2
-12
May 14 '12
HEY GUYS! THIS GUY DOESN'T LOVE THE TROOPS. GET HIM GUYS! YEAAAAAAAH!!! AMERICA!!!
12
May 14 '12
There's a difference between not agreeing with war and actively hoping someone dies.
-13
May 14 '12
You're part right. I would gladly wish death to men who create wars. Maybe not those poor retarded troops. Still though, it infuriates me that I am supposed to respect men that get paid to bring war to other men's homes. Fuck the US troops. Fuck 'em a million times.
2
May 14 '12
War totally sucks, but the troops do a lot more than just kill. They've also helped to build schools and improve infrastructure over there. Not saying we should still be over there, but it's not all as you suggest.
→ More replies (3)-11
u/bjurstrom May 14 '12
Go drink some draino you cunt. You have no reason to wish harm on another human. Especially a soldier.
12
u/kevv May 14 '12
You have no reason to wish harm on another human
Go drink some draino
Wut.
-4
u/bjurstrom May 14 '12
Yeah. Realized that made no sense after the fact.. I stand by the draino bit though.
3
-6
2
u/foureveraloan May 14 '12
look at you guys! i post a pic for a laugh or 2 and everyone jumps to conspiracies and other crazy sh*t..i dont post stuff because im just an average "lurker" i come to this site for a laugh every now and then.
3
May 14 '12
Dude, you're going to miss the D3 launch. You didn't think this through at all!
1
u/foureveraloan May 14 '12
i'll probably be downvoted to hell..but i've never played em D:
1
May 15 '12
o.O people actually DID downvote you, that ain't cool guys.
Stay safe in the 'ghan. Make sure you come home with your mates.
9
u/DustyFloor May 14 '12
Do not forget to take a toothbrush in your carry on or in your cargo pocket. You'll appreciate this advice.....it's a long flight.
2
7
u/hotsavoryaujus May 14 '12
Good job on getting the multicam. I thought they issued ACU, or have they finally learned the error of their ways?
5
u/HooeyPhooeyTexas May 14 '12
Multicam for those going to Afghanistan, ACUs for everyone else.
0
May 14 '12
We still use DPM over here in the UK, but I think it's being phased out for Multi-Terrain Pattern
3
u/candlejack303 May 14 '12
Good luck over there, I spent 12 months in that god forsaken hell hole. My advice, eyes open and look everywhere.
3
3
3
u/The70th May 15 '12
You don't have a tuff-box. Gotta have at least one tuff-box.
--- I was deployed to Afghanistan twice ---
5
u/outsider27 May 14 '12
Those bastards are hard hemp carpet or something. Rolling into one in your sleep dries up a wet dream. That was the army answer to the need for renovation: paint shit brown and put shitty carpet halfway up the walls
5
u/DoubleSuperBuzz May 14 '12
It makes me happy when I am reminded I will never have to use a wall locker again.
Be safe.
2
2
2
u/SgtMac02 May 14 '12
You're doing it all wrong dude. You have to balance out the load. You pack 4 duffle bags. One on the back, one on the front. Grab the other two by the handles, one in each hand. Now you're all balanced and ready to move out!
2
2
u/Desmondalque May 14 '12
Thank you for your service sir. I do hope however you do not end up with a hernia. To bad we dont have robots for that sort of thing. For carrying stuff, not causing hernias.
2
2
3
u/LiefKH May 14 '12
Prior to deployment: I packed a bag and put it in container to be shipped ahead of us.
I'm nearing the end of my deployment now. That bag? I never touched it and already put it in a container to be sent home.
The Army is fucking ridiculous.
2
1
3
u/Tol3ntino May 14 '12
I don't agree with the Afghan conflict but I wish you luck fellow human. Stay Safe
4
3
3
u/zushini May 14 '12
I don't really agree with the war in Iraq. But stay safe and keep your head about you. Don't forget your morals, and humanity. Shoot if you really have to. Don't loose yourself out there.
7
3
2
0
2
u/BarcodeNinja May 14 '12
What's up with all the military pics today?
Also, stay safe bro.
3
u/smokinJoeCalculus May 14 '12
Despite the fact that people routinely forget, we are at war right now. Maybe if people took the time to recognize that on a daily basis we could avoid the next one.
4
u/i_am_tetsuo May 14 '12
Nope. This is part of the ongoing effort by the US Army to cast the uniform in a positive light.
redditor for 2 months ... this is his only post ... ever.
2
u/smokinJoeCalculus May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Right.
Even if it is, I'd still rather people be reminded that we're sending men and women abroad to fight in a War. Whether this is propaganda or not, most citizens have been so disconnected from what is going on so it has been easier to keep it going.
4
u/BarcodeNinja May 14 '12
Speaking of a disconnect... why aren't we seeing photos on of veterans returning home missing limbs? There has been an influx of happy photos, and while I want ALL of our soldiers to return home in good mental and physical health, that is not reality.
All these photos have the stink of a calculated PR move.
1
u/Eifandil May 14 '12
A military man with a smart phone is his/her own qualified paparazzi.
2
1
u/smokinJoeCalculus May 14 '12
There have been..
And a lot of these are soldiers are going away, I don't think it'd be wise to send men/women with missing limbs to War.
I also don't really see where people are making this giant leap into it being a calculated PR move. Reddit is so incredibly huge where the vast majority of users are lurkers. It doesn't surprise me that a lot of people posting may only have one post.
I'm having a hard time finding it, but that one picture of soldiers being sent to Iraq in 2007, with one man's head in his hands - that alone has such a powerful portrayal of emotion... You really think that'd be good PR for our overseas conflicts?? Even this one, where in this picture do you see good PR? The fact that our soldiers are humans with real emotions and even a sense of humor?
However, I do agree, while I'm not sure if I necessarily want to see dead/injured/PTSD soldiers, the impact of the pain and suffering caused by War would help to silence the multitudes of tinfoil hat wearers as well as show what War is really about. I don't want to say whether it is right or wrong because that is my personal opinion and I don't find it apt to get all political in this comment thread, but if we don't want to repeat mistakes of the past, we need to display some method of learning and progressing.
Hiding or downvoting posts to oblivion because you don't agree with the War just further the complacency of people into thinking that a War doesn't really affect them so why should they care.
2
u/i_am_tetsuo May 14 '12
Right, thanks for being part of the counter-culture machine.
We need the knights of r/new to keep this crap off the front page but if you think about it we're literally fighting a war with out own military, one of the most expensive branches of our government ... we can't stop this barrage of propaganda so we need to use it to our advantage.
Every time someone posts one of these "conspiracy" pro-army threads we need people like you counter it with rational, well played quips about how much this war is costing us, what our agenda in the middle east really is and why this needless invasion was so unnecessary and continues to be so unpopular.
1
u/smokinJoeCalculus May 14 '12
I look at this picture and see a human being with a clever sense of humor. I don't want to get into whether I believe the War in Afghanistan is right or wrong because that's not the point of the pic.
However, I find it humanizes our soldiers and at least offers some method of connecting with them. I see no reason to downvote this picture, whether we're at War or not.
3
u/i_am_tetsuo May 14 '12
I see a carefully constructed campaign to undermine the hivemind's genuine distaste for this war, the people funding it and the soldiers on the ground doing the killing.
If you don't want to take this issue seriously fine ... but it isn't just ruining the world we live in, it's carefully and methodologically corrupting the naive yes-men / underachiever wing of the reddit's hivemind which has meaningful consequences long term.
ie: reddit sucks now, this is why.
0
u/smokinJoeCalculus May 14 '12
I see a carefully constructed campaign to undermine the hivemind's genuine distaste for this war, the people funding it and the soldiers on the ground doing the killing.
If you don't want to take this issue seriously fine ... but it isn't just ruining the world we live in, it's carefully and methodologically corrupting the naive yes-men / underachiever wing of the reddit's hivemind which has meaningful consequences long term.
I'll take it seriously when we actually have some solid proof. I don't like to make such leaps of judgment when there has been little to nothing to prove it possible. We still live in an organized society and should hold those that make such claims responsible when they have nothing to prove it so.
ie: reddit sucks now, this is why.
ohgreatthisthreadagain.jpeg
1
u/i_am_tetsuo May 14 '12
1
u/smokinJoeCalculus May 14 '12
I know. I've seen and read it, and it is far from enough proof to make such a blanket statement. Even the guardian article isn't proof that every single one of these posts on reddit are that.
Are people not allowed to make posts that may be War related if they don't have other comments/posts??
I also don't see how my opinion that it is a funny picture that contains little context of War still doesn't apply. My thoughts about the War the US is in right now may have evolved from the time we initially engaged in them but only when I would read facts from reputable news sources or talk with veterans who have been there.
If individual people are getting swayed by a humorous picture into believing that what is going on abroad is good then we have a larger problem with our society than a fairly long-standing tradition of propaganda.
Don't get in the way of me enjoying a funny picture because of a fairly unsubstantial claim on a behemoth content aggregating website. You created your account two days ago, but I don't use that to speak down to you and your abilities to understand what is allowed here or not. If you don't like the content, downvote + hide. And for the love of god, don't form too much of an opinion based on something we have little to no extra information about.
2
May 14 '12
I'd still rather people be reminded that we're sending men and women abroad to fight in a War.
Another redditor fails to recognize that /r/pics isn't /r/OnlyAmericansGoHere
Let's get real here, the only thing that comes of this is, either you are a true red blooded American and support kids signing up to join militaries (a terrible waste of time and money if you ask me) or you are a disrespectful dickwad that doesn't understand how some kid joining the military, fighting in Afghanistan is defending your freedom of speech.
1
u/smokinJoeCalculus May 14 '12
Apologies, I do forget that international folks do come visit Reddit. A heavy majority of users are US Citizens (I'm assuming you aren't Canadian, since they are also technically Americans), so I hope you can understand my mistake.
However, whether it's a picture of a US Soldier, Canadian Soldier, Polish Soldier, French, Iraqi, Chinese, etc.. They are all human beings and deserve to be treated as such when the context displays them doing things that any human being would do.
There are some things I support and some things I don't support about the US' War effort, but unless it requires it, I don't try to force a political discussion into a picture of some kid being funny as you essentially have with your last phrase there.
My point is that if people are aware that their Nations' soldiers are fellow citizens with the same hopes, desires and emotions, it becomes more difficult to disconnect yourself and let those men and women be sent off into certain danger. It is one of the method of creating a more responsible populous in regards to War.
1
u/JamesTrivettesHat May 14 '12
I wish we didn't have to send people away to war.
1
u/smokinJoeCalculus May 14 '12
Right. But the point is that when you create a connection based on emotions with these soldiers, it becomes more difficult to do so. That the justifications are a lot more specific and tested.
1
2
u/i_am_tetsuo May 14 '12
Redditor for two months ... this is in his only post.
Thanks for doing our government's dirty work!
You may not be the 1% but you're certainly their errand boy.
Seriously though, don't come back in a body bag!
1
1
u/wolfie1010 May 15 '12
What's in your head that makes you think going to fight over there makes sense?
1
1
u/Jester814 May 16 '12
And shit like this is why I'm permanently disabled with a back injury from the US Army. No hard feelings though. I'd still be in if I could, and if my back ever miraculously gets healed, I'll be going right back in.
1
1
u/coyleh May 18 '12
Say hi to my sister! Shes been serving there for the past 7 Months as a Marine. And everyone is right, you won't need most of that.
1
u/aanalogbrother May 21 '12
You'll be a shitty baby killer and corpse pisser over there if you can't even carry your gear. Sheesh. Way to let the terrorists win...
0
1
u/pusangani May 14 '12
Why you want to go to Afghanistan, they don't want you people in their country
0
0
u/clonn May 14 '12
Don't forget you're occupying a foreign country. That use to piss off local people.
1
1
1
-2
u/Geezer_Spud May 14 '12
Be safe and thank you
3
u/MK_Ultrex May 14 '12
Thank you for what?
-4
u/qtprot May 14 '12
His service.
3
u/MK_Ultrex May 14 '12
And why is it worthy of gratitude exactly?
3
u/Gauthaman May 14 '12
Although I disagree with the american invasions of iraq and afghanistan, i don't think this is the best place to actually have a rational discussion on the topic(r/pics).
0
May 14 '12
[deleted]
5
u/MK_Ultrex May 14 '12
Why don't I have any decency? I did not comment either positively or negatively. I am just curious about the mindset that makes Americans thankful towards something that doesn't affect them in the least. Where I am from flag waving is frowned upon. Ergo I am curious of the apparently unwarranted and atavistic national pride.
→ More replies (2)-3
u/Geezer_Spud May 14 '12
I'm thanking him for putting his life in harms way for this great country you live in regardless you clearly are a peice ofshit who was no respect
3
u/qtprot May 14 '12
So I'm the piece of shit with no respect? I'm the one respecting him meanwhile the other guy isn't.
-1
u/Geezer_Spud May 14 '12
Replied to wrong person I'm on iPod it was meant for the douche bag mk ultrex
2
u/Johnjohngoose May 14 '12
How does him killing Afghans protect America?
0
u/Geezer_Spud May 14 '12
hes killing terrorist groups like the Taliban and Al Qaeda who were part of 9/11 which killed thousands of US citizens and if we don't stop them and eliminate them and their leaders it will happen again. This great man is putting his life in danger for a cause he believes in, I believe, and America believes in.
0
0
u/holdenmode May 14 '12
Seabee/HM? Good luck there and don't lose your soul. Shitcan 4/5 of that gear, though. Sub Vet opposed to the war.
0
May 14 '12
[deleted]
2
May 14 '12
Wow dude, you're a dick. Let me guess, your a vet of the 101st Keyboard Commandos? Terrible war, the Great War of Twinkies was.
0
u/Piotr555 May 14 '12
I'm leaving later sometime this week. I have a 3 bag minimum. It's a blessing and a curse.
Stay safe man! See you on reddit once I'm down there :P
0
0
-3
May 14 '12
You don't have to go there and bring war to those people. You can make the choice not to.
But if you choose to participate in this war anyway, then I hope you did hundreds of hours of research into the conflict to determine whether or not it is a just war, and that you came to the conclusion that it is.
0
u/Tyrsyn May 14 '12
In all seriousness, STFU
0
May 14 '12
In all seriousness, no. I won't stand silent while war mongers congratulate each other.
1
u/Tyrsyn May 14 '12
"Blah blah blah, self righteous bull shit, blah blah blah." You done yet?
-1
u/Johnjohngoose May 14 '12
"blah blah kill rape plunder invade"
1
u/Tyrsyn May 15 '12
You could have said something like "be safe" instead you go on this rant about how the war is wrong and you can not go. Yes he could not go but then he is a deserter of war. That makes him a criminal. Then you go on to complain about warmongers. People like you only have the right to bitch and complain because of the people who protect us. I spent a year in Iraq and hated every moment of it. Do I think that we went there for the right reasons? Maybe not. However, I stepped up when people like you wont/can't/are to afraid to. This is what he is doing he is fighting for his country, and if he believes in the cause or not he HAS to do it because he signed the paper saying he would.
TL:DR Take your hippie, self righteous, sensitive attitude and kindly shove it up your ass.
-9
u/pussyclamp May 14 '12
You disgust me.
7
u/foureveraloan May 14 '12
your name is pussyclamp. you disgust me.
-4
u/pussyclamp May 14 '12
Does it offend you as much as what this man is about to do?
7
u/foureveraloan May 14 '12
that man is me. and i am going to do what i can i get home. i'm not a bad person, i just want to see my family again.
7
May 14 '12
You don't have to leave your family in the first place. I don't really understand that string of reasoning. What you do is not necessary.
Good luck, though and stay safe anyways.
0
u/pussyclamp May 14 '12
Why would you enlist? You obviously have the resources to understand the purpose of our military involvement.
1
u/SgtFish May 14 '12
For many people, joining the military is the most economical investment they can make for a higher education, among other things.
It's also pretty underhanded of you to associate our government's moral ambiguities to the people who volunteer their service, especially when the agenda and acceptance of our military isn't as clear-cut as something like the Nazi regime.
6
May 14 '12
How about instead of succumbing to such a military regime you start opposing it so that it's possible for young men to make a decent living without being pressed into such service?
Your first argument is ridiculous on so many levels.
It's also pretty underhanded of you to associate our government's moral ambiguities to the people who volunteer their service
WIthout people enforcing it (=the soldiers) the "government's moral ambiguities" would be completely irrelevant. The soldiers are what enables this behaviour.
especially when the agenda and acceptance of our military isn't as clear-cut as something like the Nazi regime.
Godwin doesn't give your point any more validity. That comparison was as irrelevant as throwing a snowball at the sun.
-1
u/SgtFish May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
... start opposing it so that it's possible for young men to make a decent living without being pressed into such service?
This has nothing to currently do with when somebody is in a position where they need to join the military for financial reasons. Having people not have to join the military is fine, but if somebody is currently at a point in their life where joining our military is something that would potentially be of high benefit to them, I don't see why that would make them an asshole.
I only point out the Nazi party in preparation/because of all the stupid arguments that come up about the trials of those Nazi soldiers. I've seen plenty of (more than likely non-propaganda) evidence of some good on our part, so it would seem that we do hold some moral ground within the military (and therefore that it would be possible for someone to join with the ambition of morality).
4
May 14 '12
but if somebody is currently at a point in their life where joining our military is something that would potentially be of high benefit to them, I don't see why that would make them an asshole.
The ends justify the means. I see.
Sorry, I have nothing further to say to you if that's your opinion on what constitutes an excuse.
This has nothing to currently do with when somebody is in a position where they need to join the military for financial reasons.
Of course it does. You can choose to act against the system and thereby prevent yourself and others to be forced into it... or you act in its favour.
0
u/SgtFish May 14 '12
You can choose to act against the system ...
You keep maintaining this standpoint that our military is like some 100% evil force. Yes, it may have many grey areas, and joining it may not be the most morally righteous thing to do, but like I've pointed out, it is in fact not a pure force of evil, and nor do people have to live by some absurd and idealistic code of honor.
→ More replies (0)
-1
0
-1
-1
u/GueroCabron May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Good luck!
Stay safe!
Getting downvotes, assumably from the anti-war crowd? or the people who Don't want him to have luck or stay safe.
-4
0
u/n2srv2 May 14 '12
Thank you for your service to our country. Good luck and be safe. Tell us how your doing when you can. Thanks again for all you do.
0
0
-2
u/RomeoTango May 14 '12
OPSEC....
3
u/foureveraloan May 14 '12
i've seen worse
1
u/RomeoTango May 14 '12
Yeah, when I was in Egypt the Unit I had the pleasure of serving under saw no problems posting troop movement times, bus size, number of occupants along with names and SSN in the hallway... Oh yeah and this was a civilian hotel with guests walking freely on all levels. I was not impressed with my army that day.
-7
0
May 14 '12
[deleted]
6
u/redworm May 14 '12
Be that as it may, how would we feel about that same person going if images of their sacrifice were used to try to manipulate how we thought about the military?
Upvoting because even though I doubt that this the government's doing, it's an interesting discussion and should be researched further. Having shown that to someone in public affairs, the laughter was biblical.
Most people seem to think the current wars are "wrong", but that the people who go are making a noble sacrifice to safeguard our freedom.
I would change that to lives rather than freedom. There's a solid debate to be had on whether our presence over there aids the intelligence community in rooting out potential terrorist attacks (at least more than we inspire) but I don't think even the most jingoist fox news viewer can seriously claim that our freedom has ever been at stake.
It really bothers me that national security has been confused with freedom. I'm not blaming you for using that word, I've caught myself doing it as a result of how the national discourse has treated the word over the past decade.
0
May 14 '12
[deleted]
0
u/redworm May 14 '12
I wasn't speaking from a production quality point of view but the idea that the military would bother with something like this is laughable. They don't care - or have to care - what people on reddit think of the military. If they want to do something like this it'll happen on twitter or facebook or televised media. Reddit isn't significant on the radar regardless of the claimed reader base.
Like I said, there's a solid debate to be had on that matter (which answers the question regarding how operations there may or may not be protecting lives). There are numerous intelligence gathering operations that would not have been possible without a direct occupation of the relevant region while there are also numerous intelligence gathering operations that would not have been necessary had said occupation not angered the local populace.
It's certainly not a simple answer, I just think that even people who think the war/invasion/occupation is justified recognize that the only thing potentially at risk is lives rather than freedom.
0
May 14 '12
[deleted]
0
u/redworm May 14 '12
They wouldn't be foolish not to. Public affairs doesn't have to care about a specific demographic (and I don't think reddit is distinct from others, there are too many varied opinions here for any to be truly representative of the site) if they've already got all the approval they need from the majority of the population.
It's a conspiracy theory like all the others. A couple of unexplained quirks does not a conspiracy make. It's a little silly thinking they'd waste their time on this.
0
May 14 '12
[deleted]
-9
May 14 '12
Please stop with this shit. People who join the military in this day and age aren't doing anything worth respecting, regardless of their motives.
1
u/rustyplastic May 14 '12
I see where you are coming from and shall try and Offer a different view. While the armies of western countries have done little of late to directly influence the freedom that we have in our homes, as a whole they have done a great deal of good in second and third world countries. Let alone that should a country be attacked wrongfully and diplomatic relations allow it, armies of the world will be there to defend the helpless, the weak or those who cannot stand to the force that may be invading.
0
May 14 '12
[deleted]
11
May 14 '12
I'm sorry you've lost friends and family members for bullshit euphemisms about patriotism and freedom.
8
u/Eyeless_Sid May 14 '12
Maybe the people you lost were in the past wars that were wars actually protecting our freedoms and well being. Lately the wars are on invisible men and things like terror or drugs or what have you and they are not able to be won. They are wars of conquest and imperialism not protection of the free world. People in these recent wars have the option to go to war or not to because they are not real wars that need to be fought. Sorry to say but if your loved ones died in the current wars than they died in vain.
2
1
May 14 '12
Your dead relatives bring a smile to my face :). I hope more of them die soon, you fucking nationalist cunt.
1
u/rustyplastic May 14 '12
While I in no way agree with what 77_65_65_64 said, how dare you say "keep your opinions to yourself". You directly disrespect all those who stepped up and put their lives on the line for him to have the same and equal right you do, the freedom to state your opinion.
0
13
May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/HooeyPhooeyTexas May 14 '12
I may be able to provide partial insight, I've been to Iraq and Afghanistan. The question is, did the op volunteer or is it just his units turn to deploy and didn't have a say. I didn't volunteer for either of my deployments. Was I happy to go, not necessarily, but I made a commitment when I signed up. If the Army wanted me to go to Iraq and Afghanistan then that's what I would do. I was raised to honor all my commitments and to do the best that I could, which is what I did. I would never, ever ask someone to support the wars but I will ask them to support our troops. It was not our troops decision to invade Iraq or Afghanistan but they are the ones making the sacrifice. These are just my opinions and I hope it gives you just a little bit of a different perspective.
3
1
u/DBuckFactory May 14 '12
I think what discodiablo is saying is that this person probably chose to join the military while the wars were going on. We know that the soldiers didn't choose the war, but soldiers sign up with a risk of fighting them. If you sign up during a time when we are in a war, it's likely that you'll be deployed to fight that war at some time. So, yes, they are making a sacrifice, but, if they joined after the war began, it was wholly their decision to make said sacrifice.
Also, I want to point out that I don't think I should have to respect everybody that's ever been in the military. Some of those guys are complete assholes that use their training to hurt others. Respect will be earned when it is shown that you deserve it, no matter what career path you've chosen.
I am just offering some possible clarification on his comment mixed with my opinions. I absolutely support the troops and hope nobody has to kill or be killed out there any longer.
1
u/HooeyPhooeyTexas May 14 '12
I suppose I should clarify what I meant by supporting the troops. My idea of supporting them is not talking ill of them or being disrespectful towards them i.e. you're dumb for being in the military, I hope you get injured over there, how do you like killing babies?(actually said to me in an airport), just general things like that. You don't have to buy bumper stickers, donate to military charities, put signs in your yard or profess your support on facebook. I guess what I'm saying is no support is still support and it's better than anti-support, if that makes sense.
I also agree that respect should be earned, but it's different for me because I know what the military is from the inside therefore it's easier to respect my fellow members. I can see how it would be more difficult to have that respect if you were on the outside looking in. I dislike 75% of the people in the military because they are ignorant, looking for attention or glory seeking, kinda like why I don't like 75% of the people on reddit.
I can also agree with you on the joining during a time of war piece to a point. Many people join now because the benefits are just too good to pass up depending on their socioeconomic standing. When the military began hurting for soldiers they lowered standards and increased benefits. These benefits outweighed the cons of having to be deployed. The sacrifice portion will always be a matter of contention. I'm in the National Guard and sometimes when I look at my deployments I feel as though I made a sacrifice and other times I think that is was my job and I knew it might happen.
TL:DR I completely understand your points and I enjoy having a meaningful discussion on reddit that doesn't turn into name calling.
1
u/DBuckFactory May 14 '12
I don't think people should be dicks to military. I have a good friend of mine that I respect very much who used to serve in the marines. (Once a marine, always a marine, so I don't want to say ex-marine and blah I have no idea how to put it.) I don't respect him because he was in the military, I respect him because he's respectful, helpful, and an all around good guy.
I think that a lot of people don't put much weight on the risks and just want the rewards. There are a lot of great benefits that I wish I could've taken. I just didn't want to have to go to war or give up 4 years of my life. My socioeconomic standing wasn't even middle class growing up, so I know how that is. In the end, it's still a choice to accept the risk and I will hope that nothing bad happens. Some people just like to rub it in everyone's face or hold it over peoples' heads to try and get something out of them. It's great that you did that, but the fact that I chose to live my life differently doesn't mean one of us is better than the other.
TL;DR I love veal chops, but I'd rather go with a good old steak some days.
7
u/SgtMac02 May 14 '12
We don't get to choose not to go and not to support any particular military effort. If we sign up, then we go where they tell us to go...period. You comment makes it sound like you think a soldier can simply say "I don't like this war. I'm going to sit this one out and wait for a better one." Or are you making the case that people should only join the military during wartime, during a war that they actively support, and then get out of the military once that war is done?
3
u/DBuckFactory May 14 '12
I've said this above, but I figured that I would give the perspective again:
I think what discodiablo is saying is that this person probably chose to join the military while the wars were going on. We know that the soldiers didn't choose the war, but soldiers sign up with a risk of fighting them. If you sign up during a time when we are in a war, it's likely that you'll be deployed to fight that war at some time. So, yes, they are making a sacrifice, but, if they joined after the war began, it was wholly their decision to make said sacrifice.
Also, I want to point out that I don't think I should have to respect everybody that's ever been in the military. Some of those guys are complete assholes that use their training to hurt others. Respect will be earned when it is shown that you deserve it, no matter what career path you've chosen.
I am just offering some possible clarification on his comment mixed with my opinions. I absolutely support the troops and hope nobody has to kill or be killed out there any longer.
4
u/SgtMac02 May 14 '12
I agree with you completely. Personally, I signed up as an 18 year old kid in 1996. I could never have fathomed what wars I might be required to fight in. Yes, if you enlist during wartime, you should expect to be a part of that war.
And yes, there are a LOT of people in the military that don't deserve a lick of respect. I'm with you on that point too.
Honestly, most of the people who are in the military don't even really put much consideration into the political ramifications of their service. It's sad, but the reasons many of us are in, basically makes us mercenaries. Many of us (I obviously don't speak for everyone) do it because we need the financial help that the military provides. I've got great insurance (even as a reservist), an extra paycheck every month outside of my regular job, it opens up doors for me that would have otherwise been inaccessible. I wouldn't have the job I have now if it weren't for the Army. Oh, and let's not forget all that sweet college money!
0
u/DBuckFactory May 14 '12
Oh, I absolutely understand the pros of the job. I thought about it long and hard when I was getting to be that age, but I just couldn't push myself into that kind of life.
I ended up having to work while going to college to pay for my own way. I got on scholarship that helped on tuition. Graduated and have a job, but I currently have no insurance to speak of other than for my car. Having those extra military benefits are no doubt nice, but I didn't want to risk my life or take that of anyone else.
Thanks for the chat!
1
u/SgtMac02 May 14 '12
It really is a sad state of affairs that one of my primary reasons for staying in right now is for the health insurance. My entire family of 4 is covered with excellent coverage for about $185/month. On top of that, my civilian employer has a policy that any employee who is eligible for Tricare (the military insurance) can get the company to pay for our coverage. It's cheaper for them to pay my portion of tricare than to pay their portion of the regular company policy. So...I get great insurance for my whole family...absolutely free*!
*Free...if you don't factor in the costs of actually having to serve in the Army.
1
u/DBuckFactory May 14 '12
That is pretty freaking awesome. Next year, I'll be able to take advantage of my fiance's plan, but I want to just get the fuck out of my current job and get into something that I want to do as a career. But, I also want to get my MBA, so I'm not sure of what I should do in the mean time. It's frustrating trying to figure out what I should do first or how I am going to afford anything and make life work. GOOD TIMES!
1
May 16 '12
I agree with you on the respect issue. I've met a lot of scumbag troops (and pretend troops) that leech off of the real heroes and use it to their advantage.
Respect the 'deed' of the troops as a whole being generally a force for good - but as far as the individual goes... well, I'll never 'ask' for your respect.
1
May 14 '12
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/SgtMac02 May 14 '12
You don't get to sit it out and wait for another one. If you choose not to obey the orders given, and not go to war, you don't get to stay in and "wait for a better one. It's called desertion:
Maximum punishment.
(1) Completed or attempted desertion with intent to avoid hazardous duty or to shirk important service. Dishonorable discharge, forfeiture of all pay and allowances, and confinement for 5 years.
(2) Other cases of completed or attempted desertion.
... (a) Terminated by apprehension. Dishonorable discharge, forfeiture of all pay and allowances, and confinement for 3 years.
... (b) Terminated otherwise. Dishonorable discharge, forfeiture of all pay and allowances, and confinement for 2 years.
(3) In time of war. Death or such other punishment as a court-martial may direct.
Note that last one...
Also, dishonorable discharges don't hold quite the same weight that they used to. But it can still hamper your ability to find jobs if you're looking for work in any sort of governmental capacity. This includes working for civilian organizations with ties to government contracts, especially if a security clearance is involved. My current civilian employer works on a lot of military contracts for training and requires security clearance. I wouldn't be able to work here had I chosen desertion.
1
May 15 '12
A college degree being a primary goal of mine since I was very young, I went because I wasn't born into a rich enough family to pay for my college, but wasn't poor enough for financial aid. Having thousands and thousands of dollars in loan repayments for the next decade didn't sound appealing. Also, I wasn't responsible enough to take care of school.
I wanted the VA home loan, and to really separate myself from my family and friends in my accomplishments, to have done something that noone could ever take away.
I wanted to develop leadership skills, I wanted to challenge myself. I wanted to see if I could become a Marine.
I believed in the efforts in Iraq and Afghanistan, and I was educated and up to date on current events. Though patriotism and feelings about these wars weren't my primary motivations, they were factors. I knew many people disagreed with the troops, disagreed with the wars. I know how people spat on the troops after Vietnam, and the best way that I could show my solidarity with the heroic victims (I consider the troops as the victims, they were drafted and those who weren't saved some draftee the spot in line) was by joining into the brotherhood. Something real, as opposed to a paid group of rich kids in the form of a fraternity.
For me it was a building block - providing a crucial piece in the structure of the man that I wanted to be. That's a pretty good summary of why I risked what I risked.
-5
u/RomeoTango May 14 '12
You don't go because you want to, you just do what you're told out of respect for the nation. You take it on faith that the good people of this country will not needlessly throw away your life; you do your duty when called.
→ More replies (3)
30
u/outsider27 May 14 '12
those shitty walls look like ft. riley. Enjoy the time over, keep safe, hooah.