85
u/webby_mc_webberson May 12 '12
The cost of maintaining a swimming pool per hotel room would be prohibitive. I love that word; 'prohibitive'.
18
May 13 '12
hmmmm what about a central filtration and water unit servicing multiple units?
Water is filtered and cleaned in one central pool(maybe roof top) and water is gravity fed to each individual level. If engineered properly the major costs would only be chemicals and hydro necessary to pump water from pools up to central pool.
12
May 13 '12
Depends on the height of the building. From what I remember from physics, pumping anything up more than a few stories starts getting difficult (expensive) fast. Granted they pump concrete up skyscrapers (with some difficulty), but on a continuous basis for long periods of time... I can only guess the cost would be quite high.
7
May 13 '12
To be honest though, if you have these types of pools in a hotel, the hotel is definitely going to be expensive. Most likely easily covering the costs of pumping water up the floors.
5
u/Jonyb222 May 13 '12
How about an Archimedes' screw? you have a small holding pool at every floor so that it's less stress than 1 big one
5
May 13 '12
Can't make one vertical, I imagine some sort of chain elevator would be more effective from a space requirement but I don't know about operating cost.
→ More replies (3)2
u/toomanycarrots May 13 '12
That's right. Holding it high is problematic too. Heard that a 10meter water filled straw would break a barrel at the bottom due to hydrostatic pressure.
2
u/43214321 May 13 '12
These problems have all already been solved for making the faucets run in skyscrapers. They have mechanical floors every once in a while instead of residential floors with all the pumps needed and whatnot. Similarly, there are plenty of hotels with pools in the room if you pay a high rate, or jacuzzis in the room (for more reasonable rates). The OPs picture could be implemented with standard designs used for those.
1
u/bb9496 May 13 '12
not necessarily because there could be small holding tanks at each level, with pumps that only go from one floor to the other thus only needing enough pressure to go up one floor at a time.
6
May 13 '12
...heh heh...I like the idea of peeing in my pool, and it going to multiple units...
This is why they won't let me have anything nice...or sharp.
3
u/EmmKay May 13 '12
I've stayed in a hotel in Jamaica that had pools, little mini ones, on every balcony. It was pricey, not hugely though. So, they exist already.
3
1
1
u/JWN6513 May 13 '12
so all the people on floors 1 and 2 get water that is a majority of urine. yeah that works. but i suppose that if you get someone like trump or the UAE that can spend gobs of money then anything is possible.
1
1
u/thegreatmunizzle May 13 '12
Someone shits in 1 pool you have to shut down all of them.
2
u/Namaha May 13 '12
I'm not sure you understand what filtration is
1
u/thegreatmunizzle May 13 '12
I sell swimming pools for a living.
A shit-contaminated central pool would have to be shut down and super-chlorinated for over a day. This means no other pools are getting water. The initial infested pool would require the same thing.
Gravity drained would not work as it would be enough pressure to provide popular circulation to the swimming pool and keep it clean. Every pool needs it's own pump, so there is no point in having 1 central pump, as every pool needs it's own pump anyways.
3
u/toomanycarrots May 13 '12
Not to mention the weight issue... A cantilever pool as such would require quite a deep beam for support. Very nice idea though.
1
u/thecatosborne May 13 '12
Exactly. Imagine dumping a couple of full size automobiles on each slab edge and that's essentially what you've got. Engineering nightmare.
1
u/suchandsuch May 13 '12
You could invest in lots of those little sucker fishes that clean your aquarium perhaps.
51
u/Bl33p May 13 '12
Hey look a suicide balcony for $200 a night! :D
32
u/adrianmonk May 13 '12
Your comment was pretty funny. Not because suicide is funny, but because... $200 per night? Hahahaha, more like $2000/night.
2
u/SmuggleCats May 13 '12
Well if you're killing yourself anyway money won't be an issue, so it works out.
58
u/ThatGuyRememberMe May 13 '12
If you were floating on your back near the edge and someone cannon balled, you would probably fly off the side.
12
31
u/johnriven May 12 '12
Nope.
3
u/tacosandcheese May 13 '12
14
1
u/SpaizKadett May 13 '12
You don't deserve the downvotes! I laughed and I had never seen that animation before
12
29
u/exLearner May 12 '12
Place a tube filled with water at the end so you can swim up and down levels easily.
139
May 12 '12
...? But physics?
93
u/webby_mc_webberson May 12 '12
Not in this thread, bub.
5
u/CocoSavege May 13 '12
This comment is proof that I can only read a comment with 'bub' in it a la Wolverine.
Snikt.
0
19
May 13 '12
Have double doors that control pressure between the tube and the pools. Swim into the lock, the door closes behind you, then the other door opens.
I doubt anyone would ever do this given safety concerns and having to rely on mechanical doors.
23
u/American_Pig May 13 '12
The instant pressure changes are going to rupture some eardrums.
45
3
May 13 '12
Oh yeah, the boxes on the top of the doors are pumps. Forgot to mention that. Not sure what speed they would need to pump at the prevent damages. Also not sure if it's possible for them to take too long before someone runs out of breath.
→ More replies (2)13
u/honus324 May 13 '12
Ignoring the physics issues... I doubt the hotel would keep that system active after the first person drowns trying to swim to another level and going through two pressure locks before running out of breath
2
May 13 '12
Yeah, I was more thinking about the physics and engineering and less so the practicality of it.
3
u/honus324 May 13 '12
I get that. The first thing I thought when I saw your picture was that there was no margin of error for the person swimming between levels.
3
→ More replies (8)1
8
9
u/SimonAdebisi May 13 '12
I hope for a future when a week goes by on Reddit that I don't see this pic reposted.
5
2
u/rmg88888888 May 13 '12
silly architect, physics is for engineers
Honestly, I really don't know how the metal frame and glass would be able to hold that water as depicted.
2
May 13 '12
the words "catastrophic failure" come to mind
1
2
u/chicagogam May 13 '12
there could be a dead body in one and people 10 feet away would be blissfully unaware..i guess that's a feature and not a flaw..
3
6
4
3
u/xcforlife May 12 '12
Don't walk below unless you want to be in the splash zone. Hopefully they have some sort of catcher below to conserve water.
22
3
2
2
2
u/Zeag May 13 '12
In case it's not obvious: This is a concept, not a real hotel. As evidenced by the nice windows-less buildings in the background.
2
u/mealasvegas May 13 '12
"Hey kids, look, we have a pool on the deck!"
"Mom, watch! It looks like I'm going to jump!-slip-"
"WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY?"
Yeah, fuck no, I got a panic attack by looking at this mock up.
2
u/28_06_42_12 May 13 '12
All an assassin would need to do would be to break a single panel, and all the swimmers would be sucked out off the ledge!
2
u/beefybear May 13 '12
Hitman Blood Money anyone?
2
u/Lord_Bradford May 13 '12
I prefer my hotels in the Hitman games to have random ghost murder mysteries, thank-you very much!
1
u/beefybear May 13 '12
Hey I know you! ;)
3
u/Lord_Bradford May 13 '12
I know, right? I had +friended you from before because you seemed like a pretty chill dude, so your orange name now stands out in the comments for me to e-stalk. Unless you're talking about some other Lord_Bradford I have no idea about.
2
u/beefybear May 13 '12
Nope, I friended you too gaybro!
1
u/Lord_Bradford May 13 '12
It's like you know me (and the subreddits I go on) or something. Interesting.
2
u/beefybear May 13 '12
Well naturally I had to reddit stalk you. And you get the beefybear seal of approval as an awesomebro.
→ More replies (3)
2
u/jokes_on_you May 12 '12
Mumbai has some of the most ridiculous buildings I've ever seen. This hotel is gorgeous.
http://www.mymodernmet.com/profiles/blogs/james-law-wadhwa-group-aquaria-grande-pool-balcony
2
1
u/TheFluxIsThis May 13 '12
Holy crap. I did not actually think that this was an actual thing. >_>
6
u/MonkeeSage May 13 '12
It's not, those are design renderings (look at the "buildings" in the background).
2
u/TheFluxIsThis May 13 '12
That's what I thought when I saw the first image. There's something about the object symmetry that doesn't seem right to me.
-1
May 13 '12
TIL Mumbai is beautiful.
5
u/neilsdeal May 13 '12
Not really; there is plenty of interesting and beautiful architecture, but as a whole there are some pretty intense slums and not a whole lot of vegetation. Not to mention the miles (literally) of poop trucks that line the roads outside of Mumbai because of their terrible plumbing.
1
1
u/justdoitok May 13 '12
I believe the last time this was posted someone provided proof that this was a concept rendering and not an actual real life place, and there were some engineering hurdles that would have made the actual execution of this design impossible or very difficult
1
1
1
May 13 '12
You realize this also leads to the inevitable future where some jackass tries to jump in and overshoots.
1
1
u/kleptobismol May 13 '12
kind of a waste of space... the walk room on the balcony is non-existent, you could even lay out and tan if you wanted to.... Also the shape, while cool looking , isn't optimized for space. A rectangular balcony would provide a lot of square footage.. Neat picture though, looks like a SIM . ..
1
1
1
1
1
u/deathtone May 13 '12
are you crazy? that's scary as shit, fall over the edge and plummet 45 stories down.
1
1
u/sicinfit May 13 '12
That's a fuck load of water pressure for so little enjoyment.
Enjoy your trip to the 1st floor.
1
1
1
1
u/wolfchimneyrock May 13 '12
as an architect I am marvelling at all of the super costly elements and gestures in that computer rendering, dare I say its flamboyantly expensive
1
u/canarding May 13 '12
how are you supposed to meet the pretty ladies at the community pool if they have their own??
1
u/Yaymemes May 13 '12
Btw, this is a hotel in Dubai and these "awesome" hotels use most of the country/city's water.
1
1
u/windowzombie May 13 '12
I know I'd manage to smash one of those glass panels somehow, and take a water slide ride to my doom.
1
1
1
1
May 13 '12
That's a pretty big cantilever that has to support all the water as well as occupant loads. Cool concept though.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Grazfather May 13 '12
That looks awesome but I would be too afraid to use it. If one of the wall sections broke you'd shoot out.
1
u/MagicMert May 13 '12
Either make the glass around it a couple foot higher or let some of the water out or screw that I know ill swim over the edge
1
u/Spades54 May 13 '12
Yeah, I was about to say, the water won't be completely still 100% of the time, and considering the water lines up with the brim of the wall, the spillage would have to be dealt with.
1
May 13 '12
Am I the only one who is afraid of swimming in such a pool? This is the way I will die. I know it.
1
1
1
u/singularityneuromanc May 13 '12
I'd totally tie my ankle to a door handle or something so that if the wall broke, and I was flushed over the edge, it would save me.
1
1
u/markth_wi May 13 '12
I don't want to go the way my goldfish did when I was a kid. Have a tank panel break and get flushed out the side of my hotelroom.
1
1
u/halfkidding May 13 '12
I agree. There should be a guy in a banana hammock in every hotel pool. Glad I'm not the only sane one in this world.
1
u/thecatosborne May 13 '12
Nice rendering, but the glass panels would have to be really think to be sufficient (expensive)!, and then you'd still need a rail around it to meet code.
1
1
1
1
u/erkose May 12 '12
Let's face it, these will end up being mosquito breeding ponds.
6
May 13 '12
Mosquito Larva are killed of easily by pool chemicals...
Also mosquitoes wouldn't really be able to get to these pools too easily. Mosquitoes prefer shaded and sheltered from wind areas, they are very weak fliers and tend to be blown where the wind takes them if they don't stick to these rules.
0
May 12 '12
[deleted]
2
u/Gigglestheclown May 13 '12
You do realize this is just cgi right? Look at the low polygon trees on the very bottom.
1
1
1
u/Chicago63 May 13 '12
Heck no, I'd only think about stepping near one of those things is if the glass went all the way up and made sort of a wall around the pool. That thing just looks plain dangerous
1
May 13 '12
Yeah, but when you put your genitals against the water jet for orgasm, everyone will see you.
1
1
1
u/Scheckschy May 13 '12
Yeah, but only pretty people are allowed to stay there. Fattys are still at Motel 6.
1
u/pavedwalden May 13 '12
Suppose the glass cracks or a panel pops out. Imagine scrambling to get a hold of something as the sudden rush of water sweeps you out over the edge.
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
u/ASmellyFrostTroll May 13 '12
This may possibly be the most unsafe pool idea ever. Just put up some tall, sturdy railings on the edges and then fuck yeah, put them in every hotel in the world!
0
0
0
0
u/kingofbigmac May 13 '12
Here in Vegas there is a hotel with something like that. I think its at the Palm. They have a tall wall so people can't float over the side to their death.
0
u/ShitBabyPiss May 13 '12
And you are the one with the dude on the lower part of the pic, lubing your asshole for him to pound. ಠ_ಠ Douchebag.
-2
-5
0
0
May 12 '12
[deleted]
11
u/webby_mc_webberson May 12 '12
Have you ever had sex in a swimming pool? It's not as awesome as it looks on TV. The water adds way too much resistance for a satisfactory thrust.
4
May 13 '12
That and the water wisks away the natural lubrication you both create.
→ More replies (4)1
277
u/tragopanic 🍿 May 12 '12
Seems dangerous.