r/pics • u/justincase1021 • May 09 '12
More parents need to do this!!!
http://imgur.com/xyP5K348
u/imontopofit May 09 '12
191
201
u/Yunlokzi May 09 '12
I wish I could read what his sign is saying. :(
→ More replies (12)477
u/Pastpremonition May 09 '12
"Hi, I'm 13 years old. I steal. I want to go to prison to be with daddy!!"
→ More replies (3)324
61
u/dividezero May 09 '12
That is a badass grandma taking charge when the parents fail. Awesome. Love the look on her face and the ice tea. She's in it for the long haul.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (19)49
u/wthulhu May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
>!!!!!i'm 12(?) yrs old. i steal i want to go to prison to be with daddy!!
thats kind of a low blow, really.
→ More replies (3)136
u/IDKFA_IDDQD May 09 '12
As a former juvenile prosecutor, this is the type of parenting that we need. Prevents the need for juvi courts altogether. Consequences and repercussions, muthafucka.
→ More replies (16)
2.0k
u/Slexx May 09 '12
I like how she's crying.
What is wrong with me?
581
u/aakaakaak May 09 '12
Parents: Powered by the tears of children
→ More replies (5)84
u/HawaiianBrian May 09 '12
No no, you're thinking of the city in Monsters, Inc.
→ More replies (1)125
1.2k
u/allisondojean May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Oh man. I thought she was grinning at first. Realizing that she's crying makes this picture so much more satisfying.
Regardless, A++++ parenting, should reproduce again.
EDIT: Oh fun, I don't think I've ever had to do one of these! I feel the need to clarify on a couple of points that were brought up in the replies so apologies for the novella ahead.
First of all, no I do not have kids, but I have worked one-on-one with children professionally for the last 7 years. I have been a babysitter, a tutor, an au pair, a volunteer, and a nanny. I have worked with boys and girls, toddlers and teenagers, privilleged and at-risk, suburbs and inner city. I have had an incredible relationship with every child I've worked with, but especially those aged 8-15. I am very sensitive to the pressures and emotions these kids deal with on a daily basis without the maturity to put it all into perspective.
That said, I find all of the "public humiliation" replies to be a bit far-fetched. It's not like they made her drink a handle while they filmed it for youtube. It's akin to being grounded or having your phone taken away.
Maybe the word "satisfying" was a little much on my part. A little later in the thread, citizen059 puts it really well: "Speaking as a parent, it's satisfying to know that a step you take to correct a child's behavior is hitting home with them. Crying is one of these signals - if she was like 'yeah, whatever' then it's unlikely a lesson would be learned."
The 2 y/o I watch was not happy today when I wouldn't let her walk home or even let her buckle herself into the stroller, or that we went home instead of to the park. But she needs to know that if I let her walk by herself, she cannot let go of my hand and bold off towards the street. Even though there was no real harm as I would never let her wander beyond what I call "grab range", and even though she is still too young to fully understand the potential consequences of her actions, for the rest of the day she kept talking about how you have to "stay with (allisondojean)" when you're walking and if not, "go in stroller, cry".
As a young teenager, this girl is starting to test her boundaries, establish some control, and question authority. I say bravo to the parents for handling a situation in a way that shows compassion and humor, and is straight to the point as far as that behavior is concerned. If anything, the funniness/satisfaction comes from a mix of totally relating to how unjust this girl is SURE her parents are being (as we all had that phase, and mine was a doozy) and knowing now that sometimes making a kid hate you for an hour is a small (and often daily) price to pay to make sure your kid grows up with a good head on their shoulders.
→ More replies (44)481
770
May 09 '12
I got a kick out of it, too.
166
u/Genius4Hire May 09 '12
I always wondered what powered reddit, now I know its the tears of regretful rapscallions.
→ More replies (7)→ More replies (40)453
453
u/citizen059 May 09 '12
Speaking as a parent, it's satisfying to know that a step you take to correct a child's behavior is hitting home with them. Crying is one of these signals - if she was like "yeah, whatever" then it's unlikely a lesson would be learned.
My son (age 7) cries, for example, if I ban him from playing video games for X amount of time. Part of me hates the fact that he's crying, but at the same time part of me is satisfied because he's learning that I won't accept whatever behavior led me to the punishment.
279
u/ckmhill May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
im not sure thats entirely true, kids are clever little bastards, i seem to remember using the crying technique to get my parents to ease up and calm down with me alot of the time.
→ More replies (27)105
u/citizen059 May 09 '12
That much can be true - I learned how to manipulate my parents as I was growing up and I'm sure he'll have his ways eventually.
But for right now, it's still pretty easy to tell when it's genuine and when he's faking it.
→ More replies (31)→ More replies (58)5
u/Mystery_Hours May 09 '12
As a parent, would you ever post a shameful/embarrassing picture of your child on the internet to teach them a lesson?
→ More replies (1)195
u/Time_Loop May 09 '12
After looking through this thread, is there anyone else who doesn't like that she's crying? This thread in a meme.
→ More replies (28)56
409
u/IAmTheWhiteDevil May 09 '12
I don't like how she is crying. I LOVE how she is crying.
→ More replies (137)119
u/SaltyBabe May 09 '12
It's funny because really, who is going to cry over not using "social media" (facebook) other than a teenager...
→ More replies (88)7
u/funfungiguy May 09 '12
I actually felt a little sad at her crying. I mean, she shouldn't be posting boozery pics if she's not old enough to engage in boozery, but the crying made me wonder what lead to the moment this pic was taken.
→ More replies (3)53
u/SonicFlash01 May 09 '12
The suffering of children is the sweetest nectar.
Watching their happy asses get slapped around by the same life we all trudged through, getting broken down dust.Their mistake was being shameless.
Someday I will teach my children shame and pride from an early age.
"I wanna wear sweat pants!"
"Don't. You'll look like an asshole"
"...Okay... :<"→ More replies (37)22
u/throwaway-o May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Nothing's "wrong" with you per se.
You live immersed in a sadistic culture of pervasive abuse, where physical violence, psychological manipulation and humiliation, are seen as righteous ways to treat other human beings. Where prison rape is a joke. Where yelling at people, and humiliating people, are de facto normalized behaviors. Where the victims of these perversions are, more often than not, children (though brown foreigners are also made to endure the same horrors, just to a higher degree). And where the abuse happens behind closed doors (be it in the household, or a foreign war).
You like that she's crying, because you have been incorrectly taught -- against your better judgement and your human empathy -- to believe that her suffering is good and virtuous, that the perpetrator is acting righteously and honorably, and that she will become a good person as a result of her misery. You like that she's crying because, in all probability, you too were a victim of this type of treatment, so seeing someone else undergo the same injustice, generates pleasure in you.
You live in a world where "do as I say, or else" is the default.
Unlearning that... is going to take massive effort. It's hard to live in such a world, because being the only one sane person surrounded by individuals mentally disturbed to various degrees by aggression... is just fucking hard.
→ More replies (5)23
u/KevinCharles May 09 '12
By far the best part of the picture.
Also, apparently something catching.
→ More replies (2)13
May 09 '12
Wait, you like how she is crying, or that she is crying? Is there a certain kind of crying that just does it for you?
→ More replies (95)7
279
u/somecrazybroad May 09 '12
The girl is/was stupid, but nothing ensures the teenage and young adult years filled with hiding, sneaking and secrecy than publically humiliating the kid. You want open lines of communication, this is exactly the opposite of what you should do.
77
u/rljacobson May 09 '12
How else can we publicly display our domination of our children? </sarcasm> The parenting ethics of reddit are mysterious to me. Your comment seems utterly obvious to me, yet I'm being downvoted and called names for point it out. But hey, that's the internet.
→ More replies (7)46
u/Korbie13 May 09 '12
I'm disappointed I had to scroll this far down to find a comment like this.
→ More replies (1)37
u/nolog May 09 '12
Exactly. Breaking the child's self-confidence is not really productive.
Want to do stupid things? Fine, we'll destroy your social life.
→ More replies (4)27
u/Trapped_in_Runescape May 09 '12
And yet the top rated comments are reveling in the fact that she appears to be crying.
I hope those redditors never have kids.
13
→ More replies (89)23
u/SuperSpaceExplorer May 09 '12
I am very happy to see this. The idea that anyone thinks this is a good idea shows a lack of understanding about how people (kids included) work. This will just lead to secrecy and resentment.
I mean, imagine if somebody did this to you. How would you respond? People do not respond well to subjugation and humiliation. It is dehumanizing. Nothing leads to rebellion quicker than feeling dehumanized.
49
May 09 '12
Reminds me of the 4chan post where the parents wanted to sell their kid's Bayblades on eBay after they ruined their tub.
→ More replies (24)
133
u/etihw2 May 09 '12
Humiliation is a terrible form of parenting. I'm all open to new ideas but the least you could do is let your child learn a lesson without her friends laughing at this in the future.
Reddit needs to stop hopping on bandwagons like this.
→ More replies (11)
439
u/IAMANaquariumdrinker May 09 '12
I'm not sure how I feel about public humiliation, especially in THIS public of a sense. Why not just take away the internet/computer?
35
u/BoogerPresley May 09 '12
I really wonder about the effectiveness of these solutions; most of the time it seems like there's a judgment + moral scolding component to 'em. If my parents publicly humiliated me like this when I was a kid, I would have trusted them a lot less and would've been drawn closer to the kids who were bad influences on me who weren't trying to publicly humiliate me in front of my friends. It also seems that the primary driver for underage binge drinking is the stigma that it's considered something "only for adults", and doing something like this just makes it seem that much more like a tempting forbidden fruit.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (26)178
May 09 '12
Because the kid thought they were showing off to their friends about how badass they were. Don't look very badass now, do you? Then again, I think that people who get caught stealing should have to stand at busy intersections wearing sandwich boards that say I GOT CAUGHT STEALING (insert merch here and hope it's something truly humiliating)!!!!!!
→ More replies (49)41
u/dmsheldon87 May 09 '12
There was part of an episode of "This American Life" about how ineffective that punishment actually is. Listen to it here. Bonus: Joss Whedon does act three.
→ More replies (2)
696
u/ArizonasFinest May 09 '12
Gonna go against reddit hive mind here, and prepare myself for downvotes. But I don't think this was a good idea really, to post this up where her friends could see this. The parents could have merely done something that did not involve public embarrassment.
I mean if this kid went to my school (even though she looks way too young to go to my school or anything) she would get torn to pieces by friends making fun of her. Things could easily escalate and have her retaliate against people who may bully her because of this.
I don't think it is a good idea to publicly embarrass your child like that especially in front of an audience that would know her quite well. It reminds me of the guy who shot his daughter's laptop. Yes it more than likely taught her a lesson, but I'm sure it was extremely embarrassing for her and may have cost her some of her dignity.
Things which involve emotions should never really be put up on social networking sites.
239
u/Bluebraid May 09 '12
Humiliating your child is a terrible punishment.
First of all, if the parent wants to make sure she doesn't put something on the Internet so that it doesn't come back to haunt her later in life, this is more than a little counterproductive. Look, she's already on the front page of Reddit in a compromising situation. How is that doing her any good?
Second, if I were this kid, from this day forward I would do everything in my power to make sure my parents never find out about anything I do. I would never trust them again and I would never forgive them.
Third, social lives matter. Our friends and connections have a huge effect on our success in life. Sabotaging the way your child's friends and acquaintances perceive him or her is an easy to way to limit his or her chances of both of short- and long-term happiness.
Fourth, this will have a similar effect on how she sees herself. Squashing her confidence and self-esteem is obviously a bad idea.
→ More replies (8)66
u/kangtea May 09 '12
I agree entirely with you. At this age or younger, although she may have been doing illegal things, social interaction is what pretty much constructs us for adult life. This kind of punishment is aimed at directly subverting that and honestly seems tactless.
I am shocked at how the majority comments overlook how this could so easily lead to bullying.
313
u/Jeepersca May 09 '12
I agree, public shaming of a child teaches nothing useful, and creates a bigger divide between parent and child. She did something stupid, now you punish her by publicly shaming her? That can do far more damage than good.
→ More replies (13)117
u/skillet42 May 09 '12
I see it as the internet equivalent of getting yelled at in the yard when your friends are over, then you have to be the one that says "You have to go home now because I'm in trouble".
I had to do that when I got too mouthy when my friends were over. Its very embarassing, but not every embarassment is a horrible emotional scar on a fragile psyche.
→ More replies (18)81
u/SphericalArc May 09 '12
I absolutely agree. The parents clearly don't realize the consequences of embarrassing their daughter over social media, yet they berate her for being the one not ready to use it.
Yes, the daughter clearly did something unacceptable by the parents' standards and should be punished for it; but by embarrassing her in such a way, she's in for a lot more punishment among her peers as well, which just isn't fair to her.
→ More replies (12)39
May 09 '12
Agreed. As recently as last week I would have disagreed, but my wife argued successfully against it. The gist of her argument was that, while satisfying, the punishment is kind of childish and not something we would want the child to do to someone else.
Therefore, a good talking-to and removal of privileges, without public shaming, is probably a better response.
That said, the shaming is probably better than no response. Parenting - you're probably doing it wrong, but you're doing it better than people that aren't doing it at all.
→ More replies (2)72
u/modex20 May 09 '12
I agree. Punish your child if he/she needs punishment. But don't humiliate them.
Also fuck reddit and its circlejerk hivemind.
→ More replies (16)13
May 09 '12
Indeed. The vultures in this thread laughing at a girl who received an excessive punishment for a minor infraction make me embarrassed to visit this community. This thread shows precisely how fucking moronic and immature a lot of redditors are.
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (53)18
May 09 '12
I completely agree, you are Arizona's finest. I agree with what you said too. Regarding the guy who shot his daughter's laptop. I think she ended up running away, and she said her relationship with her father was over.
→ More replies (2)
52
u/Batrok May 09 '12
Why would you shame your child?
I'd never do that to either of my kids. I'd certainly address it, and they would surely get banned from social media for some period of time... but I see no reason why I would want to shame my child in front of her peers.
→ More replies (3)
65
May 09 '12
Publicly shaming your child? That just shows how little power you have left over your own daughter, because you need the power of public shame (not your own). Sure, it works for now.. but it's a fast track to losing your daughter.
127
u/kingblackacid May 09 '12
no. they should not. public humiliation is no way to teach someone, especially a teenager (i'm assuming).
she's not going to understand that this action is coming from a place of worry about future actions. she's not going to get that it comes from a position of love. all she is going to remember is the sting of embarrassment and the start of trust issues.
parenting, doing it wrong.
33
May 09 '12
If you hit a child to gain obedience, the child learns that hitting is used to get what you want.
If you use social media mock your child to get what you want, they learn that belittling and mocking gets what you want. Is she being punished for posting alcoholic pictures? Is she being punished for drinking? The actions are blurring the parenting moment.
17
u/delightedwhen May 09 '12
Yup, you're changing the immediate behavior, but what are you really teaching? You're not modeling respect, so I doubt you're teaching it.
→ More replies (7)21
u/delightedwhen May 09 '12
1000X agreed. As a way to change her behavior, the public humiliation method is viable. But it's not a good way to teach her why what she did was wrong, respect (teach it by showing it maybe?), or maturity (same).
If my parents took a picture of me crying and distributed it, I guarantee you the lesson I would've learned would not have been about drinking.
155
u/delightedwhen May 09 '12
Humiliating your kid publicly isn't good parenting.
The girl was stupid, but there are other ways to handle the situation.
→ More replies (7)3
May 09 '12
But, I like to shame people in front of millions in a public fora.
On an unrelated note, DAE hate bullies?
367
u/slowly_turning_sad May 09 '12
The ignorance of some kids... "herp derp im going to post ILLEGAL STUFF TO A VERY, VERY PUBLIC WEBSITE LA DEE DA DEE"
C'mon man I'm only 18 and that seems stupid as shit
112
u/w3sticles May 09 '12
Sorry for being unfamilliar with (i'm assuming) American laws, but is it completely Illegal for everyone under 21 to even drink?
I'm pretty sure that here in Britain, It's all good as long as it's on private property.
→ More replies (43)57
u/slowly_turning_sad May 09 '12
You can drink in the confines of your house, with parental permission, but the consumption and purchase of alcohol is illegal anywhere else, under 21.
→ More replies (42)356
u/whimmy_millionaire May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
I know how reddit is bashing her for posting illegal stuff, but what's the difference between what she did and /r/trees ?
211
u/slowly_turning_sad May 09 '12
I don't have 500+ friends who all have access to my reddit account.
→ More replies (7)463
u/pleasingbaritone May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Parent: I saw you on r/trees. What are you doing on there?!?
Kid: What are you doing on there?!?
Suddenly family game night isn't shitty, and that's the difference.
Edit: I repeated repeated a word.
→ More replies (15)39
→ More replies (43)29
u/billbaggins May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Reddit is an anonymous global site. Other countries where trees are legal do come to reddit so not everybody is breaking the law.
This is a minor on a non anonymous site who I'm assuming is from a country where they are below age.
Edit: Ambiguous Gender.
→ More replies (9)→ More replies (23)9
u/etihw2 May 09 '12
I'm only 18
This doesn't mean anything because you should have common sense in your head by the time you're 18.
→ More replies (3)
96
u/hiccupstix May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
This is horrible fucking parenting. Do parents not realize that nothing on the internet goes away, and anything you post can be used against your kids later on when they're seeking to establish themselves professionally? You should be taking down any pics of him/her holding liquor, and tell them how idiotic they're being -- don't just post more ammunition to be used against them and exacerbate the problem.
22
u/stompanie May 09 '12
...nothing on the internet goes away...
...should be taking down any pics of him/her holding liquor...
wat
→ More replies (4)
166
u/albionlegend May 09 '12
Publicly embarrassing and bullying your child is not what I'd call good parenting.
→ More replies (9)8
May 09 '12
I'm not a parent, but generally I'm a fan of the ridicule in private, praise in public approach to "management". There is no need to embarrass your child in front of all of her friends.
62
May 09 '12
You Americans need to chill out a little. In Europe/UK it's quite normal to start drinking at 16 and we're no more/less fucked up than you guys!
14
u/macusual May 09 '12
That's what I was thinking. I grew up in Brussels, and drinking laws there are not very well enforced which meant we could easily buy alcohol at the age of 13. Most people I can think of grew up to be very responsible people.
4
u/Digestive May 09 '12
It's legal to buy alcohol at 16, but many kids start before that. At least in here in Denmark.
→ More replies (6)25
May 09 '12
Understood, but it is a crime here. No parent wants their child to be a criminal.
→ More replies (22)
29
48
55
42
u/fai714 May 09 '12
Seems a tad cruel, didn't have to take a picture of the girl crying, if she had just posted what it said instead of a pic, that would have been enough. Idk why you need to publicly embarrass your kid in order to get your point across.
→ More replies (12)24
u/kangtea May 09 '12
I honestly agree with your comment, I'm surprised at how supported this post is...
→ More replies (1)
26
u/luvmesumtrees May 09 '12
I like how the parents seem to be much more concerned with the fact that she posted it to a social media site rather than the fact that she was drinking in the first place.
→ More replies (3)
4
May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
I hate seeing bratty kids in public, especially at my job. I had an 11 year old girl call me an idiot last week. I walked away. Mom just sat there and said nothing. Because she didn't speak english. Yes, I'm the idiot because I don't speak spanish.
17
u/wild_bill70 May 09 '12
Our daughter threw her lunch away and told the lunch lady she forgot her lunch so she could have a hot lunch.
We made her write an apology to her teacher and the lunch lady. She will be working off the $1.95 as well.
She is in First Grade.
Got a thank you from the lunch lady today for making her apologize.
→ More replies (2)
134
u/the-nub May 09 '12
A lot of people are posting things like, "It reminds me of THIS awesome parenting!" and then a link to something completely disproportionate gets posted, like a kid getting beat for acting like a gangster or that girl's laptop being shot up by her dad. No, those aren't examples of good parenting; those are knee-jerk, overly-violent reaction from authority figures who are just as immature as the person they're punishing.
This is good parenting because it gives solid consequences to an action which is both illegal and immature.
47
u/diaperedpupp May 09 '12
I never saw the laptop shooting as overly dangerous, of course I live in the same area as the man. It was sure as hell over the top though. I respect peoples opinion on the matter but definitely disagree with the hive mind on that.
→ More replies (3)33
u/MyWifesBusty May 09 '12
It wasn't particularly dangerous, no. Definitely crazy over the top and very wasteful.
→ More replies (13)→ More replies (7)46
u/Mystery_Hours May 09 '12
Is public shaming really something that should be in the toolkit of a good parent?
→ More replies (26)
7
May 09 '12
I strongly disagree. Humiliation is a fine form of punishment when it is natural. Forcing someone to do something humiliating is stupid. Yea, they might not do what you don't want them to do anymore (in this case, take pictures with liquor in her hands), but it won't be for the right reasons. They will simply avoid the pictures not to be humiliated. It's not even a form of respect-- it's a form of fear, and respect and fear are two entirely different things.
66
u/jbenz May 09 '12
It's nice that you can also see the lower half of her face conveying her absolute anguish about this situation.
3
0
6
u/that_cad May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
To all the people who think this is a terrible idea and terrible parenting, I have to ask: what effective alternative do you propose? Now, I am not saying you are wrong, per se, I seriously just want to know what you think would be a viable means of preventing behavior that could (a) get your child in serious trouble (e.g., arrested) and (b) hurt. As far as we know, this is not the first time this girl has done this, and perhaps the parents have tried other, less controversial means of remedying the situation. Perhaps they're at the end of their rope. What then? What do you do if you've tried other options and they haven't worked?
Edit: forgot a.
→ More replies (2)3
u/darkwave90 May 09 '12
The legal age for drinking where I'm from is 18, which means that everyone starts drinking at 16-17. It's easy to get alchool in convenience stores, even without a fake ID (Every minor knows a store near their house who sells alchool and cigarettes to them)... My parents were always cool and open about soft drugs and alchool during my teen years, so I developed a link of trust and I knew I didn't have to lie or hide when I wanted to drink or smoke weed. In a few weeks, I'm graduating from college. I'm in a steady relationship, I'm not taking any drugs, my alchool consumption is very reasonable and I never drink and drive. Heck, I don't even smoke cigarettes. Teens do stupid things, with or without alchool. Sometimes, it's better to make your experiences at an early age to be a responsible adult. It's impossible to shield your child from everything and every trouble he or she might get into. I personally think that this form of public humiliation could lead to a low self-esteem, which could actually be the cause of alchoolism and drug addiction.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/Jeepersca May 09 '12
I guess based on the fact that the punishment is identical to the crime, i.e. posting what should be embarrassing photos, I can't help but note that "shaming" a child publicly reflects poorly on the parent, too.
So you publicly humiliate your kid to teach them a lesson? I'm not even a fan of kids, but I know there's considerable research on the topic, and generally shaming kids in this fashion is more likely than not going to create more problems than it solves.
3
May 09 '12
this, but with duck faces.
if and when I have a daughter and if and when she does a duck face on any social network, she will have to wear this for 48 hours.
it may seem harsh but she will thank me when she grows up.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/NonchalantSavant May 09 '12
My favorite aspect is that her sign is spelled perfectly.
I'll bet her parents had a lot to do with that as well.
3
3
3
u/Tmbrwn May 09 '12
All you whiteknights getting on your high-horse about under-age drinking need to get a grip. I assume this is in the US which is even worse as 21 is a ridiculous drinking age.
Fact of the matter: the more liberal you are with something, the less likely it will be misused by teenagers. Keeping it away will only cause more desire.
→ More replies (2)
3
May 09 '12
this generation is no more fucked up than the previous.. well maybe it is but there is nothing that a bit of smart parenting can't solve..
3
u/Newmans_Own May 09 '12
No, more parents need to explain to their children what is appropriate for social networking sites, including the gravity posts can have on college admissions and job applications, and then let them make their own decision.
Or simply use the privacy features...
3
3
5
5
May 09 '12
Stopping social media usage == good parenting move.
Public humiliation of your child == crap parenting move.
17
u/rantberries May 09 '12
No one has fully addressed the fact that the kid was most likely punished because she was compromising herself: posting a very public picture of herself posing with liquor could compromise her later. Her mother gave her very real consequences which also let her feel some of the effects that injudicious use of social media could have. It was done in a controlled environment, and very straightforwardly.
I don't think the mother was bullying her child or anything of the sort. I think that she was trying to impress upon her daughter that there are appropriate and inappropriate uses of social media. Sure it was embarrassing, but how embarrassing would it be for a prospective employer to see that stuff? Also, as kids, when weren't you embarrassed to get punished? I mean, if you really did something stupid, and your parents caught you, and meted out some kind of discipline, how in hell were you not embarrassed about it at some point?
→ More replies (7)6
May 09 '12
She punished her for publicly displaying she underage drinks... by publicly displaying that she publicly displays herself underage drinking........
12
May 09 '12
Until you realize that kids should be drinking at 16 so that their parents can teach them how to drink in home, with supervision, and not with fellow idiots kids. They also won't have this excitement for booze anymore, and it won't be the "cool" thing to pose in pictures holding alcohol containers.
→ More replies (24)
32
May 09 '12
I'm sure that won't do any psychological damage. Mom, good luck when it's your time to go to the nursing home.
(And, no, I do not think irreparably humiliating your child in public and among all their peers while producing a permanent document of it on the internet is "good parenting".)
→ More replies (20)
12
u/liquidstate May 09 '12
I'm thinking that these people on here that advocate public shaming are the successful result of such a thing.
My parents would do similar things and I was always so embarrassed when my friends and especially my family found out the things that I did, that I decided that I didn't want to give my parents a reason to expose that kind of stuff, which made me stop.
This is why I advocate doing something like this, a bit differently than this post's example, but the goal is to embarrass the child and make them feel ashamed so that they won't do it again. I'm all for the idea, and I think the way that all of you respond to this depends a lot on how your parents raised you.
Just my $.02
→ More replies (11)
4
u/OneWhoHenpecksGiants May 09 '12
In my opinion, this is no different than when a parent forces their child to go into a store and give back merchandise they have stolen.
One day, I saw a child (8-9) being dragged around a store being told to apologize to everyone because he had decided to go missing and hide from his mother. She freaked out and the whole store was looking for him and when he confessed he had just been hiding from her, he got to take the walk of shame around the store apologizing to each and every employee that had to take time away from working to look for him.
I think it teaches children to be aware of how they are perceived.
12
u/elmexdela May 09 '12
Teach them while they're young that flaunting about drinking really isn't all that cool.
→ More replies (1)
10
May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Good job! You may have just taught your kid to hate you.
→ More replies (3)
2
May 09 '12
Many parents don't post pictures of themselves boozing it up, especially if their kids are around, in the first place.
2
May 09 '12
As someone english, I really do not understand why this is such a big deal. Can authorities actually use this in a form of prosecution? I've never heard of anyone over here getting into trouble for having pictures online.
→ More replies (2)
2
u/Jorgeen May 09 '12
I'm against parenting like this. Seriously, parents act like they were angels until the legal age. My mom always knew when I went drinking, she just called me at some point of the party, asked me how I was and where I am (exact address as well, just incase something happens) and never made a big deal out of it.
2
u/Direlion May 09 '12
I like how the parents prove they themselves are ready for parenting by posting a picture of their crying and defeated child on the internet.
2
2
2
u/danyquinn May 09 '12
More parents need to understand that their children are humans who aren't deliberately fucking up. I did all sorts of dumb shit while I myelinated, and my parents never felt the need to publically humiliate or dehumanize me. Never humiliate your kids. Never. And stop acting like they're being dumb just to hurt you.
2
u/MasterSplinters May 09 '12
I'm kind of embarrassed that a lot of you seem think this is good parenting are are relishing in the fact that this kid is so humiliated. Do you truly believe that such a public display of degrading your child is good parenting?
2
2
u/mindctrlpankak May 09 '12
Nah man. you just get your kid so drunk they throw up, then they wont do either.
2
u/cross-slash May 09 '12
Do they, really? I find this shit quite ridiculous. With that said, if she's crying over this than she is also ridiculous. BAH! (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻
2
u/wanderso24 Survey 2016 May 09 '12
This is a bit more reasonable than the dad who shot the girl's laptop after her angsty facebook post.
2
u/alucard4269 May 09 '12
'Omg, my parents took away facebook, I'm gonna die with out it!' Whenever my parents did that I just shrugged and did the same thing I did everyday (read a book, play videogames, hang out with friends, etc). Zero fucks were given.
2
2
u/Todomanna May 09 '12
Fuck you and your multiple exclamation marks. Your parents should take away your ability to post on reddit until you learn to use them sparingly.
2
May 09 '12
What I want to know is how this had 10k down votes. Maybe lots of redditors like annoying facebook girl's antics?
2
u/Galfritius May 09 '12
Embarrassment is one of the most effective and humane punishments for teenagers. Stop acting like they beat the kid.
2
u/Swainler2x4 May 09 '12
The point is if I was a teenager I would delete Facebook until it blew over before I'd give my parents access to it. That's opening up way too many avenues for humiliation.
2
u/rogurt May 09 '12
I support this punishment. I have a feeling this child won't end up on a stripper pole.
2
2
2
u/tailOfTheWhale May 09 '12
I feel like people need to take a step back from this, posting pictures of drinking on facebook does not equal end of the world no job ever your the biggest fuck up, especially when you can de activate your facebook in times of seeking employment. Maybe it was just the attitude my dad took towards drinking but most highschool kids will drink and I feel its better if parents just understand that so the kid isnt afraid to call for a ride home when they have been drinking to get home safe. When I was in highschool the people who got hurt the most from drinking were the ones doing something to avoid getting caught by their parents. And when in college I can always tell who hasnt been around alcohol in highschool because they are out of control and do not know how to drink.
2
u/beyerch May 09 '12
?!?!?!? What ?!?!?!?
Ummmmmmm 'Until i learn what i shouldn't post'? What about the fact that she SHOULDN'T have alcohol at all at her age.
WTF?
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/rxninja May 09 '12
Hey, all of you folks saying that public humiliation is bad parenting: Go look up "reintegrative shaming." Use Google Scholar to find the best stuff (Braithwaite and Sherman are good authors to start with).
As long as the punishment is part of a reintegrative process (in this case, learning what you should and shouldn't post to social media sites), this kind of parenting can be very effective at reducing future instances of delinquent behavior.
2
u/thatassholeyouknow May 09 '12
Parents unto you I decree, should you make your children cry for the right reasons, grow in strength and resolve for you are paving their path to a brighter future.
2
2
2
u/FunkiPorcini May 09 '12
My oldest is 14 and doesn't have a Social media account...anywhere! Kids are stupid & vicious so I don't think it's appropriate.
2
May 09 '12
I'm a high schooler and I really wish more people did this because all I see is drunk pictures. I wonder how a parent will feel if they saw a picture of their 16 year old drunk daughter swinging a belt over here head in the bathtub.
On the other hand, I saw a girls album where the mom commented "Great pictures honey!" The album was just party pictures of her in her underwear running around drunk. The mom was just happy her daughter is having fun.
Also, you would be surprised how many parents are fine with drinking and readily provide alcohol to their kids for a party.
2
2
2
u/Uraeus May 09 '12
I wonder if she is under 16 ~ I believe the drinking age/limit in America is a joke.
→ More replies (3)
2
2
2
u/Arrrreeee May 09 '12
I just got banned from srs for saying that only 14 year old girls would think that this is an inappropriate punishment for flaunting liquor bottles on fb.
Getting banned from srs for saying something they don't like: further proof they're a bunch of 14 year old girls. And I'm not popular enough to join their clique :(
2
u/Longerhin May 09 '12
Oh no, she was holding liquor? That's so irresponsible for a teenage girl, she should be studying for a test instead.
2
May 09 '12
Excellent. Now if we can only get the parents of the guys who flex till they crap themselves to show off their "six packs" we can make Facebook a better place.
2
u/CalliopesSong May 09 '12
My parents used to beat the ever-loving shit out of me... I can't tell which of these two methods I find most effective...
Also, after I read that sign, I scrolled back up again just to make sure that her mouth was in fact in a grimace.
2
u/dookieface May 09 '12
reminds me of that video where that dad belted the shit out of his son for pretending to be a gangster online
4
2
2
u/APpookie May 10 '12
Shaming your children because YOU didn't teach them how to act is NOT good parenting.
2
5
17
May 09 '12
More parents need to raise their children properly with liquor instead of chastising for use. America's parents are fucking idiots and have a problem accepting that their 'babies' are going to grow into adults who will drink alcohol.
7
20
u/stompanie May 09 '12
Except this "fucking idiot"'s daughter is clearly under the age of 21, which would make even possessing alcohol a crime. So it's not that this parent has a problem with alcohol, it's that they have a problem with their child doing, you know, illegal stuff. Sounds like a pretty good parent to me.
→ More replies (5)8
u/get2thenextscreen May 09 '12
They might not even mind consuming alcohol. The only thing we can say for a fact is that her parents think it's irresponsible for a minor to post pictures posing with alcohol on the internet.
12
May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Yes, America is literally the worst place ever. There are no good parents here. None. 300 million people, not a single one has anything to offer the rest of the world.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (7)3
6
4
May 09 '12
Oh look, a bunch of college students with no children debating on how to raise children.
Valid arguments everywhere.
4
u/dismal626 May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Stupidest shit ever, can't stand when people advocate things like this. Publicly humiliating your kid in front of all their close friends as a form of punishment is cruel as fuck, don't act surprised when your kid ends up committing suicide.
5
u/williamj35 May 09 '12
Publicly shaming your kids for normal teen behavior. Not good parenting. Nor will it stop them from doing anything. Total violation of her privacy and an intrusion on all her relationships. This will only make her relationship with her parents more resistant. The only thing she'll learn from this is that she can't trust her parents, it's best to defriend them, and don't tell them anything.
3
3
May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
In Japan, parents use public shaming as a threat. Kids are afraid of being shamed in public and tend to act quite a bit different than American kids. I wonder if anyone has done a study on long term effects. Critics of this claim that shaming kids will cause them social anxiety and a host of other problems.
About this photo? We have no idea what the history behind this photo is. For all we know, this has been a chronic issue and the girl is lying to her parents constantly and she finally got busted. We simply have no idea and are passing judgement without all the facts. Again.
→ More replies (2)
3
u/poeboy May 09 '12
If you're dumb enough to post pics of you drinking on a public site that your parents can see, you deserve this.
3
u/LunaD_W May 09 '12
I'd rather be humiliated than taking the belt that was used so often in my childhood. And at 21 my parents can still threaten me with it. If you are sooo soft that a little humiliation, a picture, and having your FB taken away can hurt you; you are a weak person.
3
3
u/Trolio May 10 '12
Yeah, because bullying your children against their friends and peers is the right way to teach them things.
It's not like she will be made fun of for that... No, no physiological repercussions at all.
3
3
May 10 '12
I have seen a lot of posts here trying to say how this is good parenting. I personally believe it is not. If you treat you child poorly, such as making them cry, they will not respect you. This happened to me as a child. My parents only wanted the best for me and whenever I would do something bad they got mad and I ended up crying and feeling bad. Over the years the tactic stopped working on myself and I began to just yell back, insulting my parents. After many shouting contests, my parents realized that the more they yell, the more I yell. And that the only way to make me believe is talk to me, in a calm manner, and fully explain the situation.
I think rather than making you child cry, taking a picture with a sign, and posting it online you should talk to you child about what they did. Explain the dangers of drinking and how it can lead to bad decision, and how easily you could get in the seat of a drunk drivers car. Explain how pictures online of underage partying can affect your future jobs and college options. Making you child cry like this is only going to make them rebel more, whether it is once they leave for college or the next weekend.
TL;DR - Making you child cry only makes your child disrespect you. Explain to them the consequences of their personal decisions.
3
May 10 '12
No, what more parents need to do is actually know what their kids are doing and where they are. Publicly humiliating them is just going to cause more problems.
4
4
May 09 '12
How old is she? when you are 17 your parents shouldn't care if you drink anymore.
She looks at least 17
→ More replies (7)
4
u/TinyZoro May 09 '12
Fuck you Reddit with your unprocessed puritanical need for punishing the wicked.
Relationships are built on love, honesty, trust, kindness, respect. This is not good parenting. These parents are as clueless about the use and abuse of online public spaces as the kid.
Humiliation is one of the most abhorrent things for humans to endure adults will not tolerate it in any situation but apparently its ok for this kid.
For all you so sure that humiliation will get the results of a well balanced child with respect and love for her parents and self-confidence amongst her peers please show me a social-psychology / educational-behaviour paper on it. Of course you don't care that you wont find one because she was a punk and she got punished so now you can all go back to self-righteously watching porn, skiving work and wasting your parents financial help with your college fees.
→ More replies (1)
4
May 09 '12
And here comes all the college students with no parenting experience to comment...
→ More replies (1)
3
May 09 '12
Am I the only one who thinks this might be going a bit far? The parent put words in the kid's mouth, then posted a picture of them holding the sign while crying, adding some major social humiliation...and it's just for posting a picture of them with alcohol, not even drinking it. Eh, just seems a bit cruel and unusual to me.
→ More replies (2)
795
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Just shoot her laptop, jeez