141
u/kittypoopappledrink May 09 '12
350
u/brucemo May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
TL;DR: It's partly fake.
The original image is cool but the one attached to the submission has a star background added.
I spent a lot of time trying to figure out why there were typical open-tube Newtonian diffraction spikes on the stars when the telescope used has no spider, until it occurred to me that it was an overlay, then I verified against the linked photo. I should have known immediately due to exposure length differences, but I haven't actually used modern equipment to take photos of the moon, so I figured I might not understand the new technology.
The linked picture, being more or less real, is much prettier than the submission, in my own opinion.
Well, that's kind of subjective, too. The colors are not what you see with your eye.
And FYI to all of you, while this picture is cool, actually looking at the moon through a good-sized amateur telescope is way, way, cooler.
edit: It's been pointed out to me numerous times that the star background is the Pleiades (M-45).
Speaking of M-45, it's pretty cool. If you run across it in the sky without knowing what it is, it's a fuzzy little patch of stars, easily visible to the naked eye. Every ancient culture has noticed it, because it's impossible to miss if you spend any time walking around outside at night if the sky is even moderately dark.
If you own a Subaru, you drive around with the Pleiades on your car -- it's their logo.
As is true of many cool things in the sky, it's cooler if you look at it with binoculars.
32
May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Yep, it wouldn't be possible to take that picture in one shot. Either the moon would be too over exposed, or you'd only get the moon and there'd be no stars.
As you pointed out, the only way to get a picture like that is to take two separate photos, one exposed for the moon, and one exposed for the stars, and then combine them.
→ More replies (7)19
u/brucemo May 09 '12
I haven't taken an astrophotograph since 1981. It would have been impossible then because of insane over-exposure. You'd have moon all over everything.
I don't know what the star field is but I'm guessing it is nowhere near that moon.
14
→ More replies (6)7
May 09 '12
Yep. I don't think there's anyway you can get around it, even with today's technology. You'll get either the moon or the stars.
I'm also kind of disappointing that the star field is not near the moon (at least, I'm assuming that). It would have been an awesome picture to have the stars in the correct position behind the moon.
→ More replies (17)16
10
u/Sicks3144 May 09 '12
I spent a lot of time trying to figure out why there were typical open-tube Newtonian diffraction spikes on the stars when the telescope used has no spider, until it occurred to me that it was an overlay, then I verified against the linked photo. I should have known immediately due to exposure length differences, but I haven't actually used modern equipment to take photos of the moon, so I figured I might not understand the new technology.
Magic, got it.
→ More replies (1)13
u/FOR_SClENCE May 09 '12
And FYI to all of you, while this picture is cool, actually looking at the moon through a good-sized amateur telescope is way, way, cooler.
Indeed it is. These are shots of the "Supermoon," through a 40-year old Questar Cassegrain, taken by a smartphone. It always scares me when I take the thing out. I have the original receipt; it was $2,600 back in July of 1969. When I took it to my astronomy professor, he was very impressed with the craftsmanship. I've heard that the Russian mirrors are rare.
The whole "Supermoon" thing is totally bullshit by the way; the night before was better.
→ More replies (1)5
u/brucemo May 09 '12
The half moon is what someone should look at if they want to be impressed.
→ More replies (3)4
u/Appreciation622 May 09 '12
Can you inform me as to what "open-tube Newtonian diffraction spikes" are? I have a general guess as to what you're visually referring to, yet an internet search yielded no significant results. As a beginner amateur astronomer, I'd love to know!
15
u/brucemo May 09 '12
A Newtonian is open at one end. Light comes in the front, bounces off a mirror at the back, goes back toward the front, hits a small mirror, and spoots out sideways through the tube, through the eyepiece, and into your eagerly awaiting eyeball.
That second little mirror (the diagonal mirror) is sitting in space in the middle of the tube. It has to be attached somehow, and a typical way of doing that is to have thin vanes of metal attaching it to the side of the tube.
Here is an image from the wiki article.
That's the view peering down the front of the tube.
The vanes attaching the diagonal (that circle near the camera) to the tube are called the spider.
The mirror in the center degrades the image a little, but the spider produces noticeable effects.
Here is the wiki article, which includes a cool looking picture. These effects are okay, unless you don't want them, in which case you're screwed and have to modify your design, which results in trade-offs.
I'm surprised I got the terminology right, since the last time I dealt with this shit I had zero kids and now I have one in college.
When I said "open tube" I meant that some Newtonians have a glass "window" across the end of the tube, and the diagonal support is just glued to that, so no diffraction spikes. This is rare in a Newtonian because that would be a piece of optical grade glass that's flat on both sides, which is expensive, and a big point of a Newtonian is that it's a cheap design, because light doesn't actually have to go through the optics until it gets to the eyepiece, so the interiors of the mirrors can have bubbles and stuff, and the back can be lumpy.
Some other types of telescopes use a corrector plate where this window would go. Those are obviously more expensive, and since you have to have that plate, and in those designs the diagonal support is attached to the corrector plate.
These days people have money, so the other kinds of scopes are more common than when I was a kid. I got mine with money I made picking strawberries.
The best thing about my telescope? It was just big enough to be awesome, and just small enough to use all the time. It's so easy to mess that up in either direction. The worst telescope is always the one in the garage.
→ More replies (24)2
u/sapzilla May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
And the background stars are actually 'The Pleiades Cluster'! You can tell by the 3 brightest stars to the right of the moon OP posted and to the right of the cluster kittypoop posted. So they covered something awesome with something awesome. I'd like to say that's not awesome... but it looks pretty awesome.
*edit: deleted a misplaced word :)
→ More replies (4)3
u/DislikesUSGovernment May 09 '12
Are all of those taken with a camera/telescope. If so its pretty amazing the detail you can see from stuff that is so far away. Man I love space.
59
u/PandaElDiablo May 09 '12
For anyone who is wondering, the colors are an exaggeration of the true (faint) colors created by minerals beneath the moon's surface.
36
10
u/epicshizniz May 09 '12
No way man, it's not exaggerated, thats the ocean.
26
u/BenCelotil May 09 '12
"We're whalers on the Moon, we carry a harpoon.
But there ain't no whales so we tell tall tales and sing our whaling tune."
→ More replies (3)5
2
u/TheRedComet May 09 '12
I keep forgetting to ask, but in case you know... What's the deal with pictures of nebulae and galaxies? They're always so beautifully colorful... But how would they look to the naked eye?
I remember reading that they just take pictures of each wavelength of light present and assign a color to each, so that's not what they really look like, or something like that. Also something about coloring certain elements present in the dust clouds.
2
u/PandaElDiablo May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Correct! Those pictures are taken with cameras that are able to see a greater spectrum of light than the human eye.
If you were to fly close to them, you would see something very different.
And you are also correct about elements having color. In "the Pillars of Creation", for example, the green is produced by hydrogen, the red is produced by sulfur, and the blue is produced by oxygen!
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)1
u/thefalcone May 09 '12
Actually the faint colors were used to are an exaggeration of the true vibrant colors.
9
24
u/emceefall May 09 '12
Would be better if the photographer's shadow wasn't covering up half the damn thing.
32
6
u/armrha May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Nice. People will still photograph the moon though! And should. : )
Edit: Those stars don't seem right though.
4
6
u/ctony May 09 '12
Imgur A photo I took a few months ago. I just used a Canon 40d with a Sigma 300mm lens from the balcony of my flat. I didn't even have a tripod I just used a table and a few books to place my camera and take the photo. You don't need crazy equipment to have fun. It's no way as cool as the op's photo but I like it.
By the way there is some PS sharpening and curves adjustment.
→ More replies (1)
35
5
13
8
u/bikiniduck May 09 '12
Nope, this one is cooler. And its in 3D.
→ More replies (3)2
u/Volpethrope May 09 '12
[boob joke]
3
u/give_me_a_number May 09 '12
If your boobs are shaped like that you might want to see a doctor
→ More replies (2)
4
4
3
15
4
u/oivitz May 09 '12
I like how the seas look blue. This picture makes me feel spectacular, like I've just slipped into a fantasy world where other life forms are right at our doorstep.
3
May 09 '12
P.S. - the coloration isn't real.
10
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/Albuyeh May 09 '12
When I was younger (~4 years old), I used to think that the Moon I saw in the sky was actually the Earth because the craters on the moon looked like the different continents I would see in pictures.
I was not a clever child.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/Aljn May 09 '12
DAE think at this angle, the seas of serenity, tranquility and fertility on the right sort-of come together to form the outline of a Yorkshire Terrier? (or some other small dog).
... just sayin.
2
2
2
May 09 '12
I might be alone on this but is there anyone willing to do a photo comparison of this size to the size of, say, Texas or Alaska? I'd love to see a comparison of the Moon's craters to a large state to get a better understanding of the Moon's surface.
2
2
2
2
2
3
1
1
1
1
u/BeerMe828 May 09 '12
Just realized how badly i need to clean my laptop screen when it appeared that there were stars in front of the shadowed portion of the moon...
1
1
u/coreyf May 09 '12
I've always wondered; what is the the explanation of the streaks that emanate from the (I'm guessing) poles of the Moon?
2
May 09 '12
They look like the pattern of debris that would be ejected from a large impact. Because of the lack of atmosphere, and no seismic activity, patterns like that on the Moon (as well as craters) wouldn't fade with time.
2
2
u/sohighlydubious May 09 '12
I think those streaks radiate out from the Tycho crater, as you say, near the pole. They were caused by what I assume was a higher than usual velocity impact, which sprayed some material across the surface in that pattern.
1
u/EightySixxed May 09 '12
Wow. Amazing. I would kill to watch a video of a crater that size being made on the moon in HD.
1
u/Monsterella May 09 '12
If I see pictures like this, I always feel this great desire to stand on the moon. Even for one second, be close to something that's been there long before us and will be there long after we've all gone.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Sniperizer May 09 '12
wonder where the first mcdonalds will be put up once a perm human base is set up?
→ More replies (1)
1
u/HorseMeatSandwich May 09 '12
Does anybody else want to reach out and give it a hug? I love celestial bodies.
1
May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Was gonna say 'why are there stars in the dark of the moon, when it should just be completely black?' until I realised that those 'stars' were, in fact, dust on my computer screen.
God, I'm disgusting.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Importchef May 09 '12
Looking at this picture makes me wonder "What fuck am I doing with my life?"
1
1
u/TwistTurtle May 09 '12
Really? That's the moon picture to end all moon pictures? Not like, a person actually standing on the moon or anything?
1
1
1
1
May 09 '12
Has the moon been taken away from us since this photo was taken? I'm just somewhat confused by the title, that's all.
1
u/richlittle69 May 09 '12
thank man, i don't want to ever look at another picture of the moon after this and i don't even want to look at the real moon anymore
1
1
u/eponym_ May 09 '12
All those stars in the background though? Must be fake....according to NASA you can't see stars in space
1
May 09 '12
Very nice. I miss having a telescope. It is usually dark enough where I live to just see Andromeda with naked eye.
1
1
1
u/jannroc May 09 '12
What a cool picture! I've never seen such a sweet picture of the moon! Thanks for sharing!
1
1
1
u/CptHair May 09 '12
Hmm, I know I'm red/green colorblind but that moon looks much more green than I'd thought.
1
1
u/aBitRevealing May 09 '12
That's what they said when I got the restraining order, but did it stop me from pursuing my entrepreneurship in Fanny-Photography? No. No it did not.
1
u/hmistry May 09 '12
I upvoted, checked out the links, realised it was seriously manipulated, then down voted. Does that make me a bad person ?
1
1
1
u/phazshifter11 May 09 '12
THIS IS THE FIRST TIME I SEE THE MOON IN COLOR...IT'S FUCKING 2012 NASA !!!-STOP THE BLACK AND WHITE SHIT YOU MOTHERFUCKERS !
1
1
u/_NeuroManson_ May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Looking at the lower left, I wonder, what could the Earth have been gravitationally deflecting to cause such a massive amount of semi recent bombardments?
Could it have been debris from the asteroid/planetary impact that devastated Mars? The debris that came from the asteroid impact that killed off the dinosaurs? Just a random cluster of asteroids that barely missed us? Seriously, it looks like a shotgun blast on a lunar scale.
We need to put a probe/lander there to find out.
Edit: Looking at http://www.lunarrepublic.com/atlas/, there isn't a clear answer, only what the mappings provide. But even then, maybe the moon saved us from some big bullets. I recall something about an ancient astrologist noting a massive flash on the moon, leaving the "big star" crater (AKA Tycho Crater), if that's the case, we barely missed having a mass extinction event.
1
u/cryptobeast May 09 '12
Edit: Looking at http://www.lunarrepublic.com/atlas/, there isn't a clear answer,
Why not go to the source? NAC camera on the LRO craft? http://lroc.sese.asu.edu/EPO/LROC/lroc.php?pg=what
Oh and lunarregistry.com..
Become a member-citizen of the Luna Society today and receive an acre of land on the Moon (or more!) as your gift, connecting you directly with our nearest planetary neighbor! source
Scam http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extraterrestrial_real_estate
1
1
1
1
u/SugarBeef May 09 '12
Guys, I think karmacy is warning us that he or she is gonna destroy the moon! How else would it end all moon pictures? It all makes sense!
1
1
1
1
1
u/tetefather May 09 '12
I'm suprised no one has noticed the object that is sitting in the middle of the crater on the bottom-left.
1
1
1
u/nitrostealth May 09 '12
I like how all the moon pics from nasa are NOT in full colour, even from the hubble
1
u/boringnamehere May 09 '12
I'm still gonna stick with NASA's picture of the moon. The detail on the picture is incredible. Of course, the image is well over 500 MB...
1
1
May 09 '12
lol what is this, looks like a photoshop of a skyrim screenshot
or do people actually believe the moon is blue and brown
1
1
1
1
May 09 '12
When will people learn that whenever you take pictures of a bright object, not so bright objects (like stars a million light years away) around it will be invisible?
1
1
1
1
1
u/ohpollux May 09 '12
Does anyone know if it's possible with powerful enough equipment to see the zone of the moon landing? And roughly how expensive would that equipment be?
2
u/Jha420 May 09 '12
No, you cant see it even with the best of telescopes unfortunately.
→ More replies (1)
1
May 09 '12
Last time this was posted (or a similar one anyway) someone photoshopped Calvin and Hobbes in. Does anyone still have a link to the C&H giant moon wallpaper?
1
u/jogloran May 09 '12
Someone needs to tell the moon about a clean towel over your pillow every night.
1
u/Its_the_Fuzz May 09 '12
There all so good! I now have about 6 pictures of epic moons on my iPad...
1
1
u/cmbezln May 09 '12
Why are there large lines on the moon coming from that deep impact on the bottom left?
1
1
1
u/Atnevon May 09 '12
Carl Sagan was right when he said astronomy was a character building experience.
I look up now and somewhat feel small, but, that means that's how in comparison my troubles are too.
1
u/NudeTayneMNW May 09 '12
If someone wants a lot of karma they should make three moons looking up to a wolf.
1
1
u/Mechanikal May 09 '12
Is it just me or does that thing look like its made of metal with a rock coating?
1
1
1
1
1
u/beanswiggin May 09 '12
One of many reasons why I love reddit. You don't even need to try and you'll find awesome wallpapers.
1
u/skintigh May 09 '12
Pro-tip: if the moon and the stars are equally exposed, the photo is fake. Either the stars will be underexposed or the moon overexposed.
1
1
u/happyclowncandyman May 09 '12
Did anyone else read that "The motion picture to end all motion pictures" ? Only to click on it and wonder "what the fuck, it's just a picture of the moon.."
1
u/flarker May 09 '12
If you ever wanted to know where the first moon landing was: the two dark vertically overlapping craters (dark round spots) towards the right are the Seas of Serenity and Tranquility. The first landing was on the inside edge of the Sea of Tranquility - the lower of the two. "Tranquility Base Here. The Eagle has Landed"
1
1
1
May 09 '12
I'm a fan of this one.
And here is the gigantic 24,000 x 24,000 pixels version (warning: its 550mb)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/lastmachine May 09 '12
Am I the only one seeing the skull?
2
1
1
u/ofcourseimright May 09 '12
This just occurred to me: how come there are so many visible craters on the moon yet none visible on Earth?
4
u/pianobadger May 09 '12
No erosion whatsoever on the moon. Not even geologically active (volcanoes, plate tectonics). Also, barely any atmosphere, which burns up the small stuff.
3
u/rcpilot May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Mostly just the differences an atmosphere and other natural processes make. Things on the moon pretty much don't get shifted around at all, and there's not much in the way to dissipate impacts when they do happen. So, the craters you see there are probably nearly all ridiculously old by humanity's standards, but these impacts do happen a lot, everywhere, in the really long run.
1
u/sweetaskiwi May 09 '12
Quick over lay it with quotes saying how great atheism is!
→ More replies (1)
5
u/brentcos May 09 '12
Wow, really fantastical. How was this accomplished?