r/PasswordManagers • • Apr 17 '25

Best Password Manager List & Comparison Table

503 Upvotes

Hi, I made this updated password manager list & comparison table to help people decide which password manager to use. Please feel free to share any suggestions for improvement.

Best Password Managers

Proton Pass

Proton Pass is made by the team behind ProtonMail and ProtonVPN. It is open source, audited, and built around privacy with end-to-end encryption. It has a clean interface and a good free tier, but no option for local storage.

Bitwarden

Bitwarden is open source, audited, and uses end-to-end encryption. It works across all major platforms and offers a solid free plan. The interface is functional but can feel clunky compared to others.

1Password

1Password is closed source but audited and highly polished. It has no free tier, but it is easy to use and integrates well with different devices and browsers. Strong security and a smooth interface are its main selling points.

Comparison Table

Password ManagerAuditsOpen SourceFree Tier2FAE2EECloud BasedLocal StorageEmail AliasClean UINo Security IncidentsAndroidiOSWindowsmacOSLinuxChromeFirefox
Proton Pass✅✅✅✅✅✅❌✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅
Bitwarden✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅❌✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅
1Password✅❌❌✅✅✅❌✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅
NordPass✅❌✅✅✅✅❌✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅
Dashlane❌✅✅✅✅✅❌❌✅✅✅✅❌❌❌✅✅
RoboForm✅❌✅✅✅✅❌❌✅✅✅✅✅✅❌✅✅
Keeper✅❌❌✅✅✅❌❌✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅
Enpass✅❌✅✅✅✅✅❌✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅
Sticky Password❌❌✅✅✅✅✅❌❌✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅
LastPass✅❌✅✅✅✅❌❌✅❌✅✅✅✅✅✅✅
KeePassXC✅✅✅✅✅❌✅❌❌✅❌❌✅✅✅❌❌
KeePassDX❌✅✅✅✅❌✅❌❌✅✅❌❌❌❌❌❌
Strongbox❌❌✅✅✅❌✅❌✅✅❌✅❌✅❌❌❌
Google Password Manager❌❌✅✅✅✅❌❌✅✅✅❌❌❌❌✅❌
iCloud Keychain❌❌✅✅✅✅❌✅✅✅✅✅✅✅❌✅❌
Microsoft Autofill❌❌✅✅❌✅❌❌✅✅✅❌❌❌❌✅❌

Last updated: 4/17/2025.


r/PasswordManagers • • Nov 19 '25

Best free Password Manager right now?

214 Upvotes

I’ve been looking into finding the best free password manager available right now, but it’s hard to tell which ones are actually safe to use. I just want something reliable, secure, and not shady with ads or hidden data tracking. Sure, writing passwords in a notebook might be the safest method, but let’s be real, no one’s carrying that around all the time, especially with so many accounts these days. If you’re using a free password manager that’s been working well for you, I’d really like to hear which one and why you trust it. I’m not looking for fancy extras, just something simple and private that does the job without forcing a paid upgrade.


r/PasswordManagers • • May 15 '26

Bitwarden BAD NEWS

195 Upvotes

From their site some stuff have changed, and internet archive testify it. They removed "Always Free", and changed GRIT from "Gratitude, Responsibility, Inclusion, Transparency" to "Gratitude, Responsibility, Innovation, Trust".

Also I discovered that the people that were CEO and CFO from 2019, changed without any public announcement. What do you guys think about it? Tbh it's a little bit concerning, I understand they have 10 millions users but...


r/PasswordManagers • • Feb 27 '26

ELI5: What is a Passkey and why are so many websites trying to get me to use one?

187 Upvotes

I already use a password manager with strong, unique passwords, and 2FA via a different app. A passkey just seems to be a different password they want me to use instead?

I don't think they're talking about a physical key?


r/PasswordManagers • • Jul 06 '26

Techlore just dropped a password manager tier list

Post image
148 Upvotes

S: Keepass, Protonpass, Bitwarden
A: 1Password, Passbolt
B: Enpass, Roboform, Dashlane
C: Nordpass, Apple Password, Keeper
D: LastPass, Google Password Manager
(Thanks to Xypheric for mentioning this.)

what are your thoughts on it?

video link: https://youtu.be/R13NHqWxZx8


r/PasswordManagers • • Sep 01 '26

THe password manager 1password donates 300k to an org standing for the Ethnic Cleansing of Europe

Thumbnail
alilleybrinker.com
147 Upvotes

Omarchy is a Linux distribution created and controlled by David Heinemeier Hansson, usually known as DHH.
In the last year DHH has also called for the ethnic cleansing of Europe.
Today the Omacom Foundation, which financially supports development of Omarchy and is controlled by DHH, announced that 1Password has committed $300,000 to them over the next three years.

Apparently DHH’s support for ethnic cleansing is not disqualifying to 1Password.

r/1Password blocks this article.


r/PasswordManagers • • Mar 18 '26

Finally leaving 1Password. Pheww 4 Years..

147 Upvotes

I have been a 1password user for about 4 years now. Love the app and all its features. I was happy to move to their subscription model as well. To this date, one of the best designed password apps.

But, after the recent price hike, continuing to pay half the cost of MS365 (single user in Europe) as subscription for a password manager is really inane. I can understand subscriptions run businesses, keep the servers safe, maintain the app etc etc. However, it is just a password manager. Users are not asking for more than saving, syncing, using and creating credentials.

When i found out today i can migrate all my passwords and passkeys without any loss in data, I pulled the trigger.

(tried posting in 1password sub with also a thank you note. Got removed. I mean, what was i thinking 🤔)


r/PasswordManagers • • May 25 '25

Best Password Manager?

132 Upvotes

Hi, I'm looking to start using a password manager instead of writing my passwords down. What is the best password manager as of 2025? Also, what makes it the best, and what should I look for? I found a coupon for LastPass, is that a good option? Or should I go with 1Password, NordPass, Bitwarden, Proton, etc.? I'm willing to pay. Thanks for the help!


r/PasswordManagers • • Sep 12 '25

PSA Do not use google password manager. I lost everything

112 Upvotes

I was using google password manager due to the smooth integration with google chrome and andriod.

One day I noticed it was not autofilling passwords. i checked the password manager and only a few passwords were there.

I went to all of the troubleshooting steps, verified my account was not comprimised, used google takeout, but to no avail.

Just shcked other people have had similar issues, and there is no way of getting it back. They chalk it up to a "sync" issue. Welp it is back to other PMs


r/PasswordManagers • • Mar 27 '26

🚨 Warning: New FAKE website offering FAKE KeePassXC downloads!

Post image
105 Upvotes

New FAKE website offering FAKE KeePassXC downloads! Do not fall for it. The correct domain is https://

keepassxc.org without hypens!

The website is asking for your email address to access the downloads. We never ask for your email address. Do not enter your data there, it's a phishing attempt.

Fountain: https://fosstodon.org/@keepassxc/


r/PasswordManagers • • 14d ago

Mseven email - msecure compromised? received 11/3/2026 @ 1:52 am

Post image
98 Upvotes

Time to get off my lazy and secure my accounts I guess.

For those using screen readers:

Important Security Notice

mSeven Software (“mSeven”) recently learned of suspicious activity associated with the mSecure password management application. In response, mSeven quickly launched an investigation, took steps to mitigate the issue, and engaged external cybersecurity experts to assist. You are receiving this email because you are a current or former mSecure customer.

Given the potential security implications, mSeven recommends that you immediately take steps to protect all confidential information stored within the mSecure password management application. This may include changing passwords, resetting or re-enrolling two-factor authentication methods, or removing existing passkeys.

We regret any inconvenience that this may cause.

Sincerely,

The mSeven Software Team

edit:

email headers with my info removed:

Email header: "Important security notice about your mSecure account" Received: Tue, 03 Nov 2026, 06:52 UTC

Sent by mSecure (mSeven Software LLC) through its email provider, SendGrid.

• From: mSecure [email protected] • Reply-To: mSecure Support [email protected] • Sending server: o1.sendgrid2.msecure.com (168.245.26.232) • Bounce domain: em3993.msecure.com

Authentication • SPF: pass (em3993.msecure.com) • DKIM: pass (signed by msecure.com, 2048-bit key) • DMARC: pass (msecure.com, policy quarantine) • Spam score: 0, delivered to inbox


r/PasswordManagers • • Aug 25 '26

Just got this 2fa thing

Post image
94 Upvotes

r/PasswordManagers • • May 15 '26

Bitwarden scrubs ‘Always free’ and ‘Inclusion’ values from its website as longtime execs step down

Thumbnail fastcompany.com
93 Upvotes

r/PasswordManagers • • Oct 28 '25

What password manager is everyone using in 2025?

81 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I finally decided to get serious about organizing my digital life and setting up a proper password manager. I've been reading a bit about how some of them handle cross-device syncing and family sharing, and it seems like things have changed a lot recently.

Ideally, I'd love something that works across all my devices (both mobile and desktop), has solid encryption, and doesn't break the bank.

It's hard to tell which ones actually feel smooth to use day-to-day or are best for families. If you've tried any of these (or others), what's been your experience? Any tips for someone switching over for the first time or setting it up for a small household?

Would love to know what password manager in 2025 everyone is using and why.


r/PasswordManagers • • Aug 26 '26

AI-Slop Password Managers

75 Upvotes

Seeing many people now attempting to create password managers. AI is making it easier now, which worries me a lot. I've been in the cybersecurity industry for quite a while now and have seen huge problems with password managers, especially new ones that focus on local-first, offline-first, air-gapped (fill in your AI-slop buzzword here), without understanding that's not where the security enforcement should rely.

Every day on HN and Reddit now, it’s the exact same post:

Tired of Bitwarden (1Pass, LastPass, ...), so I spent the last couple of months building VaultSlopAI, a zero-knowledge, local-first, air-gapped, post-quantum-ready password manager written from scratch with next-gen semantic entropy.

...and people are going to lose their life savings over hallucinatory XOR ciphers.

Every single one of them:

- "Air-gapped architecture" (Bro, you just disabled network permissions in the Electron manifest).

- "Local-first sovereign vault" (It writes unpadded base64 to localStorage and calls it a day).

- "Self-healing zero-knowledge enclave" (Literally just crypto.getRandomValues() wrapped inside a buggy Next.js server action).

Can we please go back to letting boring, audited, battle-tested tools manage our digital lives instead of downloading 400MB of hallucinated Tailwind wrappers masquerading as military-grade security?

(Ohh and yes, I’m building one too 😄 except I’ve actually worked in cybersecurity for years, know how the primitives work, and didn’t just vibe/slop prompt the entire architecture over a weekend.)


r/PasswordManagers • • Nov 12 '25

My 1-Month Verdict on Using Bitwarden as My Primary Password Manager (as a Former Proton Pass User)

74 Upvotes

Test period: Since October 11th, 2025
Bitwarden version: 2025.9.0 to 2025.10.0
Proton Pass version: 1.32.9
Browser: Firefox (extension only)
Credentials used: 300+ (normal usage - no feature stress-testing)

Important Notes

  • I used (and still use) the Bitwarden Firefox extension only.

  • I used it in my normal daily routine.

  • I didn’t go out of my way to test extreme scenarios or advanced features.

Bitwarden - Pros:

  1. In-line autofill dropdown stretches fully across the login field - much cleaner UI than Proton Pass.

  2. Free tier includes credit card & identity storage - Proton Pass hides those behind a paywall.

  3. Folders for better organization (Proton Pass still doesn’t have this).

  4. Login field detection is miles ahead of Proton Pass.

  5. Premium plan costs only €10/year (≈€0.83/month) - significantly cheaper than Proton Pass Plus at €5/month, despite Proton Pass lacking many essentials.

  6. I really like the extension “Fill” autofill method - it works 99.9% of the time flawlessly. Occasionally, you must click the username/email field first for it to detect the form (possibly a bug).

  7. Manual vault logout doesn’t log you out of the browser extension - unlike Proton Pass, which does, and that’s super annoying.

Bitwarden - Cons (and Bugs)

(Yeah… this list is longer than it should be for a password manager
These are my personal preference issues after one months of daily use.)

  1. Extension Menu Auto-Open Missing

Bitwarden doesn’t automatically open the extension menu when a login field is detected.
-> Keeper Security does this perfectly - it should be a toggle option in Bitwarden.

2. Favorites Not on Top

Favorited logins are listed after auto-suggestions, which defeats the point - scrolling through 20–40 entries per site is painful.

3. Small Separate Login Windows Break Autofill

Websites with popup login windows (like Reddit, Ubisoft Connect, Twitter) cause the Bitwarden menu to close when clicked - making it impossible to autofill.
You must manually click into the field first.
This is especially frustrating when the in-line list has the scrolling bug.

4. No Toggle for Autofill “Zoom” Animation

There’s a toggle for menu animation, but not for the autofill zoom effect - and it can cause motion sickness.

Fun fact: a Reddit user shared a CSS fix for this, usable with uBlock Origin or any Extensions that supports CSS rules:

*##.com-bitwarden-browser-animated-fill:style(animation: none !important; -webkit-animation: none !important)

Huge thanks to that person - still works perfectly!

5. Extension Doesn’t Save Settings After Firefox Profile Refresh

Bitwarden resets extension settings when you refresh the Firefox profile.

6. Two-Step Login Pages Are a Hassle

Sites like Google or the Unreal Engine Store require two Bitwarden clicks:

  • One for the email,

  • One for the password (since the menu closes after the first). You can use the in-line autofill instead, but it’s clunkier.

Examples:

  • icloud.com: must click the “Sign in with Apple ID” box before autofill works, otherwise error: "Unable to autofill the selected item on this page. Copy and paste instead."

  • Reddit (if logging in via Gmail): the popup login window disappears if you click the Bitwarden icon, making autofill impossible.

  • Google login itself is a clear Bitwarden issue, not the site’s fault.

  1. Favorites Not Sorted to Top (again!)

Same as point 2 - this issue’s been requested since 2020.🤦

8. Pre-Typed Data Not Cleared

After a successful login, pre-filled credential data stays visible - not cleared immediately.

9. Credentials Don’t Auto-Save or Update Reliably

This is a very well known issue with Bitwarden. The Extension is very inconsistent with offering to save credentials or update them - I must do it manually.
Proton Pass does this every single time without fail.
(Firefox’s native password manager is disabled, so that’s not interfering.)

10. Doesn’t Work on Some Sites

Example: auth.griefergames.de/login

Bitwarden shows suggestions but clicking them does nothing.

Not even the Fill button works on this website.

Forced to copy/paste manually.

11. Autofill Field Mismatch (shop-apotheke.com)

Bitwarden incorrectly fills “First Name” and “Last Name” with account credentials instead of identity data.
It also refuses to fill in the phone number field at all, even though it exists in the stored identity.

12. In-Line Dropdown Only Shows 3 Credentials

You can’t resize it, and scrolling is clunky — finding one out of many credentials per site is a pain.

Bugs I’ve Noticed

  1. Once, Bitwarden failed to detect Google’s login field entirely (Firefox's Sidebar, 144.0). Haven’t seen it again.

  2. Steam’s login form only shows autofill suggestions in the password field, not the username field: Reported on Bitwarden Community

  3. Bitwarden Extension causes very stuttery typing in Firefox: Reported on Bitwarden Community

Proton Pass - Pros

  1. UI design is much cleaner and more modern.

  2. In-line pre-typing and scrolling through suggestions works flawlessly.

  3. Managing entries (pin, edit, view history, delete) is simpler and faster.

  4. Pre-typing speed is faster overall.

Proton Pass - Cons

  1. Autofill dropdown is tiny and doesn’t stretch across the login field.

  2. Credit cards & identities are paywalled (Bitwarden offers them for free).

  3. Notes can’t be saved on the free tier either.

  4. No folders yet.

  5. Autofill fails on major sites like iCloud and Reddit - even though Proton said this would be fixed in their Summer 2025 roadmap (which ended ~3 months ago).

  6. Master password = email password, which isn’t ideal for security.

  7. Pricing: €5/month vs Bitwarden’s €0.83/month - despite lacking features.

  8. Password generator window is very small compared to Bitwarden’s.

  9. Free tier limitations basically force users like me to switch to Bitwarden.

  10. With my Proton Pass Plus expiring Oct 22, 2025 - my credit card & identity info went back behind the paywall.

  11. Extension setup resets theme and preferences randomly after login - very annoying.

  12. The Proton Team is VERY inconsistent with holding up to their announced feature release schedules as mentioned in their roadmaps. Many announced features - reaching back to Fall of 2024 - still haven't been implemented.

Final Thoughts

Despite its flaws and quirks, Bitwarden still wins for me - mainly because of:

  • Better autofill detection,

  • Free credit card & identity storage,

  • Folder organization, and

  • Much better pricing.

That said, Bitwarden seriously (!) needs UX improvements (especially with popup logins, autofill animations, and favorites sorting).
If the devs addressed just a few of these, it could easily become the best password manager overall.


r/PasswordManagers • • Mar 04 '26

PSA: Posts to 1Password Community are actively censored

Post image
67 Upvotes

EDIT 2: 1Password reached out to me quickly via DM on Reddit. They said that there was no issue with my original message but that it was accidentally swept up with some other moderation activities. When asked why my second message (pictured) was also deleted, they said it was because it concerned moderation and that someone was in the middle of responding to me privately about it. I hope that's true. In any case, they suggested that I repost my original message. I have done so.

EDIT 1: Sure enough, my copy of this post to r/1Password was also deleted, just minutes after I posted it.

Today, 1Password quietly DELETED a post I made to a very busy thread in the 1Password Community forum. It was not rude or offensive, but it did mention a competitor.

When I saw that the message was deleted, I posted a SECOND message (as pictured), removing the product reference and restating the main point I had made. Again, not rude or offensive.

That post has ALSO BEEN DELETED.

Since r/1Password may be moderated in the same way, I'm cross-posting this here for good measure.

1Password, I think your product is actually the best out there. But manipulating your community forum in this way is wrong.


r/PasswordManagers • • Feb 27 '26

MASTERPLAY! Proton Pass gives you an extra 33% OFF "for no particular reason" just as 1Password goes up 33%... coincidence? 😏

Post image
67 Upvotes

POR NINGUNA RAZÓN EN PARTICULAR, ahora puedes obtener un 33% de descuento adicional en Proton Pass.

Asegura tu vida digital con encriptación de código abierto, con sede en Suiza.

Seguridad de alta gama con una filosofía de precios que se mantiene estable… sin sorpresas, solo privacidad: https://proton.me/l/pass-switch

Termina el 13 de marzo 🥳

Publicación del anuncio (x): https://x.com/Proton_Pass/status/2027478880039116922?s=20


r/PasswordManagers • • Jul 26 '25

What Password Manager do you guys recommend best?

63 Upvotes

I can’t decide on if I should use Bitwarden or Enpass…

I’m on Android btw.


r/PasswordManagers • • Oct 12 '26

Bitwarden alternatives: anyone considering switching after the recent changes?

60 Upvotes

I've been following the recent discussions around Bitwarden, especially the move towards commercially licensed builds, the price increase earlier this year, and concerns about its open-source direction.

I know Bitwarden has said the free plan and open-source version aren't going anywhere, but I take their words with a grain of salt honestly.

I've started looking into Bitwarden alternatives like NordPass, Proton Pass, 1Password, KeePassXC. They all seem to have their pros and cons.

I also saw this post that seems pretty useful for seeing how different password managers compare up against each other.

For those considering switching, which Bitwarden alternatives are actually worth looking into?

I'm interested in something reliable with good autofill, passkey support, and reasonable pricing. Ideally, something that won't gradually move basic features behind more expensive subscriptions.


r/PasswordManagers • • Sep 05 '26

Every 1Password alternative worth considering in 2026, and who each one suits

58 Upvotes

I see "alternatives to 1Password" a good twice a week here so here's your full list of what to choose and why:

Bitwarden
Choose if: cost matters and you want open source. Teams runs $4 per user, Enterprise $6, and the free tier covers unlimited passwords on unlimited devices.
Avoid if: you want polish. The admin console and apps are plainer than 1Password's, and non-technical staff tend to notice.
Self-hosting is available if you want the vault on your own infrastructure.

Keeper
Choose if: you're in a regulated industry. FedRAMP Moderate, HIPAA, SOC 2, and ISO 27001, with granular RBAC and SCIM provisioning. Business Starter sits around $3.75 per user.
Avoid if: you want something light. The admin depth is the point, and it's heavier than most small teams need.

NordPass
Choose if: price is the deciding factor. Cheapest paid tier at roughly $1.49 to $1.79 per user, modern interface, and the parent company is Lithuania-based so it sits inside the EU.
Avoid if: you need to audit the code. It's closed source, and audits get summarised without the full reports published.

Passwork
Choose if: you need self-hosting or EU data residency. Runs on your own server or as EU cloud hosted, around €3 per user, with per-user audit logs and LDAP sync at that price. A one-time self-hosted licence is also available.
Avoid if: you're solo or a two-person team. It's built around team access control, so you'd carry structure you don't need.

Proton Pass
Choose if: privacy is the priority. Swiss jurisdiction, end-to-end encryption, built-in email aliases, around $1.99 a month personal.
Avoid if: you rely on autofill working every time. It misses forms more often than 1Password does.

Dashlane
Choose if: you want identity protection bundled in. VPN and dark web monitoring included, family plan covers 10 accounts.
Avoid if: budget is tight. Business lands near $8 per user, so you're at 1Password money already.

My top picks overall:
Passwork if self-hosting or EU residency is a requirement, since few options at that price include per-user audit logs. Bitwarden if you want the most capability for the least money and can live without polish. Keeper if you're regulated and need the compliance certifications on paper.


r/PasswordManagers • • Oct 10 '26

Alternatives to bitwarden?

56 Upvotes

Does anyone have any good recommendations for alternatives to bitwarden, now that it's going partly closed source? Thanks so much!


r/PasswordManagers • • Jul 14 '26

1P: Well, Hello there price increase!

Post image
54 Upvotes

Well, Hello there price increase! - 1Password


r/PasswordManagers • • Mar 07 '26

🔥 Attention Bitwarden users!

Post image
52 Upvotes

If you have a paid subscription, get ready for an improvement many of us have been waiting for.

Now you can archive items from your vault to keep them out of search and autocomplete… without having to delete them. An elegant way to keep your vault clean, organized, and under control.

✨ They announced that this new feature will begin rolling out in the coming days, so stay tuned.

https://community.bitwarden.com/t/archive-items/94527