r/offbeat • • May 31 '12

Eagle scout challenges Boy Scouts with 275,000 signatures demanding it change its anti-gay policy

http://abcnews.go.com/US/eagle-scout-challenges-boy-scouts-anti-gay-policy/story?id=16459135
2.4k Upvotes

576 comments sorted by

84

u/Sturdy_Muffin May 31 '12

I have been a BSA leader in the past with 20 plus years of experience. This policy is absurd and should have been changed. I will tell you why I do not think that it will be changed any time soon and it has to do with money, plain and simple. Money comes into play because the Mormon faith has one youth development program for their boy members and that program is Boy Scouts of America. Virtually every Mormon boy is enrolled in the Boy Scouts at age 11. The Mormons give large amounts to the BSA, in the form of dues and in donations. At one point not that long ago the application form to join the boy scouts had a box on the lower left corner marked LDS. When I became a scoutmaster I questioned our council on this and they informed me that LDS stood for Latter Day Saints-which is another name for the Mormon Church. I asked them why there was a box for LDS and not other religions- they had no good response. I wrote a letter to council asking for a wrtten response to this question and asking why they were seemingly, for some reason, treating the religion of one group of scouts differently than all others. After all, the BSA is very clear in its policy that it does not differentiate between different religions of its members. I never received a reply. In discussing this with a good friend who is a Mormon, he explained to me the Mormon program and told me that he was aware that the Mormon faith donated a lot of money to the BSA. The Mormons believe that being gay is wrong and I believe that if the BSA changed their policy on gays, they would immediately lose a huge portion of their membership and a huge donor. The BSA has gone from 5.7 million scouts in 1970 to around 2.3 million today. They cannot afford to lose any more members so that is why the BSA will not change this policy, in my opinion.

4

u/yourdadsbff May 31 '12

Also:

Following the meeting, the Boy Scouts released a statement that said they have "no plans" to change their policy.

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

[deleted]

12

u/Sturdy_Muffin May 31 '12

I do not think that this change alone would make that much of a difference. Scouting, at its core, does have great value and can teach boys many things they will never learn any other way. Watching a boy build his own shelter, cook his own food and be reliant upon only himself and his fellow scouts to survive, if only for a weekend, is a marvelous thing to see. But the BSA is so far removed from real life, I do not think they will ever catch up. I can give you an examples-just last summer, one summer camp the BSA runs added jet skis to their activities and the BSA magazine had a big article on it, touting how modern and with it the BSA is. The problem is that jet skis have been around for 30 years and the BSA is just now allowing them to be used by scouts. There are many examples of this across scouting. The BSA reminds me of the Roman Catholic Church, hanging on to old beliefs and ways because they are run by old, dogmatic, narrow minded individuals who do not believe in change and who are afraid of alienating their current followers and losing them.

Second,the way the BSA has structured itself is very ingenious and insulates them from having to do anything that their constituents, the boy scout troops themselves, want. To have a troop, it must be sponsored by an organization, a church, a Moose lodge, almost any group can sponsor a troop. The local governing body of the boy scouts is called a council. The employees of the council are paid (some make over a hundred thousand per year) employees. The boy scout troops they supervise and support do not have any right to direct council. This right to direct the council is held by the sponsor of the troops. Most sponsoring organizations are more than happy to sponsor a troop but they are very reluctant to get involved in the running of the local council and have neither the desire nor the knowledge sets needed to do so. The local council rarely, if ever, have any contact with the sponsoring organizations, they only talk to the troops so the councils have the perfect boss, someone not interested in them, willing to allow them to do anything they want and very reluctant to get together with the other sponsors to effect change. You may look at this akin to having a board of directors in a corporation but this board of directors never meets, is rarely given any information about the organization they are supervising and is rarely asked what their opinion is on anything.

2

u/Sturdy_Muffin May 31 '12

To answer your question more directly, no, I do not think that they would make up the loss of the Mormons. Please see my other note on why.

→ More replies (4)

42

u/unquietwiki May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12

For anyone who's curious, I went to the Scouting Museum a few years back. A trajectory I noticed in its history: a gradual shift from Native folklore; to classic patriotism; to individualism, mixed with church involvement.

One part I didn't get pictures of: their art gallery, wherein a similar shift also was displayed. The older stuff: scouts doing deeds + exploring America. The newer stuff: family + church reverence.

Added note to the second paragraph: the scouting billboards you see in your towns; the artwork for that was in the "newer" set (kids racing a soap box is the common one).

21

u/Frencil May 31 '12

This is most definitely apparent in the evolution of Boy Scout handbooks. I had the 10th Edition when I was going though scouts in the 90's. It has plenty of stuff regarding personal character, family, and reverence but not overtly so. It's still dominated by illustrated skills like knot tying, wilderness survival, orienteering, etc. You know, useful stuff. This is why I still have it - it's excellent reference material.

Through kids of friends I've been able to flip through the current 12th Edition. The skills are still there but family/character/reverence plays a much bigger role. As a reference guide for how to live life in the outdoors it's sadly lost some of its clout.

12

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

That's pretty disgusting.

→ More replies (3)

91

u/Neepho May 31 '12

Wait...Boy scouts have an anti-gay policy? Can someone clue me up on this, I've never even heard of it, is it US only?

78

u/jhontheunmortal May 31 '12

I'm not sure if it's US only, but it's been a pretty big controversy for awhile. The wording of the official policy has changed so much since I was last active, but it basically boils down to "we don't think it is in line with the Scout Oath and Law, so we're not going to have it". Speaking as an Eagle Scout, I think this policy is pants-on-head retarded, but as private organization has the right to hold what rules it will.

51

u/Bionic_Pickle May 31 '12

There is a problem with the 'private organization' argument in this case. Eagle Scouts get to skip right to E-3 after basic training when they enlist in the US Military. Either this benefit needs to be removed or the discrimination needs to stop.

16

u/darwin2500 May 31 '12

Also they get to use public grounds for free which are off-limits or expensive to other parties, get preferential treatment from public schools, etc. They ma not be directly funded by the government, but they couldn't exist in their current configuration without massive governmental support.

→ More replies (3)

44

u/jhontheunmortal May 31 '12

The flaw with that is that it isn't just Eagles that get that bump in rank/rate/whatever term your branch uses. I can only speak for the USN, but having college credits, completing the pre-basic PQS (and passing the first knowledge and physical assessments), referring people, shooting for certain ratings (Nuclear field in particular) all grant either E-2 or E-3. It isn't an acknowledgement of organization membership, it an acknowledgement of skills and qualities relevant to the military.

12

u/Sheol May 31 '12

Is there a way you can demonstrate you have the skills an Eagle Scout would without actually becoming an Eagle Scout and still receive the bump up in rank?

→ More replies (4)

21

u/pho75 May 31 '12

I agree the policy is bogus, but I think your argument is specious. The Military will give you a bump if you have graduated from a 4 year college. Do you suggest removing that benefit for people who graduate from an all female college?

30

u/Bionic_Pickle May 31 '12

Of course not. If females were not allowed to go to college at all, I certainly would though.

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/SantiagoRamon May 31 '12

They even have a supreme court decision to back up their right to discriminate against gays. As a person I don't like it but as a student of the law I don't see why a private organization shouldn't be allowed to discriminate on their membership.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/yargdpirate May 31 '12

There was even a Supreme Court case on it. Boy Scouts vs. Dale

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Coloneljesus May 31 '12

Never seen that South Park episode with Big Gay Al?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/erockdye May 31 '12

I never really knew either, but since it seems to be official, I'd like to say as an Eagle Scout myself, that policy was never enforced in my area (Atlanta, Georgia). Our troop had an unspoken 'mind your own business' rule I think. Somewhat relevant, I'm atheist and I still made it to Eagle Scout.

2

u/RedHotBeef May 31 '12

I'm also an atheist Eagle from the Atlanta area. Our troop never cared about anyone's religion. It was no more uncomfortable than having to say the pledge of allegiance in school every day.

2

u/tajmaballs May 31 '12

If you were an atheist at the time of becoming an Eagle Scout, then you must've lied in order to achieve that rank. That seems antithetical for the BSA to force a member to lie, as an organization whose purpose is to install values in young people.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/stfnotguilty May 31 '12

The position of the BSA is that being a homosexual prevents one from keeping the "keep myself morally straight" and "Do my duty to God" promises of the Scout Oath.

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

From what I've been told when I've inquired about it, it's basically whatever is the "head council", that's populated by useless and tired old people, that clings to this, along with some regional groups (Utah, the deep South). All the younger leadership doesn't want it but has no power to force a change.

1

u/PenalAnticipation May 31 '12

Last big camp I was at had a LGBT-tent, so I'm pretty sure we don't have any policies about gays up here in Finland.

1

u/derangedbrain1 May 31 '12

yes they do...and it's lame

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

It seems mostly US you can read more here It basically says there are restrictions for gay people to become scout leaders in the US but not in the UK, Canada, Australia, germany, sweden.

As for atheists, there are strong restrictions in the boy scouts of america for atheists and agnostics.

The UK requires an acknowledgment of a higher power (but you don't have to follow a religious tradition AFAIK so it sounds relatively laid back in comparison). Also UK doesn't exclude atheists from roles in scouting as long as the applicant basically isn't militant.

Canada similar

few places in france and Italy seem full secular

Theres more crap about the US too.

1

u/TrustYourFarts Jun 01 '12

The scouts in the UK have a policy to encourage gay kids to join, and gay adults to become leaders. They attend gay pride events too.

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

[deleted]

22

u/dcousineau May 31 '12

Correctomundo. Unfortunately this is how I have to defend scouting, by deemphasizing the role of the national organization in troop affairs. Some troops are bad, some troops are great, it's a regional thing. It's just a shame that the national organization (A) garners so much media attention and (B) meddles negatively in the affairs of its chartered troops.

13

u/airjavier May 31 '12

Upvoted. This needs to get close to the top. I'm an old Eagle Scout (got it in 98) At the troop level, boys of all ethnicities, and religious background (even atheists) are allowed and encouraged to join. It's not until a single narrow minded parent reports activity and complains to the top that it becomes a problem.

2

u/The_Dirty_Carl May 31 '12

It's basically a don't-ask don't-tell policy.

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

[deleted]

29

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

The BSA troop I was in let a girl join.

I have no idea why or how. But talk about weird.

50

u/GMUSSTN May 31 '12

Was it a Venture Patrol? Those are much more lax on the moral requirements and much more centered around having fun in the outdoors with older scouts. We had girls in ours--it was a blast. You got to go camping with all your friends regardless of gender.

11

u/mrva May 31 '12

or Explorer Scouts.

6

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

I have no idea. This was over a decade ago and I was 13ish. I've never heard of "Venture Patrols". As far as I know, it was a standard Boy Scouts of America Troop.

5

u/invisiblewar May 31 '12

I earned my eagle through Venture scouting. It was such a better experience than normal BSA situations. People acted normal which was never the case in normal scout troops.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

7

u/Noppers May 31 '12

It was probably a Venture patrol. Venturing is part of the BSA for youth ages 14-20 and allows girls.

6

u/reddit_user13 May 31 '12

There may be some local governance/leeway.

4

u/xJFK May 31 '12

There is. My troop had an adult who came out, and we had no problem letting him stay. He ultimately left because of pressure from our charter church. Anyway, I think each troop is allowed to have some autonomy.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Every troop is run it's own way and the national policies mean nearly diddly squat until someone with a stick up their ass tries to get you kicked out.

3

u/TheMuffnMan May 31 '12

Venture, Sea Scouts, Air Scouts, etc all allow females to join. These are all separate entities and while related to BSA are not subject to their policies.

Boy Scouts of America permits female leaders, not female members.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

19

u/AAjax May 31 '12

"The American group is entirely religious based"

Um.... This was not my experience as a boy scout... at all.

My scoutmaster was an ex-hell's angel :P

→ More replies (12)

7

u/breetai3 May 31 '12

not entirely true. You are correct on the atheist front. As far as homosexuality, their stance is homosexuals are not allowed to hold leadership positions. So it does not affect kids until higher levels. Still a stupid policy to be sure. Their official stance is ""Boy Scouting makes no effort to discover the sexual orientation of any person." So they basically have a DADT policy currently. All of which is based on the premise that atheists and homosexuals can't be morally straight, which is ABSURD.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/misplaced_my_pants May 31 '12

And this is why no child of mine will ever join them unless they change their outdated ways. No child should have to hide who he (or she) is.

And I wouldn't be opposed to a uniform change, either. Those neckerchiefs . . . .

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Takingbackmemes May 31 '12

The American group is entirely religious based

Nope. They've been more or less taken over but don't confuse their current practices with what they were actually founded on.

11

u/IAmPud May 31 '12

Before my board of review, I was told I if I said I was an atheist they would say "Well, thank you, but you are ineligible to be an eagle scout." Luckily i knew this before hand, so I had to pretend I wasn't throughout the whole process. Hell, part of getting it is having your religious leader fill out a form on your character. It makes you feel like they believe you couldn't possibly be a moral person without a god.

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Before my board I spent a little bit of time thinking about what i'd say if i was asked about my religious beliefs. I debated just saying that i was raised catholic and leaving it at that, and eventually i settled on a somewhat complicated answer about how i'm ignostic (not agnostic) and i'd come up with what i thought would be a fairly bulletproof answer that they couldn't deny me for. Then my board came and went and no one bothered to ask about it or look into it at all.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (59)

41

u/tdobson May 31 '12

Zach Wahls is a legend.

Reddit AMA's

His Iowa speech

6

u/misplaced_my_pants May 31 '12

And don't forget he was on the Daily Show a few weeks ago to promote his book.

1

u/franklyimshocked May 31 '12

He's being pushed to the front as a leader and I think he has some very good qualities.

→ More replies (1)

235

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

How about changing its anti-Atheist policy?

143

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

My son was in Cub Scouts and it was fine because it was run by a group of parents using (public) school facilities, and they went out of their way to make it as secular as possible. There were still "faith" requirements to get the various badges, but it was all up to the parents to sign off on those parts while the leaders took their word for it.

When he was old enough to move to Boy Scouts, though, it was a whole different story. Literally every Boy Scout troop in my area is run through a church of some kind, and the religious part of it is much more overt. It's still not the central focus, but it's definitely much harder to avoid. We eventually stopped going because the whole thing was so uncomfortable.

So yeah, the Boy Scouts is a religious organization, much more so than it was when I was a kid. I'm not sure how much that varies by area, but around here being an atheist boy scout requires being "in the closet" just as much as being a gay boy scout does.

103

u/GMUSSTN May 31 '12

I was lucky enough to be in a non-religious troop. Greatest experiences of my life growing up were spent in the scouts. Hopefully by the time I have kids the organization will have become much more accepting.

42

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

I was part of a non-religious troop as well, although we still required "spiritual stuff", which no one really minded. When we went to Philmont, someone had to be Chaplain's Aide, and since no one was terribly religious, we picked out of a hat. I got chosen, and led all the Vespers each night. I actually loved doing it.

That being said, I can't imagine being forced to be in a troop that is of a certain religion. Scouting shouldn't be associated with religion.

43

u/GMUSSTN May 31 '12

Well tell that to the Mormons, who seem to be intent on making it a Mormon organization. Then again, they also want the whole world to be Mormon, but that's another argument for another time.

35

u/misplaced_my_pants May 31 '12

Why can't they just posthumously baptize us and leave us the hell alone while we're alive?

→ More replies (7)

10

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Heh. Our troop had the laziest an most politically correct chaplains aid. For every prayer after troop meetings

"would everyone please bow their heads for a moment of silence?"

36

u/genericname12345 May 31 '12

You know, even though I'm an atheist, I have absolutely no issue with having moment of silence times. I think it is a perfect happy medium. Religious people are able to pray if they wish, while non-religious people can use the time to reflect on things.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/Cheat2Lose May 31 '12

I think it really just depend on the area of the country and/or the individual troop. I'm from the Northeast and we were based out of the local AOH hall. The only time religious services were required was at summer camp where usually there was a Catholic service and a Protestant service once a week. None of the merit badges I got were religious in nature, but they did have a religious knot you could get in your particular religion if you wanted to, but was completely optional.

15

u/dubsideofmoon May 31 '12

I think that's just a bad experience in your area. The BSA is faith-based without being actually religious... as in, members can be any religion they choose. I'm sorry to hear that every single Troop met at a church - usually, everyone can find a secular Troop within driving.

17

u/Rudacris May 31 '12

We met at a church and had absolutely no involvement from the church. They welcomed us into their facilities and never bothered us. In return we did one troop project per year to help them out with landscaping or similar things.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (10)

46

u/rotll May 31 '12

One of the things scouting claims to be is a "reverent" organization. They do not promote any single religion or god. In the United Staes, Buddhists, Hindus, and Jains are all acceptable to BSA even though they do not worship a god. Atheists, however, need not apply. My 8 years as a leader, cub master, committee chairman, and stepfather to two scouts was, as an atheist, rather enlightening.

Source

37

u/dubsideofmoon May 31 '12

You need to believe in a higher power. This can include atheism depending on how you approach it. Our organization greatly discourages any sort of proselytizing. To be "reverent" means to have a great feeling of awe and respect - in the case of an atheist, this can be awe and respect either toward humanity, nature, or science (for example.)

If you are wondering my credentials on speaking about this, I work professionally for the BSA and have been coached to answer in this way.

23

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

My dad once told me about how my grandfather claimed the higher power he believed in was a doorknob. His reasoning was that, if you tripped and hit your head on it, you could die.

14

u/dubsideofmoon May 31 '12

That's awesome. My boss said "A boy can believe in that oak tree out there in the yard. He just have to believe in it. We don't care if he believes in God or not."

I hope the rest of the organization can reach this point, then the Boy Scouts can be saved.

p.s. we also have a different gay policy than the National Office.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Is believing in the laws of Physics acceptable?

I was lucky enough to be involved with a troop that was essentially non-religious when I was younger. We even had a gay member. Some of the best times of my childhood were spent with those guys with no mention of religion.

→ More replies (8)

10

u/rotll May 31 '12

And I bet you don't live here in Mississippi!! (grin!) I appreciate this type of response and wish it were applied equally across all councils.

9

u/dubsideofmoon May 31 '12

Indeed - I am in one of the most progressive Councils, our Council is trying to get National to understand why we do things the way we do and why our organization needs to be more progressive.

Yeah, I heard in Mississippi there are people who think Scouting should still be race-segregated.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (6)

5

u/RandomChance May 31 '12

Hinduism is polytheistic and does involve worship of divinities and their manifestations. (If you want to get very very technical, its monotheistic/pantheist in that all is the one and the one is all, and all the Gods are manifestations of THE God/Wholeness of all, but that is more a scholarly thing than day to day practice)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

13

u/TheUsualChaos May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12

It's important to note (before this becomes some kind of flame war) that these policies are really a regional thing. There was a discussion on Reddit several months ago where I learned that some troops really do discriminate based on articles of faith or sexuality, and this came as a huge surprise for me.

The troop I grew up in over in NJ was nothing like the horror stories that we hear from troops in the deep south where the BSA is less progressive.

→ More replies (9)

6

u/leftajar May 31 '12

I was fortunate enough to be part of a secular-leaning scout troop. But I do remember, when my Scoutmaster was helping me prepare for my Eagle Board of Review, he pulled me aside and, in quiet tones, explained how I was going to have to fake being religious.

And then I did the act and achieved the rank.

Kinda sucked, though. I mean, a scout is supposed to be trustworthy and reverent. As a young atheist, I had to pick one. "On my honor, I will do my best, to do my duty to god..."

→ More replies (1)

15

u/ErrorF002 May 31 '12

One step at a time.

2

u/sTiKyt May 31 '12

Just like how LGBT civil rights was effective by only worrying about the rights and safety each group sequentially. We need to stand divided, not united. We need focus on getting gays in scouts now so we can finally stop caring about this whole issue.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/dukec May 31 '12

Yup. I was kicked out of the boy scouts when I was 13 because that's when I figured out I was an atheist. I'm not too pissed about it because the troop leader at the time had just taken over a year earlier from an amazing troop leader who moved, and the new guy was just some kids overly religious dad who knew jack shit about anything related to the boy scouts.

2

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

relevant to my interests. (I'm an eagle scout too)

7

u/troissandwich May 31 '12

Came here to say this. If I ever "came out" over my (lack of) religion I would have been kicked out just the same as those that come out sexually. It seems somewhat hypocritical for people to defend one while downvoting the other.

7

u/tboner6969 May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12

maybe in your troop. mine would have just not cared at all, no matter how gay or atheist a kid was. but maybe I was lucky.

the discrimination in BSA seems to be mainly up to the leadership which varies from troop to troop. I haven't seen much application or enforcement of discriminatory BSA policies from the top-down, aside from their official stances or statements.

for the whiny ones out there, no, this comment does not mean that I endorse discriminatory policies of organizations or find such policies excusable.

what I am saying is the boy scout leadership that I knew growing up is not the discriminatory beast waiting to throw the hammer down and boot out gay or atheist kids from their troop. but of course my opinion doesn't cater to this sites' narrative of the BSA being an oppressive authority figures over kids so downvotes awayyyyyy

6

u/yourdadsbff May 31 '12

Did you read the article? This whole petition got launched because a den mother was removed from her position in a Boy Scouts troop because of her sexual orientation.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/quintios May 31 '12

I was of the understanding that this was a Christianity-based organization? Is that not correct?

28

u/aedile May 31 '12

Incorrect. The scouting movement was founded in 1908 by Robert Baden-Powell as a way to increase citizenship and develop character. While religion has often been a part of it, it isn't christian-specific. The BSA (the american branch of the international scouting movement) has basically been hijacked by the LDS (aka mormons) so the national leadership has a heavy christian bent to it.

→ More replies (14)

12

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

That doesn't mean it has to be Christian exclusive. For example: Christian schools allow atheists to enrol.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (14)

1

u/dougbdl May 31 '12

Mormons.

1

u/whiskeytango55 Jun 01 '12

To be fair, most religions aren't down with gays either

→ More replies (22)

30

u/Xanthan81 May 31 '12

As an Eagle Scout, this guy makes me proud.

14

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

As a gay Eagle Scout, I am also proud of this man.

5

u/Rileyswims May 31 '12

As a gay atheist eagle scout, me too.

1

u/miyatarama Jun 01 '12

Fellow supportive eagle scout checking in.

→ More replies (12)

6

u/THE_GREAT_SHAZBOT May 31 '12

I think that this link is interesting to see how much religion has taken the Boy Scouts hostage.

"When it comes to funding, at the troop level most groups aren't exactly rolling in the dough; everything they receive goes right to the scouts (as it should). So when it comes to finding a location for a troop to organize, they look for someone to sponsor them, to take the scouts in and use their space as their own. Sometimes these are schools or other federal buildings. But overwhelmingly the troops are sponsored by churches, with 68.4% of all scout units chartered sponsored by a religious group. Units referring to scout troops, cub packs, and venture crews."

"What scares me is that the churches, on a national level, have used their sheer numbers to adjust scouting's policies to fit that of the church's views."

"the Mormon church went so far as officially stating that in the event the Boy Scouts admitted homosexual men, the LDS church would immediately withdraw all support from the organization. "Should the LDS Church leave the program, it would take more than 400,000 Scouts and 30,000 scout troops with it."

It is sick and disgusting that such organizations have this much of an influence over the BSA. It is one of, it not the best organizations for a kid to be in.

10

u/yelloueze May 31 '12

Likely, nothing will happen, sadly. I am an Eagle Scout as well, but religion is too enshrined in the Boy Scouts. The organization is hugely popular with the Mormon community and their influence will keep progressive changes from happening on the national level. I am sure local troops will allow gay/atheist members and leaders, but I think it is unlikely to change nation-wide.

115

u/CheesyGoodness May 31 '12

The young man is extremely well-spoken, and good for him for standing up for what he believes in, obviously he has an extremely bright future.

However, I have an inherent dislike for trying to force individuals or private groups to change (for lack of a better term) their "core beliefs", no matter how misguided the mainstream or the hivemind thinks those beliefs may be. I guess my thinking is that, if they want to be stupid, let them be stupid and keep living in the 1950s, they will become less and less relevant. They already are.

But things like this seem to me as if the group (change.org) is saying, "you don't think like we do, so we're going to try to force you to think like we do." Anytime someone tries to force morality on someone else, it grates on me.

42

u/jamkey May 31 '12 edited Jun 01 '12

You do realize the guy that raised the signatures is an Eagle scout, right? Thus the title and his silly uniform (I can make fun of it as I used to wear one as a kid). He's trying to make changes from the inside. That's not exactly forcing your values on another group, it's showing that the people withIN the group don't necessarily agree with the stance.

EDIT: grammar

2

u/ilovetacos Jun 01 '12

Thank you! I was about to post just that.

56

u/klaruz May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12

I'm an Eagle, and a few decades ago the scouts were not like that at all. There's been a large effort on the part of certain church to take over a lot of the BSA. Between that and the conservative tard revival that swept the country in general, the BSA has been hijacked. There's a ton of great things about scouting that don't revolve around what a minority of leadership that has attained power believes are important. It's up to people who still think the organization is worth saving to convince those in power to either change their mind, or get out of the way. I do hope it can be saved, but their hard line stance really alienated a lot of people like yourself, and that damage is going to be very hard to undo.

→ More replies (12)

22

u/TheUsualChaos May 31 '12

I guess my thinking is that, if they want to be stupid, let them be stupid and keep living in the 1950s, they will become less and less relevant. They already are

If you watched the video, you'll see how he talks about this point specifically. One of his drivers is that he wants the BSA to change because it IS an awesome organization when you take away the anti-athiest/lbgt policies (many troops already do this on their own). By showing executive leadership that it's time to change, they allow the organization to continue to exist and provide many benefits for young kinds w/o all the antiquated point of views.

Keep in mind that even though it was first brought up on change.org, this scout who is A PART OF the BSA, is the one who went and got all those signatures. He is affecting change in something he is a part of and believes in. I don't see how any sensible person could be opposed to that.

10

u/mindbleach May 31 '12

Exclusion is not a "core belief" in scouting. Rejecting boys for traits they cannot control and probably don't fully understand is pointless and cruel. Even if homosexuality is seen as a tendency toward 'moral unfitness,' inclination is not action, and every gay virgin who's had to lie for their Eagle is being taught entirely the wrong lessons.

The BSA is treated as more than a private organization by the government, especially by the military. It is openly respected by congress and given preferential treatment on bases at home and overseas. Until such time as it stops mandating religious belief (however broadly) and kicking people out based on blatantly religious dogma, it should be out on its ass with every other church.

Anyway, a petition is hardly forcing anyone to do anything. What's your preferred method of enacting change - groveling?

6

u/thehackattack May 31 '12

I have an inherent dislike for trying to force individuals or private groups

That's irrelevant. The BSA is not currently a private organization. The BSA receives money and favors and the expense of taxpayers to promote scouting. I actually don't have an issue with this, as long as the group isn't discriminatory. But the BSA is, so one of two things needs to happen for the situation to right itself. The BSA either needs to end their discriminatory practices, or stop taking favors from the government on local, state, and national levels.

This isn't about forcing morality on a private group, this is about forcing morality on a group that wants to continue receiving the benefits of being a publicly funded group. If the BSA wants to continue their discriminatory practices, they can start paying actual rent to use public spaces, stop running troops out of public schools, and give up their status as a paramilitary organization to fast-track a military career for their members, etc.

9

u/strolls May 31 '12

The young man is extremely well-spoken,

The young man is a redditor - clearly we're all like that. ;)

/u/zachwahls

8

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Jesus, it's like this kid was made in a lab for reddit. Next thing you know we'll find out he's just a bunch of kittens in a man suit.

6

u/sTiKyt May 31 '12

Has everyone gone insane? Asking someone to change their organization with a petition doesn't equal "forcing" them to change. There's no legislation, there's no banning, there's no government. Your point is completely null.

2

u/steve-d May 31 '12

Those in charge of groups like this don't represent the entire group though. There may be tons of scouts that want their gay friends and classmates to join but due to those running the organization, they aren't allowed.

Not everyone in the organization is anti-gay so I think this is worth pursuing.

2

u/ecchimaru May 31 '12

I had great times in scouts all the way through eagle. In my troop and in most troops faith is not the focus, leadership and camping is.

2

u/wjbc May 31 '12

You forget that this is a Scout trying to change the Scouts. He cares because he is a Scout. He doesn't want the organization to be stupid and become irrelevant.

2

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

He might have a bigger stock in this because, as an Eagle scout, it's his organization that's screwing this up. There's no merit in being an Eagle scout if the organization is nothing but a bunch of mouth-breathing homophobic zealot yokels.

3

u/cole1114 May 31 '12

I'd like to take an unrelated thing, and make it related. Let's say that there's a big chain grocery store in your town. This grocery store has all this cool stuff, fresh veggies, organic meat, etc. But it refuses to sell your particular favorite food. There's a much smaller local grocery store nearby, that sells the same stuff on a lower level. However, it also sells your favorite food. Hypothetically, you should switch to the smaller local grocery store.

That's what this is. If the Boy Scouts don't change their anti-gay policy, fine. They aren't required to. But there are plenty of alternatives. So hey, maybe you change how you run your business so that you don't lose it.

2

u/PropMonkey May 31 '12

Alternatives? Like... the girl scouts?!?

Do any of the alternatives give you an automatic pay-grade bump in any branch of the U.S. armed services after you graduate, as well? Because that's a nice touch to the boy scouts (and not the only touch a boy scout might encounter either..).

3

u/cole1114 May 31 '12

So you get a few extra sales at Mondo-Con, the largest retail store in America. But the only place you can buy fruits, vegetables, or any other good-for-you foods is the Localson's General Store. Which do you pick?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

4

u/ConnorTheDinosaur May 31 '12

That was an amazing speech and that gay couple raised a son who is less flawed in his character and is already a greater contributor to society than man twice his age. I aspire to be like him and hope to one day shake his hand.

11

u/orthonym May 31 '12

As an Eagle Scout, I say that's awesome. My only question is, why didn't I get the chance to sign it?

3

u/scottyah May 31 '12

It wasn't through any scouting channels, it was on a gay rights-like website

8

u/Pseudonyms May 31 '12

I may have just come from a more progressive area but I never noticed any types of anti-gay (or anti-atheist for that matter) activities happen in my local council. I am an Eagle Scout (and also an atheist), and when you participate in the final "Board of Review" for the rank there is a religious portion. My reviewers almost entirely ignored it.

It is just interesting to see how local charters are different from area councils and then national councils. I do disagree with the universal stance they have on many things and would be very interested to see what happens because of this.

14

u/aedile May 31 '12

I almost failed my board because I said that atheists and gays should be in the scouts. One guy in particular grilled me on this for like thirty minutes. I walked out, sure that I wouldn't get Eagle, but they came out and congratulated me. The dude who had grilled me said he disagreed with me, but he was glad that I had strong opinions and stood by them. Another guy said if I had backed off so much as an inch, he would have voted against.

5

u/Pseudonyms May 31 '12

That's really interesting, actually. Thanks for sharing your story from another district.

3

u/Kennedy_190 May 31 '12

Not just any Eagle Scout. Zach Wahls. That man is going places.

3

u/Cheat2Lose May 31 '12

Based on my experience, what a kid gets out of scouting depends greatly on the adult leadership that is running the troop. If you have leaders that don't care, don't plan camping trips and other events, and generally can't keep the troop active and organized, you're gonna have a bad time. My troop made sure we went camping once a month, went to summer camp every year and focused on advancement (the motto was First Class, First Year). I got my Eagle was I was 15, but stuck around until I was 18 because I wanted to help out the younger kids and be a part of the troop. None of this would have happened without strong adult leadership. If there's someone who is gay who wants to be involved and wants to help out, it would be a shame to deny them based solely on their sexual orientation.

2

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

This man speaks the truth.

3

u/breetai3 May 31 '12

I'm seeing a lot of confusion on this issue. Wikipedia has a nice page that sums up all the official positions on it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boy_Scouts_of_America_membership_controversies

3

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

As an Eagle Scout, I feel obligated to help this fine venture. Anyone have any further information on how to help?

1

u/ZombieBroad May 31 '12

Sign the petition and spread the word!

3

u/sicklaxbro May 31 '12

This guy is a redditor! He did an ama when he was going to go on the daily show for his book two moms. Link to original ama link to second ama

7

u/iamfromreallife May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12

Aren't the boy scouts a non profit organisation funded by private donations? If so, people who disagree with them just have to not donate. You can't make them change their policies if they don't want it, because they aren't a state sponsored organisation. I'm from Europe and got my info on wikipedia, so I could be wrong course...

6

u/rnelsonee May 31 '12

Before a lawsuit a few years ago, a few hundred chapters did receive funds from the government. It wasn't a big conspiracy - it was local facilities like military bases "sponsoring" local groups.

Although that's ended, the Boy Scouts still receives above-board (as in, it's openly acknowledged) preferential treatment from some government agencies (use of land for events, for example, including taxpayer-funded assistance in setting up such events), so there's still some mixing going on. With so many local chapters and past involvement with the government, it's hard to completely disassociate the two entities.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

They may not be a state sponsored organization, but they very frequently get assistance from taxpayers in the form of free (or heavily subsidized) meeting space. So if they aren't going to change their policies they should not be receiving subsidized rent in public schools, etc.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/UnapologeticalyAlive May 31 '12

How about if those 275,000 people just dropped out of the organization? That would send a much clearer message than a petition.

37

u/genthree May 31 '12

The problem is that the Boy Scouts provide an excellent experience that is very hard to find elsewhere. I'm certain that 275,000 people wanting the organization to stop being bigoted does not translate to 275,000 people willing to lose the scouting experience. The best solution would be an alternate organization who provides the same services, but without the bullshit.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/John_Barleycorn May 31 '12

It isn't 275,000 current and former scouts that want the policy changed. It's just a bunch of internet activists who signed a petition on Change.org. I'll bet virtually none of them were ever in the program.

5

u/UnapologeticalyAlive May 31 '12

Yeah, that possibility occurred to me, too. As if the leaders of the boy counts give a crap what 275,000 non-members think of them.

3

u/scottyah May 31 '12

Yea, I somehow doubt Ellen Degeneres was ever a boy scout.

4

u/Andernerd May 31 '12

Girls can become Boy Scouts if they join a Venturing Crew. I actually know an Ellen that was in one.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/jhontheunmortal May 31 '12

From my perspective as an Eagle Scout, it's a fine example of what happens when leadership and policy-making is left in the hands of anyone other than the current membership. My troop was lead and directed entirely by the youths, the adult leaders were just there for the sake of appearance. We decided what we wanted to do, planned the events, prepared, carried them out and cleaned up afterwards. Why can't something similar be done for the organization as a whole? Let the kids decide, the entire organization is about them anyway.

2

u/rotll May 31 '12

That's how "Boy" Scouts is supposed to work, and the troop I was a leader in stressed this. I was primarily a Webelos leader, and we encouraged them to lead themselves as well. Each and every boy that left our pack and decided to continue in scouting was ready for his tenderfoot badge on day one as a Boy Scout.

1

u/Neckwrecker May 31 '12

Let the kids decide

Yeah, somehow I don't have the utmost faith in teenage boys on this one.

Speaking from experience as a long-time scout.

2

u/tubcat Jun 01 '12

With proper adult mentoring, self-monitoring skills, and senior (teen) leadership, kids can make GREAT choices. The key is teaching them great foundations and then giving them just enough supervision to succeed on their own. It's also VERY important to keep older trained kids around. The senior staff in my troop micro managed during the course of most events and trips with very minimal adult direction. But, that youth leadership can break down easily and things go to bunk quickly.

4

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Zach Wahls never ceases to amaze me. We love you, Zach, keep fighting the good fight. :)

4

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Just a reminder, these rules are only enforced in some troops. Think of it like selective incorporation. In my troop in Nor Cal (like Oregon border Nor Cal) where almost everyone is conservative and christian, we have a number of athiest scouts and a few homosexual scouts.

I am a man of faith but my best friend in the troop isn't. At his Eagle Board of Review, the Mormon dude who runs those things tried bringing it up but the other people on the board told him off.

I am really annoyed by one of the gay scouts but that's just because he is an immature 8th grader. His mom's are really cool though and are very nice people.

4

u/haggs May 31 '12

That kid is the fucking man.. as a 26 year old straight guy.. he motivates me to do more for LBGT rights. Nothing infuriates me more than people not giving people the rights of other people.

2

u/misplaced_my_pants May 31 '12

He's another 20-something straight guy. He has two moms.

Pretty badass how he's taken on this fight, though.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/gynoceros May 31 '12

Offbeat... Or awesome?

11

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Personally, I think the boy scouts are outdated and cannot be changed as they have been taken over by the Mormon church. I think we should start a new boy scout like organization that teaches the same stuff, but more liberal and accepting of others.

Also, I'm an eagle scout.

20

u/danchan22 May 31 '12

You mean like Spiral Scouts?

Pete Davis, the founder of Spiral Scouts: "There needs to be a group that will include all children and families, regardless of creed, color, gender, or sexual orientation. Boys and girls should learn together, just like in the real world, not segregating little soldiers over here and little homemakers over there.”

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Your tent is the tent that will tame the wilderness!

5

u/jamkey May 31 '12

The fact that they are founded by Wiccans does not bode well for their PR. She's a witch!

1

u/billin May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12

I was just thinking that. But what would it be named? Should we go for brand confusion, e.g. the Goy Scouts? I guess using an offensive term for non-Jews isn't really giving across the all-inclusive vibe we want....

I think we might have to keep "The Boy [x]" to mirror The Girl Scouts, who rock. Hmm...

I was thinking the Pathfinders, but it's taken.

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

[deleted]

6

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Not overtly, but the influence is definitely great- many high-up Mormon leaders have spoken extensively about Boy Scouting's merits, and the church does officially support the program (whereas it does not support Girl Scouts in the same way, likely because of the Girl Scouts' liberal bent). The relationship between the two is often most obvious at the local level, because nearly every Mormon congregation will charter a Boy Scout troop. Both organizations are highly conservative, against gay rights, and put a strong emphasis on traditional families and whatnot.

Source: Experience in a Mormon scout troop, Eagle Scout, etc.

5

u/Andernerd May 31 '12

They haven't been "taken over" but something like 20% of BSA members are Mormon. Obviously that results in a lot of influence.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/strolls May 31 '12

The Eagle Scout in question is a redditor, and has done a couple of AMAs in the past: /u/zachwahls

2

u/immortalsix May 31 '12

That's not just some Eagle Scout - that's ZACH FUCKING WAHLS!!!

2

u/invisiblewar May 31 '12

Good luck to him. I hope that he can make this happen. I really hope that Boy Scouts of America can make some serious changes in a lot of their policies. This needs to be the first of many.

2

u/ZombieBroad May 31 '12

I typed out this comment a million times and I guess all I wanted to express was how proud of Jen I was and still am! Our town really came together to support her so I guess for once in my life, I'm proud of them too.

2

u/Salty-Sailor May 31 '12

His moms must be very proud of him. I am.

2

u/maxd May 31 '12

Zach Wahls for president 2016.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12

uh, give it a few more years than that. But still, I agree Zack Wahls for president 20XX

2

u/somerandomguy02 May 31 '12

Oh my! A private organization that has its own beliefs! Get them!!!!!!!!!!!

2

u/AwesomeOrca Jun 01 '12

I'm a Eagle Scout and favor Gay marriage but the Scouts will be among the last organizations in the country to relax about this issue. Almost Every troop in the country meets in a church, 40% of the board is LDS and the largest Friends of Scouting Donors are almost all LDS too. The internal politics of BSA just don't allow leadership any flexibly.

4

u/tdrules May 31 '12

First his Iowa speech now this, I can see him going very far.

1

u/misplaced_my_pants May 31 '12

Don't forget the Daily Show!

3

u/aforu May 31 '12

"The Boy Scouts of America teaches its members to treat those with different opinions with courtesy and respect at all times," and then calmly inform them that they will be going to hell, and that they're not welcome here.

3

u/Rockshell May 31 '12

Eagle Scout here, and while I agree that it is unfair for gays to be excluded from the program, I'm surprised no one has mentioned that there are other underlying reasons for this.

The first is the same reason that Boy scouts and Girl scouts are separate. Think about it from a parent's perspective if it was co-ed, sending your 13-17 year old girl off on a 3-day camping trip with a bunch of guys the same age? I doubt i'd let that fly and your parents probably wouldn't either. It sucks that girls are just as excluded as gays are but allowing girls into boy scouts doesn't solve that, re-vamping girl scouts does.

-This brings up an interesting point about discovering sexuality, when a boy does make the discovery that he is attracted to other boys (which I would think would happen around the same time he would be looking to join or is already involved in scouting) how would he be treated within scouts? Do you make them sleep in a separate tent like you would with a girl? Knowing this would he risk being alienated from his other friends in the troop? Does it matter as long as the other boys he's sleeping with are straight? As far as I can tell, it isn't the program that is alienating gays from boy scouts it's our perspective on sex in general. Boys aren't keeping the closet door closed because they'll get kicked out, they're doing it because it would alienate them from their friends and possibly even ruin their friend's opportunities as well.

The second is again, the parents. Disregarding all the bigots that would pull their child out of scouting simply upon discovering that there was a gay boy in the troop. Say your son hasn't quite discovered his sexuality yet, would you really want him discovering that a hundred miles away in a tent and probably without cell-phone coverage? It's pretty shaky imo. Remember when there was a whole scandal with troop leaders molesting Scouts on camping trips? this is the same issue except adults are easier to separate from the boys

The only way I can see this working is if there is constant monitoring of the scouts day and night, with some kind assurance for the parents that nothing bad will happen. Which by itself goes against the idea of the program which is to teach independence, responsibility, and character to the boys. As well as allowing them opportunities to learn and experience things that they never would have.

Idk, this goes pretty deep for me, we either have to all accept that we will always be separated depending on sexuality or we all have to accept that our kids will have sex and trust them to be able to accept responsibility for their actions... Or we monitor our children's lives constantly and mercilessly.

TL;DR - If gays no longer face the same separation that girls do from the program the next logical step is to allow girls to join and earn the same achievements, which would be a good thing, equal opportunity. However, how do we get parents to agree to let their child go on a camping trip where they could very possibly have sex with another child? (while still allowing the values that Boy Scouts tries to instill to form?)

3

u/reply May 31 '12

Gay is the new black.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/rotll May 31 '12

Eventually, I hope, sexual orientation will be treated no differently than a person's race or religion. Zach is spot on in his approach, and he is a credit to BSA while trying to change it for the better.

3

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

I really didn't like the Boy Scouts of America, thinking that all of the scoutmasters and such were pretty biggoted, stuck-up old men. Especially after watching Pen and Teller's Bullshit take on the whole anti-gay, anti-atheist, anti-anythingbutachristianfamily thing. Well, the company I work for catered to a large Boy Scouts dinner, and for the first time since I had worked there, the head guy pulled our supervisor to the side and gave her a fifty dollar tip for each worker (there was only three.) Still, I was aghast. I've worked hundreds of dinners and that was the first time I had gotten a tip. He also shook my hand and told us how good of a job we were doing. Still, I felt dirty taking the money, but when you work minimum wage and live an hour away from your job, every bit counts.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12

What about their anti-atheist policy?

1

u/faatbuddha May 31 '12

I'm pretty impressed by his eloquence. I'm also proud to say my signature is included in that box! Here's hoping...

1

u/octaffle May 31 '12

Tongue-in-cheek remark: It's funny they made the lesbian step down as scout leader... seems like by introducing a straight woman to the all-male troop, chances of sexual abuse should increase significantly!

1

u/Cheat2Lose May 31 '12

Zach Wahls also appeared on The Daily Show a few weeks ago to talk about his book "My Two Moms" which is about growing up with, well, two moms. It's actually broken down into sections based on the 12 tenets of The Scout Law.

1

u/zaulus May 31 '12

Doesn't matter how many signatures they have, BSA will not back down from their stance. I dont necessarily agree with that , but it's just something they're never going to change.

1

u/JessicaMaple May 31 '12

I think I have a crush.

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

This kid again? Well, we might as well just start right away.

Zach Wahls 2036!

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Why doesn't someone create their own Open Boy Scouts thats allows everyone and then the original Boy Scouts will look stupid.

1

u/magritte May 31 '12

As a gay eagle scout, I approve.

1

u/golfingmadman May 31 '12

Where do I sign?

1

u/gthing May 31 '12

You can either look like the good guy and change your policy at the beginning of the civil rights movement, or you can look like an idiot and change it at the end. Your pick.

1

u/DaneGretzky May 31 '12

Hey, that's our friend from The Daily Show! That guy is fucking awesome!

1

u/notjawn May 31 '12

I really don't think they'll change the policy because the controversy only arose after they uncovered a bunch of molestation cases that were covered up. Now they kind of take it overboard if they find out someone's orientation because they're afraid they'll link it to the cover ups of the molestation cases.

1

u/franklyimshocked May 31 '12

Faith in Humanity slightly restored. Regardless of the outcome the message is out there and change will happen

1

u/falconear May 31 '12

I wish it would change. I was in cub scouts/boy scouts and it was a mostly positive experience. But I have no intention of putting my son in scouts as long as they maintain their homophobic and religiously biased stances. Anybody know of a good alternative?

1

u/reclaimer May 31 '12

One of my first gay encounters was in the BSA... Guess their policy doesn't really work when you put a bunch of pubescent boys together in tents all night...

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Fuck it man.

This guy for President.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12

Looking at the straightest looking man ever in a boy scout uniform made me realize how gay boy scout uniforms look. They would be perfect for someone gay to wear.

1

u/nolenk8t Jun 01 '12

i watched about 2 seconds before I knew this was the same kid who addressed the Iowa legislature some time ago. He's got my vote for next president.

1

u/chefanubis Jun 01 '12

I'm completely LGBT friendly but as far as I know the Boy Scouts are a "privately owned social club", their policies (outdated as they may be) are their own bussines, we should not demand them to change if they dont want to.

If you don't like their policies then just don't enroll your kids in there, enroll them somewhere else less homophobic and let the organization die out like all the other vestiges of our bigoted past as a society.

1

u/ShackelfordRusty Jun 01 '12

If you really want to make everyone happy leave it up to individual troops.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12

They can't segregate if they are going to start doing sexual favors for eachother away from adult supervision. They need to be trusted to do the right thing

1

u/HiddenKrypt Jun 01 '12

Good luck with that. Things won't change while the LDS is the biggest donator to the BSA. Like many things in life what seems like political ideology is really just a desire for money.

1

u/bananafish707 Jun 13 '12

In my Eagle-board, they asked if I "...could change one thing in scouts what would it be?" I told them let gays in and I didn't know it at the time but it almost cost me my eagle. Half the board was fundie Mormon. The head guy was visibly disturbed but I couldn't really figure it out till many weeks later. Now I'm an atheist-pro gay- Eagle scout and I don't mind telling friends in company about it. One day. If I new about it I totally would have signed. I'm from CA but I'd love to know how bad the religiosity is in other states. I could only fathon.

I remember being a star scout talking to my head master. I was a deist /reformed jewish kid and when I asked if atheists could be eagle scouts I remember distinctly that he said they lacked the morals to do the right thing when necessary.

looking back i shudder to think about it.

1

u/The_Derek May 31 '12

Got my Eagle in 2002, we had atheists and gays in our troop, I think that its more political than anything.

1

u/Vhu May 31 '12

They're not a public organization; they don't have to do a damn thing.

1

u/captainmcr May 31 '12

Too bad this means fuck all, Boy Scouts are private.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12

Fuck that. You know what? There should be just "Scouts." Any gender--male, female, transgender--would be able to join, it'd be completely secular, and everyone would be able to do the same scouting activities if they wanted to. Not just cookie selling and crafts for girls, while the boys camp and tie knots. Fucking everyone should have the opportunity to Scout however the fuck they want! That's an organization that I'd enroll my kid into.

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

I used to be so proud of my Eagle Scoutdom.

5

u/scottyah May 31 '12

You did a lot of things to become an Eagle, why would you become less proud just because the people who make rules are discriminatory?

→ More replies (3)