r/nativeamericanflutes • u/Miserable_Idea7090 • Oct 30 '25
I’m a confused and a little heartbroken player…
I started learning NAF in February, so it’s been nearly 9 months of playing every day, practicing every day, I’ve inhaled every YouTube and other tutorials and I’ve progressed a lot! I’ve played in my local park and a few people have stopped to listen and a few compliment. I’ve made TikToks and gotten a decent amount of views…(not thousands…often a 100-200).
My husband is a pro musician, I respect him a lot, he’s played everything from classical to jazz to pop gigs…he knows his stuff but nothing about wind instruments. At 1st, he was very encouraging of my music, but last week, I asked what he thought of my playing (been working on jazz scale…I think it sounds good!) and he said it sounded as though I was ‘practicing’. I asked for more specifics, he blew me off. it’s not the 1st time he’s been dismissive, but I’m also finding that my ‘audience’ for my playing has been overall pretty lukewarm-warm. I give sound baths as part of my work, and no one has really complimented, well, anything individually. Online response has been polite…only a few ‘enthusiastic’.
Am I deluding myself that I am a good player? Am I one of those poor souls who thinks they can sing, then gets laughed off the stage on tv?
Full disclosure, I have played/studied Rav drums, zills, a little piano, so I have some musical training. Playing for small audiences has always been a goal (think sound baths, yoga classes, small gatherings etc). But when I practice at home, in my backyard, in my hallway, I play also just for me and I love it…but…am I meant only to play for me? How do we know when we’re any good…or am I embarrassing myself and annoying the local birds?
(ADDED TO SAY…my ‘heartbroken‘ title was about not going forward as a player ‘in public’ because I fear I’m not very good. I love playing and I love playing for others…but without the knowledge that I’m on the right path…meh. I might distance myself from playing…and that would break my heart…)
With the terrifying changes in our country right now, I’m not able to spend on a teacher’s lessons…so that feedback’s just not possible…otherwise open for suggestions…
(video of me heavily masked, a little echo and a droning backing track)