r/muacjdiscussion • • Apr 01 '19

What do you think of Ivanka Trump's new makeup brand?

2.9k Upvotes

Given how busy she supposedly is working at the White House, I was surprised to see the announcement for Ivanka Trump’s new makeup line. She is obviously a separate person from her father, but given that she is still working for him and campaigning for his reelection I am still reluctant to purchase from the brand. I don’t think that single-person boycotts are an effective political tactic but I still don’t like the idea of using something that has her name on it.

To be fair, I do have to admit that a few of the items are a bit tempting. The Mar-a-Lago bronzer has a gorgeous satin finish and is light with a warm olive undertone. Her Private Jet blush also has a satin finish and is a very pretty light nude shade. (In swatches it looks pretty similar to Clinique Nude Pop.) Unfortunately there is only one shade of each type of item so far and they are pretty expensive so they won’t necessarily work for people with deeper skintones or who have have lower incomes. The eyeshadow palette has similar issues with inclusivity but has much worse quality. Most of the shades are light to light-medium and there is only one token dark shade to add depth. The lighter shades take up almost all of the palette. Mother is a cool ivory, Billionaire is a warm beige, and Alt-Right, Fascist, Racial Realist, Racist, and Neo-Nazi are basically all the same shade of white. I appreciate that they did include a black shade, but HUD secretary Ben Carson is pretty patchy and doesn’t do its job effectively. At first I was intrigued by the highlighter because it looked like it would be blue with a silver shift, but after the overspray is removed ((((((((Stephen Miller)))))))) is has basically the same effect as most of the shades from the I Was Chosen Purely Based on Merit palette.


r/muacjdiscussion • • Feb 04 '19

I’m kinda disappointed all the top MUAs are men

2.6k Upvotes

I get that it seems progressive to have male make up artists being mainstream and successful, but honestly I just see this as men taking the top spot in every single industry. Like I get traditionally feminine roles such as cooking and homemaking could easily be enjoyed by men so it makes sense they would be successful. But makeup? Like the one industry almost exclusive to women? We can’t have one damn thing lol


r/muacjdiscussion • • Jun 08 '18

Kat von D is an antivaxxer, apparently

2.1k Upvotes

According to her latest Instagram post, she's not vaccinating her child. As an immunocompromised person, I'm not sure I can continue to support her after this.

Does this affect what you think about her? Are you going to continue buying her products?


r/muacjdiscussion • • Mar 18 '19

CHINA ENDS ANIMAL TESTING REQUIREMENTS ON POST-MARKET COSMETICS

1.7k Upvotes

https://www.livekindly.co/china-ends-animal-testing-requirements-cosmetics/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app

https://www.plantbasednews.org/post/china-closer-banning-animal-testing?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app

Links for sources. No information on when this goes into action yet or how they will transition. It does include imported cosmetics as well as domestic. This is a step in the right direction at least for such a large market. It will eventually also allow cruelty free brands to go into that market as well.


r/muacjdiscussion • • Nov 18 '19

Down With Clean Beauty

1.6k Upvotes

This may seem like a weird hill to die on for some people, but from now on I am refusing to buy any products from companies that market products as "clean beauty." I saw that the Bare Minerals advent calender consists entirely of supposed "clean" products, Drunk Elephant has their "Suspicious Six," and many other brands have jumped on this destructive, illogical bandwagon.

When the beauty community tried to relabel highlighting as strobing to sell us new crap, we all let it slide cause we knew that they were doing. When people photoshop their ads or filter their videos so that no one ever has pores, we get it. But "clean beauty" is not just side-eye worthy, it is dangerous, anti-science bullshit.

There is nothing wrong with wanting to minimize the number of ingredients in your skincare and makeup if you're particulary sensitive, or wanting to support brands with sustainable methods. However, that is not what clean beauty is selling. They are selling a culture of ignorance that preys on people's lack of scientific knowledge and their fears. Water is a chemical. Cyanide is natural. Now tell me which one you would like to have in your skin care.

Brands throw around terms like "non-toxic" as if everything in skincare and makeup isn't already required to be non-toxic. They trot out these pseudoscience examples of how so-and-so chemical is found in toilets or some shit or how aluminum in deoderant causes cancer (it doesn't), while completely ignoring that the way ingredients are produced, stored, and dispensed makes all the difference in the world. I'll give you an example. There was a drug in the 60s called thalidomide, which was given to pregnant women as an over-the-counter morning sickness treatment. One chemical orientation of that compound (the way its bonds were arranged), caused severe birth defects and the other chemical orientation was absolutely safe to take. Same chemical. Different bond orientation. Completely different outcome.

So when you see someone claim that certain chemicals are bad, do your research on a website other than Goop. This link will take you to a website where you can type in any scientific topic, and free papers from peer-reviewed journals will appear. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/ The wording may seem a little complicated, but the Introduction and Conclusions sections should give you a good idea of what the article is saying.

One of the most promiment scientific journals in the world, Nature, publishes review articles that summarize their big papers in more general wording than would be found in the article. Nature and other prominent journals like The New England Journal of Medicine, Cell, and Lancet will put out press releases that summarize their latest publications in a way that's generally friendly to the general public.

Also, if you're reading a paper and you don't understand it, email the people who wrote it! The author's name and academic institution will be listed at the top of the paper, just under the title. Google their name and university and their email addresses are usually available. Researchers love talking about their work and would be happy to answer your questions. And also they would be happy that you're coming to them instead of WebMD.

Please do not buy into this anti-science fear mongering that is trying to convince a mom of two in Iowa that her moisturizer will give her cancer. (And also never do a juice cleanse because they're fucking stupid and your body already has a way of removing toxins that works really freaking well: your liver).

Down with clean beauty.


r/muacjdiscussion • • Jun 09 '19

Is this the worst makeup launch you’ve ever seen? Tales of even worse ones if you have them?

1.6k Upvotes

A post inspired by the new Jaclyn Cosmetics lipsticks, which may be the hottest mess of a launch I have ever had the privilege of witnessing.

A short OOTL of the drama:

  • Jaclyn Hill has been promising to release her own makeup line since 2014/2015 at least.

  • Due to life events such as her divorce in 2018, the launch date of her line was understandably pushed back several times.

  • At the end of May, Jaclyn made a launch video finally announcing her new cosmetics brand, Jaclyn Cosmetics. Her first release was 20 lipsticks, all in nude shades and priced at $18 apiece.

  • Interestingly, though her brand is named Jaclyn Cosmetics, the component on her lipstick says JH. I believe before her divorce she was planning on naming her company Jaclyn Hill Cosmetics (Hill is her ex-husbands surname); this will come into play later.

  • Recently, people have been taking to Twitter to complain about multiple bizarre issues with the lipsticks.

  • Lipsticks often arrived melted or broken. Example 2 While Jaclyn's line does contain several plant butters, it is strange that they weren't tested to withstand the heat of shipping. I have read that normally lipsticks are formulated to stay together up to 130F heat (a hot summer day is maybe 80-90F for my non-Americans).

  • In addition, many contain hard plastic balls inside the lipstick.

  • One of the most common complaints is strange texture after just a few applications. A Twitter user named Veronica tweeted this photo to Jaclyn. Jaclyn's response was pretty unprofessional and insinuated that Veronica’s dry lips could have caused the issue. Veronica was subsequently attacked on Twitter by Jaclyn fans for having crusty lips.

  • Up until this point, I kind of thought the drama was overblown. Weird texture, while aesthetically unappealing in an industry that’s all about appearances, shouldn’t affect the overall performance of the lipstick. However, the next couple of things to come out were unfathomably bad.

  • A beauty influencer named Brianna Fox posted an Instagram story of her pulling long hairs (that look like actual human hairs? who knows) out of the lipstick itself.

  • Another beauty influencer, Raw Beauty Kristi, posted this image on Twitter, as well as up-close videos with her handheld microscope zooming in on the hairs.

  • WARNING: GROSS AF 🤢😷 As you can see, both blonde and black fibers, as well as air bubbles are embedded into the very structure of the lipstick. Second link with additional photos

  • After melting the lipstick, these bizarre little balls (they actually look like metal ball bearings) remained stable, leading people to think that they weren’t just recrystallized plant butters since they would have melted along with the wax.

  • Compared to Charlotte Tilbury and MAC lipsticks shown under the same scope, you can see that the air bubbles and little fibers are not present in these brands’ lipsticks.

  • Jaclyn went on Twitter and said that the fibers were not hair, and were actually from furry gloves that her team used during quality assurance testing. I’ve never seen a cosmetics company use anything but nitrile gloves, which don’t have any fibers to shed. Furthermore, QA products are normally not introduced back into the product that’s sent to consumers.

  • Although this is not proven, people are starting to wonder whether the lipsticks are several years old. Given the JH labeling on the component, they could have been produced back in the Jaclyn Hill Cosmetics era (~2016). Cream-based lipsticks have a shelf life of 1 year, so potentially the impurities were introduced while they were sitting on a shelf for much longer than that. However, I will say that looking at my own bullet lipsticks that are over a year old, none of them have anything (hairs, plastic, fungus) embedded inside them.

I don’t know very much about cosmetics manufacturing, but I do know a lot about the FDA after working in a clinical trials lab for the past two years. The amount of bureaucracy required to meet all FDA standards is incredible— literally a full-time job for one person just to ensure a lab is compliant. Cosmetics, especially ones that can be ingested like lipsticks, are regulated by the FDA, which is why it’s insane to me that this level of uncleanliness and potential microbial growth was allowed.

While I feel awful for the people duped into buying these lipsticks and wasting their hard earned money, as well as the health risks from the possible mold, I’m also a messy bitch who loves drama. If y’all have commentary on Jaclyn Cosmetics or tales of even worse launches (Kuckian Cosmetics anyone?), I’d love to hear it!


r/muacjdiscussion • • Jan 07 '25

Lost my favorite lipstick and when I finally found it… it was unused

1.6k Upvotes

Lost my favorite lipstick and when I finally found it… it was unused

This happened just a couple of days ago.

For Thanksgiving my husband and I had went to my parents’ house a few hours away and stayed for a few days. I had packed a bag of makeup for our stay, including my favorite lipstick (Fenty Beauty Gloss Bomb Stick in Fenty Glow). This lipstick had been purchased on September 14; plenty of time for me to use it and love it before Thanksgiving.

When we came back from Thanksgiving, I unpacked my makeup bag as usual. A couple days after getting back, I went to use my favorite lipstick and I couldn’t find it anywhere. I do have a significant amount of makeup, so I figured it could be lost in all my lipsticks or maybe I had put it in a purse for an outing or maybe it fell out in my car. I just remember I had packed it for our Thanksgiving trip.

Well over a month passed and I could never find it. My husband helped me look through my car and our house for it. I almost bought a replacement because I love it so much and was really missing wearing that particular shade. But I thought “as soon as I buy another one, I’m going to find it”. Sure enough, I made a purchase at Ulta and resisted the urge to replace it and the next day I found my favorite lipstick.

The lipstick was in the makeup bag I had packed for Thanksgiving, but in a front pocket I don’t usually use. I pulled out the lipstick and opened it and was absolutely floored to find it unused. I know it was unused because this type of lipstick has the brand logo stamped into the top of the lipstick. The lipstick formula is very thin, so once you use the lipstick once, the brand stamp disappears. Here was my FAVORITE lipstick- the one I had MISSED wearing and it was brand new. Never used.

I just sat there trying to think how that is even possible. There is no way. Unless I never used the lipstick. But I have memories of using it and loving it. Loving it so much I was wanting to spend $25 to replace it. I went to show my husband the stamp and everything. He thought it was super weird.

I just don’t understand how that happened. Feels very much like a glitch in the matrix.

I posted this also in the glitch in the matrix subreddit, but I thought you all might enjoy. I was also wondering if anyone else has any similar stories. Maybe then I won’t feel so crazy!


r/muacjdiscussion • • Feb 13 '19

Just my opinion, but I am so annoyed by OPI’s new Tokyo collection

1.5k Upvotes

So OPI recently came out with new “Tokyo collection inspired by trendy Tokyo” Ok I am so tired of my culture being portrayed as a fucking hot pink cutesy hello kitty Harajuku fashion bullshit. Yes that is a subculture that exists, just like anywhere else in the world. But what annoys me the most is the naming of these nail polishes. “Rice Rice Baby” ? Did no one in their meeting room think that could be a tiny bit offensive? Yes, I know it’s just nail polish. Yes, I know it is so not a big deal in the grand scheme of things. I’m just so tired of how my culture is used as like a butt of the joke in so many contexts. This is 2019, I thought we were passed this willful ignorance. Ugh.


r/muacjdiscussion • • Apr 01 '18

What do you think of the new Jeffree Star Foundation?

1.5k Upvotes

I am surprised by how well Jeffree Star handled the shade curation for the new Groupie Facial Foundation; there are just as many shades for deeper skintones (with a wide variety of undertones and no giant jumps in between depths) as there are for lighter skinned folks.

Personally I’m still not going to try the foundation given that: a) they don’t have any olive-toned shades to match me, b) all the reviews that are up right now are from stans who got sent the entire line for free, c) even the stans say it’s not the best for oily skin types like mine, and d) Jeffree Star is still a racist ding-dong head and an inclusive shade range doesn’t excuse his pattern of harassing people and calling them slurs. If the shade range and formula worked for you would you consider buying it or would you still prefer a foundation from a less problematic brand?


r/muacjdiscussion • • Feb 11 '19

Now that intentional and forceful panning is so popular, PanPorn is starting to annoy the shit out of me

1.5k Upvotes

I realize there are more than enough people with actual interest in intentional panning, but I just can’t get with it. Whenever I see a pan like this I just get irrationally annoyed. It’s starting to look like people are just shoving their brushes in to get to the bottom...

Seriously. I’m probably overreacting and would love to hear your thoughts on intentional “forceful” panning and hate panning (hate panning! makes! no sense! to me!)

UPDATE: I have received this mute notification? So I just wanted to clear up I am expressing my personal disinterest and wondering how others may view it, and have actually found some insightful views in the comments. I do not hate the sub or the people doing this, I just don’t care for intentional panning. I also don’t expect or want a change in the sub, different people have different interests and that’s 100% ok...

UPDATE 2: I think someone just threw shade at this. Lol


r/muacjdiscussion • • Mar 07 '19

PSA (possibly): Colourpop is technically not allowed to ship to the EU

1.3k Upvotes

EDIT: I really wanted to thank everyone who took time to comment, really overwhelmed by the response! Couldn't manage to answer every comment at some point but as a quick update, esteelaundry already posted about my issue on instagram and I'm now writing to CPon twitter. I've also written to my credit card company to maybe dispute my payment and will see what happens with that.

I hope it's okay for me to post this here, I did need to vent a bit but would also like to know if anyone's had any similar experiences with Colourpop, so here goes.

I ordered from Colourpop during their BYOP Sale at the beginning of January and was crazy excited because I'd been eyeing some of their shades for a while and could finally justify shipping/possible customs charges (am from Germany) with the palette being so cheap. It got stuck in customs in Frankfurt for while and a bit later I got notified by my local customs office, that the package had arrived and I was able to retrieve it.

However when I arrived at the customs office and had to open my package the employee immediately recognised the brand and I was told that Colourpop violates EU regulations regarding the import of cosmetics and I would not be allowed to keep my package and it had to be sent back. I was also told that Colourpop is somewhat notorious for this and that the brand was probably well aware they were not allowed to ship to the EU but chose to ignore this as a lot of packages are likely to slip through customs and I was just a bit unlucky that mine hadn't.

I obviously looked into this when I got home and it seems that Colourpop violates EU regulation Nr. 1223/2009, which entails that foreign cosmetics companies need some form of representative inside the EU to be allowed to ship there, as well as the fact that they apparently don't print expiration dates on all of their products. Like the customs employee said I also apparently just got very unlucky (largely due to the fact German customs offices are the absolute worst) that my package got picked up.

Even though I was furious I politely wrote to Colourpop's customer service, mentioning the EU regulation and the fact that this isn't mentioned on their website anywhere and asked for a refund for my package. They answered pretty quickly but completely neglected to comment on the fact they are apparently not allowed to ship to the EU and just said that my tracking said the package was delivered (which it had been, to the customs office as I explained in my mail) and they wouldn't be able to send a replacement. I wrote back explaining everything again and that I still wanted my refund. I was told I would be issued a refund once the package arrived at Colourpop.

I waited more than a month (longer than the package took to get here) until I wrote to them again, explaining that I believe my package was back with them and I would like to receive my money. They're wrote to me that the tracker didn't show that my package was being returned (which, again, I had explained to them a few times now) but they knew that USPS made mistakes too and they were kindly sending me a replacement package. I obviously protested, telling them it would likely get stuck in customs again, however before I received a reply I has already gotten a shipment confirmation and Colourpop told me it was "their policy to issue a courtesy replacement".

To no surprise the package got stuck at customs again, I explained everything to the customs employers and they at least were kind enough to hand me some documents as prove to send to Colourpop. This was only yesterday and I haven't written to Colourpop again yet because i don't really know what to tell them anymore and am quite scared they will still deny me a refund. I have written to my credit card company and sent them the document from customs, so I might be able to get my money that way. I'm really quite disappointed because I had been interested in Colourpop for a while (and still am - their new palette release really wants me to forget my principles) but this experience has really been terrible. I'm really not good at conflicts and thinking about this has really takes up far too much time since I was denied my first package.

Long story short, has anyone had similarly frustrating experiences with their customer support or was even denied their package, too? I would also love to know if you had any advice on what I should do next because I really have no clue!

TL;DR: Colourpop violates EU regulations and is technically not allowed to ship there, also their customer support sucks hard.


r/muacjdiscussion • • Mar 14 '19

KVD's "I am not a" video.

1.3k Upvotes

Y'all see this??

https://youtu.be/pc1K_MXe1M4

Interested to hear what other people's feelings are, but IMO, this is a pathetic attempt to fix her public image and does not even come close to addressing the reasons people are done with her.

She doesn't even address the multiple other reasons people think she's anti-semitic, and she DEFINITELY doesn't say she's not anti-vax. The anti-vax part in particular is terrible - her apology is basically "I'm sorry I told you all about it, I'm gonna keep doing it without telling you from now on."

Yikes. Hard pass still, Kat.


r/muacjdiscussion • • Aug 12 '19

Trying on makeup "virtually" vs. the reality

1.3k Upvotes

Longtime lurker here finally deciding to post...

I decided to experiment with the Ulta app's "Glam lab" today, at first scrolling through new colors for fun, but when I clicked on Velvet Teddy, a lipstick I already owned, my first thought was "Wow, this looks nothing like it!" This led me down the rabbit hole of narrowing down every single lipstick available in the app that I already owned, trying them on in the app in various kinds of lighting, and then comparing the results to wearing the real thing.
I uploaded my results here: https://imgur.com/ijxCYcG

While many of them were a close match in at least "natural" lighting, others really did look like a completely different product regardless of which lighting it was in.

I also noticed that the app seems to "face tune" when makeup is on, since a scar I have is noticeably blurred in the "virtual lipstick" pictures. The "real makeup" photos were taken with the camera inside the app with "none" selected for products, which indicates this feature to blur face imperfections only activates when a virtual makeup item is applied, thus making it appear as though that new lipstick makes your whole face look better (sneaky!)

What do you think of this feature (or others like it, since I think Sephora has one too)? Would being able to "virtually" try on a product actually make or break deciding to get it?

Edit: wow, my first Reddit gold, thank you!!!


r/muacjdiscussion • • Sep 19 '19

A dusty old bat's guide to under eyes

1.3k Upvotes

I was but a wee lass during the color explosion of the 80s and survived the makeup dark ages (90s, don't lie to yourself, you know I'm right). Needless to say, I'm thrilled to talk smack through the current makeup revolution along side you petty pores. You are my people. I love you guys.

But what the hell is up with all the lost techniques? Like damn, did the vanity section burn down with the Library of Alexandria? There are so many YouGuruInstaFluencers that fly right by all the hard earned methods from the Bluebonic Plague 90s (though blue eyeshadow seems to be making a comeback). I may yet be a dusty pore, but I will be dammed if I let my frosted shadow pain die with the last century. History ignored is doomed to repeat, and I'm not emotionally ready to see glossier-coated gurus rediscovering lost under eye techniques like its a Renaissance. So without further ado...

An Aside about Plastic Surgery

Cosmetic surgery/fillers/etc used to be a secret that old people used to round out their gossip (about how so-and-so was clearly a tart, because back then it was shameful to admit that you cared about your appearance unless you were intentionally tarting, and even then). At the tail end of the last century cosmetic procedures had a fad period where everyone not only wanted to get plumped, but wanted the enhancements to be blatant (I'm going to resist my urge to take cheap shots at Bay Watch here, mostly because it gave cover during a dangerous time to my fellow bi/gays by letting us pretend that we just really cared about life jackets and water safety and stuff). By the 00s cosmetic procedures had become normalized and it seems to be accepted that with enough money you can get all your under eye woes wiped away like Pledge on a laminate table. I risk preaching to the choir here by confirming that it's a needle, not a wand. I've had work done on my under eyes and know a few others who have as well, and while doctors can soften the look of major issues that you might have, it's unlikely that they can erase your creasing/wrinkles/circles/puffiness completely. I'm not suggesting that these procedures won't help, just that its not a panacea. It's unlikely that you'll reemerge with Kardashian under eyes. Just saying.

Creasing and Wrinkles

Natural creasing due to the structure of your face

The idea that you should have perfectly smooth under eyes is pretty recent. Natural under eye creases used to be seen as just another unremarkable feature of the face. Cindy Crawford is the most notable example that comes to mind; generally regarded as a fashion icon of such standing that if anyone had said "but her under eye crease though," most people would have said "what is that?" and "are you wack?" There are techniques for applying under eye makeup effectively to genetic creases as a part of the architecture of the face. Samer Khouzami does a really good job with this if you're looking for tutorials. Here is a quick example.

High speed baking

I blame YouTube somewhat for misleading people about product settling times, mostly because beauty gurus can prioritize talking/shilling over results. In reality if you have creases then product will start to collect there the second that you stop blending. If you have creases/wrinkles you need to transition from blending to baking really fast. As fast as you can. The issue being that many times you can't see that your concealer had began to drift until you apply powder, which can stick to the pool of product and suddenly age you 1000 years like the guy that drank from the wrong cup in The Last Crusade

Moisturizer

Use it; what more is there really to say? The only dusty bat comment that I have is that at some point moisturizing your under eye area moved from "early morning routine" to "makeup prep." For most people this probably doesn't matter, but if you find that your concealer doesn't set well, or otherwise slides around, it may be that you haven't given your moisturizer and/or sunscreen time to absorb. Personally, I apply under eye cream after I brush my teeth and before I feed my asshole cat.

How much of your under eye do you really need to cover, be honest

The vast amount of youtube and instagram videos that I've seen imply that you need to conceal your entire under eye. Prior to the internet, people didn't have a map for where concealer should go and just concealed only what looked discolored. This is still a worthwhile approach to under eye concealing if you have noticeable creasing, since the area with the creases may not really need to be concealed. I only do my tear troughs and leave my creases alone, for example.

Real Color Correcting

People knew what a color wheel was long before the dawn of the tubes. Issac Newton was drawing circular color diagrams back in 1666, and people generally knew that you could mute one color by applying its compliment. Prior to the internet, makeup artists used to color correct by hand mixing a complimentary color specific to the individual. Around 2016-ish color correcting came into vogue and multiple companies tried to profit by putting out color correcting palettes. To make them marketable they oversimplified them into "light" and "deep" versions (if you were lucky enough to even get that) that offered one or two options for under eye correcting. But color correcting effectively was never that simple. Let's say that you buy a correcting palette that has a peach cream; peach assumes that you have visible blue veins to cover, but what if your under eyes are just a darker shade of your skin tone? What if your veins appear purple instead of blue? All you're going to do is create a peach smear that accomplishes nothing. If you really want color correcting to work you have to be much more accurate with your color choices. Luckily, we live in a world with color identifying technology, so there is a way to get an unbiased feel for what your under eye color really is (Here is an online color identifier, but there are hundreds of other programs and apps like this that let you upload a photo and extract your under eye color). For example, if you find that you have cool-purple under eyes, you would want to correct that area with light yellow, but if you have warm-purple under eyes, you would want to cancel it with a light greenish yellow. This is because the temperature of the color matters too as you can see with this chart. I'm not trying to freak y'all out by suggesting that you need to do this perfectly, obviously you can't really do that, but the closer that you can get to a color compliment of your dark circles, the more effective your color correcting will be.

Watery Eyes

My heart goes out to my fellow pores who have watery eyes. Is wack, am sorry. Two pieces of old advice for this that are still promoted today are: use eye drops to combat dry eyes (since dry eyes can cause you to create excess tears), and use allergy medication if you have allergies. The old advice that seems to have gone by the wayside: stop slamming your sponge/brush onto your eye. I know that there are approximately 1gajillion tutorials that show gurus trampolining a sponge on their under eye, but not everyone can do that. Watering can be caused by excess pressure and irritation around your eye, so if this is an issues for you, you may want to try blending and baking with as light of a hand as you can get away with while still getting the look that you want. Admittedly, it does take additional patience and practice.

Puffiness or Swelling

I still hear the "cold spoon under the eye" method, but I haven't heard "I have to take my makeup off before my eyes swell" in a long time. I would imagine that this is less of an issue now than it used to be, but there are some people whose under eyes are very sensitive to products, and can only wear under eye makeup for a short time before the area experiences minor swelling. You shouldn't sleep in your makeup anyway, but this is especially true for product sensitive people.

The Shitty Lighting at your Office/School

Is shitty. Has always been shitty. Will always be shitty. I'm sorry.

Links to my Dusty Old Guides


r/muacjdiscussion • • Feb 17 '26

Why do people insist that blush wasn't a thing in 2016? Like when people do "2016 makeup," they often don't include blush for "historical accuracy." Blush was definitely popular back then.

1.3k Upvotes

It wasn't as popular as eyeshadow palettes or liquid lipsticks or highlighters, but we still wore blush in 2016. I remember the Tarte Amazonian Clay powder blushes being popular, as well as Nars Orgasm and the Milani baked blushes. I also remember the Hourglass blushes being popular.

Brands weren't constantly releasing cream and liquid blush, but even then, those products did exist. I remember Tarte had cream blushes in stick form back then. I had the shade "Exposed." People also hyped up the cream blushes from Stila.


r/muacjdiscussion • • Jan 28 '18

Jeffree Star conspiracy theory

1.3k Upvotes

He's releasing a shade called "problematic". I think it's so when people Google "Jeffree Star problematic" it's no longer a ton of blog posts on how racist he is, and instead it's pictures of his lipstick.


r/muacjdiscussion • • Oct 01 '19

A dusty old bat's guide to foundation

1.2k Upvotes

Back in the pre-internet days if you wanted makeup advice you had to go to the library and use a card catalog to look up makeup books using the Dewey decimal system, which never really worked because Kim had checked out all the good books a year ago and never returned them (totally her real name because screw her). In those dark times we turned to the Great and Wise Elders of our communities to impart upon us solutions to the great mysteries of makeup. Honestly, even that was a crap shoot because sometimes your elders were just as clueless as everyone else, or were toxic trolls who told us to "stop acting smart or no one will want to marry you, you just need to act stupid like your mother does with your father" (I'll have you know that my cat doesn't care if I'm a smartass, Peggy (also her real name because screw her too)).

But I digress.

I love going through the current makeup Renaissance with you pores. You are my people, which is why I feel compelled to share the old school makeup techniques that I would hate to see disappear into the aether. So without further ado...

Primer

I do respect people who are suspicious of primers, mostly because the way it's marketed makes it look like a gimmick, but primer has been around since the last century just not in a form that you would immediately recognize. Now primers have a barrage of functions (moisturizing-mattifying-color-correcting-pore-filling-leprechaun-magic-straight-from-the-pot-of-gold claims), but originally it was meant for people who just couldn't get makeup to adhere to their face. Oh, and the old school primer that I'm referring to? Monistat Complete Care Chafing Relief Powder Gel. Yes, we used to put Vajayjay cream on our face. I kid you not, I used it for YEARS in the 90s and it never let me down. But you know, it's still marketed as Vajango cream, which some pores may find distasteful, so maybe someone could put a very similar formula into a bourgeois container and named it something like Bmashbox Fhoto Pinish Frimer and sell it for quadruple the price, hypothetically, just saying (in case it's the day before payday and you have to chose between a crunchwrap supreme and primer).

Non-uniformity of Foundation Application

I see most YouTubers applying foundation uniformly over their face, but this wasn't always the standard procedure. It used to be that you would apply more foundation to areas with uneven coloring and less to areas that were close to the skin color/texture that you wanted to normalize your face to. For example, more foundation to cover the acne on your cheeks but less on your acne-free nose. It is a bit challenging to blend the boundaries between the sections such that it looks seamless, but with today's blending tools it's substantially easier than it used to be. The benefit to using this technique is that you have fewer areas of your face that will look cakey or otherwise need attending to throughout the day.

Highspeed Baking for Textured Skin

I've mentioned this before, but cream products typically sink into scars/wrinkles/pores/etc much faster than you would think. You may not immediately be able to see it, but creams start shifting right after you stop blending. If you have textured skin and plan on baking then you need to transition from blending to baking really fast. I have some scaring from chicken pox (I was born before they started vaccinating people for it and VACCINATE YOUR DAMN KIDS I CAN'T EVEN BELIEVE THAT WE HAVE TO DISCUSS THIS KAT) and I apply my foundation to that area first and immediately powder it before working on the rest of my face.

A note about acne: if you notice that foundation seems to pool around or slide off of the bumps, you may be seeing the reverse effect of cream sliding into creases and would want to apply the same fast bake solution.

Mixing Products

I'm not referring to mixing shades, but mixing unrelated products into your foundation. I realize that people are wary about altering a formula, but no one will shame you for embarking on the time honored tradition of treating your vanity like a chemistry set and making some "creative" solutions such as:

  • Oily skin: add astringent to your foundation.

  • Dry skin: add oil or moisturizer to your foundation.

  • Combo skin: mix two sets of foundation, say one pump of foundation+astringent for your oily areas and one pump of foundation+moisturizer for your dry areas.

  • Glow like a Baywatch life guard: add some liquid highlighter to your foundation.

Wet Sponges and the History of CRT and HDTV Entertainment

It used to not matter if your foundation was a cakey mess since everyone was watching The Mary Tyler Moore Show on CRT TVs that tended to blur everything into a phosphorescent fog. Fast forward to 1994 when HDTV made its debut in the US and the demise of the ethereal actress trope began. Around this time makeup artists such as Kelcey Fry and Rea Ann Silva stopped using airbrushing in favor of cutting up SFX makeup sponges and soaking them in water. My point being that if you are on a budget, you can wet an old timey wedge sponge and get by just fine. Or, you know, use your hands, which does work if you can master blending with your fingers like the late Kevin Aucoin (who also said that he enjoyed learning "how to dive into people’s souls and to interpret that on their face. ... My goal in life is to have women take over the world" that man did not play).

Links to my Dusty Old Guides


r/muacjdiscussion • • Aug 23 '19

PSA: "Not eye safe" glitter lives up to it's warning label

1.2k Upvotes

I just had a woman in the ER yesterday who developed a massive eye infection and now has severe visual impairment in her right eye from using a not eye safe glitter. All it takes is one rouge piece to get a scratch that can develop into an infection.

At the very least never, ever rub your eyes if you get something in them- it can make a minor scratch much bigger. Use a sterile eye rinse from the drugstore ASAP, and use eyedrops until you heal. Glitters are made of tiny razor sharp plastic pieces, the odds may be low, but don't play the odds with your health.


r/muacjdiscussion • • Oct 13 '19

Temptalia has zero plans to purchase or review rephr brushes. Thoughts?

1.2k Upvotes

Christine from Temptalia stated in the comments of her Sonia G. Sky Face Set review about why she refuses to purchase or review rephr brushes.

Sorry, I have no plans to purchase Rephr brushes. Their marketing/spiel/origin story was so off-putting that I have no desire to spend money at that brand when there are hundreds of brushes I haven’t reviewed from other brush brands.

(a commenter asks: "Christine, Can you elaborate on the origin story and why it is so off-putting? Genuinely curious since the company seems to be listening to consumers feedback which is rare in this day and age.")

Their tag line of “luxury makeup brushes designed by 3 engineers who knew nothing about makeup” (who are all men) and just a general patronizing tone (“as engineers who loved efficiency, we were not satisfied with the idea that a person needs 12 brushes to do beautiful makeup” – the same patronizing concept of brands that say you’re wasting your time, you don’t need all that, wear less makeup). In one sentence, the community is being oversold with these brush sets and how many brushes they should have and then they simultaneously offer face (six brushes) and eye sets (eight brushes). It all just really grated on me personally, but I certainly don’t expect everyone else to be rubbed the same way.

There’s a lot of marketing about innovation/doing and being better than, but the reality is they talk about a lack of versatility/multi-tasking brushes and yet the majority of brushes–even ones sold in pre-made sets by big brands outside of Japanese brush brands–are actually multi-tasking and are very, very similar in general shape to Rephr brushes. They don’t provide insight into what type of goat hair is used, and they don’t provide standard measurements that Japanese brush brands do (width, brush length; they only provide the brush head length), which I find to be at odds with the engineering background. The idea that these brushes are fixing the issue of the community wanting brushes that last years and not months was interesting, because at the price point and type of brush, I don’t know of any Japanese brushes that are falling apart in months. For that matter, a lot of the go-to brush ranges that are more affordable, like ColourPop, elf, and Wet ‘n’ Wild, I’m not hearing from readers about the brushes falling apart.

I think it’s cool that they took feedback from the community, but outside of that, there’s nothing here that makes me want to take a leap when I have so many other brands and brushes I’ve tested and could be reviewing. My time would be better spent reviewing all of ColourPop’s brushes or in-depth reviews of Sonia G. or Chikuhodo or Hakuhodo brushes — if I was going to allocate more time to review brushes or wanted to spend my review budget on new brushes.

I’d be more interested if it was a brand who was creating synthetic brushes that rivaled the performance and organic texture of natural hair brushes, or if they spent more time on creating brush sets that worked for types of features or application methods — there is no such thing as a brush that just works perfectly for everyone, because it comes down to facial features (size/shape) as well as the types of products and the types of outcomes you want (do you have sheerer products or more pigmented products, do you want a wash of color or what you see in the pan on your face).

For me, I completely agree with Christine. I admit that I was first tempted because YTers like Michele Wang and Tarababyz have been raving them, and I'm a huge fan of fude. I have a few Sonia G., Wayne Goss and Chikuhodo brushes that I absolutely adore. But when I looked into the rephr brand, something about it was off-putting. The pricing structure was confusing for me, like why are they offering 40% off for preorders? I love me a discount, but 40% off "artisan Japanese brushes" sounded sketch, especially because there was so little info about the hair types.

I also had no idea the rephr founders were men who admittedly have zero knowledge of makeup. It's gross that they're basically using crowdfunding to get actual makeup lovers to do the work for them. I read through the previous thread on rephr here a few months ago, and I feel like most of here feel similarly. I also appreciate that Christine mentions that more affordable brands are making synthetic brushes that are high-quality and accessible.

What are your thoughts? Do you agree with Christine? Do you have any rephr brushes, and do you enjoy them? What brush brands, fude or otherwise, do you recommend?


r/muacjdiscussion • • Sep 10 '20

“Medium” should not mean white person with a tan.

1.1k Upvotes

This is a hill I will die on, a petty hill but a hill nonetheless.

Medium means middle. Medium means the average or halfway between two extremes. My foundation shade is NC44-45, I’M MEDIUM. I am not very light nor am I very dark.

In the makeup industry and online, medium seems to mean a slightly tanned, light complexion. It doesn’t make sense to describe NC35 or even lighter as medium. It groups like 80% of all the other skin tones as colours that fall after the halfway mark.

Angelica Nyqvist (who’s content I enjoy) is pretty light with a slight tan but she continuously describes her skin tone as medium and it’s honestly laughable. I don’t really blame her as makeup marketing seems to agree. I get that there isn’t the biggest representation of imo true medium skin tones but we’re here, we exist lmao. (Perhaps Patrick Starr and Nami Emiko)

I know it’s a bit silly and really depends on perception but still. :)

Edit: okay, not silly or petty at all. I just didn’t think so many people would agree or feel as strongly as I do bc I don’t really hear it being discussed. But yeah this is something that really bothers me.


r/muacjdiscussion • • Jan 08 '21

Can we have more terms to describe the diversity of East Asian eyes?

1.1k Upvotes

Right now, there’s a BIG misconception that all Asian eyes are monolids. Monolids are eyes with an epicanthic fold over the top to make the eye look like it has no crease. These are monolids.

While yes, the surgery to add a crease to monolids is still the most popular plastic surgery globally, many East Asian eyes have naturally occurring creases & there’s also a wide diversity on how those creases look.

Even if you don’t agree that labelling everything as monolids is racist/inappropriate, we can at least agree it makes finding makeup tutorials a bitch. Imagine if hooded eye tutorials & almond shaped eye tutorials are all lumped under “eye tutorial” with no way of sorting them out.

Various Asian brands/plastic surgeons/bloggers have tried coming up with various terms to describe the different types of eyes, but they haven’t taken off either because they’re a tad offensive (“ideal eyes” vs “sleepy eyes”/“fatty eyes”) or there’s just too many categories to the point where it’s overwhelming. So I’m suggesting at least having 3 more categories, because all 3 groups need different makeup techniques, on top of the “monolids” classification:

(if they look familiar, I didn’t steal the pics. I made this video with the permission of all the bloggers featured)

Let me know your thoughts?


r/muacjdiscussion • • Dec 14 '18

Is anyone else just tired of trying to keep up with which brands are shitlords and which are ok?

1.1k Upvotes

I've been buying cruelty-free for just over a year now. This lead me into the tunnel of ethical consumerism, and honestly I'm just tired. I feel like I need to extensively research every brand before I buy to make sure they aren't shitcunts. Went to repurchase my Illamasqua Hollow pigment the other day, but a google search shows me they have refused to apologise for some pretty racist ads. But it gets to every brand I own almost; Tarte is not inclusive of all skin colours. Jeffree Star is jeffree starr. TheBalm has objectifying palettes. I'm a huge fan of the Limecrime Venus palettes and started collecting them, so you can imagine the can of worms that has been. Kat 'Vaccinate yo kids' D has some of my fav products. And then I feel like I can't watch this or that youtuber because they said all sorts of whateverthefuck. Tati said this. Huda thinks that. Etc etc etc forever.

Is anyone else just overwhelmed by this? I try my best to be an ethical consumer in most aspects of my life but damn. This is just really messing with my love of makeup. I had a come-to-jesus moment in which while I am almost militant in my pro-vax views I just really want that KVD Lolita palette. How much of my personal convictions can I push onto my makeup before it just gets bloody ridiculous?


r/muacjdiscussion • • Nov 13 '19

A dusty old bat's guide to blush

1.0k Upvotes

I used to work at the same laboratory as this old Jamaican machinist named Glaster. Everything that he made looked so simple and polished, and it wasn't accidental, he used to say that "there are aspects of every aesthetic that carry the overall look and if you screw them up they will draw attention to every other minor flaw, real or imagined, that would have otherwise been ignored."

If your eyeliner is uneven, no one is likely to notice, but if your blush is also "off" people will suddenly notice your blush, eyeliner, and your non-existent contour. It doesn't matter if everything else flawless, blush is one of those aesthetic elements that will draw a critical eye. Blush can make you or break you.

But it would be wrong to make such strong claims without also giving you some old dusty rouge-wielding tips, so without further ado...

Blush Always Looks Really Fucking Bad On Me and I Don't Know Why

I feel you, we all do. Blush can be off in a way that can be really hard to nail down. It has taken me decades (no joke) to get my blush looking good consistently. Mostly, you just have to be willing to practice, but there are some common failure modes that will screw you no matter how much effort you put in.

My blush stands out and draws all attention to my cheeks

If I had to create a "Blush Fail" table, this would be in cell A1. Your makeup is looking really good, then you put on some blush and now all you can see is BLUSH. This is usually caused by putting a single color on your face that isn't used anywhere else. It's most irritating with blush, because blush can be a bitch, but you're likely using this technique to your advantage elsewhere. Eyeshadow drawing attention to your eyes is a good thing, for example. The problem is that you aren't typically looking to focus on your cheeks, so localizing blush there is is going to interrupt the smooth transition between different sections of your face. You can avoid this by putting blush on the other areas to harmonize your cheeks with the rest of your look (temples, forehead, nose if you're brave, etc.).

I think that I'm putting it in the wrong place(s)

This one time I was bored and wanted to see a move, and am dusty enough to not give a shit about going to the movies alone (or maybe I was always this way, who remembers?). However, I am from the 80s when all movies about children involved them coming together to go on adventures and save the day, but since our world is a sliding towards a dystopia, young people can't relate to that "you can do anything" bullshit anymore, so now we have The Hunger Games where approximately 92-96% of child participants kill the shit out of each other as both a political punishment and for adult entertainment! I naively assumed that my favorite character, 12 year old Rue, would live. I have only ever cried at one other movie, but when Rue died I cried so hard that I had to leave the movie to clean myself up.

My face was red and swollen, and I looked like hell, but I was suddenly also able to see where my face swells and blushes naturally. This was instrumental to my blush game since it let me see where I should have been putting blush all along (more on my temples and forehead as well as my cheeks).

My point being, next time that you are really emotional (I hope that it's from being so happy that you cry!) have a look at your face and see where you actually blush. I would imagine that you could also see this after a really good workout, but you couldn't pay me to test it (maybe if you paid me a lot).

Also, R.I.P. Rue, you're a fucking legend.

Blush seems to make my face look droopy and not in the cute way

Ideally you would be smiling and laughing all the time, but if you work for the government like I do, you are not smiling. If you typically have a resting face then you want to be careful about smiling while you apply blush. As you smile your cheeks rise and it changes the shape of your face, so when you stop smiling your blush ends up being lower on your face and farther in towards your mouth.

It makes my skin look bad/worse

Shimmery powders tend to magnify the appearance of uneven textures (especially scars, bumps, and large pores). If this is an issue for you, try using blushes that have a matte finish.

My technique is bullshit and I don't know how to fix it

If you absolutely can't apply your blush right, you can use the old timey method of applying it through a single-ply tissue. Pull apart the layers of some face or bath tissue, hold it against your face, and stipple the blush over the tissue. The tissue diffuses the powder such that you get a more uniform application.

In addition, be careful about just using whatever brush is sold as a "blush brush." Makeup in many Western countries is made with stereotypical white-middle-class-women faces in mind, which may or may not work for you. My blush game improved noticeably once I started using an eyeshadow blending brush to apply my blush. It's small enough to cover my thin cheeks, where "blush brushes" are usually way too large.

I can't blend this shit to save my life

If you know that blending your blush will be a problem, try laying down a light layer of loose powder on your cheeks and blend your blush into it. It will give your blush something to diffuse into instead of just sitting on top of your foundation. Likewise, if you accidentally apply your blush too heavily you can put a small amount of loose powder on top of to help thin it out as you blend.

My Blush Wears Off Too Fast

I've had good success with putting on a light layer of cream or gel blush, then foundation, then the powder blush. Having said that, if you're not careful you can end up with way too much blush if you aren't careful. You want to apply two formulas, not double the color.

Cream Blush

Cream blush either ends up looking beautiful or tragic. Is there an in-between? Perhaps, but I've never seen it. He is what I've learned from other old bats about making it look good:

  • Add a very thin layer of moisturizer on top of your foundation so the blush vanishes into it. The extra layer of moisturizer will make the blush appear softer.

  • Finger paint that shit: your fingers will typically give you more control than a brush or sponge.

  • Work on one side of your face at a time. Many liquid formulas dry down faster than you can blend both sides.

Links to my Dusty Old Guides


r/muacjdiscussion • • Oct 24 '19

A dusty old bat's guide to lipstick

1.0k Upvotes

Alright, I'm going to lay some truth on you pores because I love you and want the very best for you all: for as long as I've been alive, makeup companies have been claiming that they have found the secret ingredient to make the most long-lasting-moisturizing-smudge-proof-best-looking-uniformly-applying lipstick that will change the world. Just ask some of the other dusty old bats on here and they will tell you that we have been fed these lines forever. And I don't doubt that at least some of you have found a holy grail lipstick that meets your every need, which saves me from dividing by zero when I claim that the chance of this happening is a million to one. Realistically, for most people, most lipsticks are going to be lacking in some major feature. Thus if you don't take anything else away from my rant, let it be this one overarching piece of advice: lipstick is like politics, there are no solutions only trade offs. Once you realize this you will be much less disappointed about your lipstick purchases and in a better position to decide what features you really care about. But lets be honest, you didn't come here for a dusty old lecture, you came here for some Olde Timey Lipstick Tips. So without further ado...

An Aside About Lip Fillers

I work at a laboratory near NYC and damn do I see a ton of filled lips around here. If NYC were to flood WaterWorld style, a lot of people would be floating. This is not me talking smack about lip fillers (excluding a few obvious cheap shots because I am a petty pore) because the majority of the lip jobs that I've seen looked pretty good, they just don't look natural, and that is my point with this aside. When you actually see filled lips in person, without face tune and InstaFilters, they look well shaped but overly puffy and smooth. Lips have lines because you need those folds to make your lips flexible and emotive, and while smooth lips look good in photos they tend to look rigid when in motion. Also, the fillers don't last as long in the lips as they do in other parts of the face (that don't move or flex as much). To be clear, I'm not trying to tell you not to get fillers if you want them (shit, I have under eye fillers myself), but I am suggesting that you be realistic about the physical reality of how they work.

How to Make Lipstick Last Longer

I don't think that I'm wrong in guessing that most of you are really here for this. Making lipstick last as long as possible has been a priority since Sumerian men and women invented lipstick 5000 years ago. I learned the following procedure from watching even dustier bats talk smack about their husbands' genitals while reapplying lipstick in the "powder rooms" of swanky restaurants when I was but a wee lass (you know those bathrooms that have a foyer with a couch and flower arrangements that smell like potpourri? That little pre-bathroom room is what I was told by old biddies was the "powder room". Though don't let the name fool you, they spent much more time calling Amelia an egregious whore than they did powdering their nose. And before you ask, to this day I still have no idea who Amelia was, but she sounded fucking fabulous):

  1. Exfoliate (optional): this is especially important if you have dry lips.

  2. Prime (optional): I've talked before about how we used to use vajayjay cream as an all purpose primer, but you can use whatever works best for you.

  3. Line (optional): sharpen the damn pencil if you're going to do this. Not enough to stab yourself but don't leave it blunt like a used crayon at Applebee's either.

  4. First coat: try to make the first coat even but not super thick.

  5. Light powder: lightly dust powder over your lips to set the first coat (Edit: I use a sponge, but some people in the comments have suggested putting a single ply tissue over your lips and dusting through the tissue paper with a brush). Dust away the excess.

  6. Second coat: yes, you are putting lipstick over powder. This is why it's important to make sure that you've dusted away any excess powder before you apply a second coat or you will get clumpy powder balls all over your lips (and the lipstick wand/bullet).

  7. Blot (don't skip this step!): the purpose of blotting is to make your lipstick uniform over your lips.

An aside about blotting: pull apart a piece of tissue paper, fold the single-ply sheet in half, put it between your lips, and push your lips into it. This helps absorb excess lipstick so that when your lipstick starts to wear off (you know it will) it will wear uniformly instead of just in the center. It's better to have faded lipstick than a weird ring around your lips.

If you're going out and know that your lipstick will be a shitshow

Embrace the shitshow and plan for it, then have a good time (and knock back a few for me while you're at it Whoo!). Usually lipliner will last longer than lipstick, so you can use this to your advantage by applying a neutral lipliner that is close to your natural lip color so that when your lipstick wears off you're not left with only a brightly colored ring of liner like a 90s pop star, and will still have some color on your lips.

Lipstick That Drys Hard/Flaky (Notably Liquid Lipsticks)

A lot of people don't seem to realize that they can moisturize their lips similar to how they moisturize their skin. This can help if you plan to wear liquid lipsticks (which are typically very drying):

  1. Moisturize your lips. Be careful to avoid water based moisturizers that may make it hard for your lipstick to dry down.

  2. Let your lips dry a bit, otherwise the lipstick won't stick to your lips.

  3. Apply your liquid lipstick.

  4. Let the lipstick dry.

  5. Lightly moisturize or apply light lip gloss.

Patchy Lipstick

I've never seen a good method for physically repairing a patchy lipstick, but I have seen people disguise it by coloring their lips (entirely) with a similar colored lipliner before applying their patchy-ass lipstick.

Lipstick Gets All Over My Teeth

My father was a photographer for the Miss Universe pageants back in the 80s (their hair was amazing), and they told wee me all sorts of cool makeup tips, one being that they would put Vaseline on their teeth to prevent lipstick from getting all over them when they put on their BIG SMILES.

Sticky Lip Gloss

Put a light dusting of powder over your lip gloss. The trade off is that it will be less glossy (Edit: as mentioned above, I use a sponge, but some people in the comments have suggested putting a single ply tissue over your lips and dusting through the tissue paper with a brush).

Biologically Asymmetric Lips

This is not an old tip because this used to not matter and was not something that most people even looked for, but I saw someone online say that they use a lipliner that is the same color as their lips to fill in the parts that lack pigment before they apply their lipstick, making their lips look symmetrical.

Lip Size (Width or Thickness) or You Are Otherwise Sad That You Don't Match Current Standards of Beauty

Listen ya'll, I get it, it's extremely frustrating to live in a society that simultaneously says "love yourself just how you are" and yet "here is an excruciatingly detailed list of beauty standards that we expect you to follow to be considered polished and acceptable, some of which are literally impossible for you to meet." And while my dusty old ass wants to scream at you that you as an individual are not responsible for the whole of societal bullshit and are not obligated to have deep daydreams about how you could, maybe, magically measure up to whatever marketing firms have told everyone to prioritize this decade, I know that you have Instagram and Snapchat and Existence-In-Society and are being beaten over the head everyday with the Hindenburg-style slow crash and burn that is Influencer culture. I fucking know that some of you scanned this rant/list looking for "how to make my lips look larger/smaller/different-color/something." I know this because my own formative decades had their own "must haves" of beauty, and I know that you are going to be looking for a solution regardless of how many "love yourself" Disney Channel Special Episodes were thrown at you as a child because even the child stars on those shows looked like proto-models. So I'm not going to waste your time with some "love yourself" shit because you know that you should, and hopefully you know that I love you too. Instead, I'm going to slap down some actual advice that I hope can actually embrace your lips. My method of handling features of lips (or face for that matter) that no not match current beauty standards is to try to pay homage to a style that emphasized those features as attractive. When I'm feeling a bit down on my lips, I roll into work with a Gibson Girl late Victorian makeup style, which emphasized my natural lip shape as attractive. I look classic and my lip shape adds to to the look instead of detracting (which is what happens if I try to look like a YouTubeInstaFluencer, which assumes a lip shape that I don't have). But since variety is the spice of life, and I have no idea what all you pores look like, here are some other historical looks that you can use for inspiration:

  • Ancient Egypt: tomb paintings seem to suggest that they valued symmetry over size, though ancient Egyptian history is long and had so many trends it's hard to to pinpoint a specific look. Generally speaking, they mostly focused on large eyes and straight noses than lips.

  • Ancient Greece (~200BC): A strong emphasis on a prominent cupids bow and square bottom lip. Width or thickness wasn't as important as symmetry, which seems to have been the most important factor.

  • India (~1000AD): lips of small width but of a luscious rosebud shape.

  • China (Ming Dynasty ~1350AD): lips as small as possible in both width and thickness.

  • Nepal and Tibet (~1300AD): lips that were a round overall shape.

  • Renaissance Italy (~1400sAD): very thin lips that were not emphasized as a major feature of the face.

  • Germany in the early modern period (~1500AD): lips with a slightly larger upper lip.

  • Pre-Revolution France (~1700AD): very pink lips. Size seemed to be less important than color.

  • Meiji Restoration Japan (~1790AD): lips with a petal shape, where the upper lip was slightly larger than the lower.

  • England (~1900AD): Era of the Gibson Girl, defined by lips that were of small width but vertically thick with a prominent cupids bow.

  • America (~1920AD): Flapper style lips of small width with a small lower lip and prominent cupids bow.

  • Europe (~1930AD): Era of the Gustav Klimt style lip: long width but very thin.

  • Africa (other than Egyptian which I already mentioned): it is estimated that there are currently around 3000 tribes on the continent, therefore the history is so incredibly rich that it would be impossible to list it all. Here are some of the most well known tribes/groups whose history you may want to look into: Zulu tribe (South Africa, Lesotho, and Zimbabwe), Maasai (Tanzania and Kenya), San Bushmen (Botswana, Namibia, and South Africa), and the Yoruba (Nigeria, Benin, Ghana, and Togo).

If Your Lipstick Gets on Your Glass or Straw

This used to be considered sexy af, which I approve of. But if you really hate getting lipstick on your glass or straw, the best method is to lick the surface of the glass/straw before you start drinking. The reason that this works is because most bullet style lipsticks are made from some combination of wax and oils which are typically hydrophobic and so won't dissolve in water. Lipstick is purposely made this way to account for your saliva and moistened lips, but a glass or straw is (initially) dry, and so the lipstick sticks to it. If you moisten a glass or straw with water or saliva then it will decrease the amount to which the lipstick will transfer to it.

Links to my Dusty Old Guides