r/Metaphysics • • Dec 16 '25

Ontology Why is there something rather than nothing?

Post image
864 Upvotes

This question has been troubling me lately. I'm not looking for answers; I know I won't find them, but I'm trying to get as close as possible. While we don't have answers, there are ways to approach this problem, and one that particularly intrigues me suggests that there couldn't be anything because it's a self-destructive concept. Nothingness cannot exist, and therefore there could never be absolutely nothing. But this is as clear-cut as saying "just because," and it's inevitable to feel uneasy.


r/Metaphysics • • May 04 '26 Heartwarming Mindblown

Mind / Subjective experience A 90 second explanation of panpsychism — Rupert Sheldrake

623 Upvotes

r/Metaphysics • • Jan 04 '26 Bravo

Philosophy of Mind Do you agree with Spinoza's idea of ​​God?

Post image
567 Upvotes

Summary:

Single Substance (God/Nature): There is only one infinite substance, which is God, and that same substance is Nature; everything else (minds, bodies, objects) are "modes" or finite expressions of this single substance, just as waves are part of the ocean.

Pantheism: His philosophy is pantheistic, since it identifies God with the universe and nature, not with a transcendent creator who is outside of his creation.

Immanence: God is not outside the world, but is in the world, as its essence and its efficient cause. The laws of the universe are the laws of God.

Determinism: Everything happens by natural necessity, following the laws of this infinite substance. There is no place for miracles or external divine will, since everything is part of a perfect and determined order.

Determinism: Everything happens by natural necessity, following the laws of this infinite substance. There is no place for miracles or external divine will, since everything is part of a perfect and determined order. Total Connection: All beings, thoughts, and actions are interconnected as parts of this divine reality. Understanding this unity is key to understanding existence.


r/Metaphysics • • Feb 25 '22

Theoretical physics The Double Slit Experiment anyone? Lol

Post image
500 Upvotes

r/Metaphysics • • Dec 08 '25

Time If time is happening all at once like the block suggest what does that say about the theoretical life cycle of the universe

Post image
389 Upvotes

based on our current models this universe is one a life cycle but if box theory is true wouldn’t that make the universe technical infinite since it’s in this weird this of dying and living?


r/Metaphysics • • May 16 '26

Mind / Subjective experience Existing at all, experiencing at all, is literal magic.

365 Upvotes

As I said, its quite simple really when you think about it. The fact that things exist and are experienced is a form of literal magic. Whether you think about it in the sense of something coming from nothing (supposedly impossible), a reality with no beginning, just the sheer fact that things exist at all, and the fact things are experienced at all, it has no possible explanation other than literal magic happening for real. Science has no answer to this and I truly believe that this is the most important thing to think about, the fact your here at all. Its the greatest mystery ever. I feel like nobody really notices they exist properly. Never feel the vertigo of staring at a bottomless brute fact, actual magic occurring.


r/Metaphysics • • Jan 21 '26

Mind / Subjective experience The Uncommon Sense Of Nondualism | Why naturalists should take nondualism seriously

Post image
328 Upvotes

https://7provtruths.substack.com/p/nondualism-for-naturalists-the-uncommon

Nondualism usually comes shrouded in mysticism. This is the naturalist version: grounded in biology, evolution, and phenomenology - and urgently relevant to our fractured present.


r/Metaphysics • • Aug 16 '22

Metametaphysics The title

168 Upvotes

r/Metaphysics • • Mar 20 '22

Metametaphysics "If you peel the box open, what was outside of awareness, becomes inside—and what was inside—becomes the outside, of awareness, therefore subject to speculation and belief."

Post image
168 Upvotes

r/Metaphysics • • Jun 27 '25 This

Nothing Why nothing can't create something

138 Upvotes

Since matter is something, how can nothing create something, if nothing is the absence of something? If nothing has any kind of structure, then it’s not really nothing, because a structure is something.

If someone says “nothing” can create something, then they’re giving “nothing” some kind of ability or behavior, like the power to generate, fluctuate, or cause. But if “nothing” can do anything at all, it must have some kind of rule, capacity, or potential, and that’s already a structure. And if it has structure, it’s no longer truly nothing, it’s a form of something pretending to be nothing.

That’s why I think true nothingness can’t exist. If it did, there’d be no potential, no time, no change, nothing at all. So if something exists now, then something must have always existed. Not necessarily this universe, but something, because absolute nothingness couldn’t have produced anything.

People sometimes say, “Well, maybe in a different universe, ‘nothing’ behaves differently.” But that doesn’t make sense to me. We are something, and “nothing” is such a fundamental concept that it doesn’t depend on which universe you're in. Nothing is the same everywhere. It’s the total absence of anything, by definition. If it can change or behave differently, it’s not really nothing.

So the idea that something came from true nothing just doesn’t hold up. Either nothingness is impossible, or something has to exist necessarily.


r/Metaphysics • • Feb 18 '26

Model of the Universe as a living system II

Thumbnail
gallery
128 Upvotes

r/Metaphysics • • Jul 15 '26

Ontology What is existence itself “existing in”? (Not asking about the universe’s location)

123 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about this for a while, and I can’t find an answer that addresses what I’m actually asking.
I’m not asking where Earth is, where the Milky Way is, or where the universe is located.
I’m asking something more fundamental.
Everything we know seems to exist within something else. Earth is in the Solar System. The Solar System is in the Milky Way. The Milky Way is in the universe.
But what is existence itself existing in?
If the answer is that the universe isn’t “in” anything because space and time are part of the universe, then my question is still: what is existence itself? What is the “medium,” if there is one, in which reality exists?
And if the answer is “nothing,” doesn’t that just create another question? Why is there existence at all instead of absolutely nothing?
Has any philosopher or physicist seriously addressed this exact question? Is there a name for this problem, or is it still considered an open question?


r/Metaphysics • • Feb 06 '26

Nothing Why nothing was never an option, and what that implies about existence

114 Upvotes

The question “Why is there something rather than nothing?” is usually treated as the deepest metaphysical puzzle. But I think it rests on a hidden assumption that deserves scrutiny: that absolute nothingness is a genuine possible alternative to existence.

By “nothing, I don’t mean empty space, a vacuum, or a quantum ground state. All of those are still something. I mean absolute nothingness: no objects, no fields, no laws, no spacetime, no facts whatsoever.

My claim is ontological, not psychological or semantic: absolute nothingness lacks the minimal structure required to count as a possible state of affairs at all.

For something to be a state of affairs, it must at least be differentiable, something that could obtain rather than fail to obtain. But absolute nothingness has no properties, no conditions, and no features by which it could be distinguished, sustained, or even described as “obtaining. There is nothing for it to be like. No facts, not even the “fact” that nothing exists.

Importantly, this isn’t an argument from imagination or language. It’s a claim about modality. Concepts like absence, negation, or non being are only intelligible against an already existing background of being. In that sense, “nothing” is parasitic on “something, not an alternative to it.

If this is right, then reality was never facing two options, something or nothing. Only something was ever on the table.

This doesn’t tell us what exists, why reality has these particular laws, or whether the universe is eternal or finite. But it does suggest something deeper: existence as such is not contingent in the way finite things are. Finite entities depend on conditions under which they could fail to exist.

But if absolute non existence was never a coherent possibility, then existence itself doesn’t depend on conditions in the same way.

So perhaps the real philosophical task isn’t explaining how something emerged from nothing but understanding why nothing was never an option in the first place.

I’m interested in serious objections or refinements, especially from metaphysics or philosophy of physics.


r/Metaphysics • • Dec 11 '25

Nothing What is "nothing"?

Post image
113 Upvotes

Answer: is it no-thing.

Every other day (it seems as if-) there's a post about some new theory that uses this word.

  • "nothing" (some theory derived 'from nothing', or similar...)

  • Related: "zero" ('0') — absence of any/all quantity and value.

It is absence of any/all things, [any possible descriptive] existence.

  • It is parasitic-relational in definition to "something".

  • You cannot define "nothing" except by absence (pre-supposing something).

Absence, by definition, references presence.

  • While presence is self-sufficient (fundamental, even).

Question: What is "thing", such that "nothing" is "no-thing" (not a thing)?

It is the word referencing whatever may be discerned and distinguished.

  • A non-specific reference word, placeholder, pointer.

How do you discern 'thing'?

By form, description of it. Referencing features, and attributes.

> Qualities.

Like 'triangle', and 'sphere', and 'mother', 'tree', etc.

Understanding is things/objects/forms/identities and relationships.

  • "Objects and connections."

You cannot get something from absence,
because: absence is relational to something.

It is intuitively encoded into basic math (a logical "system of communication" [language]):

Based on this understanding, as an 'assumption' (that absence remains absence).

  • Even children understand, correlate. They have some natural disposition.

If: you doubt everything, then: you will eventually get to a point where doubting becomes incoherent. You cannot doubt yourself, or reasoning. Your reasoning is the filter by which you acquire 'knowledge' (models of understanding, about reality [as per your experience]).

  • Hence, what 'science' is → some reasoned methodology, or methodo-logical study.

  • Of subjects, topics of study. They are intelligible (have description), are !nothing.

  • -- "things" that can be studied in methodo-logically (at all, in the first place).

-- meaningful operations via principles of validity (logic), based on understanding.

It is to the limits of rational thought/discourse,
> these things (so that, they must be true).


r/Metaphysics • • Nov 16 '25

Cosmology I think the distinction between natural and supernatural is artificial

110 Upvotes

If there is a "supernatural" world such as an aftterlife or other dimensions that it is just another aspect of reality with it's own rules and laws just like our observable universe has its own properties and laws.

We have a strong sense of familiarity with our reality because we are so used to living in it for so long, but if we experienced this world for the first time with no sense of familiarity of it and knowing nothing of it, it would be a surreal, insane, and "supernatural" experience, because we would be experiencing something strange.

So "supernatural" just means something we don't know about that would be very radically different from what we are used to.


r/Metaphysics • • Apr 13 '23

Metaphysics, Science, and The Real

Post image
100 Upvotes

r/Metaphysics • • 26d ago

Time Does the fact that we experience time prove that time is real?

98 Upvotes

I recently read J. Ellis McTaggart's The Unreality of Time, which argues that time is unreal. One of his main arguments is that the distinction between the past, present, and future leads to a contradiction.

I came up with one question: we all experience time passing. We remember the past, experience the present, and think about the future. But does this experience actually prove that time exists, or could our experience of time be misleading?

I personally find it difficult to imagine that time isn't real because it seems like such a basic part of our everyday lives. At the same time, I wonder if experiencing something is enough to prove that it exists.

What do you think? Does our experience of time provide evidence that time is real?


r/Metaphysics • • Feb 07 '20

Ontology I spend most of my time thinking about existence, Ive even written papers about it, but I didnt know it was called "metaphysics" until a week ago.

94 Upvotes

Everyone Ive ever met finds this topic to be a waste, but to me it feels like the only thing worth contemplating. I would like to discuss some of my theories with anyone who cares to listen.


r/Metaphysics • • 14d ago Bravo

Metametaphysics I Tried Doubting Everything I Knew. Three Questions Survived

93 Upvotes

I've been working through a line of thought for a while, and I'd like it stress-tested, because I suspect it's weaker in places than it feels.

The chain, as I've got it:

  1. My senses are unreliable. The sun doesn't go round the Earth. There's nothing blue in the sky. The light is blue; the air isn't.

  2. My mind isn't under my control. I can't predict my next thought. Tell me not to think of a pink elephant and it's already too late.

  3. Nearly everything I "know" is provisional. Pluto was a planet for 76 years.

  4. But one thing resists doubt. Augustine: "If I am mistaken, I exist." Shankara: nobody ever has the experience "I do not exist." Descartes: "I think, therefore I am."

  5. Russell's objection: Descartes wasn't entitled to the "I". All he'd shown was "there are thoughts."

  6. My response: fine, drop the "I". There is still awareness of thinking, and I can't find a way to doubt that without using it. Doubting is just another instance of it.

Where I think it's weakest:

  • Getting from "awareness is happening" to any kind of self, let alone an unchanging one. Russell's point (and Lichtenberg's older "it thinks") bites here, and I don't have a knock-down answer.

  • Deep sleep. I want to say the world and the "me" arrive together every morning and leave together every night. The obvious reply is that the world carries on whether or not I'm perceiving it. I can't refute that. All I can say is that every time I check, I'm there checking - which is a predicament, not an argument.

  • The "what noticed?" experiment. When you catch your mind wandering, a neuroscientist will say that's metacognition, the brain monitoring itself, and that's a perfectly good answer. I'm genuinely unsure the experience points anywhere beyond it.

What I'd like to know:

  • Is there a good answer to Russell, or does all this collapse into "there are experiences" and stop there?

  • For anyone who's actually tried noticing the moment the mind comes back, or checking a dream right after waking: what did you find? Not the theory - the noticing.

TL;DR: Every proof needs someone there to examine it, so "something is aware" seems impossible to doubt. But I can't get from there to "I" without help, and I'd like to know where the reasoning breaks.

Disclosure: I make a small YouTube series exploring this (@metaphysicalTechie). I've left the links out on purpose - I'm here for the objections, not the views. Happy to share if anyone asks.


r/Metaphysics • • Oct 06 '26

Ontology If the reality we experience is the only thing that we have experienced, then how do we know that there isnt anything beyond our reality?

84 Upvotes

r/Metaphysics • • May 21 '22

Mind / Subjective experience What's everyone's opinion on non duality / nonlocal consciousness. Planck and Schrodinger believed in it after dealing with the measurment problem, which is derivative of Eastern philosophies such as buddhism and Hinduism. They both believed in eternal consciousness not created by the brain

Thumbnail
gallery
84 Upvotes

r/Metaphysics • • Apr 19 '25

Ontology Is it possible the universe just… exists?

81 Upvotes

As most people have probably done before, I was questioning the existence of our universe, and the age old question of what came before. This led me to two conclusions.

My first thought was that the universe is purely physical and objective, none of it being subjective. As humans we often ask “circular questions” expecting straight answers, because as humans that’s how we are biologically coded, and after all almost everything that exists has a cause and effect. But back to my point of our universe being purely physical. Our universe is completely indifferent to human existence, and any other conscious existence for that matter. So, by that nature, it doesn’t operate under any conceptualization. That would mean there is a very high possibility that the universe could have always existed and will continue to exist forever. Now many people wouldn’t accept that answer for the simple reason that “it doesn’t make sense” but it wouldn’t have to make any sense, as it doesn’t owe us an explanation, it is indifferent.

My second and very similar thought is that we humans could be right and there could have been a big bang. Which would also usher the same question, what happened before the Big Bang? Yet again, the Big Bang could have just happened for no reason at all, and our universe could fizzle out and die in trillions of years and never explode again for no reason.

I’m sure this is a common thought amongst meta physicists and those who are interested in the subject, however it really intrigued me and I’d like to hear what others think.


r/Metaphysics • • Mar 02 '22

Mind / Subjective experience The Labyrinth: Rewiring the Nodes in the Maze of your Mind by Rei Rei

Post image
80 Upvotes

r/Metaphysics • • Oct 11 '26

Nothing Is absolute nothingness even possible?

79 Upvotes

I've been thinking about this, and the more I think about it, the less sense it makes.

Imagine a reality where absolutely NOTHING exists. No Earth, no universe, no space, no time, no life. Nothing whatsoever.

Here's the problem, we can't actually imagine that.

Whenever we try, we imagine a black void. But blackness is still something. We imagine an empty space, but space itself is something. We imagine silence, but silence is just the absence of sound. We imagine waiting in nothingness, but waiting requires time, and experiencing requires a conscious observer.

Even if you close your eyes and try to imagine nothing, you're still experiencing something.

And here's an even stranger thought, if absolutely nothing existed, there wouldn't even be a moment in which nothing existed. A moment requires time. There wouldn't be a place where nothing existed, either, because that would require space.

We can imagine the absence of individual things, but can we imagine the absence of EVERYTHING?

I'm not claiming this proves absolute nothingness is impossible. Maybe our brains simply aren't capable of comprehending it.

But if absolute nothingness is impossible, does that mean something must have always existed?

I'd genuinely like to hear other people's thoughts on this.