r/learnpython • • Sep 15 '20

IT Denied My Request to Download Python Due to Security Reasons...

I used to have admin rights (data analyst) at my previous employer.

After starting my new role, as a sales analytics manager, I can’t even get python (or even a database application) installed...

Other than personal projects, any other creative ways to continue using python?

Edit: WOW! Thanks for all the feedback. I’ve addressed it to my manager and we’ve agreed to request it again after I propose a proper justification that backs up my needs to download Python. If it gets denied by IT again, my manager might go straight to the CEO but I don’t know if that’ll be necessary. Until then, I’ll have to familiarize myself with VBA again!

Suggestions to consider:

  • VM

  • Anaconda

422 Upvotes

182 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/ka-splam Sep 16 '20

You have a ticketing system? Just use email instead?

Ticketing systems add overhead and bureaucracy which makes individual people's lives worse, and they do it so the team can hand tasks around between people in an organised way and management can get reports from it. That's like blocking individual Python installs and mandating Excel because while it's individually worse, it's collectively better because many people can use it. Many people would love to use email instead, no forms to fill in, no time to keep, no attachments to add, no categories and priorities and metadata to deal with, but they're forbidden from doing so.

You're arguing against yourself here.

You have health monitoring software and dashboards and notifications?

People generally don't build that in-house, they buy ones from companies with support contracts, standard ones with documentation and training materials that behave in well known ways that every employee knows how to use and configure. Your Python equivalent would be getting rid of standard monitoring software and every employee building their own - it would be a bad approach. Arguing against yourself again.

But no, you can't imagine doing your job without the tools that increase your productivity and make your life easier.

Working on remote servers almost always means you get to use what comes by default and nothing else, because you'll never get the approval to install some custom tool for one task. Get used to the GNU utilities, busybox, PowerShell 5 and Vi. Doing your job without tools that increase your productivity is a large part of many server managementy jobs, and IT people can imagine doing that.

You got something to save the ip address or server names of the servers you maintain? Why don't you just start using excel instead?

If you don't think companies use Excel for documentation, for IP addresses and server names, you need to rethink. They absolutely do, and again for the same reason - it may be rubbish but everyone knows it, and it's available everywhere.

There will be fires

The fires are predictable and avoidable, and to the company, cheap to avoid. Companies like to avoid fires more than they like to encourage employees to play with matches.

they'll learn about good development practices just like IT figured it out slowly over the past few decades

Did people learn that about Excel macros? About exploitable Wordpress sites? Can't they learn that first and show that they've learned it instead of expecting IT to approve of them learning it on the company time with IT on the hook for it?

There will be fires, but they'll learn about good development practices just like IT figured it out slowly over the past few decades. Hell, they're still trying to figure out of. I've seen our IT architecture drawings and documenting.

Wait, you're half arguing that ordinary people will learn Git and the proof is that IT figured it out, then saying IT are too incompetent to draw pictures? That again doesn't support your position at all.

Stop acting like it's a fucking fringe request.

Anecdotal, but I just searched our ticketing system, and found a single request for Python that wasn't relating to regular patching Linux servers, and that request was not any kind of analyst or developer and only to run an existing Python program.

You guys aren't as good as you like to make others think.

... then they definitely shouldn't be pushing a new wave of innovation which could get the company tangled up if it goes wrong. People who aren't very good should stick to doing the basics as well as they can.

I generally agree that people should have access to powerful tools, and especially data analysts should have access to Python. Your arguments still aren't very strong.

1

u/eloydrummerboy Sep 16 '20 edited Sep 16 '20

First, I admit my analogies were far from perfect, but they were of the top of my head, and I've never worked in IT, just closely with IT. I could have thought of better ones from my company but they'd have been so specific no one would relate. The point is, most IT departments use a large variety of software to get their job done, and those employees who are fine denying someone else Python would surely bitch and moan if they lost their tools. Does every IT team have all the tools that want? No. But they surely have the basics. For a data analyst, Python is literally "the basics". At this point it's almost a requirement. Just go ahead and look up data science or data analyst courses online. Your beginner level will start with excel to get the foundation, but quickly move to a programming language (likely Python, maybe R) when you start doing anything that remotely resembles "real world work". It's not a "nice to have". It's not being selfish. It's not just trying to piss off IT. it's a VERY reasonable request and any modern IT department better have a damn good reason for blocking it.

Will "ordinary" people (does that make IT abnormal or extraordinary) learn git? Yes. Yes they will. They have. I'm one. It's really not that hard. Maybe I'm biased because I'm an engineer and I work with engineers. But you don't even need to use the command line anymore if that makes you uncomfortable. Git for Windows or the web interface work just fine. Also, IT developers and IT architects are two different breeds. That's one area I feel for IT. They always get lumped together. Devs, sys admins, local tech guy, architect, DBAs, support. But I digress. Business people today have this super advantage. It's called YouTube. There are great videos on all this stuff, and Clean Code is a short easy read. But they're going to bitch. Why do they need to do this? Until the changes get too complex to manage, they put the wrong file in production, they want to go back to an old version but they can't, whatever. Then it will click, "oh, that's why IT uses version control/ documentation/ clean code/ comments/ a QA environment/..." and then they'll change. Hopefully. But people are people. Every bad habit the business might have, IT has too, they've just had it beat into them they can't do things that way... so they only do occasionally when "this really has to get to production". ;)

Again, louder this time for the people in the back,...

PYTHON IS NOT A NEW WAVE OF INNOVATION. ITS A BADIC, STANDARD DATA ANALYSIS TOOL. IF YOUR COMPANY HIRES FOR DATA ANALYSTS OR DATA SCIENTISTS AND YOUR IT DEPARTMENT REJECTS REQUESTS FOR PYTHON, YOU WORK IN A POORLY MANAGED COMPANY.

Edit: and all of this about letting there be fires is coming from the view that a policy should be in place where IT supports what they build, the business supports what they build. I agree IT shouldn't have to put out business fires. But they should spin up servers, and make risk assessments of using Python, and take steps to mitigate that risk (steps that don't include simply saying "no"). And it's also assuming any company just starting out using python for data analytics will simply be doing reporting or of the gate. We're taking, write a single file script that gives some insight, make a few plots, turn into power point or jupyter notebook, present to management, never use again. Some of those might become regularly ran reports. But they're likely not thing to try to productionalize a fucking ML prediction model that is business critical on day 1. So let's ask calm down a bit. As they grow in complexity, they be learning about proper DevOps as well. Especially if they have a good relationship with their IT department! And don't get called names for wanting basic tools to do the job they were hired for!