r/Jurisprudence • • Apr 23 '15

In The Sopranos, someone tells Tony to meet with all of the top local divorce lawyers, so that none of them will be able to take his wife on as a client. Would that really work? Is it really good advice?

14 Upvotes

r/Jurisprudence • • Apr 12 '15

Is there a legal way for overwhelmed parents of disabled children to escape their responsibilities?

13 Upvotes

If you have a child you just don't want to take care of anymore what is there you can do about that short of suicide?


r/Jurisprudence • • Mar 20 '15

If a coworker is stealing my food, can I taint the food if I give warning that it's tainted?

13 Upvotes

It's been discussed before what would happen if a coworker was stealing your food and you put laxatives/hot sauce/horse feces/semen/whatever in it to teach them a lesson. The consensus is that it's illegal because you know they'll eat it and you intend for them to ingest whatever you've tainted it with.

But what if I tainted the food and put a note on the food that said "Hey food thief, before you steal my lunch again, you should know that I jizzed in it five times this morning." Would that still be illegal?


r/Jurisprudence • • Mar 17 '15

Robert Durst facing charges after statements made on his new HBO documentary

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
11 Upvotes

r/Jurisprudence • • Mar 18 '15

Books about existing books

10 Upvotes

I see this on Amazon a lot and was wondering how it was legal. If I wrote a book about the crazy amount of racism in Harry potter or the many theories that arise from all the foreshadowing in 50 shades of grey, would I get the pants sued off me? How is this not essentially published fanfiction?


r/Jurisprudence • • Mar 17 '15

Could Tommy Chong's house be searched based on something he said in an interview?

10 Upvotes

In this interview, Tommy Chong says:

I've got so much weed in the house now, I could start a dispensary.

I know it'd never actually happen, but I was wondering if this could be used by police as probable cause to search his house and arrest him?


r/Jurisprudence • • Apr 09 '22

This made me happy and sad at the same time! Excerpt from Jurisprudence by RWM Dias

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/Jurisprudence • • Oct 11 '18

What is "Lex Mercatoria" and why does Jur represent a paradigm change in this enduring concept? Have a read of this article to find out.

Thumbnail
medium.com
9 Upvotes

r/Jurisprudence • • Feb 26 '16

Self-destruction, evidence, and passwords

9 Upvotes

Hey

Had a thought. I don't know a lot of law, but I was under the impression that currently, you can't be forced to unlock devices/enter passwords. If I have a computer with a "wipe the hard drive if the password isn't entered once a week", it gets seized as evidence, then deletes itself, is it tampering with evidence? Can you be compelled to come in once a week to reset it?

I'd be surprised if it was settled law, was wondering what the general feel was


r/Jurisprudence • • Sep 13 '15

[US] Damaging another's income by saying something good (but false) about him

9 Upvotes

Weird hypothetical: John Doe is a professional artist whose fanbase despises me. Being a troll, I put up a review saying how much I love Doe's latest album, and in response some of his fanbase stops buying his music. Is there any tort under which Doe could successfully sue me? If him losing fans was my intent, rather than just being a troll, would that make a difference?


r/Jurisprudence • • Apr 30 '15

Can the parent of a 17 year old refuse to give him/her the entirety of a bottle of medication, as long as they're still giving him/her individual doses on time?

9 Upvotes

This might be a dumb question, but it popped into my head randomly earlier and I'm curious. It's a pretty dramatic situation, but I hope you can hear me out without banging your head on your desk out of anger.

Say there's a 17 year old, Sarah, who lives with her mom. She has ADHD and is prescribed Adderall by her psychiatrist. Sarah's mom always takes the Adderall bottle and hides it from her. However, her mom still gives her the correct dose on time every day. Sarah is going camping for 4 days and asks her mom for the bottle, but she refuses. Since Sarah is 17, does her mom have "ownership" over the medication, or is Sarah entitled to possession of her entire prescription? Does it change based on what state she's in, or if the medication is a controlled substance? Would the answer be different if her mother wasn't giving them to her as prescribed (like not giving them at the correct time, withholding them temporarily as punishment, etc.)?


r/Jurisprudence • • Mar 29 '15

If cops show up to a man pointing a gun at another man, and the cops say "Go ahead, shoot them," what are the implications?

9 Upvotes

Was watching a fictional TV show where police pulled up on a man holding another man at gun point. After drawing their own weapons at the armed man, one cop eventually put their gun down and said "Go ahead, shoot him. He deserves it."

My limited legal knowledge tells me that this does not hold legal ground, but can the cop be held liable for anything? Doesn't seem like entrapment since the cop didn't coerce the person into doing something they weren't already going to do....


r/Jurisprudence • • Jul 02 '15

Are judges allowed to question witnesses?

8 Upvotes

This is in regards to big cases and not judge Judy type proceedings.


r/Jurisprudence • • Jun 26 '15

Without violating the new precedent established by Obergefell v. Hodges, defend the continuing ban on polyamorous marriage.

8 Upvotes

From the decision:

"No union is more profound than marriage, for it embodies the highest ideals of love, fidelity, devotion, sacrifice, and family. In forming a marital union, two people become something greater than once they were. As some of the petitioners in these cases demonstrate, marriage embodies a love that may endure even past death. It would misunderstand these men and women to say they disrespect the idea of marriage. Their plea is that they do respect it, respect it so deeply that they seek to find its fulfillment for themselves. Their hope is not to be condemned to live in loneliness, excluded from one of civilization’s oldest institutions. They ask for equal dignity in the eyes of the law. The Constitution grants them that right"

Defend the assertion that a marital union between 3 or more joint spouses does not enjoy the same protection as a union between 2 spouses.


r/Jurisprudence • • Apr 18 '15

How do "work from home" companies get away with paying less than minimum wage?

8 Upvotes

I do work for an audio transcription company based in New Zealand. They pay $20 (USD) per audio hour, which works out to $4 / hour (assuming 5 minutes per audio minute, which is the standard guideline). Apparently the NZ minimum wage is $11.33 (USD), so how do they get away with paying less than minimum wage?


r/Jurisprudence • • Mar 17 '15

So I'm going to throw something out there... re: courtesy visit after alarm went off

7 Upvotes

This happened last night, and nothing bad happened. But the "what if" is still over my head, so I will throw it to the public. I know the whole "don't talk to the cops, don't invite the cops in" but in the moment I did exactly the opposite.

So... this happened last night. I went to my brother's house because he is out of town and has a guinea pig. He just wanted me to check on the little squeaker, refill the food, ect. He gave me both the garage code and the alarm code. All is good, right?

I walk in the house (garage opened just fine) and the alarm starts beeping. I find the alarm pad and enter the code. It continues beeping. S%it, I entered it wrong.. so I hit it again. The alarm starts blaring, and I figure I hit the wrong button when I jumped. Try it a third time, nothing. The little butthead gave me the wrong code! So I call him, he gives me the alarm code, and it finally turns off. However, in this time they have dispatched the police. There was a knock at the door, and I knew who it would be. Yep, an officer asking if everything is OK and that he was dispatched because of the alarm.

He asks what happened, I said the HO gave me the wrong code. There are bugs flying about, so I told him he was welcome to step in. He asks for my ID and calls it in to dispatch. He looks around briefly (checked down the hall and in the room I was in). Before leaving, he mentions that "if there is a burglary call, he will know who did it".

SO... my questions...

  1. Did I have to give him my ID?

  2. If I had warrants, would he have taken me in? (no, I do not have any. Just a question)

  3. Because I am not the HO or living there, did he have a right to look around? (Again, nothing to hide just wondering)

  4. If there WAS a robbery, would I be blamed for it?


r/Jurisprudence • • Mar 17 '15

Protected Classes -- Veterans

7 Upvotes

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_class

Veteran Status is a protected class. Does that mean that every store or movie theatre that offers a "veteran discount" is in violation of Title VII (anti-discrimination law)?

Pregnancy In the same vein, what about special seats on the bus for pregnant women?


r/Jurisprudence • • Feb 16 '21

Why Liberalism Failed by Patrick J. Deneen

6 Upvotes

Essay on Why Liberalism Failed?

In this essay, I will explain how Deneen sets out the history of liberalism as a development from classical liberalism to progressive liberalism. I claim that Deneen outlined the hallmark signals of political-modernity in the form of three questions: first, in the Aristotelian sense, should the polity appeal to the high or the low; second, is human nature fixed or is it plastic to our touch; third, should we reach beyond nature and pursue Man’s conquest of human nature to the extent of reversing the Fall? I will now explore the extent to which those distinct questions illuminate our current political categories as a foray into ​Libertas.

According to Deneen, the founding thought of Western political civilization was focused on the control over the will to power. This focus gestured to a mutual understanding that the soul of the polity would not survive if the individual succumbed to vice. The only way to prevent arbitrary inequality, poverty, and oppression is through self-governance.

The political philosophy of Ancient Greece was to produce men with chests. The ethic of paideia stressed that intellect would govern the appetites for desire through the organ of virtue. This organ of virtue governed the souls of citizens and fostered correctives to tyranny. Citizenship itself was self-governance in wisdom, justice, temperance, and moderation to protect libertas​ through the ongoing habituation of tradition and law.

The political philosophy of Christian premodernity is continuous from the Greek emphasis on ​paideia​ by retaining teachings in virtue but changed by adding institutional structures of checks and balances on power and by rooting government in religion. Christian political philosophy accepts the Fall of man as fixed, and thus conquers nature through collective knowledge and systemic rationality.

The classical and Christian political philosophy appealed to themes of beauty, journey, and rest. The only way to achieve true freedom was to have a discerning mind that could perceive the proper order of things. In so doing, you could perceive what was real and meaningful and thus return to God. To both the Ancient Greeks and Medieval Christians, citizenship was preparation for death. They believed in a reverse ordering to life, so the achievement of true freedom was much like your return to God-it depended on self-governance and the dignified participation in the polity.

So, when Deneen questioned whether we should appeal to the ​high​ or the ​low​, he was demonstrating a split between premodernity and modernity. Ultimately, Deneen questioned the protoliberal conception of liberty derivative of Man’s acceptance of the Fall and reliance on collective knowledge and systemic rationality to self-govern. Thus, the first hallmark sign of modernity is that politics would be based on the low rather than the high.

According to Deneen, it was Machiavelli who first broke from the Classical and Christian teachings in virtue to limit tyranny. Machiavelli's, ​The New Prince​, instructed that the new-prince should appropriate God’s divinity to control public opinion and power all the while appearing virtuous. In this way, justice no longer belonged to God, it belonged at the convenience of the new-prince.

Henceforward, reliance on virtue was ineffectual because it had no stopping power. What is more predictable and reliable, and thus more stable, is man’s appeal to vice, checks and balances on power, and rule of law. According to Machiavelli, the future belongs to those who are ​willing​ to be wicked when the survival of the state necessitates wickedness. This, no doubt, is a critique of the reliance on virtue to safeguard armed and capable political leaders from falling into the temptation of tyranny.

Additionally, with the advent of Descartes and Hobbes, virtue as a precondition for liberty was challenged and rejected. Not only did they reject virtue as a realistic standard for behavior, but they also rejected the roots of virtue. Hobbes asserted that unexamined tradition is a source for arbitrary inequality. In fact, there is no intellect in collective knowledge because it is preanalytic, and thus based on preposition and prejudice. Thus, the structures of self-governance arranged throughout the political, religious, social, economic, and familial life are arbitrary forms of inequality.

So, when Deneen questioned whether human nature is fixed or plastic to our touch, he was demonstrating the second split between pre-modernity and modernity. Ultimately, Deneen was questioning whether we should accept the Fall of man and rely on collective knowledge that has undergone the evolutionary process of selective competition. Although systemic rationality is preanalytic, it has distilled preposition and prejudice throughout Generations A-W and is expressed in Generation X.

If we reject the Fall of man, then we deracinate a government rooted in religion. We also reject social forms of governance on the ground that they are arbitrary forms of inequality, and we redefine the purpose of government from protecting the good-life to protecting unalienable rights. The danger is that if we don’t rely on collective knowledge, then we must rely on the consolidated power of a few cultivated minds and their articulated rationality; and if we reject a government rooted in religion, then what should replace such common ground as originating from a creator?

With the advent of Locke and Baconian philosophy, Liberalism began to enter modernity. According to Bacon, we can provide “relief [to] the human estate” by projecting our desires onto the world. Individualistic rationality is a more predictable guide for action because vice is a more reliable standard for behavior than virtue.

Since Bacon and Hobbes reconceptualized the Classic and Christian ‘acceptance’ of the moral limits of man, required a new relationship between man and nature. Human potential, they believed, was plastic to our touch. We no longer need to rely on the correctives of social norms, rather a social contract. According to Locke, authority and power are only made legitimate through consent.

So, when Deneen questioned whether we should reach beyond nature and pursue Man’s conquest of human-nature to the extent of reversing the Fall, he was demonstrating the third split between premodernity and modernity. Ultimately, Deneen was questioning whether we should build a society predicated on greed, pride, conquest for glory, and selfishness. Should we accept Bacon’s reconception of natural philosophy and political science?

If we do accept, then the purpose of government is being redefined from the protector of ‘right’ to the protector of individuality. Consequently, the definition of liberty must change from self-governance to absolute autonomy, and justice evolves from society to the state. So, I must ask, in what society is a citizen most free-one predicated on vice or virtue?

Your answer to my question is the ultimate foundation of Progressivism and Conservatism in our current political categories. In a word, should we be socially virtuous and economically wicked, or should we be socially wicked and economically virtuous?

Our new type of liberalism rejects the ancient notion of a learned capacity for self-limitation to control base desires. Rather, we rely on human knowledge to separate ourselves from nature and legitimize power through individualistic consent. Today, it would appear that Liberalism is triumphant. Man’s self-interest and reliance on science have led to a never before seen acceptance of all types of ideologies and removal of prejudicial, sexist, and racist spheres of interaction that divide, discriminate, and segregate.

However, Deneen believes that the triumphs of liberalism are illusory and “even a self-inflicted decline” (pp.29). Our self-interest has gone too far, and absolute freedom pursued absolutely requires an increasingly pervasive government to protect our notion of liberty in a liberal society. In the context of our current political categories, Deneen would assert that progressivism in a liberal society has consequently allowed for a pluralism that is eroding the very foundation of liberalism. Liberalism thus requires a virtuous society. Otherwise, our reliance on judicial legislation and positive law will lead to increasing levels of authoritarianism.

In conclusion, it is imperative that political leaders discern the succession of possible consequences when deciding the type of liberty the government should protect. Even more important is how liberty is protected and furthered. Before subscribing to these revolutions in thought, first, ask what type of life you wish to lead. Second, understand the moral ramifications of your actions. Third, recognize the gap between perceived freedom and actual freedom.


r/Jurisprudence • • Mar 03 '16

Using do not resuscitate bracelet(s) as handcuffs, as their removal is often illegal.

6 Upvotes

I know this varies by state, but this is just a make believe scenario.

Given the facts:

  1. Do not resuscitate bracelets are issued by the Secretary of State and are legally binding.

  2. Removal of said bracelet(s) without consent of the declarant is a civil offense.

  3. The wearer has used his bracelet(s) as a handcuff and has hand bound himself to something.

  4. The wearer does not consent to the removal of the bracelet(s).

Questions:

  1. Who can remove the these bracelets? How and why?

  2. Who cannot remove these bracelets? How and why?

  3. How does the location and/or object that the individual handcuffed himself to come into play?

This was just a fun thought I had today that I wanted to share. There are multiple possible answers, enjoy!


r/Jurisprudence • • Apr 30 '15

Theft by Surprise.

6 Upvotes

I'm a chilean law student. Right now I'm working on a paper about a crime that's known here as "robo por sorpresa", which translates to "theft by surprise" and that can be defined as the appropriation of money or other things when this is achieved through surprise or feigning fights in places of great concurrency. I don't know if something like that exists in USA or other countries but if you could refer me to some jurisprudence about it (maybe something about its iter criminis) it would be great.

I really aprecciate any help you can provide.


r/Jurisprudence • • Mar 18 '15

Real estate poison pill

6 Upvotes

If someone is a co-borrower (50/50) on a property and decided to walk away and give away fractional ownership to as many individuals as possible, how many fractional owners could there be? Would it be legal to do so? Would a lawyer even want to handle any disputes involving 51 people (50 people each owning 1% and 1 person owning 50%)? Would anarchy rule the streets? Would global warming be accelerated?


r/Jurisprudence • • Mar 17 '15

Detroit Walking Man's EX girlfriend attempting to claim money after his success in kickstarter based on verbal agreeement. (X-post from r/news)

6 Upvotes

Post Here

Does she have a leg to stand on, she claims they had a verbal agreement but with no real hard writing what grounds would she have to stand on? Does the timing of her demand diminish her credibility? Does the fact that the money was raised on a kickstarter and then gifted to him have any impact on this?


r/Jurisprudence • • May 05 '22

Excerpt from Reviewed work: Legal Duties and Other Essays by Carleton Kemp Allen. Review by A. Kocourek. University of Pennsylvania Law Review and American Law Register Vol. 80, No. 5 (Mar 1932)

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/Jurisprudence • • Apr 14 '22

What texts can I read to better understand Amendment IX?

5 Upvotes

The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.

I find this difficult to understand.


r/Jurisprudence • • Jun 26 '21

/r/jurisprudence hit 1k subscribers yesterday

Thumbnail
frontpagemetrics.com
5 Upvotes