Since this version of Java, even being a major version, contains only preview or incubator features, we shall really see LTS versions as "proper" major releases.
The new scheme is not outright bad, however, just hopped on the bandwagon that is "we shall release a new major version at time-boxed intervals, because we will look like old-fashioned compared to Ruby and Rust and co".
The new release model is probably the best thing that happened to Java on the management side — instead of the usual churn of “this feature has to be done till this deadline”, which might work for that boring CRUD feature but is absolutely terrible for such a complex program like the JVM, it allows for each new development to take as much time as necessary. If it didn’t get ready for release N, just continue to work on it and 6 months later it can be delivered. It is especially important as many of these features have non-trivial interactions with each others.
Also, that bandwagon hype thingy is quite childish, that has absolutely no base in reality.
If it didn’t get ready for release N, just continue to work on it and 6 months later it can be delivered.
I'm not sure what you mean by "didn't get ready for release N".
Release N has a set of phases specified and a corresponding set of dates. Which date in a release do you mean "get ready"?
Every 6 months, a new release cycle with new phases start, with a repository fork from the master repository.. The feature set that will be delivered is fixed after Rampdown Phase 1. No feature changes can happen after that in the release.
So even if feature X is ready at Release Candidate Phase for Release N, sorry, too late - had to be there at RDP1.
The observation, that "it allows for each new development to take as much time as necessary." is also true for non-timeboxed releases. Every features takes as much time as needed, even if it makes release cycles nonpredictable.
That is only true if the next release is in a fixed timebox of 3 years. If it is ready, when it's ready, the next release could happen in 2 or 3 months - when a new production-ready feature is ready.
2
u/persicsb Mar 21 '23
Since this version of Java, even being a major version, contains only preview or incubator features, we shall really see LTS versions as "proper" major releases.
The new scheme is not outright bad, however, just hopped on the bandwagon that is "we shall release a new major version at time-boxed intervals, because we will look like old-fashioned compared to Ruby and Rust and co".
Why don't we call them preview releases?