I few times a year I write Tim Cook an email with my observations on Apple and their products. Neither he nor his staff ever answer, but c'est la vie. It is entertainment for me, either way. Here's my latest:
SUBJECT: "Make Them Buy Both!"
Tim,
Ok, I get it. You don't want to make the iPad a laptop substitute because then people would either stop buying it or stop buying their macbooks, and you want to sell them both.
That is a very sound business strategy, and as far as i can tell it's working!
But you have to realize that at some point, someone is going to do a really legitimate job of this, and it will be too little, too late for Apple to rush out the long awaited Screen That Does It All.
I know that there are journalists and others who clamor for a macOS on the ipad, which would be an insanely easy thing for Apple to do, but which would cannibalize sales somewhere or another. Here's a better idea: an iPadOS that works.(I still think it should be rebranded, because iPadOS is a mouthful, and sounds too much like a feminine hygiene product, and very few of us want BOTH a mouthful AND a feminine hygiene product at the same time.)
What does a working iPadOS need to do?
We're so close. SOOOO CLOSE!
If you sent out a general questionaire you would be loaded down with so many features it would be overwhelming. But you can let app developers handle most of the missing functionality if you offer these three things to capture four missing demographics:
The Missing Ingredients:
The Browsers. The vast majority of people spend the vast majority of time in a web browser. But iPadOS has crippled browsers that lack crucial functionality and often do not render as well as desktops because web site developers have failed to accomodate the limitations. Any functionality that relies on browser extensions is dead in the water. Browser fucntionality that supports developers is largely unavailable. The answer: drop the WebKit requirement. Allow app developers to develop apps that make full use of your hardware.
Filesystem and Shell. You might argue I am cheating because this is two issues in one, but in fact, the the shell that saved the mac is primarily a means for working with the file system in a sophisticated developer centric way. A robust file system supports more than just developers, though, it empowers professional work across the board. Even windows finally gave in and provided a proper shell. Bow to the inevitable!
Multitasking done right (and audio streams). Ok, maybe I am really cheating this time, but as much as Apple has offered half-hearted solutions for multi-tasking, it has never landed. As exemplified by the iPadOS's inability to handle multiple audio streams simultaneously. The iPadOS was supposed to be for artists! For creators! But the only musicians I know using an iPad use it as for sheet music! We know the hardware supports it. Give the people what they need!
The Missing Demographics:
Developers. You can't write software for the iPad on an iPad. You can't joyfully write software for ANYTHING on an iPad. If you don't make developers happy, how will developers make your users happy?
Musicians. You have made the artists happy with the touch screen and pencil. Why do you hate musicians?
Gamers. You have a smattering of games that work amazingly well on the iPad. But web-games that require extensions or native games that require the full features of an OS are still left out in the cold.
Office Workers. Until we can run spreadsheets without tearing out our hair, organize our documents without screaming, manage our workflows with professional tools, iPad's are going to be restricted to executives showing off by marking up documents with their pencils in meetings.
Finally, back to the main point... if you make iPadOS as good as macOS isn't that just as likely to cannibalize sales somewhere in the process?
Maybe so, but it won't be as bad for Apple as if someone else produces the true dream of a lean, fast, flexible, mobile general purpose device that takes full advantage of the latest evolution of hardware AND software. When that happens, as it inevitably will, it will dominate the world. Today, that could be you. Tomorrow, that could be anyone.