r/howtobesherlock • • Mar 21 '14

OBSERVATION List of observable features and reasonable deductions.

92 Upvotes

Here is a list of observable features and conclusions that you could reasonably draw from them. If you wish to add to the list, please just comment below. If approrpiate, please include your source and as much info as possible on how reliable the observation is. Thank you!

Sources need not be peer-reviewed or scholarly. We may leave it up to our friends at /r/TheScienceofDeduction to test any claims.

Clothing

Belt Orientation - The tail on a belt will almost always point away from the dominant hand. This is because of the dexterity required to put a belt on.

Shoes - Anxious, clingy people prefer new, well-maintained shoes. People who wear practical shoes tend to be relatively agreeable. Calm, collected people tend to wear shos that look uncomfortable. Aggressive people tend to wear ankle boots. (Source, Source)

Accessories

Watch Placement - Because of the dexterity required to put on a watch unaided, a watch will not often be on the dominant hand. A watch on the right wrist means the person is likely left handed.

Ash-Stained Lighter - You can tell if someone is a pot smoker by looking at the bottom of their bic lighter. Stoners always use it to pack down a half-smoked bowl so it will usually be stained by ash.

Animals - If a person has fur anywhere from their knees to their feet, or it is similarly located, they have a large dog, or have recently been somewhere that there is a large dog. If instead it is on their arms and chest, it is a small dog or cat. This is because the small animals can be lifted up and held, while larger animals can't be.

Conversation

"Little Girl Voice" - A woman with an unusually high-pitched voice was likely the victim of abuse (usually sexual) prior to puberty. The age you'd place the voice at is a good indicator of when the abuse occured. (Source, Source)

"They" - If someone uses the word "they" to refer to a single person, they may not want to reveal the persons gender.

Disengagement Behaviors - The the richer person is, more likely they are to display "disengagement" behaviors, like fidgeting or doodling or playing with a pencil while someone was trying to talk to them. The poorer the person, the more they engage in connecting behaviors, like nodding, and smiling and actually listening to the other person. (Source)

Face

Wide Cheeckbones - Because of the effects of testosterone in the male body, males with wide cheeckbones are more likely to be untrustworthy. (Source). Note : The statistical difference here is so slight that this observation is not independantly useful.

However, another study shows that wider-faced men are actually nicer and more self-sacrificing as long as they percieve that you are on their team. (Source).

Red Nose - Alcoholic or former alcoholic.

Asymmetrical Face - People with assymetrical faces are more likely to be effective leaders. (Source, Source)

Symmetrical Face - People with symetrical faces are more likely to come from a higher childhood socioeconomic status. (Source, Source).

Eyes

Dilated/Dilating Pupils - Shows interest. Depending on context, this could mean anything from romantic interest to simple familiarity. For example, a subject's eyes will dilate when seeing a photo of a place they are familiar with.

Gaze Cues - If you are conversing with someone and you glance away, pay attention to whether they glance in the same direction, or if they keep their attention locked on you. If they glance with you, they are most likely poltically liberal. If they stay locked on you, conservative. (Source).

Eye Color - Men with light eye colors, such as blue, green, grey and hazel, are more tolerant to alcohol then men with brown or black eyes. Men with brown and black eyes are also more sensitive to medications and other stimuli. Because men with lighter colored eyes require more alcohol to get buzzed, and build up more of a tolerance, they are more likely to be alcohol abusers. (Source).

Grey Ring Around Cornea - Especially in an individual under 60 years old, a grey ring around the cornea goes hand in hand with high cholesterol and triglycerides.

Cloudy Eyes - Cateracts.

Hands

Yellow Stains on fingers - Cigarette Smoker

Clubbed Nails - Excessively curves fingernails (refered to as Nail Clubbing) is a sign of cardiovascular or respiratory disease. (Source)

Cradling a Baby with the Right Arm - The vast maority of people tend to cradle a baby with their left arm, regardless of dominant hand. However, a mother who is suffering from depression is twice as likely to cradle a baby in her right arm. (Source)

Feet

Open Legs - If a woman adopts an open-legged stance with a person, she is interested. If her legs are crossed or tucked under her, not likely. (Source).

Food

Sweet Tooth - Prosocial and agreeable people generally prefer sweet snacks like candy over things like potato chips or other non-sweet junk foods. (Source)

Documents

American vs Commonwealth Spelling - Most words ending in an unstressed -our in British English (e.g. colour, flavour, harbour, honour, humour, labour, neighbour, rumour) end in -or in American English (color, flavor, harbor, honor, humor, labor, neighbor, rumor).

Likewise, in British English, some words from French, Latin or Greek end with a consonant followed by -re, with the -re unstressed and pronounced /əɹ/. In American English, most of these words have the ending -er. The difference is most common for words ending -bre or -tre: British spellings calibre, centre, fibre, goitre, litre, lustre, manoeuvre, meagre, metre, mitre, nitre, ochre, reconnoitre, sabre, saltpetre, sepulchre, sombre, spectre, theatre and titre all have -er in American spelling.

There are, of course, many exceptions and many other spelling differences, but these two are common enough to be sufficient for most pieces of writing.

Note that Canada and Australia used the American "-or" from the 19th to mid 20th century before officially swtching back to the English spelling.


r/howtobesherlock • • Dec 31 '17

So I had a Sherlock moment today...

55 Upvotes

Okay, so I was playing video games earlier with my teenage sister watching me (I'm 22) and she was telling me about how her and her boyfriend one time were playing the same game at the same time. They were talking over the phone trying to keep up with each other, and she told me he was taking on all the enemies at once in whatever they were playing and was falling behind because of it while she was using strategy to move past the enemies with minimal confrontation. Without even really thinking, I said "So he's the oldest sibling then?" to which she said yes and asked how I knew. I said "the reason you know how to use strategy to get through video games is because you grew up watching me play video games and learn how to use strategy myself. He knowd less about strategy than you, so I assumed he never had anyone older than him playing games in front of him when he was younger." THEN I was like "woah, wait that was a Sherlock moment!" And I felt so proud. No big deal, just wanted to share!


r/howtobesherlock • • Sep 19 '17

STUDY Crime Scene Science [Infographic]

Post image
48 Upvotes

r/howtobesherlock • • Oct 12 '14

BODY LANGUAGE How to use body language to spot a concealed gun.

Post image
48 Upvotes

r/howtobesherlock • • May 03 '14

PRACTICE heres a game where you use your deduction skills to tell where you are on google maps street view, can be very difficult and good practice here! :)

Thumbnail
geoguessr.com
44 Upvotes

r/howtobesherlock • • Dec 22 '14

ARTICLE How to Read People

Thumbnail
bakadesuyo.com
36 Upvotes

r/howtobesherlock • • Sep 09 '14

DISCUSSION Success!

36 Upvotes

Today I made a deduction on someone I know. I noticed short hairs on their shirt. I asked then if they had a short haired dog and they did! This was my first deduction I made and it was a success. Not only did I have a successful deduction, but today is my cake day.


r/howtobesherlock • • Jan 28 '14

PRACTICE Game of Deductions!

Thumbnail gameofdeductions.yolasite.com
36 Upvotes

r/howtobesherlock • • Jan 06 '14

IDENTIFICATION Bullets

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/howtobesherlock • • Apr 14 '16

How to Think Like Sherlock? Try Literary Theory

Thumbnail
electricdidact.wordpress.com
32 Upvotes

r/howtobesherlock • • Oct 11 '16

How-to-be-Sherlock Study Materials?

31 Upvotes

While I do appreciate all the pictures to practice observation and deduction skills, as a beginner I wanted to ask if there were any books, databases, etc. to help get to that level, or even reading people I see on a daily basis. Perhaps even methods or strategies to practice Sherlock's skills in day to day settings.


r/howtobesherlock • • May 08 '15

Adventures in Sherlockology--some tips and tricks to strengthen your skills and avoid pitfalls

31 Upvotes

So like many, the reason I initially became interested in this subject was to imitate the well-known "Sherlock scan," in which one can look at a person, object, or (ha!) crime scene and deduce every single tiny detail in an instant. The reason? Because it's super awesome! (Or creepy, depending on who you ask.) But since then, it's actually become a more practical part of my life, and I've mostly forgotten about why I wanted to do it in the first place.

Anyway, reasons aside, I believe I have indeed developed more acute skills in observation, memory, and deduction. I've seen a lot of questions around this sub with people feeling frustrated or lost, and I thought I might be able to help out with some tips. Not like I'm an expert like Joseph Bell, the inspiration for Sherlock Holmes who had genuine uncanny powers of deductions, but I'd still like to share what's working for me and what to avoid in trying to increase your powers of observation.

1: Don't expect immediate results.

I've noticed people saying that they find observation exhausting and frustrating, and I know what they mean. I felt the same way at first, but before too long I realized I was pushing myself too hard because I wanted immediate results. I was trying to take in everything in right away. It's logical. Who wouldn't want to immediately pick up Sherlock's powers of deduction?

But that's impossible. If you want to observe better, it takes baby steps. Set new observation goals every day, starting with broad, simple, and easy ones and slowly moving up to harder ones as your “observation muscle” gets stronger. Start out taking note of what colors of cars you see. Look at what color shirts and pants people are wearing. Take notes and carry a notebook. Be subtle, but if you find yourself in a waiting room or public area where you can people watch, sit and write down everything you see in the room, furniture placement, number of windows, and details about people. You'll find that you'll become more observant. I started out just noticing basic things, and slowly I've been able to immediately notice and remember things like jewelry, style of clothes, posture, hair color and styles, signs of premature aging, that sort of thing, then retain that information the rest of the day and longer. But don't try to start there.

2: Don't focus on deduction at first—at all.

The thing people like to forget about Sherlock Holmes is how easily he can be wrong. About half of the time, he's making wild guesses that happen to be right. Remember that if your goal is deduction, you pretty much have to base them on the very obvious. Today I stood in line behind a man wearing a shirt advertising a contractor's company. He wore scuffed boots and had a farmer's tan. A piece of painter's tape with measurements written in inches was stuck to the base of his shirt. It's logical that he's a construction worker.

Further, my cashier had a large cross tattooed on the interior side of her left forearm. It's commonly accepted among tattoo artists that tattoos located on the left side of the body mean more to the person, as that's where the heart is located. So, likely a Christian.

But remember, these could both be wrong. She could have been pressured to get the tattoo. The guy could have borrowed the shirt. Don't jump to conclusions.

But also don't quit. Once your observation muscle is strong enough, you have a good chance of being right in your deductions. I was recently able to deduce from a stain on a woman's skirt that she owned a dog, and on the same day I deduced from clothing and body language that two teachers I was talking to didn't work at the same school.

3: Become a master of body language.

If I had to stress one strategy above all else, it would be this one. There is a great book called What Every Body is Saying that was written by a former FBI interrogator. It's commonly called one of the most vital books to read in order to succeed in business, and I can easily see why. I've read it a few times and have gone back many other times to consult it, and holy Moses, it has changed my life. From what I've learned, I was able to deduce that a man and woman were in a serious relationship based on a brief moment early in the evening when they had stood next to each other and he had touched her on the arm. Sure enough, when I asked how long they had been together, the man said they had been married for four years.

As you strengthen your observation muscle, you'll notice more and more what people are really saying. Furthermore, I would consider knowledge of body language to be a skill so important it should be taught in schools. I am already seeing changes in my personal life that are astounding me almost daily.

Anyway, TL;DR: If you want to become more observant and cultivate your “Sherlock scan,” don't try to observe everything at once, don't try to make deductions about people until you've developed your skills enough to feel confident doing so, and study up on body language.


r/howtobesherlock • • Aug 04 '19

PRACTICE What can you tell from my desk?

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/howtobesherlock • • Feb 01 '15

IDENTIFICATION Useful resources on tumblr

29 Upvotes

I thought I'd share some useful deduction resources I found on tumblr. These aren't the only ones but they are the best/most active ones. The first blog has recently posted a deduction survey in order to test some deductive theories - I highly recommend taking part!

  1. http://thedeductionguide.com/

  2. http://aguidetodeduction.tumblr.com/

  3. http://the-brain-attic.tumblr.com/

  4. http://thinkbig0.tumblr.com/

  5. http://analyticaldeduction.tumblr.com/

  6. http://perceptivelogic.tumblr.com/

  7. http://theartoftheconsultingdetective.tumblr.com/

  8. http://deductingamateur.tumblr.com/

  9. http://theconsultingdetectiveintraining.tumblr.com/

  10. http://everydaydeductionist.tumblr.com/


r/howtobesherlock • • Apr 23 '14

META Announcement!

29 Upvotes

First of all, I would like to thank everyone who has subscribed and been active in contributing and posting. I originally started this sub because I was curious about whether it was possible to achieve the level of observational skill and "cleverness" that Sherlock possessed. I never thought so many people would join in the effort with me. Its humbling and Im sincerely grateful for you all.

Let me just mention a few thoughts I've had over the past few days.

I've noticed that a good number of people have been posting images and asking for deductions based on them. This is fantastic and I'm glad you're doing it! I'm a huge believer in the idea that you will not get anywhere by study alone. You need to practice and apply these things as well. In fact, that should be the majority of your effort.

So thank you all for posting these types of posts.

But its gotten to the point where that's all thats being posted. I just want to throw out a reminder that this sub is intended to be so much more than that. Its a library and resource for any and all things relevant to our effort.

Over the last few days, we've gotten almost nothing but these types of "what can yo tell from my desk/room/etc" posts, and we've also had our first noticeable drop in subscribers. I dont think thats a coincidence.

These posts are great, but this sub is great, too, and what makes this sub great (among other things) is that it has EVERYTHING!

In addition, the largest section of links in the sidebar is currently the "Test Your Skills" section, which contains links to several subs specifically devoted to posts like this. I'm grateful to these subs and their mods and for the resource and service they provide. I am not trying to steal subscribers or traffic from them.

I am more than ok with reposts, so if you feel so inclined to posts a "What can you tell from my..." type post, please show them some love and respect and post it there, too, or even post it there first. After all, they were around before this sub was. I think we should respect the Law of Dibs and give them some of this great activity. Also, it couldn't hurt to have MORE people looking over your image and practicing, so we can all learn and grow together.

TL;DR - There have been a lot of posts lately of the "What can you tell from my..." type. These are great, but please try to preserve the versatility and diversity of this sub.

Keep posting them! But remember to post other useful things, too. Articles, Books, Personal Experiences/Observation, Studies, etc.

If you do post an image for people to deduce from, please try to post it to the relevant subreddit in the sidebar as well. They were here first, so lets show them some respect. Im totally ok with reposts and you can also post it here if you like, but lets not steal their traffic/activity/subscribers.

Im so happy to have you all here and Im grateful for all that you guys are contributing to our effort to learn and grow in observation powers. Keep posting, keep learning, keep searching for new info and resources. You guys are awesome!


r/howtobesherlock • • Apr 07 '13

OBSERVATION Blood Pattern Analysis

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/howtobesherlock • • Apr 13 '14

PRACTICE Here is an exercise, what can you tell about me from this picture

Thumbnail
imgur.com
28 Upvotes

r/howtobesherlock • • Jan 01 '18

How To Read Animal Tracks

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/howtobesherlock • • Jun 16 '20

OBSERVATION What can you tell about me from this pic?

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/howtobesherlock • • Sep 19 '17

STUDY Cover Up A Murder [Infographic]

Post image
25 Upvotes

r/howtobesherlock • • Jun 12 '16

PRACTICE I just took this photo, have at it!

Thumbnail
m.imgur.com
24 Upvotes

r/howtobesherlock • • Nov 20 '19

The university of Sheffield offers a free course on forensic facial reconstruction- what other courseware exists that could be useful for training ourselves to be like sherlock?

Thumbnail
classcentral.com
23 Upvotes

r/howtobesherlock • • Sep 17 '19

The Social Intelligence Test | A test that measures your ability to read emotions from faces

Thumbnail
socialintelligence.labinthewild.org
23 Upvotes

r/howtobesherlock • • Mar 05 '18

The famous investigative group Bellingcat has published over 40 guides on how to conduct investigations online

Thumbnail
bellingcat.com
23 Upvotes

r/howtobesherlock • • Jan 27 '18

Just a quick note from a Mod.

23 Upvotes

Hello! My name is Curlaub and I started /r/HowToBeSherlock. It may seem like I've been inactive, but I promise Ive been poking my head in now and then to see how things are going and Im grateful and humbled that this remains a fairly active community and I thank you all for making it so.

I want you to know that my apparent inactivity is not because I dont care. Its been a hell of a 4 years for me. Ive been laid off, rehired, laid off again, got evicted, bought a house, wife was pregnant, wife miscarried, started a small business, etc. A LOT of ups and downs. Pretty soon here, Ill be going back to school on top of working full time and hopefully still keeping my business going and growing, so my time will remain limited.

I am pretty active on reddit, but I havent been able to mod like I would like. There's a huge difference between commenting now and then and trying to mod a fairly active sub. Especially if you want to be a good mod. It really is an investment. I used to be a mod for a default sub, too, but I eventually gave that up for similar reasons. No time.

So I am also very grateful for the mods who have stepped up at various points over the last few years to keep things going.

Anyways, I just wanted to thank all of you. I promise I do still care about this sub. Im grateful that you all are here. Keep it up. You guys are awesome. Every one of you.