Iâve been reading through the Childrenâs Wellbeing and Schools Bill, and the more I look at it, the less comfortable I feel.
Itâs being sold as safeguarding. Fine, nobody disagrees with protecting kids. But whatâs actually being proposed looks a lot more like increased monitoring of families whoâve made a lawful, deliberate choice to educate outside the system.
The register is a big one. Every home educated child logged, with ongoing requirements to provide information. That might sound harmless, but itâs not happening in a vacuum. Once that system exists, itâs a small step from âregistrationâ to âoversightâ, and from oversight to pressure or intervention.
More concerning is the shift in principle. In some cases, local authorities would have a say over whether home education is in a childâs âbest interestsâ. Thatâs not a minor tweak, thatâs a fundamental change. Home education stops being a parental responsibility and starts becoming something you need approval for.... not to mention each council will have it's own people who have their own specific ideas of appropriate education. It's impossible that some home ed parents won't get lumped with bad actors in some councils, it's a numbers thing...
And zooming out, this Bill centralises a lot more power generally. More structure, more standardisation, more assumption that thereâs one âcorrectâ way to do things. Thatâs exactly what many of us stepped away from in the first place.
Iâm not against safeguarding. Iâm against blanket systems that treat independent, functioning families as a problem to be managed. Thereâs a difference, and this Bill doesnât seem to recognise it.
Once these kinds of controls are in place, they donât get rolled back. They expand :/
Quick summary of concerns:
Mandatory register of all home educated children
Ongoing data sharing with local authorities
Possible requirement for permission to home educate
Shift from parental responsibility â state oversight
High risk of scope creep over time
One-size-fits-all thinking applied to very different families
Home ed framed as a safeguarding issue rather than a valid choice
Underlying lack of trust in parents
What's your take?