r/HistoricalWorldPowers • u/MamaLudie • Jul 19 '19
MOD POST The New Mechanics of HWP 3.0
Hello, Ludie here!
Since its inception, HWP hardly strayed from the formula, even if there were minor changes. Ultimately, the subreddit was a strange mix between trying to be a strategy game at times and a roleplaying/writing sub on the other.
No more.
HWP is now, more now than ever, a roleplaying and collective writing club. Things like tech, expansions, and population were often minmaxed at the cost of roleplay. It became clear that such a formula was always unsustainable. Another issue with focusing on only your own strategies meant that people's posts weren't read or interacted with, demotivating players. But this is unrealistic, especially for large states - realistically, empires in particular always had opinions of other people's ongoings.
Furthermore, the tech mechanic seemed more about planning years in advance for buffs, despite not having much roleplay involved. Therefore, we have made it much more common-sense based. Only a few pre-announced techs will be gainable through RP. For the rest, you will need to RP within reason. You cannot have techs more advanced than the start year, and of course poor states in the desert can't afford the same things that a rich state could afford. Mods will be reading every post.
Reading posts is going to be a lot more important in HWP. Not only will mods read posts, but players will be at least expected to comment meaningfully on a few other people's posts - even better if in character and saying how a state feels about developments in another country. This will be extra important for claims which want to become empires - they must prove they deserve their size by fostering RP.
If there's no tech, how do we determine which states are stronger? Firstly, tech barely had any mechanical effects, and could be min-maxed. It hardly told which states were "stronger". In its place, we will have an economy system. These will mostly be rated by roleplay in posts flaired "economy". While you don't need to post them weekly, the economy reports will come out weekly. That means you can decide whether you want really detailed posts less often, or more frequent ones. Furthermore, interaction with other claims will give even more economic benefits. This will make roleplay even more important. Some other posts will also improve economy. This economy will be linked to trade regions, which will be announced by the mod team every week. Economy should allow you to customise a bit: Do you want huge wonders? Giant defensive walls? A huge navy? An elite army? These will all be possible!
Expansion will be much less a "granted". It should not be seen as something to deserve, but rather a grant of more power which will be used to improve the roleplay. This means you must prove your nation can serve as a good source of roleplay for you to be given land. All empires may eventually fall, but cultured ones will be more like China in comparison to Alexander's short-lived empire. That takes me to culture.
Culture is essentially roleplay of every other form. It's what your nation does aside from economy, expansion, and external war. What political schemes are going on? Is there a civil war? How are new discoveries affecting your nation? What food do your people eat? How do they dress? What are their festivals? HWP is all about building a new and unique culture, so we'll want to see that you stick with the core of roleplay before we make you too powerful. Historically, large empires pushed their culture on their neighbours, either through conquest or trade. Empires who do this will almost certainly last longer, and will create fun conflict for all players involved. Again, commenting on other player's posts and interacting with their cultures will not only make things more fun, but you can also get a unique role on the subreddit discord for being a model player.
We've also changed the claim types a bit, although they're mostly renamed. There are State claims, which are at their core larger, relatively-organised states with a settled homeland. These are the most versatile claims, although they're also not specialised. There are also City-States, which are tiny nations with strong economies and slow expansion. Thanks to the economy system, as well as their raised defensiveness, these states can seriously punch above their weight, and thanks to their wealth, are versatile. However, they are also very small, and can struggle to go on the offensive or force their culture on others. Tribal states are larger, unorganised states which may or may not have an organised homeland. These states have stronger armies and can migrate, but are poorer, and often struggle to develop. In order to remedy this, they can raid for more money, although this means they can't expand or migrate that week.
Of course, sometimes there are border disputes, and war is inevitable. However, one big issue with this is that everybody seems to rely on the war calculator. Furthermore, this could be used to steamroll smaller claims and ignore roleplay: essentially a minmax. So we've changed the war system. Firstly, we insist strongly that you RP-war your neighbours. In order to deter calculated war, we are intentionally going to make it fully decided by boring calculations. We will only do a tiny writeup for your war, and the results will be nowhere near as desireable as a roleplayed war. Furthermore, calculated wars will have a harsher economic strain on your nation.
HWP 3 is looking to be one of our most ambitious and RP-friendly seasons yet, with more player interaction than ever before. We hope you join our discord and stay tuned for more news!